Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 558: Wikidata - Different death date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Wilson-77060
H
20 Jan 1941 Rt Rev Dr Cecil Wilson certain 9 Sep 1860 Islington, Middlesex, England, United Kingdom certain 19 Jan 1941 Perth, Western Australia, Australia Male Wickham-1317
Q5056364 Cecil Wilson (Anglican Bishop (1860-1941)) 9 Sep 1860 20 Jan 1941 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wickham-1153 17.04.2021 10:26:46 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong
Dewe-228
H
22 May 1993 Colleen Elizabeth Dewe certain 30 May 1930 certain Hokitika, West Coast, New Zealand certain 23 May 1993 certain Dunedin, Otago, New Zealand Female Dewe-226
Q5146247 Colleen Dewe (New Zealand politician) 30 May 1930 Hokitika New Zealand 22 May 1993 Dunedin New Zealand female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rodgers-4539 27.01.2024 10:37:22 False suggestion
Parris-864
H
9 Oct 1921 Emma Jane Richmond (Parris) 1845 New Plymouth, Taranaki, New Zealand 10 Oct 1921 Havelock North, Hastings, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand Female Orphan
Q23765931 Emma Jane Richmond (New Zealand politician) 1845 New Plymouth New Zealand 9 Oct 1921 Havelock North New Zealand female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 28.04.2019 09:57:54 False suggestion Wikitree date is correct
Anderson-47055
H
28 Jul 2014 Eric James Anderson 4 Apr 1931 Whakatane, Auckland, New Zealand 27 Jul 2014 Rotorua, Bay of Plenty, New Zealand Male Orphan
Q17437673 Eric Anderson (New Zealand rugby union footballer and coach (1931-2014)) 4 Apr 1931 Whakatāne New Zealand 28 Jul 2014 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McMichael-221 29.10.2019 09:57:30 False suggestion Based on Wikipedia data.
Graham-17925
H
20 Oct 1941 Eric Stanley Stanley George Graham certain 12 Nov 1900 Kokatahi, Westland, New Zealand certain 21 Oct 1941 Hokitika, Westland, West Coast, New Zealand Male Vincent-2548
Q7599639 Stanley Graham (New Zealand mass murderer) 12 Nov 1900 Kokatahi New Zealand 20 Oct 1941 South Island New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Vincent-2548 18.04.2019 05:09:13 Not corrected Wikipedia has it wrong.
Olney-518 23.04.2019 13:04:43 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Evans-42580
H
26 Oct 1944 Eyre Tibby Evans certain 13 Jun 1874 Awamoko, Otago, New Zealand certain 25 Oct 1944 certain Wanganui, Wellington, New Zealand Male Orphan
Q75538574 Eyre Evans ((1874-1944)) 13 Jun 1874 26 Oct 1944 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dickson-4413 24.06.2023 11:29:36 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect, three sources are given in profile
Wakefield-960
H
28 Mar 1875 Felix Wakefield certain 30 Nov 1807 certain Burnham on Crouch, Essex, England, United Kingdom certain 23 Dec 1875 certain Sumner, Christchurch, Canterbury, New Zealand Male Newport-626
Q1303923 Felix Wakefield (English colonist of New Zealand (1807-1875)) 30 Nov 1807 Tottenham United Kingdom 28 Mar 1875 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 20.03.2017 09:27:23 False suggestion
Bell-10043
H
8 Jul 1898 Sir Francis Dillon Bell KCMG CB certain 8 Oct 1822 certain Bordeaux, France certain 15 Jul 1898 certain Shag Valley (homestead), Otago, New Zealand Male Grieder-12
Q5276925 Dillon Bell (New Zealand politician) 8 Oct 1822 Bordeaux France 8 Jul 1898 Otago Region New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID4144916 20.12.2016 08:43:03 False suggestion Old False error
Neave-334
H
5 Feb 1943 Francis Edward Neave certain 1914 New Zealand 4 Feb 1943 New Zealand Male Orphan
Q75748955 Francis Edward Neave ((1914-1943)) 1914 5 Feb 1943 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 07.02.2020 23:51:33 False suggestion Wikitree date is correct
Minchin-58
H
1 Dec 1918 Frederick William Minchin 1875 certain Christchurch, Canterbury, New Zealand. 9 Aug 1962 certain Mareeba, Queensland, Australia Male Richardson-5769
Q75706177 Frederick William Minchin ((1875-1918)) Jul 1878 1 Dec 1918 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-5769 26.02.2020 05:52:18 Comment corrected wikidata
Richardson-5769 27.02.2020 00:14:27 False suggestion Completely different people
Udy-104
H
6 Aug 1934 Hart Tertius Udy certain 27 Jul 1857 certain Greytown, New Zealand certain 6 Aug 1933 certain Napier, Hawkes Bay, New Zealand Male Rockel-81
