Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 575: FindAGrave - Different birth date Help Video (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Elms-45
H 		26 Mar 1920 Chester Elms 26 Mar 1919 Cliff, Grant, New Mexico, United States 28 Mar 1996 Odessa, Ector, Texas, United States Male Pitts-33
114701641 Chester “Chet” Elms 26 Mar 1920 1996
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Smith-32867 05.05.2022 12:38:04 False suggestion
Aguirre-72
H 		8 Feb 1873 Maria Carmen Carmen Velton (Aguirre) uncertain Mar 1869 certain New Mexico Territory, United States certain 16 Oct 1918 certain Ray, Pinal, Arizona, United States Female Fritz-331
83675539 Maria Carmen “Carmen” Gutierrez Aguirre Velton 8 Feb 1873 New Mexico, USA 14 Oct 1918 Ray, Pinal County, Arizona, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Fritz-331 07.06.2023 18:55:51 False suggestion
Thornton-1845
H 		30 Apr 1908 Cora Mae Wilson (Thornton) certain 30 Apr 1909 certain Ida, Grayson, Texas, USA certain 9 May 1995 certain New Mexico, USA Female Orphan
38634432 Cora Mae Thornton Wilson 30 Apr 1908 9 May 1995
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Michaud-221 11.01.2024 09:15:33 False suggestion WikiTree birth date is correct
McCarty-931
H 		23 Nov 1860 William Henry Billy the Kid McCarty aka Bonney, Antrim certain 17 Sep 1859 New York City, New York, United States certain 14 Jul 1881 certain Fort Sumner, DeBaca County, New Mexico Territory Male WikiTree-31

Quesnell-14
94 William “Billy The Kid” Bonney 23 Nov 1860 New York, New York County, New York, USA 14 Jul 1881 Fort Sumner, De Baca County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wilson-78368 20.06.2023 21:48:51 False suggestion Unresolvable birth conflict.
Apache-25
H 		1791 Mangas Coloradas La-choy Ko-kun-noste Red Sleeves Apache certain 1793 certain New Mexico certain 18 Jan 1863 certain Fort McLane, New Mexico Male WikiTree-12
8952352 Mangas-Coloradas 1791 Silver City, Grant County, New Mexico, USA 18 Jan 1863 Hurley, Grant County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parks-2399 13.12.2020 19:17:20 False suggestion Wikidata locations did not exist in 1800’s
Pardue-183
H 		31 Jul 1880 James Elgin Pardue uncertain 31 Jul 1878 Mississippi, United States certain 31 Aug 1930 Clovis, Curry County, New Mexico, United States Male Mulhausen-2
186558005 James Elgin Pardue 31 Jul 1880 31 Aug 1930
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
mulhausen-2 19.10.2022 18:12:15 False suggestion WikiTree birth date is logically correct; FindAGrave not sourced with reliance on headstone inscription.
Yaws-5
H 		Jan 1877 Minnie Civil Sybil Stratton (Yaws) certain Feb 1876 Bastrop County, Texas, USA certain 27 Oct 1913 certain Quay County, New Mexico, USA Female Orphan
32611931 Minnie Civil Yaws Stratton Jan 1877 Bastrop, Bastrop County, Texas, USA 27 Oct 1913 Quay County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID1352259 04.04.2017 18:25:44 False suggestion WikiTree birth date is correct; FindAGrave no source
Tryon-1746
H 		26 Jan 1790 Levi Tryon uncertain 1784 certain Middletown, Middlesex County, Connecticut, USA certain 29 Dec 1860 certain Mexico, Oswego, New York, United States Male Tryon-2537

Kenworthy-226

Maranda-80
158952100 Levi Tryon 26 Jan 1790 Middletown, Middlesex County, Connecticut, USA 29 Dec 1860 Mexico, Oswego County, New York, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
tryon-1746 04.06.2019 19:05:26 Corrected edited for correction
tyron-1746 11.06.2019 14:38:48 False suggestion no source on findagrave
tryon-1746 11.06.2019 14:39:29 False suggestion no source on findagrave
Collier-3335
H 		6 Nov 1893 Edith May Smith (Collier) 6 Nov 1892 Darwin, Clark, Illinois, United States 20 Oct 1964 Albuquerque, Bernalillo, New Mexico, United States Female Orphan
64062794 Edith M Smith 6 Nov 1893 20 Oct 1964
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Downey-1809 04.10.2023 02:08:38 False suggestion i believe the birth record
Robinson-25456
H 		1850 Elijah Stanford Stanford Robinson uncertain 1855 Russellville, Pope County, Arkansas certain 25 Oct 1925 Dora, Roosevelt County, New Mexico Male McReynolds-216
10082777 Elijah S Robinson 1850 25 Oct 1925
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McReynolds-216 12.08.2018 15:44:12 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong
Wellborn-186
H 		19 Sep 1892 Della Grayson (Wellborn) certain 19 Sep 1891 Cookville, Titus county, TX certain 15 Apr 1968 Cimarron, Colfax county, NM Female Cabaniss-48
76410223 Della Wellborn Grayson 19 Sep 1892 Titus County, Texas, USA 15 Apr 1968 Colfax County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cabaniss-48 07.02.2020 07:21:06 Comment WikiTree birth date is correct. Texas Birth Certificate, 19 Sep 1891.
