Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 558: Wikidata - Different death date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Carpenter-423
H
1690 Alice Els, Elsge Bradford (Carpenter) aka Southworth before Oct 1589 uncertain Somerset, England uncertain 26 Mar 1670 certain Plymouth, Plymouth Colony Female Zoglman-1

Walter-1903

WikiTree-9

Hanson-1601

Breland-1

Kennedy-1763

Putnam-327
Q75765184 Alice Carpenter (Peerage person ID=322472) 1690 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 13.12.2020 05:42:48 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Paulet-39
H
1538 Sir Amyas Amias Paulet aka Pawlet, Pawlett uncertain 1454 certain Hinton St George, Somerset, England 10 Apr 1537 certain Chaffcombe, Somerset, England Male Greet-49
Q18670717 Amias Paulet (English landowner and soldier) 1457 1538 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Greet-49 07.05.2020 09:41:40 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Calvert-2377
H
31 Jan 1812 Ann Anstey (Calvert) certain 7 May 1732 London, England before 7 Feb 1812 Sion Hill, Somerset, England Female Smith-165384
Q75760462 Anne Calvert ((1732-1812)) 7 May 1732 31 Jan 1812 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 02.02.2022 23:46:18 False suggestion Wikidata gives no source
Hippisley-45
H
1651 Dorothy Pole (Hippisley) uncertain 15 Jun 1589 Ston Easton, Somerset, England 1652 Talaton, Devon, England Female Falvey-115
Q76369286 Dorothy Hippisley ((1589-1651)) 1589 1651 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Falvey-115 10.03.2020 09:44:02 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong
Squire-1
H
1673 Edith Adams (Squire) aka Fussell certain 29 May 1587 certain Charlton Mackrell, Somerset, England certain 21 Jan 1672 certain Medfield, Suffolk, Massachusetts Bay Colony Female Zoglman-1

WikiTree-6

WikiTree-30

Quinn-346

Soliday-33

Adams-12030
Q96197554 Edith Squire (-1673) 29 May 1587 1673 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 11.12.2020 00:16:32 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Dunkeld-76
H
1100 Edmund Edmund I King of Scots (Dunkeld) 1070 Scotland after 1097 certain Montacute, Somerset, England Male Perkins-11750

