Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Baker-45733
H
11 Jan 1907 Lt Col Addison Earl Baker 1 Jan 1907 Chicago, Cook, Illinois, United States 1 Aug 1943 Ploiești, Prahova, Romania Male Lusher-89
Q4681242 Addison Baker (United States Air Force Medal of Honor recipient (1907-1943)) 11 Jan 1907 Chicago United States of America 1 Aug 1943 Ploiești Romania male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Boyle-4376 30.01.2023 05:31:34 False suggestion Birth date listed on Wikipedia matches what was fo
Harding-4656
H
19 Mar 1764 Amos Tryon Harding certain 10 Mar 1764 certain Deerpark, Orange, New York certain 10 Jul 1839 certain Bloominggrove Township, Richland, Ohio, United States Male Tryon-2537

Maranda-80
Q96198657 Amos Harding (19 Mar 1764 Orange Co., New York - 10 Jul 1839 Blooming Grove) 19 Mar 1764 10 Jul 1839 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Tryon-2537 30.06.2021 18:27:24 False suggestion wikidata Q96198657 not referenced, Wikitree data is referenced
Coonrod-108
H
1831 Aquilla Coonrod aka Coonrad certain 3 Jan 1832 Springfield Township, Williams, Ohio, United States certain 14 May 1884 Fort Buford, Williams, North Dakota, United States Male Burch-2229
Q4782947 Aquilla Coonrod (United States Army Medal of Honor recipient; first white child born in Williams County, Ohio.) 1831 Springfield Township United States of America 14 May 1884 Fort Buford United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Burch-2229 09.01.2019 01:21:55 False suggestion Date is approximate and only 1 year off
Beckwith-1676
H
1827 Asahel Collins Beckwith certain 29 Nov 1829 certain Mentor, Lake, Ohio, United States certain 25 Jan 1896 certain Evanston, Uinta, Wyoming, United States Male Ganopole-1
Q4803331 Asahel C. Beckwith (American politician) 1827 Mentor United States of America 1896 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ganopole-1 10.09.2020 21:24:45 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Harrison-1063
H
5 May 1806 Benjamin Harrison certain 8 Sep 1806 certain Vincennes, Knox, Indiana, United States certain 17 Jun 1840 certain North Bend, Hamilton, Ohio, United States Male WikiTree-6
Q75765959 Benjamin Harrison ((1806-1840)) 5 May 1806 9 Jun 1840 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 18.12.2019 03:57:44 Comment Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced, WikiTree is based on Sources, this is a waste of time
Lee-5956 18.12.2019 04:10:39 False suggestion
Higley-570
H
30 Nov 1823 Dr. Brewster Martin Higley VI certain 30 Nov 1822 Rutland, Meigs, Ohio, United States certain 11 May 1911 Shawnee, Pottawatomie, Oklahoma, United States Male Butler-21232
Q4962759 Brewster Higley (American otolaryngologist and poet) 30 Nov 1823 Rutland United States of America 9 Dec 1911 Shawnee United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
largent-367 04.12.2018 20:10:24 False suggestion
Gavin-1015
H
1 Jan 1889 Bridget Sister Ignatia Gavin 10 Mar 1889 Shanvalley, Burren, County Mayo, Ireland 1 Apr 1966 Richfield, Summit, Ohio, United States Female Orphan
Q7531120 Sister Ignatia (American Roman Catholic Religious Sister) 1 Jan 1889 Shanvally Republic of Ireland 1 Apr 1966 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
x-8644 27.06.2023 14:38:50 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Dooin-4
H
12 Jun 1879 Charles Sebastian Red Dooin 11 Jun 1877 Cincinnati, Hamilton, Ohio, United States 14 May 1952 Rochester, Monroe, New York, United States Male Rohman-19
Q15500813 Red Dooin (American baseball player (1879-1952)) 12 Jun 1879 Cincinnati United States of America 12 May 1952 Rochester United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rohman-19 24.11.2023 05:16:31 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Stacey-2514
H
22 Jan 1842 Charles Stacey 22 Jan 1843 Earith, Huntingdonshire, England, United Kingdom certain 17 Oct 1924 Norwalk, Huron, Ohio, United States Male Hardman-1532
Q93397069 Charles Stacey () 22 Jan 1842 Earith United Kingdom 17 Oct 1924 Norwalk United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hardman-1532 05.01.2024 00:36:49 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Holloway-1615
H
1834 Charlotte Holloway certain 1833 Ohio, United States certain 11 Sep 1877 United States Female WikiTree-6
Q76329163 Charlotte Holloway ((1834-1877)) 1834 1877 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 11.01.2020 17:03:24 False suggestion WikiData/thepeerage are both unsourced, all reliable writings indicate that her birth is unknown, I am really tired of these suggestions
White-81738
H
1954 Cheryl White certain 29 Oct 1953 uncertain Cleveland, Cuyahoga, Ohio, United States certain 20 Sep 2019 uncertain United States Female WikiTree-112
Q60737401 Cheryl White (American horse racing jockey) 1954 Cleveland United States of America 20 Sep 2019 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Melick-229 08.05.2023 22:08:34 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Pulaski-8
H
9 Feb 1868 Edward Crockett Big Ed Pulaski certain 9 Feb 1866 certain Green Springs, Seneca, Ohio, United States certain 2 Feb 1931 certain Coeur d'Alene, Kootenai, Idaho, United States Male Palmer-5553
Q5335296 Ed Pulaski (U.S. Forest Service ranger) 9 Feb 1868 Ohio United States of America 2 Feb 1931 Idaho United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Tillman-416 02.01.2020 01:14:16 False suggestion Wikidate birth date 1868 is different front Wikipedia birthdate which agrees with WikiTree.
Ball-19543
H
22 Jul 1878 Ernest Roland Ball certain 21 Jul 1878 certain Cleveland, Cuyahoga, Ohio, United States certain 3 May 1927 certain Santa Ana, Orange, California, United States Male Butler-21232
Q1566974 Ernest Ball (American musician) 22 Jul 1878 Cleveland United States of America 3 May 1927 Santa Ana United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ganopole-1 05.05.2021 21:54:19 Corrected Changed to read the 21st. Wikipedia is wrong - he was baptized on the 22nd. Turned request into FindAGrave.
Ganopole-1 12.05.2021 01:35:27 False suggestion
Sheldon-55
H
1870 Flora Bush (Sheldon) 17 Mar 1872 Franklin, Franklin, Ohio, United States certain 4 Sep 1920 Watch Hill, Washington, Rhode Island, United States Female Watts-3128

