Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Dunkin-671
H
2 Dec 1792 Benjamin Faneuil Dunkin certain 3 Dec 1792 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States certain 5 Dec 1874 Charleston, South Carolina, United States Male Duncan-12685
Q18150068 Benjamin Faneuil Dunkin (American judge) 2 Dec 1792 Philadelphia United States of America 5 Dec 1874 Charleston United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bethune-87 09.05.2019 15:28:56 False suggestion Difference is insignificant
Hall-41034
H
25 Aug 1742 Commander George Abbott Hall 18 Apr 1737 uncertain Bristol, England 1 Aug 1791 Charleston County, South Carolina, USA Male Knapp-3513
Q116097215 George Abbott Hall (1737 - 1 Aug 1791) 25 Aug 1742 1 Aug 1791 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Knapp-3513 29.01.2023 07:30:37 Corrected Corrected wrong birth date.
Knapp-3513 10.02.2023 03:53:32 False suggestion WikiData is wrong. WikiData unsourced. DOB is correct as provided in Hall-41034 profile.
McDuffie-190
H
10 Aug 1790 George McDuffie certain 12 Aug 1790 uncertain Columbia County, Georgia certain 11 Mar 1851 uncertain Sumter County, South Carolina Male Whitaker-1484
Q884415 George McDuffie (American politician (1790-1851)) 10 Aug 1790 Columbia County United States of America 11 Mar 1851 Sumter County United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stuewe-5 11.05.2018 04:54:28 False suggestion All 3 Wikidata references are not actual birthdate sources but general links including one circular link.
Laurens-2
H
6 Mar 1724 Henry Laurens certain 24 Feb 1725 uncertain Charles Town, South Carolina uncertain 8 Dec 1792 uncertain St. John's Parish, Berkeley County, South Carolina Male Raber-23

WikiTree-13
Q1606981 Henry Laurens (American slave trader, planter, and congressman (1724-1792)) 6 Mar 1724 Charleston United States of America 8 Dec 1792 Charleston United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 18.10.2017 22:49:44 False suggestion Headstone indicates date shown
Woodard-2927
H
18 Mar 1919 Sgt Isaac Woodard Jr certain 8 Mar 1919 certain Winnsboro, Fairfield, South Carolina, United States certain 23 Sep 1992 certain The Bronx, New York City, New York, United States Male MacKechnie-21

WikiTree-112
Q6077345 Isaac Woodard (1919-1992 American soldier, blinded by South Carolina police in 1946 as a form of racial abuse) 18 Mar 1919 Fairfield County United States of America 23 Sep 1992 The Bronx United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
MacKechnie-21 01.11.2020 21:19:56 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Orr-125
H
10 May 1828 Jehu Amaziah Orr certain 10 Apr 1828 certain Craytonville, Anderson, South Carolina, United States certain 9 Mar 1921 certain Columbus, Lowndes, Mississippi, United States Male Orr-3767
Q1686572 Jehu Amaziah Orr (American politician (1828-1921)) 10 May 1828 Anderson County United States of America 10 Mar 1921 New York City United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Leger-741 11.12.2023 22:17:23 False suggestion
Alston-247
H
1669 John Alston uncertain 1670 England before 30 Nov 1719 certain South Carolina Male WikiTree-36
Q104900230 John Alston ((1669-1718)) 1669 1718 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 19.07.2022 18:24:25 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Winder-550
H
7 Feb 1800 Brig Gen John Henry Winder 21 Feb 1800 Somerset, Maryland, United States 7 Feb 1865 Florence, South Carolina, United States Male Jones-116753
Q1678817 John H. Winder (Confederate Army general) 7 Feb 1800 Somerset County United States of America 21 Feb 1865 7 Feb 1865 Florence United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jones-116753 07.10.2023 11:55:05 False suggestion Find a Grave and Virginia Encyclopedia have a diff
Matthews-4925
H
1812 Joseph Warren Matthews aka Mathews uncertain 3 Aug 1807 Laurens County, South Carolina, United States 27 Aug 1862 Palmetto, Fulton, Georgia, United States Male Kolze-7
Q767415 Joseph Warren Matthews (American politician (1812-1862)) 1812 Huntsville United States of America 27 Aug 1862 Palmetto United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
kolze-7 21.05.2019 19:10:33 Not corrected Death monument shows 1812, but it was erected in 1919, 55 years after death. 1807 date is in-line with 1840, 1850, 1860 census and other sources.
kolze-7 28.01.2021 10:48:43 False suggestion Grave monument is wrong. Noted in research notes.
McIntosh-1501
H
17 Mar 1725 Brig. Gen. Lachlan McIntosh certain 27 Jan 1726 certain Raitts, Alvie Parish, Scotland certain 19 Feb 1806 Savannah, Chatham County, Georgia, United States Male Miller-22094
Q3215815 Lachlan McIntosh (American general (1725–1806)) 17 Mar 1725 Kingussie United Kingdom 20 Feb 1806 Savannah United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stuewe-5 11.05.2018 04:58:27 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Casey-731
H
1752 BGen Levi Garrett Casey certain 1749 certain Old 96 District, now Newberry District, South Carolina certain 1 Feb 1807 certain Washington, District of Columbia, United States Male Murray-10306