WikiTree-65
Q729517 Edmund of Scotland (Scottish prince) 11cen 1100 Montacute United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 22.11.2020 21:31:11 False suggestion no sources, death date is disputed
Englefield-102
H
30 Nov 1547 Elizabeth White (Englefield) aka Inglefield uncertain 1475 uncertain Englefield, Berkshire, England 1548 Marriot, Somerset, England Female Orphan
Q107597404 Elizabeth White (Inglefield) "The Elder" ((1475-1548)) 30 Nov 1474 30 Nov 1547 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Greet-49 08.03.2022 04:35:28 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Pierrepont-91
H
23 Sep 1773 Evelyn 2nd Duke of Kingston-upon-Hull Pierrepont KG 3 Apr 1712 England certain 22 Sep 1773 Bath, Somerset, England Male Rowe-6599
Q5416407 Evelyn Pierrepont, 2nd Duke of Kingston-upon-Hull (English nobleman and landowner (1711-1773)) 1711 Nottingham United Kingdom 23 Sep 1773 Bath United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rowe-6599 30.07.2019 18:07:15 False suggestion Probably Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Younghusband-83
H
4 Feb 1863 Frances Younghusband certain 9 Nov 1816 Berwick-upon-Tweed, Northumberland, England certain 5 Feb 1863 Freshford, Somerset, England, United Kingdom Female Bates-10490
Q75788491 Frances Younghusband ((1816-1863)) 22 Nov 1816 4 Feb 1863 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bates-10490 18.11.2023 13:14:50 False suggestion date is clear on church memorial so wikidata is wrong
Cardew-45
H
8 Sep 1853 Frederic Cardew certain 1808 certain Curry Mallet, Somerset, England certain 19 Sep 1853 certain Allahabad, Bengal, India Male Farler-25
Q96086102 Frederick Campbell Cardew ((1808-1853)) 2 Apr 1808 8 Sep 1853 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Farler-25 02.11.2020 15:29:35 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Otis-81
H
25 Jan 1676 Hannah Gill (Otis) aka Gile certain 16 Aug 1618 certain Glastonbury, Somerset, England certain 25 Jan 1675 certain Hingham, Suffolk, Massachusetts Bay Colony Female Barton-7380
Q115903546 Hannah Gill (16 Aug 1618 - 25 Jan 1676) 25 Jan 1676 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
barton-7380 03.04.2024 22:07:32 False suggestion Georgian Dates in data
Pearson-7063
H
21 May 1831 Hannah Laycock (Pearson) uncertain 1757 Bristol, Somerset, England certain 5 May 1831 Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Female Duncan-7561
Q76018915 Hannah Pearson ((1757-1831)) 1757 21 May 1831 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 12:55:08 False suggestion Wikitree date is sourced
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 23:35:03 Comment Wikidata needs to be corrected
Burke-10022
H
15 Nov 1881 Henrietta Louisa Hetty Casement (Burke) 6 Apr 1860 Shepton Mallet, Somerset, England, United Kingdom 3 Nov 1881 Ballycastle, County Antrim, Ireland Female C-685
Q75889604 Henrietta Louisa Burke ((1860-1881)) 6 Apr 1860 15 Nov 1881 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
C-685 12.02.2022 13:26:45 False suggestion 15 Nov. was the date of burial
Elton-423
H
16 Feb 1829 Henry Elton certain 16 Feb 1779 England certain Dec 1829 England Male Farler-25
Q75912068 Henry Elton ((1778-1829)) 1778 16 Feb 1829 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Farler-25 02.11.2020 15:28:21 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
FitzRoger-62
H
1351 Henry FitzRoger 30 Nov 1318 Curry Rivel, Somerset, England 29 Jan 1352 Chewton, Somerset, England Male WikiTree-36
Q75442664 Sir Henry FitzRoger ((1318-1351)) 1318 1351 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
thiessen-117 06.03.2020 19:51:46 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Bayntun-5
H
16 Dec 1840 Adm Sir Henry William Bayntun 1766 Algiers 17 Dec 1840 Bath, Somerset, England Male Mackinnon-507
Q5730189 Henry William Bayntun (British admiral (1766-1840)) 1766 Algiers Algeria 16 Dec 1840 Bath United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
mackinnon-507 18.11.2021 19:12:25 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced DNB says 17th also unsourced
Smith-215522
H
31 Dec 1901 Lady Isabella Duckett (Smith) uncertain 1822 England certain 13 Dec 1901 certain Somerset, England Female Hunt-2329
Q76170659 Isabella Smith ((died 1901)) 1822 31 Dec 1901 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hunt-2329 23.12.2020 13:32:58 False suggestion Wikitree date is correct
Lowell-106
H
18 Jun 1677 Joanna Gerrish (Lowell) aka Oliver uncertain 1615 certain Bristol, Somerset, England certain 14 Jun 1677 certain Newbury, Essex, Massachusetts Female WikiTree-30

Bairfield-1
Q87838193 Joanna Lowell (F; born 1619; died 1677 June 18) 1619 18 Jun 1677 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
X-3336 03.01.2022 20:21:13 False suggestion
Bluett-16
H
28 Nov 1634 John Bluett aka Bluet, Blewett 31 Aug 1603 Holcombe Court, Holcombe Rogus, Devon, England 29 Nov 1634 Holcombe Rogus, Devon, England Male Farler-25
Q6222275 John Bluett (English politician) 1603 28 Nov 1634 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Farler-25 11.03.2021 15:30:19 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced. Source ( his tomb) gives 29th as date.
Cayley-138
H
1900 John Cayley certain 11 Feb 1816 Bath, Somerset, England certain 19 Nov 1899 Christchurch, Hampshire, England Male Orphan
Q75559368 John Cayley ((1816-1900)) 11 Feb 1816 1900 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 22.03.2021 11:50:35 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Oliver-1026
H
1675 John Oliver 1613 Bristol, Somerset, England before Jun 1642 Newbury, Essex, Massachusetts Male WikiTree-30