Watt-266

WikiTree-6

Morton-536

Whittington-592
Q18844144 Flora Bush (wife of Samuel P. Bush) 1870 Franklin County United States of America 4 Sep 1920 Watch Hill United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Watt-266 16.04.2018 03:26:06 Not corrected profile date correct - corrected Wikidata
Watt-266 21.04.2018 07:21:45 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Harding-586
H
12 Jun 1843 George Tryon Harding II certain 12 Jun 1844 certain Blooming Grove, Morrow, Ohio, United States certain 19 Nov 1928 certain Orange, California, United States Male WikiTree-6
Q20767999 George Tryon Harding, Sr. (American physician and businessman, father of President Warren G. Harding) 12 Jun 1843 Blooming Grove United States of America 19 Nov 1928 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 04.05.2021 23:47:24 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Harding-3794
H
26 May 1904 George Tryon Harding III certain 27 May 1904 certain Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio, United States certain 22 Nov 1985 certain Sarasota, Sarasota, Florida, United States Male Bartomeo-1
Q105957889 George Tryon Harding III (American psychiatrist) 26 May 1904 Columbus United States of America 22 Nov 1985 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
payne-15730 14.12.2023 14:57:44 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong per birth certificate
Schwartz-3431
H
20 Mar 1941 Glenn William Schwartz 20 Mar 1940 Cleveland, Cuyahoga, Ohio, United States 2 Nov 2018 Euclid, Cuyahoga, Ohio, United States Male Byers-779
Q5569097 Glenn Schwartz (American musician) 20 Mar 1941 Cleveland United States of America 2 Nov 2018 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Byers-779 10.09.2019 14:34:46 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Brown-112224
H
10 Mar 1849 Hallie Quinn Brown uncertain 10 Mar 1850 certain Pittsburgh, Allegheny, Pennsylvania, USA certain 16 Sep 1949 certain Wilberforce, Greene, Ohio, United States Female WikiTree-112
Q5642978 Hallie Quinn Brown (American writer and activist) 10 Mar 1849 Pittsburgh United States of America 16 Sep 1949 1 Sep 1949 Wilberforce United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ward-9858 13.03.2023 16:13:08 False suggestion
Freeman-14292
H
17 Jan 1837 Henry Blanchard Freeman certain 13 Jan 1837 Mount Vernon, Knox, Ohio, United States certain 16 Oct 1915 Douglas, Converse, Wyoming, United States Male Orphan
Q5718283 Henry Blanchard Freeman (American Civil War recipient of the Medal of Honor (1837–1915)) 17 Jan 1837 Mount Vernon United States of America 16 Oct 1915 Douglas United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Burch-2229 06.09.2019 00:09:35 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Campbell-45439
H
1860 James Edwin Campbell certain 28 Sep 1867 Pomeroy, Meigs, Ohio, United States certain 26 Jan 1896 certain Pomeroy, Meigs, Ohio, United States Male Houk-65

