Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Harding-4770
H
2 Jan 1805 Aaron Harding certain 20 Feb 1805 Campbellsville, Taylor, Kentucky, United States 24 Dec 1875 Georgetown, Scott, Kentucky, United States Male Nibling-2
Q302082 Aaron Harding (American politician (1805-1875)) 2 Jan 1805 Campbellsville United States of America 24 Dec 1875 Georgetown United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Nibling-2 23.05.2018 19:51:35 False suggestion WikiData is wrong; DOB is based on headstone
Truman-5
H
16 Feb 1816 Anderson Shipp Truman 18 Feb 1816 Shelby County, Kentucky 3 Jul 1887 Grandview, Jackson County, Missouri Male WikiTree-6

McDougle-1
Q75766429 Anderson Shipp Truman ((1816-1887)) 16 Feb 1816 3 Jul 1887 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 11.12.2019 21:15:46 False suggestion Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced
Shelton-8883
H
1 Jan 1902 Benjamin Frank Shelton 4 Jul 1900 Clay County, Kentucky, United States 28 Feb 1963 Corbin, Whitley County, Kentucky, United States Male Craig-4574

WikiTree-130
Q4833983 B. F. Shelton (American musician) 1 Jan 1902 Clay County United States of America 28 Feb 1963 Whitley County United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 12.07.2023 21:03:51 Corrected Corrected
Craig-4574 20.07.2023 20:25:25 Corrected edit birth date
Craig-4574 20.09.2023 12:53:57 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Ballard-2942
H
16 Oct 1761 Major Bland Williams Ballard certain 16 Oct 1759 certain Fredericksburg, Spotsylvania, Virginia certain 5 Sep 1853 certain Shelby County, Kentucky, USA Male Keagle-21

Simpson-6609
Q4924978 Bland Ballard (American politician (1761-1854)) 16 Oct 1761 Fredericksburg United States of America 5 Sep 1853 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McRorie-37 03.05.2020 08:33:58 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Payne-15298
H
1799 Buckner Harrison Payne uncertain 9 Dec 1800 certain Kentucky, United States certain 7 Jun 1883 certain Davidson County, Tennessee, United States Male Orphan
Q22020471 Buckner H. Payne (American clergyman and pamphleteer) 1799 1889 1 Jun 1883 Davidson County United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Payne-15730 14.01.2024 11:04:10 False suggestion not precise
Akeman-21
H
17 Jun 1916 David Stringbean Akeman certain 17 Jun 1915 Annville, Jackson, Kentucky, United States certain 10 Nov 1973 Ridgetop, Robertson County, Tennessee, USA Male WikiTree-130

Compton-2184
Q3398247 David "Stringbean" Akeman (Banjo player) 17 Jun 1916 Annville United States of America 11 Nov 1973 10 Nov 1973 Ridgetop United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 12.06.2023 23:59:14 Corrected Corrected
Craig-4574 20.09.2023 12:48:47 False suggestion This was corrected previously.
Craig-11
H
1743 Rev. Elijah Craig uncertain 15 Nov 1738 certain Orange, Virginia, British Colonial America certain 18 May 1808 certain Georgetown, Scott, Kentucky, United States Male Simmons-11603
Q5360904 Elijah Craig (American preacher 1738-1808) 1743 Orange County United States of America 18 May 1808 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Simmons-11603 09.12.2021 00:51:12 False suggestion
DeLong-3242
H
1879 Ethel Margaret Zande (DeLong) 20 Oct 1878 Montclair, Essex County, New Jersey, United States 18 Mar 1928 Pine Mountain, Harlan County, Kentucky, United States Female WikiTree-130
Q57728619 Ethel de Long Zande (American educator (b. 1879, d. 1928)) 1879 Montclair United States of America 18 Mar 1928 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 13.06.2023 10:05:41 Corrected Corrected
Craig-4574 20.09.2023 12:41:52 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Estill-397
H
1857 Frances Fannie R Fannie Beauchamp (Estill) 1856 Madison County, Kentucky, United States 11 Apr 1923 Geneva, Ontario County, New York, United States Female WikiTree-130

Craig-4574
Q111040090 Frances Estill Beauchamp (American suffragist, temperance leader, philanthropist (1857-1923)) 1857 1923 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 12.07.2023 21:02:42 False suggestion Not Sourced
Shannon-2373
H
1785 George F Peg Leg Shannon uncertain 1787 certain Claysville, Washington, Pennsylvania, United States certain 30 Aug 1836 certain Palmyra, Marion, Missouri, United States Male Prentice-1539

WikiTree-31
Q5544454 George Shannon (American explorer (1785-1836)) 1785 1836 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stewart-18822 06.03.2018 17:04:27 Corrected Corrected
Stewart-18822 09.11.2018 03:34:36 Corrected Changed birthdate.
Prentice-1539 03.03.2023 18:41:01 False suggestion
Jordan-13109
H
1847 1st SGT George Jordan uncertain Nov 1848 certain Kentucky, United States certain 19 Oct 1904 certain Crawford, Nebraska, United States Male WikiTree-112

