Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 558: Wikidata - Different death date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Bohun-33
H
1264 Alice de Tony (Bohun) aka de Bohun, de Toeni uncertain 1238 England after 1270 Gloucestershire, England Female WikiTree-36

Harper-1691

Wood-2151
Q76308408 Alice de Bohun ((1228-1264)) 1228 1264 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 11.03.2020 17:36:06 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Caldwell-2577
H
1895 Catherine Anne Rowan-Hamilton (Caldwell) aka Hamilton before 1824 certain Dunbar, Haddingtonshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 1919 certain Rathdown, County Wicklow, Ireland Female Lavigne-404
Q75552129 Catherine Caldwell (Peerage person ID=208720) 1895 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:18:44 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Elwes-29
H
31 Oct 1868 Charlotte Charlotte Maria Maria Tennyson (Elwes) certain 1835 certain Barton upon Humber, North Lincolnshire, Lincolnshire, England, United Kingdom certain 30 Oct 1868 Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
Q76188784 Charlotte Maria Elwes ((died 1868)) 1835 31 Oct 1868 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Winkler-407 18.05.2022 13:26:27 False suggestion
Braose-7
H
1251 Eleanor Alyanor, Alianore de Bohun (Braose) aka de Braose, de Briouze, de Brewes uncertain 1224 Brecknockshire, Wales before 25 Jun 1252 uncertain Gloucestershire, England Female Orphan
Q5354427 Eleanor de Braose (English noble) 1228 1251 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
thiessen-117 10.08.2019 18:19:31 False suggestion dates on WT and WD are estimated
Clare-89
H
Jul 1337 Eleanor la Zouche (Clare) aka de Clare, le Despenser, Mortimer before 23 Nov 1292 certain Caerphilly Castle, Glamorganshire, Wales certain 30 Jun 1337 certain Gloucestershire, England Female Dellinger-332

Noland-165

Wood-2151
Q2160835 Eleanor de Clare (Anglo-Welsh noblewoman) 3 Oct 1292 Caerphilly United Kingdom Jul 1337 Monmouth United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McCallum-662 21.04.2018 20:58:11 Comment Left a comment on the profile.
Noland-165 28.03.2019 06:32:36 False suggestion wikidata has same date as WikiTree (30 June 1337)
Jenner-1297
H
1758 Elizabeth Betty Lawrence (Jenner) uncertain 1723 Meysey Hampton, Gloucestershire, England uncertain Dec 1797 Meysey Hampton, Gloucestershire, England Female Wedgwood-216
Q76049413 Barbara Jenner Lane ((died 1758)) 1723 1758 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wedgwood-216 03.08.2020 21:44:05 False suggestion The name and date of death of Betty (Jenner) Lawrence given in many earlier genealogies are incorrect. Her husband died in 1758, but she lived for almost another 40 years.
Burghersh-16
H
1402 Elizabeth le Despenser (Burghersh) aka Despenser, Despencer uncertain 1342 certain Burghersh, Sussex, England uncertain 26 Jul 1409 Gloucestershire, England Female Noland-165

Fields-574
Q5363795 Elizabeth de Burghersh, 3rd Baroness Burghersh (English noblewoman, baroness) 1340s 1402 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 03.10.2019 06:29:18 False suggestion 1409 is sourced; 1402 isn't
Zouche-13
H
6 Dec 1314 Eve de Berkeley (Zouche) aka la Zouche, de Holland 8 Jan 1275 Harringworth Manor, Corby, Northamptonshire, England 5 Dec 1314 Berkeley Castle, Gloucestershire, England Female WikiTree-36

Wood-2151
Q56374114 Eve la Zouche ((1275-1314)) 6 Dec 1314 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
WOOD-2151 25.06.2019 16:38:43 Not corrected conflict between sources Wikipedia gives different date of death.
Noland-165 24.03.2020 21:18:05 False suggestion 5 dec 1314 sourced to Richardson/no source for wikidata date
Talbot-Ponsonby-1
H
6 Jan 2010 Lady Felicity Philippa Philippa Scott (Talbot-Ponsonby) certain 22 Nov 1918 certain Bloemfontein, South Africa certain 5 Jan 2010 certain Slimbridge, Gloucestershire, England, United Kingdom Female Smith-165384
Q10349155 Philippa Scott (British conservationist (1918–2010)) 22 Nov 1918 Bloemfontein South Africa 6 Jan 2010 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID6299430 31.12.2016 22:21:50 False suggestion Old False error
Dighton-45
H
1693 Frances Williams (Dighton) aka Deighton before 1 Mar 1612 certain Gloucester, Gloucestershire, England before 7 Mar 1706 certain Taunton, Bristol County, Province of Massachusetts Bay Female WikiTree-36

