Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Beck-4541
H
19 Jun 1857 Sir Adam Beck 20 Jun 1857 Baden, Canada West 15 Aug 1925 London, Middlesex, Ontario, Canada Male Orphan
Q520050 Adam Beck (politician and hydroelectricity advocate (1857-1925)) 19 Jun 1857 Baden Canada 15 Aug 1925 London Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cruthers-29 24.10.2022 20:07:33 False suggestion
Hunter-2212
H
27 Feb 1858 Adelaide Sophia Addie Hoodless (Hunter) certain 27 Feb 1857 certain St. George, Brant County, Ontario, Canada certain 26 Feb 1910 certain St. Margaret's College, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada Female Hunter-2201
Q4681731 Adelaide Hoodless (Canadian activist (1858-1910)) 27 Feb 1858 County of Brant Canada 26 Feb 1910 Toronto Canada female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Claus-196 21.02.2019 04:24:10 Not corrected private message sent to PM
Hoodless-90 21.06.2019 04:02:16 Comment Family Date, Find A Grave, Adelaide Hoodless, Domestic Crusader all list date of birth as 1857
Hoodless-90 21.06.2019 04:02:57 Comment
Hunter-2201 29.01.2020 18:54:57 False suggestion
Adamson-3884
H
8 Nov 1901 Agar Rodney Adamson 15 Nov 1901 Toronto, Ontario, Canada 8 Apr 1954 Saskatchewan, Canada Male Orphan
Q4691268 Agar Rodney Adamson (Canadian mining engineer and politician) 8 Nov 1901 Toronto Canada 8 Apr 1954 Moose Jaw Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cruthers-29 07.06.2023 21:27:11 False suggestion
VanKoughnet-98
H
1860 Agnes Gertie Gertrude Macdonald (VanKoughnet) certain 5 Jun 1862 Kingston, Frontenac, Ontario, Canada certain 18 Jul 1940 Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada Female Jewett-369
Q75602466 Agnes Gertrude van Koughnet (Peerage person ID=237751) 1860 18 Jul 1940 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jewett-369 06.12.2023 04:45:33 False suggestion
Jewett-369 06.12.2023 04:45:40 False suggestion
Selkirk-112
H
4 Jan 1908 Alexander George George Selkirk certain 5 Jan 1908 Huntsville, Muskoka, Ontario, Canada 19 Jan 1987 Fort Lauderdale, Florida, USA Male McEvoy-527
Q5544403 George Selkirk (Canadian baseball player) 4 Jan 1908 Huntsville Canada 19 Jan 1987 Fort Lauderdale United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McEvoy-527 12.11.2019 05:13:28 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Davidson-10167
H
6 Mar 1892 Lance Corp Allan Scotty McLean Davidson certain 6 May 1891 certain Kingston, Ontario, Canada certain 16 Jun 1915 certain Belgium Male Orphan
Q3074880 Scotty Davidson (Canadian ice hockey player and soldier (1892-1915)) 6 Mar 1892 Kingston Canada 16 Jun 1915 Belgium Belgium male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Durbin-702 18.06.2023 16:03:02 False suggestion
Ferguson-4380
H
1833 Charles Frederick Ferguson certain 20 Jul 1834 Kitley, Leeds, Upper Canada 29 Sep 1909 Kemptville, Ontario, Canada Male Jewett-369
Q5077842 Charles Frederick Ferguson (Canadian politician) 1833 Elizabethtown-Kitley Canada 29 Sep 1909 Kemptville Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jewett-369 26.07.2018 22:05:28 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Minchin-283
H
1827 Charles Minchin uncertain 1829 Ireland 31 Jul 1883 Brantford, Ontario, Canada Male Groom-187
Q75798694 Charles Minchin ((1827-1883)) 1827 1883 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Groom-187 23.03.2023 06:15:16 False suggestion
Brower-418
H
1901 Edna Mae Diefenbaker (Brower) 30 Nov 1899 Wawanesa, Manitoba, Canada 7 Feb 1951 Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada Female Jewett-369
Q5340030 Edna Diefenbaker (Wife of Canadian Prime Minister) 1901 Wawanesa Canada 7 Feb 1951 Saskatoon Canada female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID2283849 03.12.2016 17:51:08 False suggestion Old False error
Locke-5074
H
13 Apr 1883 Effiegene Wingo (Locke) 14 Apr 1883 Lockesburg, Sevier, Arkansas, United States 18 Aug 1962 Burlington, Halton, Ontario, Canada Female Orphan
