Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Shepherd-5394
H
1797 Alexander Sandy Shepherd certain 4 Jun 1798 certain Aberdeenshire, Scotland certain 20 Jul 1859 certain Auckland, New Zealand Male Ledger-534
Q4720078 Alexander Shepherd (New Zealand public servant) 1797 Aberdeen United Kingdom 20 Jul 1859 Auckland New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 14.12.2018 21:49:01 Corrected
Ledger-534 12.12.2022 19:36:14 False suggestion
Tollemache-47
H
21 Jun 1910 Archibald Douglas Tollemache certain 20 Jun 1910 Otumoetai, New Zealand certain 18 Apr 2000 New Zealand Male Thomas-7922
Q76192444 Archibald Douglas Tollemache ((1910-2000)) 21 Jun 1910 18 Apr 2000 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dickson-4413 25.04.2020 04:52:20 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Blakiston-95
H
25 Jun 1862 Arthur John Blakiston JP 23 Jun 1862 New Zealand 23 Oct 1963 Geraldine, Canterbury, New Zealand Male Orphan
Q75486675 Arthur John Blakiston ((1862-1963)) 25 Jun 1862 23 Oct 1963 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dickson-4413 25.04.2020 05:27:46 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Rhodes-2776
H
9 Apr 1892 Arthur Tahu Tahu Gravenor Rhodes certain 9 Aug 1892 Thorndon, Wellington, New Zealand certain 11 Mar 1947 St George Hanover Square, London Male Richardson-5769
Q75307431 Tahu Rhodes ((1893–1947)) 9 Apr 1892 11 Mar 1947 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-5769 14.03.2024 23:25:31 False suggestion already fixed
Davy-738
H
1825 Charles John Davy aka Lawrence 24 Aug 1824 Glamorgan, Wales, United Kingdom 16 Apr 1914 Fitzroy, New Plymouth, Taranaki, New Zealand Male Liddle-347

Wilkinson-13169
Q104286445 Charles Davy (New Zealand land surveyor (1825-1914)) 1825 Glamorgan United Kingdom 16 Apr 1914 New Plymouth New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 29.06.2022 09:50:56 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Washbourn-12
H
1843 Edward Washbourn aka Washbourne uncertain 1865 Sedgemere, Southbridge, Canterbury, New Zealand certain 28 Nov 1937 New Zealand Male Orphan
Q75748051 Edward Washbourne ((1843-1934)) 1843 1934 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dickson-4413 25.04.2020 05:34:34 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Fulton-1957
H
1 Jun 1859 Frederick Fulton certain 1 Jun 1850 certain Alīgarh, Uttar Pradesh, India certain 3 Aug 1923 certain Napier, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand Male Shelley-714
Q24203372 Frederick Fulton (cricketer (1859-1923)) 1 Jun 1859 Aligarh India 3 Aug 1923 Napier New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 05.11.2017 18:59:59 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong
Minchin-58
H
Jul 1878 Frederick William Minchin 1875 certain Christchurch, Canterbury, New Zealand. 9 Aug 1962 certain Mareeba, Queensland, Australia Male Richardson-5769
Q75706177 Frederick William Minchin ((1875-1918)) Jul 1878 1 Dec 1918 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-5769 05.03.2020 04:06:48 False suggestion name sake
Potocki de Montalk-1
H
6 Oct 1903 Geoffrey Wladislas Vaile Potocki de Montalk certain 10 Jun 1903 Remuera, Auckland, North Island, New Zealand 14 Apr 1997 Brignoles, Provence, France Male Čeh-1
Q5176661 Count Geoffrey Potocki de Montalk (New Zealand poet (1903-1997)) 6 Oct 1903 Remuera New Zealand 14 Apr 1997 Draguignan France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Čeh-1 02.12.2021 09:02:40 False suggestion
White-79020
H
14 Jul 1929 Harriet Cicely Geange (White) 13 Jul 1929 Kawhia, Otorohanga, Waikato, New Zealand 31 Mar 1987 Te Kuiti, Waikato, New Zealand Female Goulstone-18
Q76212664 Harriet Cicely White ((born 1929)) 14 Jul 1929 31 Mar 1987 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Goulstone-18 22.05.2023 01:04:10 Not corrected Wikidata date is incorrect
Goulstone-18 22.05.2023 01:04:47 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Connon-5
H