Cabaniss-48 12.07.2020 02:50:07 False suggestion
Montoya-584
H 		1858 Santana Montoya aka Montoya de Blea uncertain 1853 Agua Fria, Santa Fe, New Mexico Territory, United States certain 29 Apr 1931 certain Santa Fe, New Mexico, United States Female Orphan
3863409 Santana Montoya Blea 1858 Agua Fria, Santa Fe County, New Mexico, USA 29 Apr 1931 Santa Fe, Santa Fe County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Pérez-224 30.11.2018 23:26:09 False suggestion Date of birth (1853) estimated based on age reported on 1900 United States Census.
Beckwith-1797
H 		26 Mar 1860 Josephine D. Pino (Beckwith) certain 26 Mar 1864 Lincoln, Lincoln, New Mexico, United States certain 31 Oct 1942 El Paso, El Paso, Texas, United States Female Orphan
144529569 Josephine Beckwith Pino 26 Mar 1860 Lincoln, Lincoln County, New Mexico, USA 31 Oct 1942 El Paso, El Paso County, Texas, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ganopole-1 23.11.2018 20:36:14 Corrected Sent update request to findagrave
Ganopole-1 17.01.2019 05:10:46 False suggestion WikiTree birth date is correct; FindAGrave no source
Inglis-1396
H 		19 Jun 1909 Floyd Aaron Inglis certain 18 Jun 1910 certain Sunset, Montague Co., Texas certain 3 Nov 1991 Portales, Roosevelt County, New Mexico Male Black-9712
17317914 Floyd Aaron Inglis 19 Jun 1909 Sunset, Montague County, Texas, USA 3 Nov 1991 Portales, Roosevelt County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Black-9712 28.01.2019 04:21:14 Not corrected Date on gravestone incorrect as per birth record, school records
Black-9712 20.03.2019 18:14:13 False suggestion
Davis-65872
H 		15 Sep 1846 Austin Glen Davis 15 Sep 1845 Monroe County, Tennessee, United States 26 Apr 1933 Mountainair, Torrance County, New Mexico, United States Male Mulhausen-2
197740621 Austin Glen Davis 15 Sep 1846 Monroe County, Tennessee, USA 26 Apr 1933 Mountainair, Torrance County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
mulhausen-2 06.02.2021 13:32:52 False suggestion WikiTree birth date is correct
Davis-67063
H 		11 Aug 1885 Lillie Elvera Ellexson (Davis) aka Love certain 11 Aug 1884 Riley Township, Ringgold, Iowa, United States certain 10 Dec 1922 Las Vegas, San Miguel, New Mexico, United States Female Blair-3850
10494955 Lillie Elvira Davis Ellexson 11 Aug 1885 Riley Township, Ringgold County, Iowa, USA 10 Dec 1922 Las Vegas, San Miguel County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Blair-3850 24.04.2021 02:08:49 False suggestion DoB is correct per birth record
Custer-1029
H 		26 Feb 1903 Thelma Ruth Wood (Custer) uncertain 26 Feb 1902 certain Portales, Roosevelt, New Mexico, United States certain 31 Jul 1968 certain Fort Worth, Tarrant, Texas, United States Female Sparanese-1
194939285 Thelma Ruth Custer Wood 26 Feb 1903 New Mexico, USA 31 Jul 1968 Fort Worth, Tarrant County, Texas, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Sparanese-1 18.01.2020 16:34:38 False suggestion WikiTree birth date is correct
Shay-598
H 		24 May 1883 Oscar Dick Richard Shay certain 24 May 1884 Umatilla, Oregon, United States certain 3 May 1947 Portales, Roosevelt, New Mexico, United States Male McClain-3310
159975015 Oscar R. Shay 24 May 1883 3 May 1947
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McClain-3310 30.03.2021 02:01:59 False suggestion Earlier sources are likely to be more accurate than memorial; birth date is based on WWI draft registration record
Allen-40884