Q1296186 Effiegene Locke Wingo (American politician (1883-1962)) 13 Apr 1883 Lockesburg United States of America 19 Sep 1962 18 Aug 1962 Burlington Canada female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Honey-866 19.03.2024 04:16:14 False suggestion
Bagshaw-293
H
1 Oct 1881 Dr. Elizabeth Catherine Bagshaw certain 19 Oct 1881 Mariposa, Victoria, Ontario, Canada certain 5 Jan 1982 Hamilton, Hamilton-Wentworth, Ontario, Canada Female Cruthers-29
Q5362364 Elizabeth Bagshaw (Canadian doctor) 1 Oct 1881 Mariposa Canada 5 Jan 1982 Hamilton Canada female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dudgeon-166 01.05.2019 23:22:48 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Estill-397
H
1857 Frances Fannie R Fannie Beauchamp (Estill) 1856 Madison County, Kentucky, United States 11 Apr 1923 Geneva, Ontario County, New York, United States Female WikiTree-130

Craig-4574
Q111040090 Frances Estill Beauchamp (American suffragist, temperance leader, philanthropist (1857-1923)) 1857 1923 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 12.07.2023 21:02:42 False suggestion Not Sourced
McGee-3688
H
4 Nov 1882 Francis Frank Clarence McGee certain 4 Nov 1878 certain Ottawa, Ontario, Canada certain 16 Sep 1916 certain Courcelette, France Male Orphan
Q3028377 Frank McGee (Canadian ice hockey player) 4 Nov 1882 Ottawa Canada 16 Sep 1916 Courcelette France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cruthers-29 20.09.2021 22:55:16 False suggestion
Pegahmagabow-2
H
9 Mar 1892 Chief Francis Peggy Pegahmagabow aka Binaaswi 9 Mar 1889 Shawanaga First Nation in Nobel, Ontario 5 Aug 1952 Parry Island Reserve, Wasauksing First Nation. Male Baraboo-1
Q3049605 Francis Pegahmagabow (Canadian First Nations soldier, politician and activist) 9 Mar 1892 9 Mar 1891 Parry Sound Canada 5 Aug 1952 Parry Sound Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Baraboo-1 10.09.2019 22:56:23 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography and sourced
Lawson-7404
H
30 Aug 1886 Frank Ray Ray Lawson O.B.E. 30 Sep 1886 London, Ontario, Canada 4 Apr 1980 Miami Beach, Florida, United States Male Orphan
Q7297741 Ray Lawson (Lieutenant Governor of Ontario (1886-1980)) 30 Aug 1886 London Canada 4 Apr 1980 London Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cruthers-29 27.04.2019 14:24:51 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Strong-2072
H
1879 Lady Helena Emeline Squires (Strong) 29 Oct 1878 Little Bay Islands, Newfoundland Mar 1959 Toronto, Ontario, Canada Female Jewett-369
Q5703738 Helena Squires (Newfoundland and Canadian politician) 1879 1959 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jewett-369 27.10.2023 20:39:26 False suggestion
Jewett-369 27.10.2023 20:39:33 False suggestion
Greenfield-505
H
25 Nov 1869 Herbert Greenfield certain 25 Nov 1865 certain Winchester, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom certain 23 Aug 1949 certain Calgary, Alberta, Canada Male WikiTree-58
Q1000799 Herbert Greenfield (Canadian politician (1869-1949)) 25 Nov 1869 Winchester United Kingdom 23 Aug 1949 Calgary Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jewett-369 20.03.2023 19:59:10 Corrected
Jewett-369 20.03.2023 19:59:52 Corrected
Jewett-369 30.03.2023 17:42:48 Corrected
Jewett-369 04.04.2023 21:23:41 False suggestion
MacPherson-1237
H
25 Nov 1875 Isabella Ecclestone Mackay (MacPherson) 24 Nov 1875 Woodstock, Oxford, Ontario, Canada 15 Aug 1928 Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada Female Orphan
Q6077691 Isabel Ecclestone Mackay (Canadian writer (1875-1928)) 25 Nov 1875 Woodstock Canada 15 Aug 1928 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cruthers-29 31.12.2019 16:08:44 False suggestion Wikipedia wrong; birth certificate and DCB give 24th
Viczián-24
H
24 Jun 1874 István Viczián certain 21 Jun 1874 Tápiószele, Pest-Pilis-Solt-Kiskun, Hungary certain 3 Apr 1959 Toronto, Ontario, Canada Male Kóczy-1
Q1426045 István Viczián (Hungarian politician (1874-1959)) 24 Jun 1874 Tápiószele Hungary 3 Apr 1959 Toronto Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kóczy-1 22.08.2020 20:16:39 False suggestion Wikidata date is probably date of baptism.