1860 Helen Macmillan-Brown (Connon) 16 Jan 1857 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia 22 Feb 1903 Rotorua, New Zealand Female Baxter-2766
Q16030754 Helen Connon (New Zealand women's education pioneer (1860–1903)) 1860 Melbourne Australia 22 Feb 1903 Rotorua New Zealand female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 03.02.2018 20:48:47 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Jackson-21196
H
17 Mar 1843 Henrietta Priscilla Selfe (Jackson) aka Dyson-Holland, Martelli certain 23 Feb 1843 certain Selby, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 1906 certain Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Female Bates-10490
Q76334164 Henrietta Priscilla Jackson ((born 1843)) 17 Mar 1843 1906 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bates-10490 31.12.2019 15:49:38 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Mills-13072
H
16 May 1873 Hugh Parsons Mills certain 6 Jun 1873 Timaru, Canterbury, New Zealand 26 Mar 1905 New Plymouth, Taranaki, New Zealand Male Rockell-39
Q24004655 Hugh Mills (New Zealand rugby union player (1873-1905)) 16 May 1873 Timaru New Zealand 26 Mar 1905 New Plymouth New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rockell-39 10.12.2022 10:02:06 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Snow-4337
H
27 Jul 1853 Isabella Maud Hamersley (Snow) certain 29 Apr 1853 Blandford, Dorset, England certain 27 Jan 1955 Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire, England Female Smith-165384
Q76102999 Isabella Maud Snow ((1853-1954)) 27 Jul 1853 Feb 1954 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Roughan-57 03.03.2021 00:36:50 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect - gravestone has correct date of death as in profile. Findagrave also has the same birth date as in the profile. The incorrect dates are from Ancestry.com.
Rutherford-964
H
24 Nov 1838 James Rutherford uncertain 1839 certain Dundee, Forfarshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 23 May 1928 certain New Plymouth, New Zealand Male Newport-832

Wiegand-310
Q75451548 James Rutherford ((1838-1928)) 24 Nov 1838 1928 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Povey-138 30.12.2019 04:34:11 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Strongman-69
H
1818 Jane Fitzsimmons (Strongman) certain 4 Dec 1817 certain St. Clement, Truro, Cornwall, England certain 3 Apr 1906 certain Timaru, Canterbury, New Zealand Female Partridge-1859
Q96236249 Jane Strongman (1818 in England - 3 Apr 1906 in New Zealand) 1818 1906 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Partridge-1859 12.03.2024 14:48:18 False suggestion
Partridge-1859 12.03.2024 14:57:10 False suggestion Wikidata source had incorrect birth date; it was based upon the baptism, which occured 5 months after the birth, in the following year..
Finlayson-284
H
1890 John Alexander Finlayson 25 May 1891 New Zealand 16 Jan 1960 New Zealand Male Cullen-643
Q6218571 John Alexander Finlayson (New Zealand politician) 1890 1960 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID4089851 07.03.2017 10:20:16 False suggestion Old False error
Woods-2643
H
1849 John Joseph Woods uncertain 22 Oct 1848 certain Hobart Town, Van Diemen's Land certain 9 Jun 1934 certain Lawrence, Otago, New Zealand Male Orphan
Q382064 John Joseph Woods (New Zealand songwriter) 1849 Van Diemen's Land United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland 1934 Lawrence New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 03.02.2018 20:47:47 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Dick-2409
H
17 Jul 1842 Margaret Doig (Dick) certain 4 Jul 1842 certain Alloa, Clackmannanshire, Scotland certain 24 Mar 1925 certain Chertsey, Canterbury, New Zealand Female Doig-176
Q75682229 Margaret Dick ((1842-1925)) 17 Jul 1842 24 Mar 1925 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Doig-176 21.10.2022 10:49:58 False suggestion Wikidata date is christening date
