Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Mosley-970
H
Mar 1777 Anne Feilden (Mosley) uncertain Mar 1763 certain Lancashire, England certain 27 Mar 1810 certain Didsbury, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom Female Shelley-714
Q76136098 Anne Moseley ((1777-1810)) Mar 1777 1810 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 15.09.2020 14:35:56 False suggestion
Caldwell-7693
H
Feb 1739 Adm Sir Benjamin Caldwell GCB RN uncertain 31 Jan 1739 certain Liverpool, Lancashire, England before 4 Nov 1820 certain Basingstoke, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom Male Orphan
Q2896020 Benjamin Caldwell (British Royal Navy admiral (1739-1820)) Feb 1739 Liverpool United Kingdom Nov 1820 Basingstoke United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Fehd-10 29.08.2023 00:56:24 False suggestion MORE SPECIFIC BIRTH DATE
Plantagenet-104
H
25 Mar 1342 Blanche Countess of Derby, Duchess of Lancaster of Lancaster (Plantagenet) uncertain 1341 Lancaster, Lancashire, England certain 12 Sep 1368 Tutbury Castle, Staffordshire, England Female WikiTree-113
Q238334 Blanche of Lancaster (English noblewoman and heiress, died 1368) 25 Mar 1342 Bolingbroke Castle United Kingdom 12 Sep 1368 Tutbury Castle United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID3986582 27.03.2017 06:38:39 False suggestion Protected project
Smith-154149
H
3 May 1896 Dorothy Gladys Dodie Beesley (Smith) 2 Mar 1896 Whitefield, Bury, Lancashire, England 24 Nov 1990 Uttlesford, Essex, England Female Haywood-41
Q449085 Dodie Smith (English children's novelist and playwright) 3 May 1896 Whitefield United Kingdom 24 Nov 1990 Finchingfield United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Haywood-41 22.05.2019 17:39:45 False suggestion
Simon-3926
H
1880 Lady Eleanor Christadora Hamilton (Simon) Jan 1882 Didsbury, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom 6 May 1958 Suffolk, England, United Kingdom Female Miall-40
Q76149087 Eleanor Christadora Simon ((1880-1958)) 1880 6 May 1958 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Miall-40 03.02.2022 11:45:49 Not corrected Wikidata date is incorrect
Miall-40 28.09.2023 17:52:33 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Knipe-87
H
1764 Elizabeth Cobbold (Knipe) aka Clarke before 6 Mar 1765 uncertain London, England uncertain 17 Oct 1824 uncertain Ipswich, Suffolk, England Female Palmer-9783
Q18528540 Elizabeth Cobbold (English poet, artist, geologist) 1764 London United Kingdom 1824 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Palmer-9783 26.11.2022 14:06:26 False suggestion WikiData is incorrect, see sources on WikiTree profile
Bell-32507
H
1765 Elizabeth Crompton (Bell) certain 1764 Manchester, Lancashire, England 1807 Derby, Derbyshire, England Female Heathcote-126
Q76182591 Elizabeth Bell ((died 1807)) 1765 1807 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Heathcote-126 04.05.2021 10:51:11 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Bromley-106
H
1583 Elizabeth Cromwell (Bromley) certain 1566 Lathom, Lancashire, England certain 1603 Hinchingbrooke, Huntingdonshire, England Female Urschel-11
Q76273045 Elizabeth Bromley (Peerage person ID=654130) 1583 1658 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gambie-2 05.06.2023 18:09:00 False suggestion
Mosley-44
H
Mar 1773 Frances Mary Parker Smith (Mosley) certain 19 Feb 1773 certain Manchester, Lancashire, England certain 5 Jul 1844 certain Heathfield, Sussex, England, United Kingdom Female Shelley-714
Q61610896 Frances Mary Mosley ((1773-1844)) Mar 1773 5 Jul 1844 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 28.04.2019 22:15:45 Comment Where did this come from???
Shelley-714 02.01.2020 05:29:32 Corrected Removed date, DOB ranges between 1767 - Mar 1773
Shelley-714 11.02.2020 13:04:42 False suggestion
Ball-16695
H
30 Nov 1859 Frederick Ball certain 1860 Lenton, Nottinghamshire, England, United Kingdom 26 Jul 1915 Blackpool, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom Male Parker-41651
Q47476823 Frederick Ball ((1860-1914)) 30 Nov 1859 30 Nov 1913 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parker-41651 28.09.2021 23:00:12 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Dibnah-16
H
28 Apr 1938 Frederick Travis Dibnah certain 29 Apr 1938 Bolton, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom certain 6 Nov 2004 Bolton, Greater Manchester, England, United Kingdom Male Bronks-59
Q5494999 Fred Dibnah (English steeplejack and television personality, with a keen interest in mechanical engineering) 28 Apr 1938 Bolton United Kingdom 6 Nov 2004 Greater Manchester United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Whitfield-2424 24.01.2024 18:30:53 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Mullin-1272
H
15 Aug 1892 George Harry Mullin VC certain 15 Aug 1891 certain Portland, Multnomah, Oregon, United States certain 5 Apr 1963 certain Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada Male Thompson-40998