Paton-1724
H
1885 James Alexander Paton 25 Jul 1884 Clinton, Lincoln, Ontario, Canada 19 Feb 1946 Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada Male Orphan
Q6128552 James Alexander Paton (Member of Legislative Assembly of British Columbia) 1885 Beamsville Canada 19 Feb 1946 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mutter-136 20.01.2021 06:34:08 False suggestion Birth source is cited
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Rennie-309
H
18 Apr 1890 James Malachi Rennie 18 Apr 1889 Toronto, Ontario, Canada 31 Jul 1965 New York City, New York, U.S Male Pierce-5610
Q13494127 James Rennie (Canadian actor (1889-1965)) 18 Apr 1890 Toronto Canada 31 Jul 1965 New York City United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ponzetta-1 28.05.2021 19:01:03 Not corrected data del profilo corretta
Ponzetta-1 28.05.2021 19:01:45 Not corrected profile date correct
Ponzetta-1 03.10.2021 15:26:32 Comment exact date on the profile according to reported sources
Ponzetta-1 03.10.2021 15:49:04 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Tupper-390
H
29 Oct 1851 James Stewart Tupper 26 Oct 1851 Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia 29 Apr 1915 Oxford, Oxfordshire, England, United Kingdom Male Jewett-369
Q76197520 James Stewart Tupper (Canadian lawyer (1851-1915)) 29 Oct 1851 Amherst Canada 29 Apr 1915 Oxford United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jewett-369 11.03.2023 22:14:02 False suggestion
Aird-331
H
15 Nov 1885 Sir John Aird certain 15 Nov 1855 Longueuil, Champlain, Canada East 30 Nov 1938 Toronto, Ontario, Canada Male Orphan
Q6218358 John Aird (Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce president) 15 Nov 1885 Longueuil Canada 30 Nov 1938 Toronto Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cruthers-29 03.09.2019 19:52:36 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
MacKell-23
H
12 Apr 1896 John Ambroise Jack MacKell 4 Dec 1894 Ottawa, Carleton, Ontario, Canada 25 Nov 1961 Como, Hudson, Vaudreuil, Quebec, Canada Male Bogues-15
Q6113818 Jack Mackell (Canadian ice hockey player) 12 Apr 1896 Ottawa Canada 25 Nov 1961 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bogues-15 12.07.2023 23:22:50 False suggestion
McLaughlin-2115
H
3 Mar 1865 John Jack James McLaughlin 2 Mar 1865 Enniskillen, Durham, Canada West 28 Jan 1914 Toronto, York, Ontario, Canada Male WikiTree-58

Henderson-4785
Q19666399 John J. McLaughlin (Canadian pharmacist) 3 Mar 1865 Enniskillen Canada 28 Jan 1914 Toronto Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Henderson-4785 19.09.2018 20:48:51 Not corrected conflict between sources - but source of March 3 date uses source of March 2 date as its source.