WikiTree-112
Q3806539 James Edwin Campbell (American poet, editor, short story writer and educator) 1860 Ohio United States of America 26 Jan 1896 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Melick-229 01.03.2022 20:24:41 False suggestion
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Forsyth-2608
H
8 Aug 1835 BG James William Forsyth 8 Aug 1834 Maumee, Lucas, Ohio, United States 24 Oct 1906 Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, United States Male Cain-1665
Q538575 James W. Forsyth (Union Army general (1835–1906)) 8 Aug 1835 Maumee United States of America 24 Oct 1906 Columbus United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cain-1665 29.03.2024 13:21:56 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Cain-1665 29.03.2024 13:25:27 False suggestion
Hemingway-18
H
30 Apr 1824 Jane Burdg (Hemingway) 1 May 1824 Mahoning, Ohio, United States 5 Apr 1890 Jennings, Indiana, United States Female WikiTree-6
Q75763313 Jane M. Hemingway ((1824-1890)) 30 Apr 1824 5 Apr 1890 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 18.12.2019 04:00:40 False suggestion Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced, WikiTree is based on death record
Kimball-3656
H
6 Oct 1844 Joseph Kimball certain 2 Feb 1836 Tyler District, Charles City County, Virginia, United States certain 26 Jul 1909 Centerville, Tyler, West Virginia, United States Male Orphan
Q17421461 Joseph Kimball (Medal of Honor recipient (1844-1910)) 6 Oct 1844 1 May 1910 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 20.07.2023 21:55:28 False suggestion Referencing another person
Randolph-3770
H
1914 Lillian Castello McKee (Randolph) aka Briddell, Short, Lott, Chase, Sanders certain 14 Dec 1898 certain Knoxville, Knox, Tennessee, United States certain 12 Sep 1980 certain Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, United States Female WikiTree-112

Craig-4574
Q2340500 Lillian Randolph (American actress) 1914 Knoxville United States of America 1980 12 Sep 1980 Los Angeles United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 17.02.2022 19:20:38 False suggestion Sourced per 1900 Census + SSDeath Index. Tombstone, Find A Grave are incorrect.
Craig-4574 17.02.2022 19:23:36 Comment
Craig-4574 17.02.2022 19:23:47 Corrected Updated
Craig-4574 20.01.2023 17:00:23 False suggestion Not Sourced
Harrison-1061
H
5 Sep 1800 Lucy Singleton Este (Harrison) certain 31 Jul 1800 Richmond, Virginia, United States certain 7 Apr 1826 certain Cincinnati, Hamilton, Ohio, United States Female WikiTree-6
Q75765955 Lucy Singleton Harrison ((1800-1826)) 5 Sep 1800 7 Apr 1826 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 11.12.2019 21:09:40 Comment Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced
Lee-5956 11.12.2019 21:11:12 False suggestion Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced, WikiTree is based on death record
Mallow-71
H
1819 Martha Holloway (Mallow) 20 Jul 1810 Delaware, United States 30 Dec 1888 Ross, Ohio, United States Female WikiTree-6
Q96197862 Martha (Mallow ?) (20 Jul 1819 in Ohio - 30 Dec 1888 Ross County, Ohio) 1819 1888 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 01.04.2021 22:58:24 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Butler-243
H
15 Jul 1850 Mary Elizabeth Sheldon (Butler) 15 Jul 1849 Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, United States 16 Jan 1897 Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, United States Female WikiTree-6
Q75764648 Mary Elizabeth Butler ((1850-1897)) 15 Jul 1850 Columbus United States of America 16 Jan 1897 Columbus United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 18.12.2019 04:06:01 False suggestion Wikidate/the peerage is unsourced, WikiTree clearly explains the difference in potential birth years
Kemery-67
H
9 Apr 1925 Mary Linda Alice Goodman (Kemery) aka De Vore, Snyder 7 Apr 1925 Morgantown, Monongalia, West Virginia, United States 21 Oct 1995 Colorado Springs, El Paso, Colorado, United States Female Orphan
Q4261927 Linda Goodman (American astrologer) 9 Apr 1925 Morgantown United States of America 21 Oct 1995 Colorado Springs United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 24.10.2022 22:47:01 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Harrison-1046
H
1835 Mary Mary Jane Jane Jennie Morris (Harrison) 5 Jul 1836 North Bend, Miami Township, Hamilton, Ohio, United States 14 Sep 1867 Ohio, United States Female WikiTree-6
Q75766030 Mary Jane Harrison ((1835-1867)) 1835 1867 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 20.11.2021 23:20:29 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced and incorrect....WikiTree has sources and proof of data
Lee-5956 20.11.2021 23:49:06 Corrected
Lee-5956 15.12.2021 02:13:07 False suggestion not sure what went wrong, but, suggestion was already marked as False
Patterson-6240
H
1835 Mary Sampson Langston (Patterson) aka Leary uncertain 1837 certain Fayetteville, Cumberland, North Carolina, United States certain 8 Apr 1915 certain Lawrence, Douglas, Kansas, United States Female WikiTree-112
Q96311869 Mary Sampson Leary (abolitionist and grandmother of Langston Hughes (est. 1837 - certain 8 Apr 1915)) 1835 North Carolina United States of America 1915 Lawrence United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Díaz-2569 07.09.2023 07:15:11 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced and we say 'uncertain' anyway.
Comstock-3095
H
11 Aug 1875 Maude Edith Waitt (Comstock) certain 11 Aug 1874 certain Middlebury, Addison County, Vermont, United States certain 13 Dec 1935 certain Lakewood, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, United States Female Melick-229
Q6792290 Maude C. Waitt (American politician (1875-1935)) 11 Aug 1875 Middlebury United States of America 13 Dec 1935 Lakewood United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Melick-229 17.01.2023 22:08:22 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced and wrong. Birth record on WT profile.
Gass-757
H
29 Feb 1828 Octavius Decatur O. D. Gass certain 28 Feb 1827 Troy Township, Richland, Ohio, United States 10 Dec 1924 Bryn Mawr, San Bernardino, California, United States Male Head-5589
Q16993969 Octavius D. Gass (American prospector and politician) 29 Feb 1828 Mansfield United States of America 10 Dec 1924 Bryn Mawr United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Head-5589 13.05.2023 07:39:17 Corrected
Head-5589 19.06.2023 07:28:54 Corrected
Head-5589 31.03.2024 06:38:27 False suggestion
Head-5589 31.03.2024 06:38:59 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Neville-1674
H
1756 General Presley Neville 6 Sep 1755 Westchester, Virginia 1 Dec 1818 Neville, Clermont, Ohio, United States Male Locke-2058
Q7241575 Presley Neville (American army officer) 1756 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cunningham-4010 31.01.2023 00:15:06 False suggestion Find A Grave is the source of 6 Sep 1755 Birth. Change it and another error will be recorded.
Gilmore-3134
H
28 Feb 1825 Maj. Gen. Quincy Adams Gilmore 25 Apr 1825 Black River, Lorain, Ohio, USA 11 Apr 1888 Brooklyn, Kings, New York, United States Male Simpier-2
Q7272114 Quincy Adams Gillmore (Union Army general) 28 Feb 1825 25 Feb 1825 Lorain United States of America 7 Apr 1888 11 Apr 1888 Brooklyn United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Robins-1306 28.05.2020 09:28:01 False suggestion Date is approximate and only 1 year off
Poland-397
H
1824 Sarah Armour (Poland) aka Poling uncertain 16 Mar 1826 uncertain Ohio, United States certain 19 Mar 1912 uncertain Quincy, Adams, Illinois, United States Female Altmann-126

