Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Davidson-10167
H
6 Mar 1892 Lance Corp Allan Scotty McLean Davidson certain 6 May 1891 certain Kingston, Ontario, Canada certain 16 Jun 1915 certain Belgium Male Orphan
Q3074880 Scotty Davidson (Canadian ice hockey player and soldier (1892-1915)) 6 Mar 1892 Kingston Canada 16 Jun 1915 Belgium Belgium male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Durbin-702 18.06.2023 16:03:02 False suggestion
Cardon-62
H
1 May 1772 Anthony Cardon the Younger Cardon certain 15 May 1772 certain Brussel, Hertogdom Brabant, Oostenrijkse Nederlanden certain 17 Feb 1813 certain London Street, Fitzroy Square, London, England Male Heath-1701
Q16931050 Anthony Cardon (Flemish engraver in England (1772-1813)) 1 May 1772 City of Brussels Belgium 16 Apr 1813 London United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Heath-1701 06.06.2017 00:09:33 False suggestion Wikidata dates are alternate and not in agreement with multiple sources listed
Flandre-5
H
863 Baudouin Baudouin II le Chauve, Comte de Flande, Baldwin II de Flandre (Flandre) uncertain 864 Flanders, Nord, France certain 10 Sep 918 Ghent, Flanders, Belgium Male Atkinson-107

WikiTree-113

VanderLeest-211
Q366998 Baldwin II (margrave of Flanders) 863 10 Sep 918 Ghent Belgium male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 30.06.2021 11:47:32 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Habsburg-105
H
25 Feb 1500 King Charles Charles V Karl V, Kaiser, Carlos I, Rey de España Habsburg certain 24 Feb 1500 certain Ghent, Flanders, Belgium certain 21 Sep 1558 certain Yuste, Spain Male Atkinson-107

LeBlanc-2419

WikiTree-53
Q32500 Charles V (Holy Roman Emperor, King of Spain and Duke of Burgundy (1500–1558)) 25 Feb 1500 Ghent Belgium 21 Sep 1558 Yuste Spain male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
thiessen-117 13.01.2021 00:12:42 False suggestion
Ligne-12
H
13 Jan 1857 Ernest Louis Henri Lamoral de Ligne (Ligne) certain 12 Jan 1857 certain Paris, Seine, France 23 Jun 1937 Brussels, Brabant, Belgium Male Lavoie-802
Q3057234 Ernest, 10th Prince of Ligne ((1857-1937)) 13 Jan 1857 1st arrondissement of Paris France 23 Jun 1937 City of Brussels Belgium male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lavoie-802 30.04.2020 23:53:07 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Cartier-300
H
23 Feb 1872 Fernande Louise Marie Ghislaine de Cartier de Marchienne (Cartier) uncertain 22 Feb 1872 Suarlée, Namur, Belgique 19 Jun 1903 Bruxelles, Brabant, Belgique Female Orphan
Q5444556 Fernande de Cartier de Marchienne (mother of Marguerite Yourcenar) 23 Feb 1872 Suarlée Belgium 19 Jun 1903 Brussels-Capital Region Belgium female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 08.08.2017 20:37:34 Not corrected Wikidata is unsourced and her birth record is not available on line.
Rassinot-1 31.03.2020 14:15:43 False suggestion
Van Renesse-28
H
1470 Frederik Frederik II van Renesse aka van Elderen uncertain 1474 certain Holy Roman Empire 19 May 1538 Breda, North Brabant, Netherlands Male Baijense-2
Q2145026 Frederik van Renesse (Dutch-Belgian judge (1470-1538)) 1470 Utrecht Netherlands 19 May 1538 Breda Netherlands male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 19.03.2024 16:33:02 False suggestion
Scrope-101
H
1285 Sir Geoffrey le Scrope (Scrope) uncertain 1280 Yorkshire, England uncertain 2 Dec 1340 Ghent, Belgium Male Saucier-101