Sarapuu-1
H
22 Jan 1924 Ortvin Sarapu (Sarapuu) MBE 21 Jan 1924 Narva, Estonia 13 Apr 1999 New Zealand Male McNabb-412
Q249824 Ortvin Sarapu (Estonian–New Zealand chess player) 22 Jan 1924 Narva Estonia 13 Apr 1999 Auckland New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McNabb-412 10.07.2022 11:51:41 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Evans-29501
H
15 Sep 1871 Percy Evans certain 16 Sep 1871 certain Oamaru, Otago, New Zealand certain 26 Apr 1959 Wanganui, Wellington, New Zealand Male Orphan
Q75538557 Percy Evans ((1871-1959)) 15 Sep 1871 26 Apr 1959 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dickson-4413 25.04.2020 00:05:14 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Storkey-70
H
7 Dec 1891 Percy Valentine Storkey VC LLB certain 9 Sep 1893 certain Napier, Hawkes Bay, New Zealand certain 3 Oct 1969 certain Teddington, Middlesex, England, United Kingdom Male Evans-20927
Q7167598 Percy Storkey (recipient of the Victoria Cross) 7 Dec 1891 Napier New Zealand 3 Oct 1969 Teddington United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 21.09.2019 21:00:50 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Te Wherowhero-3
H
1775 King Pōtatau Te Wherowhero uncertain 1780 Waikato, New Zealand certain 25 Jun 1860 certain Ngaruawahia, Waikato, New Zealand Male Howie-675

Whitaker-808
Q887437 Pōtatau Te Wherowhero (The first Māori king) 1775 Waikato District New Zealand 25 Jun 1860 Ngāruawāhia New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Paul-5413 25.02.2024 21:51:04 False suggestion Precise birth date in unknown, only a general rang
Kettle-230
H
7 May 1887 Lt-Col Randal Dudley Dudley Kettle MC certain 7 Mar 1887 New Zealand certain 1979 New Zealand Male Whitaker-808
Q76027375 Randal Dudley Kettle ((1887-1979)) 7 May 1887 1979 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dickson-4413 25.04.2020 06:18:05 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Fairburn-152
H
1819 Richard Alexander Fairburn certain 29 Mar 1820 certain Kerikeri, Auckland, New Zealand certain 1 Nov 1896 Auckland, New Zealand Male Curtis-11335
Q104286470 Richard Fairburn (New Zealand land surveyor (1819-1896)) 1819 Kerikeri New Zealand 1 Nov 1896 Papatoetoe New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Allen-31849 15.09.2021 13:01:31 False suggestion
Macgeorge-10
H
1796 Robert Forsyth Macgeorge uncertain 18 Dec 1822 Glasgow, Lanark, Scotland 17 Sep 1917 Dunedin, Otago, New Zealand Male Groom-187
Q19668776 Robert Forsyth Macgeorge (Scottish tailor and businessman in South Australia) 1796 26 Oct 1859 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
kellett-33 01.08.2017 03:16:01 False suggestion Completely different people
Gillies-497
H
1835 Robert Gillies certain 31 Jul 1836 Rothesay, Bute, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 15 Jun 1886 Dunedin, Otago, New Zealand Male McLeish-374
Q7344781 Robert Gillies (New Zealand politician) 1835 Rothesay United Kingdom 15 Jun 1886 Dunedin New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 31.07.2018 20:30:01 False suggestion Wikidata has no references, source for date is in bio
Evans-29508
H
1 Nov 1907 Sylvia Elizabeth Chittick (Evans) certain 1 Oct 1907 certain Waimate, Canterbury, New Zealand certain 3 Jul 1992 certain Merrow, Surrey, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
Q75538624 Sylvia Elizabeth Evans ((born 1907)) 1 Nov 1907 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dickson-4413 25.06.2023 06:26:07 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, two sources for this birth date
Te Wherowhero-5
H
1880 King Te-Rata Mahuta Potatau Te Wherowhero (Te Wherowhero) uncertain 1877 Hukanui, Waikato, New Zealand uncertain 1 Oct 1933 Waahi Pa, Huntly, New Zealand Male Howie-675
Q7690953 Te Rata (Third Māori King) 1880 New Zealand New Zealand 1 Oct 1933 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 28.04.2019 08:17:05 False suggestion Unique name is correct.