Q16027157 Hart Udy (New Zealand rugby player) 27 Jul 1857 Greytown New Zealand 6 Aug 1934 Napier New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 15.12.2021 08:00:37 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Every-168
H
1 Jun 1956 Helen Penelope Every certain 22 May 1873 certain Oamaru, Otago, New Zealand certain 30 May 1956 certain Nelson, New Zealand Female Shelley-714
Q75969256 Helen Penelope Every ((1873-1956)) 22 May 1873 1 Jun 1956 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 02.01.2020 22:49:00 False suggestion Suggested date is burial date
Jackson-7762
H
12 Aug 1906 Henry Jackson 5 May 1830 Macao 29 Oct 1906 The Hutt, New Zealand Male Nicholls-499
Q5723758 Henry Jackson (New Zealand politician and surveyor (1830-1906)) 1830 12 Aug 1906 Christchurch New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hardy-7997 10.08.2022 12:57:58 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Hardy-7997 10.08.2022 12:58:25 False suggestion Data Doctor - Error 558: Wikidata - Different deat
Hika-7
H
6 Mar 1828 Hongi Hika certain 1772 certain Kaikohe, Northland, Aotearoa-New Zealand certain 3 Mar 1828 certain Whangaroa, Northland, New Zealand Male Howie-675

Wilkinson-6008
Q1627025 Hongi Hika (New Zealand Maori chief) 1772 Kaikohe New Zealand 6 Mar 1828 Whangaroa New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Fowler-8613 17.11.2018 06:44:35 Not corrected Wikidata is NOT sourced - Wiki Tree is using Dictionary of NZ info
Olney-518 04.12.2018 19:40:41 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Turbott-7
H
11 Aug 2016 Sir Ian Graham Turbott AO CMG CVO certain 9 Mar 1922 certain Whangarei, Northland, New Zealand certain 10 Aug 2016 certain Fairlight, Sydney, Australia Male Woods-548
Q950745 Ian Graham Turbott (British politician (1922-2016)) 9 Mar 1922 Whangārei New Zealand 11 Aug 2016 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 15.05.2018 21:41:41 False suggestion Wikitree date is correct
Prins-376
H
1918 Ina Winifred Murray-Aynsley (Prins) uncertain 1885 uncertain 12 Apr 1917 New Zealand Female Orphan
Q75265456 Ina Winifred Prins ((died 1918)) 1918 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Tuck-697 24.04.2020 20:31:21 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Snow-4337
H
Feb 1954 Isabella Maud Hamersley (Snow) certain 29 Apr 1853 Blandford, Dorset, England certain 27 Jan 1955 Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire, England Female Smith-165384
Q76102999 Isabella Maud Snow ((1853-1954)) 27 Jul 1853 Feb 1954 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Roughan-57 03.03.2021 00:36:51 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect - gravestone has correct date of death as in profile. Findagrave also has the same birth date as in the profile. The incorrect dates are from Ancestry.com.
Crichton-239
H
25 Sep 1961 James Bell Scotty Crichton VC certain 15 Jul 1879 certain Carrickfergus, County Antrim, Ulster, Ireland certain 22 Sep 1961 certain Takapuna, Auckland, New Zealand Male Stent-34
Q6131935 James Crichton (Irish recipient of the Victoria Cross) 15 Jul 1879 Carrickfergus United Kingdom 25 Sep 1961 Takapuna New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID4144916 20.12.2016 08:49:39 False suggestion Old False error
Clendon-4
H
26 Oct 1872 Captain James Reddy Clendon R.M. certain 1 Oct 1800 certain Deal, Kent, England certain 24 Oct 1872 certain Rawene, Bay of Islands, New Zealand Male Nixon-1915
Q6141896 James Reddy Clendon (New Zealand farmer) 1 Oct 1800 26 Oct 1872 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McClintock-715 10.05.2023 05:59:41 False suggestion wikidata is wrong, Wikipedia give the 24 or 26, I
Shepherd-4861
H
15 May 1903 James Shepherd uncertain 1822 Clackmannan, Clackmannanshire, Scotland, United Kingdom 16 May 1903 Rangiora, Canterbury, New Zealand Male Doig-176
Q75691616 James Shepherd ((1822-1903)) 2 Dec 1822 15 May 1903 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Doig-176 21.10.2022 10:47:29 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Lecky-162
H
22 Jun 1917 John Gage Lecky 4 Nov 1863 Auckland, New Zealand certain 6 Apr 1917 certain Newmarket, Auckland, New Zealand Male Welsford-8