Noland-165
Q5535002 Geoffrey le Scrope (English judge) 1285 2 Dec 1340 Ghent Belgium male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 12.12.2020 01:40:36 False suggestion no source for birth (be it c1280 or c1285)
Wilmot-441
H
26 Oct 1612 Henry 1st Earl of Rochester Wilmot MP before 26 Oct 1613 London, Middlesex, England certain 19 Feb 1658 Sluys, Belgium Male Mackinnon-507
Q15502383 Henry Wilmot, 1st Earl of Rochester (English diplomat) 26 Oct 1612 19 Feb 1658 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
mackinnon-507 31.08.2017 18:42:22 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Cardon-103
H
18 Nov 1754 Joannes Bernardus Jean Bernard Cardon certain 19 Nov 1754 uncertain Waregem, Graafschap Vlaanderen, Oostenrijkse Nederlanden certain 13 Jun 1832 certain Paris, Seine, France Male Orphan
Q71402381 Jean Bernard Cardon ((1754-1832)) 18 Nov 1754 13 Jun 1832 Paris France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 22.10.2019 13:32:17 False suggestion Only baptism date is known. Can't have a birth date that is precise to the day.
Rassinot-1 27.10.2019 09:05:11 False suggestion WikiTree uses the baptism in the case, but the baptism act does state that the child was born on the same day. So WikiTree is correct and Wikidata is wrong.
Ruflin-1
H
1831 Justine Éléonore Ruflin certain 2 Jul 1832 certain Paris, Seine, France certain 13 Oct 1905 certain Paris XVI, Paris, Seine, France Female Orphan
Q3588121 Eleonore Justine Ruflin (spouse of prince Pierre Bonaparte) 1831 Paris France 13 Oct 1905 Paris France female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 02.07.2017 17:41:53 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Gressin-Dumoulin-1
H
1837 Marie-Pauline Tadema (Gressin-Dumoulin) certain 12 Sep 1836 certain Bruxelles, Brabant, Belgique certain 28 May 1869 Schaerbeek, Brabant, Belgique Female Trueblood-273
Q96080157 [Marie] Pauline Gressin (1837 - certain 28 May 1869) 1837 1869 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Trueblood-273 28.04.2022 15:03:56 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Mac Mahon-163
H
14 Oct 1754 Maurice François François Mac Mahon 13 Oct 1754 Autun, Bourgogne, France 22 Mar 1831 Autun, Saône-et-Loire, France Male Orphan
Q3300279 Maurice-François de Mac-Mahon (French officer) 14 Oct 1754 Sully France 22 Mar 1831 Autun France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
rassinot-1 03.07.2018 16:18:17 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Clermont de Nesle-1
H
1255 Raoul Raoul II Sire de Nesle Clermont de Nesle uncertain 1242 certain 11 Jul 1302 Kortrijk (Courtrai), , West-Vlaanderen, Belgium Male Marchal-178

Holland-3338

Atkinson-107
Q2131265 Raoul of Clermont (Lord of Nesle, Vicecount of Châteaudun, Grand Chamberlain of France and Constable of France) 1255 11 Jul 1302 Kortrijk Belgium male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marchal-178 26.10.2021 13:56:26 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Flandre-14
H
1029 Robert Robert I The Frisian, Count of Artois, Count of Flanders Flandre uncertain 1033 Flanders, Belgium 13 Oct 1093 certain Flanders, Belgium Male Nilsen-785
Q333346 Robert I, Count of Flanders (Count of Flanders) 1029 13 Oct 1093 Torhout Belgium male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-10705 18.01.2018 19:30:02 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Mosselman du Chenoy-2
H
20 Nov 1804 Théodore Jean Mosselman du Chenoy 22 Nov 1804 Bruxelles, Dyle, Empire Français 27 May 1876 Court-Saint-Étienne, Brabant, Belgique Male Orphan
Q2040665 Théodore Mosselman du Chenoy (Belgian private banker and politician) 20 Nov 1804 Brussels metropolitan area Belgium 27 May 1876 Court-Saint-Étienne Belgium male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID2737113 15.03.2017 09:51:29 False suggestion Old False error
Limburg Stirum-2
H
29 Dec 1904 Thierry François-Xavier Marie Joseph Ghislain de Limburg Stirum (Limburg Stirum) 28 Dec 1904 Bruxelles, Brabant, Belgique 13 Dec 1968 Huldenberg, Brabant, Belgique Male Rassinot-1
Q75376884 Thierry François Xavier Marie Joseph Ghislain de Limburg Stirum ((1904-1968)) 29 Dec 1904 13 Dec 1968 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 18.12.2019 13:33:33 False suggestion Wikidata is incorrect. Primary source for birth on profile.
Penn-83
H
1681 William Penn 14 Mar 1680 England 1720 France or Belgium Male WikiTree-32
Q8016747 William Penn (Eldest surviving son of William Penn, founder of the colony of Pennsylvania) 1681 1720 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McGee-1611 27.11.2017 02:48:00 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate; linked wikipedia article has same dates as WT profile
Wassenberg-2
H
1090 Yolande Heiress of Dorenweerd, Regent of Hainaut van Gelre (Wassenberg) aka von Wasseberg, van Gueldres certain 1087 certain Gelderland certain 1137 Mons, Hainaut, Belgium Female Lamoreaux-297
Q2075550 Yolande de Wassenberg ((1090-1131)) 1090 1131 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 16.03.2020 15:37:05 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Lamoreaux-297 17.12.2020 18:23:36 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
ኣስረስ-1
H
8 May 1955 መለስ Meles Zanawi ዜናዊ Asres (ኣስረስ) certain 9 May 1955 certain Ādwa, Tigray Province, Ethiopia certain 20 Aug 2012 Brussels, Belgium Male Luckie-23
Q161184 Meles Zenawi (Ethiopian politician; Prime Minister of Ethiopia (1955-2012)) 8 May 1955 Adwa Ethiopia 20 Aug 2012 City of Brussels Belgium male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Luckie-23 24.11.2023 05:33:37 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status