H 		23 Apr 1913 Lorena E. Kizer (Allen) certain 23 Apr 1912 Nogal, Lincoln, New Mexico, United States certain 18 Feb 1995 Southwest City, McDonald, Missouri, United States Female Barnes-8744
65739029 Lorena E Allen Kizer 23 Apr 1913 Nogal, Lincoln County, New Mexico, USA 18 Feb 1995 Southwest City, McDonald County, Missouri, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Barnes-8744 19.02.2020 13:30:52 False suggestion Year of birth on gravestone and FindAGrave conflicts with multiple other sources as noted in bio references
Cook-30810
H 		11 Sep 1856 Daniel Jacob Cook Sep 1855 Rimersburg, Pennsylvania 26 May 1922 Albuquerque, New Mexico Male Orphan
23411431 Daniel J Cook 11 Sep 1856 USA 26 May 1922 Albuquerque, Bernalillo County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kelts-7 21.11.2019 14:40:58 False suggestion DoB is unsourced
Kelts-7 21.11.2019 14:44:20 False suggestion May date is correct per obituary; notified FindAGrave of its error
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Winn-2398
H 		23 Mar 1879 Ann Annie Columbia Mosley (Winn) certain Mar 1880 certain Texas, USA certain 24 Apr 1923 certain Lea, New Mexico, USA Female Mills-7869
15943728 Cloumbia Ann Winn Mosley 23 Mar 1879 Texas, USA 24 Apr 1923 New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mills-7869 10.08.2021 12:17:21 False suggestion WikiTree sourced. FindAGrave unsourced.
Gonzales-1999
H 		27 May 1870 Emilio Gonzales certain 27 May 1873 certain New Mexico Territory, USA certain 23 Oct 1959 certain Harding, New Mexico, USA Male McBeth-165

Hatzenbuehler-3
47058708 Emilio Gonzales 27 May 1870 23 Oct 1959
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McBeth-165 20.05.2020 05:48:42 False suggestion headstone may be incorrect
Stevenson-8190
H 		1872 John Walter Stevenson 1868 Douglasville, Georgia, United States 1962 Pinon, Otero, New Mexico, United States Male Gilbreath-460
15896491 John Walter “Pop” Stevenson 1872 1962
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gilbreath-460 30.06.2020 22:25:55 False suggestion FamilySearch contains one birth date for him, and FindAGrave has another (his headstone). The FamilySearch source gives his birth date as per census records.
Wing-2962
H 		27 Jul 1819 Reuben Alonzo Wing uncertain 27 Jul 1821 Mexico, Oswego, New York, United States certain 10 Jan 1910 Whitehall, Muskegon, Michigan, United States Male Norway-114

Honda-10
63790288 Reuben Alonzo Wing 27 Jul 1819 Mexico, Oswego County, New York, USA 10 Jan 1910 Whitehall, Muskegon County, Michigan, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Norway-114 02.09.2021 09:15:00 Comment WikiTree birth date is correct.
Norway-114 01.03.2024 03:29:41 False suggestion See Research Note.
Leyba-54
H 		24 Jun 1890 Adelaida Montaño (Leyba) aka Tachias uncertain 1881 certain México uncertain 30 Jan 1959 uncertain Albuquerque, Bernalillo, New Mexico, United States Female Korte-201
76433402 Adelaida Leyba Montaño 24 Jun 1890 28 Feb 1959 Albuquerque, Bernalillo County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Korte-201 27.11.2020 00:19:18 False suggestion Several sources that conflict. Date is unknown.
Montaño-261
H 		2 Jul 1887 Pedro C. Montaño certain 24 Jul 1889 certain Casa Salazar, Sandoval, New Mexico Territory, United States uncertain 25 Jun 1977 uncertain New Mexico, United States Male Korte-201
76432608 Pedro C Montaño 2 Jul 1887 25 Jun 1977
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Korte-201 27.11.2020 00:21:46 False suggestion No source for FindaGrave, WikiTree has a signed source.