WikiTree-58
Q3101781 George Mullin (Canadian recipient of the Victoria Cross (1892-1963)) 15 Aug 1892 Portland United States of America 5 Apr 1963 Regina Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thompson-40998 27.11.2019 18:37:34 False suggestion
Stanley-6291
H
17 Dec 1630 Henrietta Mary Countess of Strafford Wentworth (Stanley) certain 17 Nov 1630 certain Ormskirk, Lancashire, England certain 27 Dec 1685 certain Ormskirk, Lancashire, England Female Gray-8215
Q75939887 Lady Henrietta Maria Stanley (Peerage person ID=416533) 17 Dec 1630 27 Dec 1685 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gray-8215 01.12.2022 02:02:08 False suggestion WikiData is wrong. See www.findagrave.com/memorial/102844052/henrietta-maria-wentworth
Gray-8215 01.12.2022 02:04:29 False suggestion
Pierrepoint-6
H
1874 Henry Albert Pierrepoint certain 30 Nov 1877 Normanton on Soar, Nottinghamshire, England, United Kingdom uncertain 14 Dec 1922 certain Failsworth, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom Male Pierpoint-129
Q1607158 Henry Pierrepoint (British executioner) 1874 Normanton on Soar United Kingdom 14 Dec 1922 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parker-41651 10.11.2021 15:30:13 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, if born as early as 1874 he would have been older on 1881 census (recorded as 3 years old)
Every-Clayton-4
H
1851 Henry Every-Clayton certain 17 Jan 1849 Carr Hall, Barrowford, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom certain 18 Jan 1936 20 Hyde Road, Blackpool, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom Male Shelley-714
Q75916895 Henry Every-Clayton ((born 1851)) 1851 18 Jan 1936 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 25.02.2020 04:14:54 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Jones-112762
H
20 Sep 1777 Hugh Jones certain 20 Sep 1776 uncertain Wrexham, Denbighshire, Wales uncertain 1842 uncertain Kensington, Middlesex, England, United Kingdom Male Connolly-2986
Q75241010 Hugh Jones (English banker) 20 Sep 1777 1842 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hardy-7997 31.07.2022 18:03:26 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Hardy-7997 31.07.2022 18:04:02 False suggestion Data Doctor - Error 555: Wikidata - Different birt
Smyth-2978
H
15 Feb 1834 Hugh Lyle Smyth uncertain 15 Nov 1834 Ireland certain 25 May 1911 Liverpool, Lancashire, England Male Wilson-67373
Q5931545 Hugh Lyle Smyth (businessperson) 15 Feb 1834 Derry United Kingdom 25 May 1911 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wilson-67373 26.02.2024 19:33:49 Not corrected No source available currently for exact DOB
Wilson-67373 31.03.2024 19:11:40 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Larkin-824
H
21 Jan 1876 James Big Jim Larkin certain 21 Jan 1874 certain Liverpool, Lancashire, England 30 Jan 1947 Dublin, County Dublin, Ireland Male Larkin-764
Q1583571 James Larkin (Irish socialist and trade union leader) 21 Jan 1876 Liverpool United Kingdom 30 Jan 1947 Dublin Republic of Ireland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
X-8644 05.01.2022 14:56:35 False suggestion
Potter-3399
H
1776 James Potter before 29 Dec 1775 certain Manchester, Lancashire, England 1821 England, United Kingdom Male Partridge-1859