Q6244350 John Lecky (New Zealand rugby union player (1863-1917)) 4 Nov 1863 Auckland New Zealand 22 Jun 1917 Auckland New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McNabb-412 03.03.2022 11:02:43 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong
Bjelke-Petersen-10
H
28 Jan 2003 Josephine Christian Rousell Joe Gordon (Bjelke-Petersen) certain 12 Feb 1911 certain Hobart, Tasmania, Australia certain 22 Jan 2003 certain Karori, Wellington, Wellington, New Zealand Female Ganopole-1

Gordon-16751
Q114984020 Josephine Christian Gordon (New Zealand botanical collector) 12 Feb 1911 28 Jan 2003 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ganopole-1 17.11.2022 00:23:24 False suggestion
Allen-42968
H
15 Jun 1984 Keith Reading Allen certain 27 Nov 1931 New Zealand certain 21 Jul 1984 New Zealand Male Orphan
Q6383974 Keith Reading Allen (New Zealand politician) 27 Nov 1931 15 Jun 1984 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 14.09.2020 08:56:23 False suggestion
Corry-448
H
7 Jan 1890 Louisa Barbara Evans (Corry) certain 20 Dec 1812 Newry, County Down, Ireland certain 6 Jan 1890 certain Oamaru, Otago, New Zealand Female Orphan
Q75351042 Louisa Barbara Corry ((died 1890)) 20 Dec 1812 7 Jan 1890 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dickson-4413 01.09.2022 03:52:28 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Studholme-103
H
25 Sep 1886 Michael Studholme certain 31 Jan 1833 Kingstown, Cumberland, England certain 28 Sep 1886 Waimate, Canterbury, New Zealand Male Orphan
Q75302561 Michael Studholme (New Zealand runholder (1833-1886)) 31 Jan 1833 25 Sep 1886 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dickson-4413 26.04.2020 00:30:29 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Macgeorge-10
H
26 Oct 1859 Robert Forsyth Macgeorge uncertain 18 Dec 1822 Glasgow, Lanark, Scotland 17 Sep 1917 Dunedin, Otago, New Zealand Male Groom-187
Q19668776 Robert Forsyth Macgeorge (Scottish tailor and businessman in South Australia) 1796 26 Oct 1859 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
kellett-33 01.08.2017 03:16:02 False suggestion Completely different people
Lysaght-12
H
1949 Sophia Augusta Moore (Lysaght) certain 18 Dec 1861 Mowbray Lodge, Kirkby Malzeard, Yorkshire, England uncertain 1945 New Zealand Female Newport-626
Q76017166 Sophia Augusta Lysaght (New Zealand artist) 1949 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Burlinson-44 05.05.2023 04:08:53 False suggestion
Peacocke-31
H
30 May 1872 Hon. Stephen Ponsonby Peacocke certain 1813 England, United Kingdom certain 29 May 1872 certain New Zealand Male Spencer-13906

Bull-1493
Q7610260 Stephen Ponsonby Peacocke (Indian artist (1813-1872)) 1813 England United Kingdom 30 May 1872 New Zealand New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 09.05.2018 21:30:58 False suggestion Wikitree date is correct
Cheeseman-75
H
6 Oct 1923 Thomas Frederick Cheeseman certain 8 Jun 1845 certain Kingston upon Hull, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 16 Oct 1923 certain Auckland, New Zealand Male Olson-6823
Q1361590 Thomas Cheeseman (English-born New Zealand botanist (1846-1923)) 8 Jun 1846 Kingston upon Hull Kingston upon Hull Kingdom of England United Kingdom 6 Oct 1923 Auckland New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kellett-33 06.02.2024 10:37:01 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Drummond-4640
H
15 Feb 1934 Thomas McKay Drummond 12 Dec 1846 Evans Bay, Wellington, New Zealand 16 Feb 1934 Greytown, Wairarapa, Wellington, New Zealand Male Theng-4
Q104286456 Thomas McKay Drummond (New Zealand land surveyor (1846-1934)) 12 Dec 1846 Wellington New Zealand 15 Feb 1934 Wairarapa New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Theng-4 06.04.2024 08:17:15 False suggestion
Dron-7
H
Feb 1927 William Dron 8 Sep 1838 Arngask, Perth and Kinross, Scotland 21 Jan 1927 Waimea West, Tasman, New Zealand Male Newport-832
Q75453410 William Dron (Peerage person ID=151547) 1838 Feb 1927 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:19:27 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:19:31 Comment
Rogers-36819
H
14 Apr 1947 William Rogers uncertain 1848 certain 25 Feb 1884 certain Nelson, New Zealand Male Leachman-36
Q76172063 William Reginald Rogers ffrench ((died 1947)) 1848 14 Apr 1947 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Watson-15643 22.06.2022 02:56:26 False suggestion