Surber-530
H 		12 Mar 1902 John Surber 8 Aug 1899 Nebraska 15 Mar 1975 Albuquerque, Bernalillo, New Mexico, United States Male Meyer-8354
58420338 John Surber 12 Mar 1902 Kansas, USA 5 Nov 1972 Chicago, Cook County, Illinois, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Meyer-8354 30.07.2023 18:05:10 False suggestion
Grimes-4498
H 		22 Feb 1907 Lilly Luvenia Lemen (Grimes) aka Miller, Adair, Setzer, Babek 22 Feb 1908 Portales, Roosevelt, New Mexico Territory uncertain 5 Jun 1989 Bethany, Oklahoma County, Oklahoma, United States Female Miller-82908
75287395 Lilly Luvenia Grimes Lemen 22 Feb 1907 Portales, Roosevelt County, New Mexico, USA 5 Jun 1989
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mulhausen-2 22.06.2023 17:37:01 False suggestion WikiTree birth date is correct; FindAGrave no source & gravestone inscription 1908
Montgomery-14391
H 		23 Dec 1875 Samuel Tillman Montgomery 23 Dec 1874 Pleasant Ridge Township, Fulton, Arkansas, United States 22 Nov 1940 Alamogordo, Otero, New Mexico, United States Male Kerbow-16
67436698 Samuel Tilden Montgomery 23 Dec 1875 Izard County, Arkansas, USA 22 Nov 1940
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kerbow-16 05.03.2024 03:49:14 False suggestion See research notes
Gajovich-1
H 		8 Apr 1898 Mitar Mike M Gajovich certain 8 Apr 1893 certain Ozrinići, Nikšić, Montenegro certain 8 Feb 1923 certain Dawson, Colfax, New Mexico, United States Male Orphan
70496459 Mitar M Gajovich 8 Apr 1898 Montenegro 8 Feb 1923 Dawson, Colfax County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Robinson-27225 26.04.2022 21:24:20 False suggestion
Honey-988
H 		8 Mar 1840 William Gervan Bill Honey certain 8 Mar 1842 certain Pickens, Pickens, South Carolina, United States certain 3 Sep 1920 certain Folsom, Union, New Mexico, United States Male Honey-866
49456657 William Gervan “Bill” Honey 8 Mar 1840 Alabama, USA 3 Sep 1920 Folsom, Union County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Honey-866 17.05.2022 15:49:15 False suggestion
Foster-27779
H 		2 Oct 1892 Kunigunda Foster certain 20 Oct 1888 Wisconsin certain 23 Apr 1978 Albuquerque, New Mexico Female Clement-1386
47628203 Kunigunda Anna “Cunie” Foster Bartlett 2 Oct 1892 23 Apr 1978
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Clement-1386 18.08.2021 19:12:48 False suggestion FindAGrave record is unsourced.
Parris-1443
H 		12 Oct 1881 William Alexander Paris (Parris) certain 12 Oct 1880 Benton, Polk County, Tennessee, United States certain 7 Jan 1959 Las Cruces, Doña Ana, New Mexico, United States Male Miller-33353
122683526 William Alexander Paris 12 Oct 1881 Benton, Polk County, Tennessee, USA 7 Jan 1959 Las Cruces, Doña Ana County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Miller-33353 10.11.2021 01:54:29 False suggestion Birth date is based on delayed birth record
Cox-35698
H 		13 Apr 1900 Caton Allan Dick, Dickie Cox certain 13 Apr 1901 certain Birmingham, Jefferson, Alabama, United States certain 8 May 1922 certain Albuquerque, Bernalillo, New Mexico, United States Male Ivey-594
54590750 Caton Allan “Dick” Cox 13 Apr 1900 Birmingham, Jefferson County, Alabama, USA 8 May 1922 Albuquerque, Bernalillo County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ivey-594 06.01.2022 02:14:51 False suggestion headstone inscribed 1900; death certificate states 1901
Braden-1253
H 		1822 John Braden uncertain 1827 16 Oct 1896 New Mexico Territory, United States Male Orphan
15960958 John Braden 1822 17 Oct 1896 Albuquerque, Bernalillo County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 17.02.2022 19:33:03 False suggestion no source on findagrave
McCarty-4870
H 		25 Jan 1873 Edward Albert McCarty 25 Jan 1877 Fayette, Illinois, United States 4 May 1930 Colfax, New Mexico, United States Male Orphan
44473117 Edward Albert McCarty 25 Jan 1873 Ramsey, Fayette County, Illinois, USA 4 May 1930 New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stephens-6538 07.03.2024 15:19:25 False suggestion Date of birth taken from death certificate
Oliver-15966
H 		18 Aug 1913 Thelma Anna Porterfield (Oliver) aka Bradford 18 Aug 1903 Jonesboro, Craighead, Arkansas, USA 18 Feb 1992 Albuquerque, Bernalillo, New Mexico, USA Female Johnson-107455
58718151 Thelma Annie Oliver Porterfield 18 Aug 1913 Jonesboro, Craighead County, Arkansas, USA 18 Feb 1992 Albuquerque, Bernalillo County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Johnson-107455 07.03.2023 22:24:58 False suggestion birth correct per birth record.