Wiltshire-219
Q96076868 John Oliver ((1613-1675)) 1613 Bristol United Kingdom 1675 Newbury United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 11.01.2024 07:38:40 False suggestion
Seymour-42
H
30 Nov 1382 Lettice Seymour uncertain 1355 Hatch, Somerset, England after 1383 England Female Noland-165
Q99084364 Lettice Seymour (St.Maur) ((1355-1383)) 30 Nov 1354 30 Nov 1382 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 19.10.2021 09:08:59 False suggestion bizarreness of wikidata dates
Blathwayt-36
H
Feb 1919 Linley Blathwayt 1839 Bath, Somerset, England 17 Sep 1919 Bath, Somerset, England Male Orphan
Q62624660 Linley Blathwayt (Colonel of British Indian Army) 1839 Feb 1919 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 18.01.2022 23:46:52 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Gurney-1402
H
28 Mar 1932 Margaret Hanson Masterman (Gurney) uncertain 23 Apr 1841 Camberwell, Surrey, England, United Kingdom certain 29 Mar 1932 Wells, Somerset, England, United Kingdom Female Miall-40
Q96081273 Margaret Hanson Gurney ((1841-1932)) 23 Apr 1841 28 Mar 1932 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Miall-40 24.04.2023 17:32:29 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Chiselden-1
H
30 Nov 1473 Margaret Wadham (Chiselden) uncertain 1390 Devon, England 1474 Merrifield, Somerset, England Female Cochoit-2
Q105820818 Margaret Cheseldon ((1375-1474)) 30 Nov 1374 30 Nov 1473 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 24.01.2024 03:00:48 False suggestion
Whetham-56
H
1894 Maria Agatha Boddam-Whetham (Whetham) certain 1818 certain Wraxall, Somerset, England certain 21 Oct 1895 Warwick, Warwickshire, England, United Kingdom Female Cook-32010
Q75595328 Maria Agatha Whetham ((1818-1894)) 1818 1894 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parker-41651 07.10.2021 17:21:11 False suggestion Wikitree date is supported by probate record
Wyvill-30
H
23 Sep 1918 Sir Marmaduke Asty 7th Baronet Wyvill of Constable Burton Wyvill Bt 1740 1774 Bath, Somerset, England Male Orphan
Q6772042 Marmaduke D'Arcy Wyvill (British politician (1849-1918)) 5 Mar 1849 23 Sep 1918 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bulmer-1043 17.01.2022 00:44:54 False suggestion
Peyvre-1
H
26 Jul 1409 Mary St Maur (Peyvre) aka Broughton certain 1382 certain Toddington, Bedfordshire, England certain 25 Jul 1409 certain Castle Cary, North Cadbury, Somerset, England Female Acworth-41
Q76100297 Mary Peyvre (Peerage person ID=530721) 1382 26 Jul 1409 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Acworth-41 29.01.2024 07:00:12 False suggestion
Thatcher-114
H
1641 Rev Peter Thatcher aka Thacher certain 6 Mar 1588 Queen Camel, Somerset, England 11 Feb 1640 St. Edmunds, Salisbury, Wiltshire, England Male Smith-318599
Q18534875 Peter Thatcher (Church of England clergyman 1587/8–1641) 1587 1641 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Smith-318599 20.12.2023 00:10:41 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Unknown-137762
H
28 Dec 1645 Rebecca Lowell (Unknown) aka Lowle uncertain 1575 certain 28 Feb 1645 certain Newbury, Essex, Massachusetts Female WikiTree-30

Hill-11959

Hoyt-576
Q96076442 Rebecca ((born 1645)) 1575 28 Dec 1645 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hoyt-576 19.10.2020 23:06:43 False suggestion julian calendar
Randolph-9
H
1749 Colonel Richard Randolph 2 May 1686 Turkey Island, Henrico County, Colony of Virginia 17 Dec 1748 Bath, Somerset, England Male WikiTree-24

Price-5385

Myers-2401

Athey-67
Q7328595 Richard Randolph (American politician) 1691 1749 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rish-15 06.09.2017 01:49:46 False suggestion Dates are correct on profile
Rish-15 12.09.2017 14:56:04 False suggestion Other dates are just guessed years.
Treat-10
H
14 Feb 1669 Capt. Richard Treat Esq. aka Trott, Treet certain 28 Aug 1584 certain Pitminster, Somerset, England after 11 Oct 1669 certain Wethersfield, Hartford, Connecticut Colony Male Harrington-1921