WikiTree-30
Q75926784 Frances Deighton ((1610-1693)) 1610 Gloucester United Kingdom 1693 Taunton United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 10.08.2020 22:04:30 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Stewart-26209
H
12 Jan 1855 Helen Olympia Cokayne (Stewart) aka Littler uncertain 1809 Ceylon certain 12 Jan 1885 'Beechwood', Painswick, Gloucestershire, England. Female Norton-2150
Q76351223 Helen Olympia Stewart (Peerage person ID=706643) 1809 12 Jan 1855 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
X-8644 14.08.2022 22:58:52 False suggestion
Popham-81
H
11 Sep 1820 R. Adm Sir Home Riggs Popham KCB KCH certain 12 Oct 1762 certain Gibraltar certain 2 Sep 1820 Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, England Male Richardson-5769
Q333951 Home Riggs Popham (Royal Navy admiral (1762-1820)) 1762 12 Oct 1762 Gibraltar Gibraltar 11 Sep 1820 Cheltenham United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-5769 01.04.2019 04:49:50 Corrected corrected date
Richardson-5769 10.04.2019 07:37:44 Corrected Fixed incorrect Wikidata date
Richardson-5769 17.04.2019 06:26:21 Corrected Fixed incorrect Wikidata date
Richardson-5769 24.04.2019 23:40:29 False suggestion Wikitree date is correct
Fry-1782
H
3 Jan 1838 Joseph Storrs Fry certain 18 Jun 1767 Narrow Wine St, Bristol, England 18 Nov 1835 Redland, Gloucestershire, England Male Andrews-13016
Q3044404 Joseph Storrs Fry (British businessman) 25 Oct 1769 3 Jan 1838 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Schwartz-2715 01.11.2022 03:26:00 False suggestion
Blathwayt-36
H
Feb 1919 Linley Blathwayt 1839 Bath, Somerset, England 17 Sep 1919 Bath, Somerset, England Male Orphan
Q62624660 Linley Blathwayt (Colonel of British Indian Army) 1839 Feb 1919 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 18.01.2022 23:46:52 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Penn-77
H
2 Dec 1750 Margaret Penn 7 Nov 1704 London, Gloucestershire, England 12 Feb 1750 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Female WikiTree-32
Q75595837 Margaretta Penn (Peerage person ID=233240) 7 Nov 1704 2 Dec 1750 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 08.09.2020 16:55:20 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Poyntz-112
H
5 Oct 1591 Mary Sydenham (Poyntz) 1558 Iron Acton, Gloucestershire, England 7 Oct 1591 Iron Acton, Gloucestershire, England Female McAdoo-199
Q75620533 Mary Poyntz (Peerage person ID=250394) 1558 5 Oct 1591 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McAdoo-199 22.05.2023 08:39:05 False suggestion
Berkeley-505
H
12 Feb 1347 Maurice de Berkeley (Berkeley) uncertain 1298 Berkeley, Gloucestershire, England certain 12 Feb 1346 Battle of Crecy, Crécy-en-Ponthieu, Picardie, France Male WikiTree-36

Felch-7
Q75418780 Sir Maurice de Berkeley ((1298-1347)) 1298 12 Feb 1347 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 04.08.2020 20:06:45 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Berkeley-42
H
Jun 1326 Sir Maurice the Magnanimous, 2nd Lord Berkeley de Berkeley (Berkeley) uncertain 1271 uncertain Gloucestershire, England certain 31 May 1326 Wallingford Castle, Oxfordshire, England Male WikiTree-36

Noland-165

Wood-2151
Q6793554 Maurice de Berkeley, 2nd Baron Berkeley (English noble and rebel) Apr 1271 Jun 1326 Wallingford Castle United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 09.09.2018 16:10:58 False suggestion clicking the Wikidata link goes to page with date of death as 31 May 1326, same as WikiTree... don't know why 1326-06 got Wikidata is shown in the error.
Noland-165 16.10.2018 23:50:07 False suggestion no source for April birth; clicking through to the wikidata page reveals it has the same death date as WikiTree's sourced 31 May 1326
Poyntz-15
H
1449 Nicholas Poyntz Esq aka Poyntz uncertain 1393 Iron Acton, Gloucestershire, England Sep 1460 Iron Acton, Gloucestershire, England Male WikiTree-36

Cochoit-2
Q75620372 Sir Nicholas Poyntz (Peerage person ID=250289) 1449 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 07.03.2020 18:09:37 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong
Tracy-243
H
4 Mar 1625 Sir Paul 1st Baronet Tracy of Stanway Tracy Bt aka Tracie Tracey before 1549 certain Stanway, Gloucestershire, England before 5 Mar 1626 certain Stanway, Gloucestershire, England Male WikiTree-57