Lovato-154
H 		9 Oct 1922 Leonor Smith (Lovato) certain 9 Oct 1923 Pueblo, Pueblo, Colorado, United States certain 26 Jun 1976 Albuquerque, Bernalillo, New Mexico, United States Female Smith-228480
3881984 ENS Leonor Lovato Smith 9 Oct 1922 Colorado, USA 26 Jun 1976 Albuquerque, Bernalillo County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Throp-36 27.04.2023 04:07:20 False suggestion
Shipman-3297
H 		26 Oct 1900 Robert Floy Floy Shipman 26 Oct 1901 Oak Grove, Pickens, Chickasaw Nation, Indian Territory, United States 4 Oct 1946 Albuquerque, Bernalillo, New Mexico, United States Male Orphan
24286052 Robert Floy Shipman 26 Oct 1900 Oklahoma, USA 4 Oct 1946 Albuquerque, Bernalillo County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kennedy-10564 19.07.2023 16:26:48 False suggestion
Barrows-1710
H 		Sep 1859 Emma Arvilla Rice (Barrows) certain Sep 1860 uncertain New Haven, Oswego, New York, United States certain 27 Dec 1919 Mexico, Oswego, New York, United States Female Norway-114
143762533 Emma A. Rice Sep 1859 New York, USA 27 Dec 1919 Mexico, Oswego County, New York, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Norway-114 29.11.2023 21:02:09 False suggestion
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Dreher-864
H 		16 Nov 1893 Sr. Mary Mary Philip Dreher 16 Nov 1894 Liebenthal, Rush, Kansas, United States certain 7 Nov 1933 certain Carlsbad, Eddy, New Mexico, United States Female Rienerth-1
113778686 Sr M. Philip Dreher 16 Nov 1893 Liebenthal, Rush County, Kansas, USA 7 Nov 1933 Carlsbad, Eddy County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rienerth-1 11.11.2023 16:52:20 Comment Notified FaG manager; kept the same as headstone shows 1893. He added sources to the bio on FaG showing 1894 documentation.
Rienerth-1 11.11.2023 16:56:25 Corrected Marked birth date as uncertain until better source is found.
Rienerth-1 15.03.2024 01:54:10 Corrected Notified FindAGrave of its error
Rienerth-1 23.03.2024 22:12:25 False suggestion Already addressed
Morrow-7703
H 		26 Feb 1858 Samuel Walker Morrow Sr. 26 Feb 1859 Round Rock, Williamson County, Texas, United States 9 Mar 1937 Tucumcari, Quay County, New Mexico, United States Male Mulhausen-2
20069298 Sam Walker Morrow Sr. 26 Feb 1858 Round Rock, Williamson County, Texas, USA 9 Mar 1937 Tucumcari, Quay County, New Mexico, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mulhausen-2 05.08.2023 15:40:24 False suggestion WikiTree birth date is correct; FindAGrave no source
McKinney-9549
H 		8 Feb 1922 Richard Dwight Bailey (McKinney) 8 Feb 1921 Denver, Colorado, United States 29 Jan 1972 Male Orphan
116194614 Richard Dwight Bailey 8 Feb 1922 29 Jan 1972 Arizona, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kolze-7 02.02.2024 05:27:10 False suggestion Conflict between sources. SS application and WW2 draft card show 1921.
Graf-346
H 		28 May 1892 Joseph Joe Lloyd J.L. Graf certain 28 May 1894 certain Elkhart, Elkhart, Indiana, USA certain 25 May 1979 certain Springfield, Greene, Missouri, USA Male Graf-565

True-315
42496497 Joseph Lloyd “J.L.” Graf 28 May 1892 Elkhart, Elkhart County, Indiana, USA May 1979
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
True-315 16.07.2023 15:56:21 False suggestion