Sears-3708

Murtaugh-30
Q5541166 George Jordan (United States Army Medal of Honor recipient) 1847 Williamson County United States of America 24 Oct 1904 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Díaz-2569 13.02.2022 01:53:21 False suggestion
Routt-190
H
24 Apr 1824 Col. Henry Lewis Routt Esq 22 Apr 1824 Woodford, Kentucky, United States 23 Feb 1881 Clay, Missouri, United States Male Taylor-25258
Q17183254 Henry Lewis Routt (American soldier) 24 Apr 1824 Woodford County United States of America 23 Feb 1881 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Taylor-25258 29.01.2021 23:23:12 False suggestion wikipedia/f-a-g give DOB Apr 22 ...
Birney-256
H
17 Jun 1817 James Birney certain 7 Jun 1817 Danville, Boyle, Kentucky, United States certain 8 May 1888 Bay City, Bay, Michigan, United States Male Hull-2993
Q1680730 James M. Birney (American lawyer, newspaper publisher & politician (1817-1888)) 17 Jun 1817 Danville United States of America 8 May 1888 Bay City United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hull-2993 18.05.2021 15:30:56 False suggestion Wikidata birth date is unsourced
Pope-2649
H
Feb 1770 John Pope uncertain Feb 1773 Prince William, Colony of Virginia 12 Jul 1845 Springfield, Washington, Kentucky Male Trigg-355

WikiTree-46

Jester-173
Q364769 John Pope (American politician (1770-1845)) Feb 1770 Prince William County United States of America 12 Jul 1845 Springfield United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jester-173 04.10.2019 08:33:46 False suggestion Conflicting DATA!
Jester-173 04.10.2019 22:34:37 False suggestion
Eversole-180
H
26 Jul 1852 Joseph Castle Eversole certain 26 Jul 1853 Perry County, Kentucky, United States certain 15 Apr 1888 Hazard, Perry County, Kentucky, United States Male Gillispie-297
Q24205999 Joseph C. Eversole (American politician) 26 Jul 1852 15 Apr 1888 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Weddington-53 09.01.2024 17:22:52 False suggestion Wikidata is incorrect.
Jewett-2321
H
30 Sep 1815 Joshua Husband Jewett certain 13 Sep 1812 Bachelor's Good Luck, Harford, Maryland, USA 14 Jul 1861 Elizabethtown, Hardin, Kentucky, USA Male Jewett-369
Q1708577 Joshua Jewett (American politician (1815-1861)) 30 Sep 1815 14 Jul 1861 Elizabethtown United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID7253105 17.11.2016 22:19:27 False suggestion Old False error
Chinn-7
H
1790 Julia Ann Chinn uncertain 1780 Scott, Kentucky, United States (then Virginia) uncertain 1833 uncertain Kentucky Female WikiTree-6
Q20789976 Julia Chinn (American slave) 1790 Scott County United States of America Jul 1833 Georgetown United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 31.03.2021 20:13:39 False suggestion Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced, again a waste of my time
Todd-1296
H
1757 Brig. Gen. Robert Todd certain 19 Apr 1754 Trappe, Montgomery, Pennsylvania certain 20 Mar 1814 Lexington, Fayette, Kentucky, United States Male Johnson-61091

Kirksey-162
Q7350419 Robert Todd (Kentucky pioneer and statesman) 1757 Province of Pennsylvania Province of Pennsylvania Kingdom of Great Britain Kingdom of England Mar 1814 Lexington United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Johnson-61091 15.10.2021 21:12:43 Not corrected Wikidata date is incorrect
Johnson-61091 19.10.2021 17:28:02 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, Date taken from Tombstone.
Hite-249
H
1759 Sarah Clark (Hite) certain 19 Oct 1760 Frederick, Virginia certain 11 May 1818 Kentucky, United States Female Odom-804
Q96088763 Sarah Hite ((1759-1819)) 1759 1819 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gardiner-1534 14.10.2020 04:58:51 False suggestion WikiData has approximate dates, profile has exact dates.
Sharp-401
H
22 Aug 1787 Solomon Porcius Sharp uncertain 22 Aug 1786 certain Abingdon, Washington, Virginia, United States certain 7 Nov 1825 certain Frankfort, Franklin, Kentucky, United States Male Boy-41
Q126644 Solomon P. Sharp (American politician (1787–1825)) 22 Aug 1787 Abingdon United States of America 7 Nov 1825 Frankfort United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Boy-41 31.12.2020 00:15:28 False suggestion Have not found independent original source for either date
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Craig-171
H
1705 Rev. Taliaferro Toliver, Tolliver Craig Sr. uncertain 1704 St George Parish, Spottsylvania, Virginia 5 Feb 1795 Woodford, Kentucky, United States Male Plumley-88

Galloway-3172

Sell-103

Turley-30

Foster-2926
Q7814277 Toliver Craig, Sr. (American pioneer) 1705 Spotsylvania County United States of America 1795 Woodford County United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Avis-179 30.12.2019 05:11:28 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong. Wikipedia clearly uses 'c.1704'
Beauchamp-3142
H
1778 Thomas Beauchamp uncertain 1777 Kent, Delaware, United States after 1850 Kentucky, United States Male Tirey-10
Q107339145 Thomas Beauchamp ((1778-1830)) 1778 29 Aug 1830 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Tirey-10 29.11.2023 13:01:31 False suggestion
Griffith-3710
H
15 Mar 1886 Lillian Mildred Gladys West (Griffith) aka Klawans, Parker uncertain 1888 uncertain Russell, Greenup, Kentucky, United States not living uncertain Female Jones-39993
Q3832414 Lillian West (actress (1886-1970)) 15 Mar 1886 New York City United States of America 23 Apr 1970 Woodland Hills United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jones-39993 01.08.2018 01:52:08 False suggestion Wikidata is not a source document repository.
Jones-39993 10.12.2019 21:27:16 Comment probable conflation regarding Griffith-3710