WikiTree-6
Q96197867 Sarah Poland (Mar 1824 Alleghany Co - Aft 1880) 1824 19 Mar 1912 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 01.04.2021 23:14:46 False suggestion Wikidata has no reliable source
Sharon-184
H
1826 Smiley Sharon uncertain 1827 Ohio uncertain 1907 Virginia City, Storey, Nevada, United States Male Prince-3397
Q75385909 Smily Sharon ((born 1826)) 1826 1907 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Prince-3397 21.10.2021 14:15:48 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Howard-3167
H
17 Feb 1792 Sylvia Taft (Howard) certain 1 Feb 1792 certain Townshend, Windham, Vermont, United States certain 28 Feb 1866 certain Cincinnati, Hamilton, Ohio, United States Female WikiTree-6
Q96198710 Sylvia Howard (17 Feb 1792 Townshend - 1866) 17 Feb 1792 28 Feb 1866 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 15.01.2023 19:45:05 False suggestion
Rickey-34
H
20 Dec 1881 Wesley Branch Mahatma Rickey certain 20 Nov 1881 certain Madison Township, Scioto, Ohio, United States of America certain 9 Dec 1965 certain Columbia, Boone County, Missouri, United States of America Male Borgers-1
Q126019 Branch Rickey (American baseball player and coach) 20 Dec 1881 Stockdale United States of America 9 Dec 1965 Columbia United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jones-39993 26.04.2019 05:55:21 False suggestion date obtained from government record
Piatt-69
H
1 Oct 1743 Capt. William Piatt certain 7 Oct 1743 Sixmile Run, Somerset, New Jersey 4 Nov 1791 Fort Recovery, Mercer, Ohio, United States Male Kinman-87

Skeehan-1
Q122070225 Captain William Piatt ((1743-1791)) 1 Oct 1743 Santo Domingo Six Mile Run Kingdom of France Dominican Republic United States of America Kingdom of France 4 Nov 1791 Fort Recovery United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kinman-87 18.09.2023 23:53:06 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source