Q75553599 James Potter ((1776-1821)) 1776 1821 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Partridge-1859 16.01.2021 20:38:58 False suggestion Original birthdate was correct, proven by baptism record; Wikidata record did not have a primary source.
Booth-199
H
1319 John de Booth (Booth) uncertain 1270 Lancashire, England after 1343 England Male Cochoit-2
Q75558941 John Booth (Peerage person ID=212099) 1319 1390 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 18.02.2022 03:01:48 False suggestion
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Hibbert-315
H
1732 John Hibbert certain 7 Apr 1731 certain Manchester, Lancashire, England certain Aug 1769 certain Agualta Vale, Saint Mary, Jamaica Male Lowry-3068
Q96185858 John Hibbert (of Jamaica, d. 1769) 1732 1769 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lowry-3068 22.08.2020 03:01:18 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Tryon-5674
H
1 Jul 1914 John Jack Tryon 10 Jul 1914 Lancashire, England, United Kingdom 17 Feb 1958 Parksville, British Columbia, Canada Male Tryon-2537
Q75374844 John Tryon ((1914-1958)) 1 Jul 1914 17 Feb 1958 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mutter-136 11.05.2021 20:52:04 False suggestion Using DOB from death registration source. No additional evidence provided on Wikidata.
Barton-420
H
1330 Loretta del Booth (Barton) aka de Barton uncertain 1275 Eccles, Lancashire, England after Female Athey-67
Q75558943 Loretta Barton (Peerage person ID=212100) 1330 1370 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 18.02.2022 02:55:26 False suggestion
Feilden-63
H
20 May 1835 Louisa Willis Feilden 12 Apr 1835 Blackburn, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom 26 Mar 1868 Hereford, Herefordshire, England, United Kingdom Female Shelley-714
Q76113882 Louisa Willis Fielden ((1835-1868)) 20 May 1835 1868 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 02.01.2020 09:08:20 False suggestion Suggested date is baptism date not DOB
Kurtz-1877
H
11 Apr 1861 Lucy Cometina Lúsaoi Hyde (Kurtz) aka Bean de hÍde certain 30 Jun 1861 Liverpool, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom certain 31 Dec 1938 certain Ratra, County Roscommon, Ireland Female Hennigan-514
Q6698245 Lucy Cometina Kurtz (Wife of Douglas Hyde, 1st President of Ireland (1861-1938)) 11 Apr 1861 Berlin Germany 31 Dec 1938 Frenchpark Republic of Ireland female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hennigan-514 17.01.2023 00:17:15 False suggestion DOB is Sourced.
Gregg-Hopwood-1
H
9 Apr 1814 Mary Augusta Molyneux (Gregg-Hopwood) aka Gregge-Hopwood certain 19 Apr 1814 certain Hopwood, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom certain 5 Oct 1906 certain Kirkby, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom Female Horner-437
Q75271759 Mary Gregg-Hopwood ((1814-1906)) 9 Apr 1814 5 Oct 1906 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Churm-1 16.12.2021 18:37:42 False suggestion
Howgill-9
H
1623 Mary Howgill uncertain 1620 Lancashire, England after 1662 Female Cayley-55
Q26997581 Mary Howgill ((1620-1662)) 1623 1681 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 14.01.2021 09:52:16 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Towneley-1
H
13 May 1614 Mary Warner (Towneley) before 15 May 1614 Colne, Lancashire, England certain 11 Aug 1662 Warner Hall, Gloucester, Colony of Virginia Female Stough-48