Cruthers-29 09.02.2023 01:10:31 False suggestion
Pope-1841
H
16 Aug 1857 Sir Joseph Pope certain 6 Aug 1854 Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island 2 Dec 1926 Ottawa, Ontario, Canada Male Pope-6975

Jewett-369
Q6286313 Joseph Pope (Canadian civil servant (1857-1926)) 16 Aug 1857 Charlottetown Canada 2 Dec 1926 Ottawa Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID3264441 23.11.2016 17:08:53 False suggestion Old False error
Strange-1694
H
22 Mar 1820 Maxwell William Strange certain 20 Mar 1820 certain Kingston, Frontenac, Upper Canada certain 28 Sep 1880 certain Kingston, Frontenac, Ontario, Canada Male Orphan
Q6796160 Maxwell W. Strange (Canadian politician (1820-1880)) 22 Mar 1820 Kingston Canada 28 Sep 1880 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Reid-2564 16.11.2017 14:47:25 Corrected Corrected
Reid-2564 06.12.2017 11:42:23 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong
Mills-9822
H
21 Oct 1910 Pauline Emily McGibbon (Mills) 20 Oct 1910 Sarnia, Ontario, Canada 14 Dec 2001 Toronto, Ontario, Canada Female WikiTree-58

Cruthers-29
Q7155057 Pauline Mills McGibbon (Lieutenant Governor of Ontario) 21 Oct 1910 Sarnia Canada 14 Dec 2001 Toronto Canada female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID2478430 13.02.2017 03:12:49 False suggestion Old False error
Rynard-73
H
25 Jun 1897 Dr. Philip P.b. Bernard Rynard certain 25 Jun 1896 Georgina, York, Ontario, Canada certain 20 Nov 1980 Orillia, Simcoe, Ontario, Canada Male Orphan
Q7183223 Philip Bernard Rynard (Canadian politician (1897-1980)) 25 Jun 1897 Udora Canada 20 Nov 1980 Orillia Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cruthers-29 05.07.2023 22:50:14 False suggestion
Gilmour-933
H
1884 Sutherland Campbell Suddy Gilmour 7 Aug 1883 Ottawa, Carleton, Ontario, Canada 14 Feb 1932 Ottawa, Carleton, Ontario, Canada Male Orphan
Q7633671 Suddy Gilmour (Canadian ice hockey player) 1884 Ottawa Canada 14 Feb 1932 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cruthers-29 26.06.2023 16:27:54 False suggestion
Cayley-123
H
26 May 1807 William Cayley certain 14 May 1807 Sankt-Peterburg, Sankt-Peterburg, Sankt-Peterburg, Russian Empire certain 23 Feb 1890 Toronto, Ontario, Canada Male Orphan
Q8006651 William Cayley (Canadian politician (1807-1890)) 26 May 1807 23 Feb 1890 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
cayley-55 26.11.2017 16:54:53 Not corrected Conflict between sources. I have now given both birth dates in the biography section, with an explanation and sources.
Cayley-55 31.01.2020 14:12:28 False suggestion See profile
Kirby-3502
H
23 Oct 1817 William Kirby certain 13 Oct 1817 Hull, Yorkshire East Riding, England, United Kingdom certain 23 Jun 1906 Niagara-on-the-Lake, Niagara, Lincoln, Ontario, Canada Male Orphan
Q585351 William Kirby (Canadian writer (1817-1906)) 23 Oct 1817 Kingston upon Hull Kingston upon Hull Kingdom of England United Kingdom 23 Jun 1906 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Morris-18630 28.06.2023 04:00:45 False suggestion
Smith-171934
H
1798 William Mein Smith certain 7 Sep 1799 Capetown, Cape Colony, South Africa certain 3 Jan 1869 Greytown, Wellington, New Zealand Male Orphan
Q8015537 William Mein Smith (artist, surveyor, and New Zealand politician (1798-1869)) 1798 Cape Town South Africa 3 Jan 1869 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bethune-87 09.05.2019 15:28:30 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Salmon-3443
H
2 Jun 1802 William Salmon 18 Jun 1802 Alveston, Gloucestershire, England, United Kingdom 8 Feb 1868 Simcoe, Norfolk, Ontario, Canada Male Orphan
Q8018051 William Salmon (Lawyer, judge and political figure in Upper Canada (1802-1868)) 2 Jun 1802 8 Feb 1868 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cruthers-29 29.09.2023 14:25:32 False suggestion
Oliver-9726
H
1836 William Silver Oliver MD uncertain 12 Nov 1835 Kilfinnane, County Limerick, Ireland 27 Apr 1908 Farnborough, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom Male Orphan
Q8018439 William Silver Oliver (Irish-born Canadian military surgeon) 1836 27 Apr 1908 Farnborough United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Scannell-33 17.07.2022 08:18:45 False suggestion
Aikins-136
H
4 Jun 1827 Dr William Thomas Aikins uncertain 5 Jun 1827 Toronto Township, Upper Canada uncertain 24 May 1897 Toronto, Ontario, Canada Male McEvoy-527
Q56512357 William Thomas Aikins (Canadian surgeon and educator) 4 Jun 1827 25 May 1897 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cruthers-29 06.06.2023 17:02:14 False suggestion