Wood-2151

Bowen-274
Q76184008 Sir Paul Tracy, 1st Bt. ((died 1625)) 4 Mar 1625 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Fitz-Henry-9 24.04.2021 22:35:34 False suggestion Wikitree year is correct (accounting for old style calendar)
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Sudeley-14
H
1222 Sir Ralph de Sudeley (Sudeley) uncertain 1162 Sudeley Castle, Gloucestershire, England before 26 Feb 1221 Male Orphan
Q18674358 Ralph of Sudeley (English knight (d. in or before 1222)) 1162 1222 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Greet-49 08.03.2022 04:28:13 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Clifford-1545
H
28 May 1344 Sir Robert 3rd Lord Clifford de Clifford (Clifford) certain 5 Nov 1305 uncertain England certain 20 May 1344 England Male WikiTree-36

Wood-2151
Q7351393 Robert de Clifford, 3rd Baron de Clifford (British noble) 13 Nov 1305 28 May 1344 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 16.09.2018 14:49:58 False suggestion WikiTree dates are sourced
Kingscote-24
H
31 Aug 1762 Robert Fitzhardinge Kingscote certain 20 Aug 1724 certain Kingscote, Gloucestershire, England uncertain 1770 certain London, England Male Fearn-339
Q75567870 Robert Fitzhardinge Kingscote ((died 1762)) 20 Aug 1724 1731 1731 20 Aug 1724 31 Aug 1762 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Fearn-339 01.01.2023 16:30:14 False suggestion research shows that Robert was alive until at leas
Mushet-27
H
29 Jan 1891 Robert Forester Mushet certain 8 Apr 1811 certain Coleford, Gloucestershire, England, United Kingdom certain 29 Nov 1891 Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, England, United Kingdom Male Davies-5942
Q1244219 Robert Forester Mushet (British metallurgist and businessman) 8 Apr 1811 Coleford United Kingdom 29 Jan 1891 Cheltenham United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Davies-5942 13.01.2022 13:05:31 False suggestion
Davies-5942 14.02.2022 17:42:18 Comment will be dealing with this in the near future
Baynham-10
H
1499 Sir Thomas Baynham Esq. 2 Apr 1422 certain Mitcheldean, Gloucestershire, England certain 16 Feb 1500 certain England Male Orphan
Q75446288 Thomas Baynham ((1422-1499)) 9 Apr 1422 1499 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Greet-49 08.01.2023 04:43:29 False suggestion double dating
Throckmorton-87
H
1607 Sir Thomas Throckmorton MP before 1538 certain Corse, Gloucestershire, England certain 31 Jan 1608 certain Tortworth, Gloucestershire, England Male WikiTree-57

Greet-49

Wood-2151

Kezar-5
Q18672663 Thomas Throckmorton (English politician, died 1607) 1539 1607 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Greet-49 24.09.2022 03:59:15 False suggestion
Master-301
H
20 Nov 1868 Ret. Col. William Chester Master certain 4 Jan 1785 certain Cirencester, Gloucestershire, England certain 26 Nov 1868 certain Torquay, Devon, England, United Kingdom Male Huggett-431

Kiellor-4

Keillor-128
Q75540902 William Chester Master (d.1868) 4 Jan 1785 20 Nov 1868 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
keillor-128 25.05.2023 23:04:39 False suggestion
Tracy-1110
H
1173 William de Tracy (Tracy) aka Sudeley uncertain 1133 Castle Sudeley, Gloucestershire, England certain 1172 uncertain Toddington, Gloucestershire, England Male Greet-49
Q76183969 William de Sudeley (Peerage person ID=588466) 1133 1173 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Greet-49 08.03.2022 04:27:00 False suggestion Wikidata is Unsourced
Hoby-34
H
1602 William Hoby uncertain 1555 uncertain Gloucestershire, England certain 19 Mar 1603 certain Hailes, Gloucestershire, England Male Canning-229
Q76324706 William Hoby (Peerage person ID=689617) 1550 1602 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Greet-49 02.03.2023 03:39:04 False suggestion
Master-8
H
1662 Sir William Master 1600 Cirencester, Gloucestershire, England 3 Mar 1661 Cirencester, Gloucestershire, England Male Raber-23

Weaver-370

Bissett-12
Q8015220 William Master (Member of Parliament) 1600 1662 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Snow-2128 07.06.2017 09:43:39 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate and less than one year from Gedcom date
Whittington-1183
H
Jul 1379 William Whittington certain 1335 uncertain Pauntley, Gloucestershire, England uncertain 1398 uncertain Pauntley, Gloucestershire, England Male WikiTree-57
Q83144791 William Whittington (English Member of Parliament in October 1377 (d. 1379)) 1350 1335 1335 1350 Jul 1379 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Greet-49 06.05.2022 06:36:54 False suggestion