Scrutchin-1

WikiTree-36

WikiTree-6

Sigmund-6
Q75494717 Mary Towneley ((1614-1662)) 13 May 1614 11 Aug 1662 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 09.06.2020 22:20:45 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Master-103
H
1884 Mildred Estelle Sybella Assheton (Master) CBE certain 12 Apr 1876 Bellary, Madras, India certain 18 Aug 1949 Clitheroe, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom Female Shelley-714
Q75512046 Mildred Estelle Sybella Master ((1884-1949)) 1884 18 Aug 1949 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 02.01.2020 00:22:56 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Crumpe-18
H
3 Feb 1803 Nathaniel Bland (Crumpe) 6 Oct 1803 Liverpool, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom certain 10 Aug 1865 certain Hombourg, Haut-Rhin, Alsace, France Male Falvey-115
Q1966718 Nathaniel Bland (British orientalist (1803-1865)) 3 Feb 1803 Liverpool United Kingdom 10 Aug 1865 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Falvey-115 23.07.2020 10:08:42 False suggestion WikiData is using secondary source
Mather-208
H
20 Mar 1630 Rev. Nathaniel Mather MA 20 Mar 1631 Much Woolton, Lancashire, England 26 Jul 1697 Whitechapel, London, England Male Coleman-5109
Q16499791 Nathaniel Mather (American colonial clergy) 20 Mar 1630 1697 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Coleman-5109 17.07.2018 15:01:13 Corrected changed to 1631 (1630/1) but possibly 1629/30 , the ODNB uses 1630
Coleman-5109 11.02.2020 17:58:07 False suggestion false suggestion wikidata using Julian calendar
Mosley-570
H
1693 Nicholas Mosley aka Moseley uncertain 1688 Holborn, Middlesex, England certain 12 Mar 1734 certain Manchester, Lancashire, England Male Smith-122965

Shelley-714
Q76135908 Nicholas Moseley (Peerage person ID=556076) 1693 1734 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Soofie-1 23.01.2024 08:11:13 False suggestion
Heywood-720
H
1630 Rev. Oliver Heywood certain 4 Mar 1629 certain Little Lever, Bolton, Lancashire, England certain 4 May 1702 certain Northowram, Yorkshire, England Male Wattie-111

Blomfield-390

James-11261
Q7087600 Oliver Heywood (English minister) 1630 1702 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Blomfield-390 11.02.2023 03:03:47 False suggestion
Fiennes-Clinton-32
H
18 Jul 1839 Osbert Fiennes-Clinton before 29 Aug 1839 Cromwell, Nottinghamshire, England certain 7 Nov 1900 Chorlton, Lancashire, England Male McCarthy-2108
Q75857355 Osbert Fynes-Clinton ((1839-1900)) 18 Jul 1839 7 Nov 1900 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parker-41651 13.10.2021 12:18:57 False suggestion Both are correct as wikitree is 'before' baptism date. Date on wikidata is only sourced from the peerage.
Clegg-506
H
19 Mar 1874 Lady Quenelda Mary Royden (Clegg) aka Williamson certain 4 Feb 1874 uncertain Ashton-under-Lyne, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom 17 Feb 1969 uncertain Liss, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
Q75608473 Quenelda Mary Clegg ((1874-1969)) 19 Mar 1874 17 Feb 1969 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hardy-7997 02.08.2022 11:37:06 False suggestion WikiData is wrong; date is of her baptism
Hardy-7997 02.08.2022 11:37:38 False suggestion Data Doctor - Error 555: Wikidata - Different birt
Croshaw-6
H
1584 Captain Raleigh Rawly Croshaw Esquire aka Crashaw, Crowshaw uncertain 1580 uncertain Crashaw, Lancashire, England before 27 Dec 1624 certain Elizabeth City, Jamestown, Colony of Virginia Male Emery-2445

Snow-2128

Myers-2993
Q7286907 Raleigh Croshaw (American politician) 1584 Lancashire United Kingdom 1624 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Spradley-150 28.09.2021 04:47:32 False suggestion Submitted edit to FindAGrave to disconnect wrong parents
Milnes-51
H
21 Mar 1696 Richard Milnes 21 Apr 1695 Wakefield, Yorkshire, England 4 Feb 1755 Derby, Derbyshire, England Male Mosley-217
Q75594220 Richard Milnes ((born 1696)) 21 Mar 1696 4 Feb 1755 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Heathcote-126 23.06.2020 18:23:39 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Dickinson-3914
H
1835 Robert M. Dickinson before 4 Feb 1836 certain Liverpool, Lancashire, England certain 1 Nov 1889 certain New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada Male McCarthy-2108