Cheeseman-75
H
8 Jun 1846 Thomas Frederick Cheeseman certain 8 Jun 1845 certain Kingston upon Hull, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 16 Oct 1923 certain Auckland, New Zealand Male Olson-6823
Q1361590 Thomas Cheeseman (English-born New Zealand botanist (1846-1923)) 8 Jun 1846 Kingston upon Hull Kingston upon Hull Kingdom of England United Kingdom 6 Oct 1923 Auckland New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kellett-33 06.02.2024 10:37:00 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Armson-17
H
1832 William Barnett Armson 17 Jun 1833 London, England 25 Feb 1883 certain Christchurch, Canterbury, New Zealand Male Irwin-2099
Q8004537 William Armson (New Zealand architect (1832/3–1883)) 1832 London United Kingdom 25 Feb 1883 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 22.05.2019 10:10:28 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Bedlington-16
H
27 Sep 1823 William Bedlington certain 7 Mar 1810 certain Corbridge, Northumberland, England, United Kingdom certain 24 May 1891 certain Mount Eden, Auckland, New Zealand Male Simmonds-1055
Q104286290 William Bedlington (New Zealand land surveyor (1823-1891)) 27 Sep 1823 Ovingham United Kingdom 24 May 1891 Auckland New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Simmonds-1055 29.03.2022 02:29:43 Not corrected My data matches Source information
Simmonds-1055 29.04.2022 03:42:57 Comment Conflicting Birthday Source removed
Simmonds-1055 29.04.2022 03:43:33 Corrected minor correction made to Wikidata
Simmonds-1055 29.04.2022 03:44:44 Corrected
Simmonds-1055 09.05.2022 03:11:30 Not corrected the Subject of my profile is aged older than the subject referredv to in the Wikidata so its my suggestion that somebody has boobed when they added this Data to my Profile
Simmonds-1055 05.08.2022 11:16:53 Not corrected ERROR 555 -My information is Correct -William was 50 y/0 when he Married.Q104286290
Simmonds-1055 06.08.2022 10:00:03 Corrected Error 555 Amended - Incorrect information removed.
Simmonds-1055 22.08.2022 08:51:08 Corrected Wrong Data removed came via GEDCOM IMPORT AND WAS WRONG
Simmonds-1055 14.09.2022 01:52:32 Comment
Simmonds-1055 14.09.2022 01:54:10 Not corrected Bottom information incorrect -due to corrupted Smart Match.
Simmonds-1055 30.11.2022 08:44:47 Comment William Bedingtons Birth is 1810 -he was Aged 50 and Caroline 32
Simmonds-1055 30.11.2022 08:45:17 Comment
Simmonds-1055 02.12.2022 05:50:38 Comment William Bedington, 1810 - 1891 William Bedington was born on month day 1810, in birth place . William was baptized on month day 1837, in baptism place . William married Caroline Elizabeth Bedington (born Mair) on month day 1861, at age 50 in marriage place . Caroline was born on October 15 1828, in Paihia,Auckland,New Zealand. They had 4 children: Blanche Bedlington and 3 other children . William passed away on month day 1891, at age 81 in death place .
Simmonds-1055 02.12.2022 05:53:20 Comment
Simmonds-1055 02.12.2022 05:55:32 Comment Please read commens in Status History- Wikidata has wrong person
Willis-3607 28.12.2022 05:26:12 Not corrected wikidata incorrect - died 24 May 1891 at age 81= b: 1810
Willis-3076 28.12.2022 05:27:57 False suggestion
Massey-1785
H
26 Mar 1856 The Rt.Hon William Bill Ferguson Massey PM certain 25 Mar 1856 certain Limavady, County Londonderry, Ireland certain 10 May 1925 certain Wellington, New Zealand Male Tennant-365
Q923806 William Massey (Prime Minister of New Zealand (1856-1925)) 26 Mar 1856 Limavady United Kingdom 10 May 1925 Wellington New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID3951562 03.11.2016 05:45:44 False suggestion Old False error
Olney-518 11.01.2018 09:23:43 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Smith-171934
H
1798 William Mein Smith certain 7 Sep 1799 Capetown, Cape Colony, South Africa certain 3 Jan 1869 Greytown, Wellington, New Zealand Male Orphan
Q8015537 William Mein Smith (artist, surveyor, and New Zealand politician (1798-1869)) 1798 Cape Town South Africa 3 Jan 1869 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bethune-87 09.05.2019 15:28:30 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Wood-30879
H
1827 William Wood uncertain 1817 certain Leicestershire, England, United Kingdom certain 30 Aug 1884 certain Wellington, Wellington, New Zealand Male Stokes-6649
Q8020526 William Wood (19th-century New Zealand politician) 1827 30 Aug 1884 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 27.12.2023 22:51:34 False suggestion WikiData is wrong