WikiTree-30

Hill-7181

Harrington-1886
Q16863810 Richard Treat (American city founder (1584-1669)) 28 Aug 1584 Pitminster United Kingdom 14 Feb 1669 Wethersfield United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Smith-32867 23.04.2019 12:23:25 False suggestion Wipiedia provides no source for death date
Willoughby-296
H
28 Sep 1502 Robert 1st Baron Willoughby of Broke Willoughby KG certain 1452 uncertain Clutton, Somerset, England certain 23 Aug 1502 certain Callington, Cornwall, England Male Bairfield-1
Q7351141 Robert Willoughby, 1st Baron Willoughby de Broke (English commander against Cornish rebels for Henry VII) 1452 Westbury United Kingdom 28 Sep 1502 Callington United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McCallum-662 21.04.2018 23:34:07 Comment Left a comment on the profile.
Cayley-55 05.01.2020 10:05:33 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Day-1904 06.01.2020 14:39:45 Comment Richardson has an August death date, ODNB and Wikidata have a September birth date. We have examined the IPMs which are the primary source, and the preponderence of evidence favors August.
Hungerford-5
H
14 May 1459 Sir Robert 2nd Lord Hungerford Hungerford uncertain 1409 uncertain Farleigh Hungerford, Somerset, England certain 18 May 1459 England Male WikiTree-36
Q7345699 Robert Hungerford, 2nd Baron Hungerford (English nobleman) 1409 14 May 1459 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Chittem-20 03.05.2017 10:49:53 Not corrected Date corrected as per Wikidata-Date shown was probably burial date.
Chittem-20 03.05.2017 10:51:13 False suggestion Corrected
Elliston-15
H
7 Jul 1831 Robert William Elliston certain 8 Apr 1774 certain Bloomsbury, London, England certain 8 Jul 1831 certain Blackfriars, London, England, United Kingdom Male Elliston-395
Q1432748 Robert William Elliston (British actor (1774-1831)) 7 Apr 1774 London United Kingdom 7 Jul 1831 London United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Elliston-395 22.11.2023 12:41:26 False suggestion
Ludlow-37
H
1664 Roger Ludlow before 7 Mar 1590 uncertain Dinton, Wiltshire, England uncertain 1666 uncertain Dublin, Ireland Male WikiTree-36

WikiTree-30
Q7358553 Roger Ludlow (English lawyer, founder and deputy governor of Connecticut Colony) Mar 1590 Dinton United Kingdom 1664 Dublin Republic of Ireland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 05.09.2019 01:10:50 False suggestion WikiTree profile sources 1665/1666 probably death date; wikidata has 0 references for 1664 death date
Conway-886
H
1800 Brig Gen Thomas Conway 27 Feb 1735 Cloghane, County Kerry, Ireland certain 26 Feb 1795 certain Bath, Somerset, England Male Falvey-115

N.-17
Q2330005 Thomas Conway (American general) 27 Feb 1735 Ireland Ireland Republic of Ireland United Kingdom 1800 Republic of Ireland Republic of Ireland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Falvey-115 28.06.2018 22:00:25 False suggestion Wikidata gives no source
Gaisford-16
H
2 Jun 1855 Very Rev. Thomas Gaisford certain 22 Dec 1779 certain Tockenham, Wiltshire, England certain 3 Jun 1855 Christ Church College, Oxford, Oxfordshire, England Male Orphan
Q2424118 Thomas Gaisford (English classical scholar) 22 Dec 1779 Wiltshire United Kingdom 2 Jun 1855 Oxford United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID4551504 09.12.2016 20:19:33 False suggestion Old False error
Trowbridge-9
H
1672 Thomas Trowbridge certain Apr 1598 certain Taunton, Somerset, England certain 7 Feb 1673 certain Taunton, Somerset, England Male Cochoit-2

Trowbridge-764

WikiTree-30

Lahr-19

Thompson-9881
Q96199046 Thomas Trowbridge (Mar 1598 Taunton, Somerset - 7 Feb 1672 Taunton, Somerset) 1598 1672 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cole-12288 22.01.2021 17:31:03 Corrected Corrected parents in WikiData; sent update to genealogics
cochoit-2 15.07.2021 20:54:27 False suggestion Double dating error by Wikidata
Portman-97
H
1646 William 5th Baronet Portman of Orchard Portman Portman MP certain 1608 Orchard Portman, Somerset, England Sep 1645 Orchard Portman, Somerset, England Male Mackinnon-507
Q7529732 Sir William Portman, 5th Baronet (English politician) 1646 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mackinnon-507 09.04.2024 09:20:53 False suggestion
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Arnold-18
H
1674 William Arnold certain 24 Jun 1587 certain Ilchester, Somerset, England before 3 Nov 1677 certain Pawtucket, Providence, Rhode Island Male Williams-25982

WikiTree-30

Ridgley-10

Fillingim-12
Q8004555 William Arnold (English settler of the Colony of Rhode Island) 24 Jun 1587 1586 Ilchester United Kingdom 1674 1676 Pawtuxet Village United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cole-12288 14.02.2020 04:53:46 Comment WikiTree profile is using a documented fact to support the date estimate
Williams-25982 03.07.2020 21:05:51 Not corrected No source available currently for exact DOB
Williams-25982 31.07.2020 19:17:46 False suggestion There are conflicting sources for death date.