Parkes-654

Crofton-57
Q7343533 Robert Dickinson (Canadian businessman and political figure in British Columbia) 1835 1 Nov 1889 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID6068317 14.02.2017 08:15:44 False suggestion Old False error
Milnes-264
H
3 May 1718 Robert Milnes certain 2 Mar 1719 Liverpool, Lancashire, England certain 15 Apr 1771 Wakefield, Yorkshire, England Male Heathcote-126
Q75594225 Robert Milnes (Peerage person ID=232431) 3 May 1718 Apr 1771 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Heathcote-126 15.02.2022 11:14:03 Corrected
Heathcote-126 22.02.2022 12:42:22 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Staniforth-135
H
26 Feb 1769 Samuel Staniforth 26 Mar 1769 Liverpool, Lancashire, England 5 Apr 1851 Liverpool, Lancashire, England Male Welburn-134
Q30345373 Samuel Staniforth (Liverpool slave-trader, merchant and local politician (1769-1851)) 26 Feb 1769 5 Apr 1851 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Welburn-134 31.03.2020 11:52:25 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Segrave-17
H
1171 Sir Stephen de Segrave (Segrave) 1179 Segrave, Lancashire, England 9 Nov 1241 Barton, Lancashire, England Male Lamoreaux-297
Q3498645 Stephen de Segrave (English justice and administrator) 1171 9 Nov 1241 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 28.10.2020 14:52:56 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Stanley-421
H
2 Aug 1406 Sir Thomas 1st Lord Stanley Stanley KG uncertain 1405 certain Lancashire, England certain 11 Feb 1459 certain Lancashire, England Male WikiTree-36

Fields-574
Q456361 Thomas Stanley, 1st Baron Stanley (English peer and King of Mann (1406-1459)) 2 Aug 1406 11 Feb 1459 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 17.09.2018 19:23:03 False suggestion wikidata cites DNB but DNB source not found & Wikipedia article has c1405
Parr-50
H
1478 Sir Thomas Parr aka Perye, Parye 1483 Kendal Castle, Kendal, Westmorland, England 12 Nov 1517 Prescot, Lancashire, , England Male Orphan
Q7529231 Sir Thomas Parr (English knight) 1478 1517 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gunn-471 19.04.2017 04:52:55 False suggestion Matches wikipedia birth date
Barcroft-112
H
4 Aug 1612 William Barcroft certain 4 Oct 1612 Noyna Near Colne, Lancashire, England 2 Apr 1696 Drumcooley, Offaly, Ireland Male Watson-7240
Q75643257 William Barcroft ((1612-1696)) 4 Aug 1612 2 Feb 1696 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Watson-7240 16.10.2022 12:21:03 False suggestion
Gilpin-369
H
4 Oct 1813 Gov. William Gilpin Sr certain 4 Oct 1814 certain Yealand Conyers, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom certain 20 Jan 1894 certain Denver, Denver, Colorado, USA Male Stamper-1306
Q2578969 William Gilpin (American politician (1813–1894)) 4 Oct 1813 Wilmington United States of America 20 Jan 1893 20 Jan 1894 Denver United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Crawford-15512 19.03.2019 04:57:58 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Stanley-10276
H
18 Oct 1640 William Stanley certain 28 Nov 1640 certain Ormskirk, Lancashire, England certain 25 Oct 1670 certain Ormskirk, Lancashire, England Male Gray-8215
Q8018725 William Stanley (Member of Parliament) 18 Oct 1640 25 Oct 1670 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gray-8215 05.07.2021 02:54:13 Corrected Changed DOB
Gray-8215 12.02.2022 07:42:29 Corrected Adjusted birth date
Gray-8215 16.02.2022 07:15:01 False suggestion WikiData is wrong. His father confirmed DoB in the Diary of James 7th Earl of Derby.