Peebles-1436

Grant-3042
Q1821849 Levi Casey (American politician (1752-1807)) 1752 South Carolina United States of America 3 Feb 1807 Washington, D.C. United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Murray-10306 19.07.2017 23:49:17 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography and project protected
Murray-10306 19.07.2017 23:50:54 False suggestion Death occured on 1 Feb, he was buried 3 Feb; error in several records; project protected
Berringer-23
H
31 Jan 1643 Margaret Moore (Berringer) certain 1661 Barbados uncertain 9 Jun 1720 certain Berkeley County, Province of South Carolina Female Bairfield-1
Q108060899 Margaret Moore ((1643-1720)) 31 Jan 1643 9 Jun 1720 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Morgan-33325 22.12.2022 18:06:45 False suggestion
Foissin-6
H
1720 Mary Elizabeth Pawley (Foissin) uncertain 1713 Province of South Carolina before 5 Oct 1770 Prince George Parish, Province of South Carolina Female Morgan-33325

Thompson-34031
Q96288459 Mary Elizabeth Foissin (- Abt 11 Aug 1768/5 Oct 1770) 1720 1768 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Morgan-33325 03.04.2024 19:18:22 False suggestion cites secondary source
Bailey-20543
H
1820 Mary Polly Hines (Bailey) uncertain 1811 uncertain South Carolina, United States after 1870 uncertain Mississippi, United States Female Carter-262
Q75763032 Mary (?) (Peerage person ID=321531) 1820 6 Apr 1893 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carter-262 23.12.2023 06:01:24 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Evans-31323
H
13 May 1872 Matilda Arabella Evans uncertain 1866 certain Aiken, South Carolina, United States certain 17 Nov 1935 certain Columbia, Richland, South Carolina, United States Female WikiTree-112

Jousma-11
Q4793653 Matilda Evans (African-American physician in South Carolina (1872-1935)) 13 May 1872 Aiken United States of America 17 Nov 1935 Columbia United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Melick-229 18.06.2022 11:18:10 Corrected Research note explains difference - WT date is cor
Gardner-10299 09.04.2023 20:34:21 False suggestion
Murdaugh-75
H
15 Jan 1915 Randolph Murdaugh Jr certain 9 Jan 1915 Varnville, Hampton, South Carolina, United States certain 5 Feb 1998 Hampton, Hampton, South Carolina, United States Male Burch-2229
Q117103616 Randolph "Buster" Murdaugh Jr. (South Carolina man (1915–1998)) 15 Jan 1915 5 Feb 1998 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
burch-2229 30.03.2023 03:48:41 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Richardson-5981
H
30 Apr 1704 Brig. Gen. Richard Richardson uncertain May 1704 certain Jamestown, James City, Virginia uncertain 2 Sep 1780 certain Rimini, Clarendon, South Carolina, United States Male Baker-23496

Stevens-10339

Hudson-1980
Q65071111 Richard Richardson ((1704-1780)) 30 Apr 1704 Virginia United States of America 2 Sep 1780 South Carolina United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Sharpless-254 18.12.2021 18:00:20 False suggestion
Anderson-2169
H
5 Nov 1741 Colonel Robert Anderson 15 Nov 1741 Augusta County, Colony of Virginia before 9 Jan 1813 Oconee County, South Carolina, United States Male Gilbert-5219
Q7341508 Robert Anderson (American politician, militia officer, and surveyor (1741–1813)) 5 Nov 1741 Augusta County United States of America 9 Jan 1813 Oconee County United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gilbert-5219 13.02.2019 11:01:55 Not corrected No source available currently for exact DOB.
Gilbert-5219 13.02.2019 11:33:47 False suggestion WikiDate is incorrect per wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Anderson_(Revolutionary_War)
Turnbull-957
H
Jan 1775 Robert James Turnbull certain 14 Jan 1774 New Symrna, Florida certain 15 Jun 1833 Charleston, Charleston, South Carolina, United States Male Braun-712
Q7346055 Robert James Turnbull (American lawyer, planter, writer and politician) Jan 1775 15 Jun 1833 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Buckner-1530 12.08.2023 18:06:30 False suggestion
Blue-489
H
30 May 1868 Dr Rupert Lee Blue certain 30 May 1867 certain Richmond, North Carolina, United States certain 12 Apr 1948 certain Charleston, Charleston, South Carolina, United States Male Orphan
Q549814 Rupert Blue (Surgeon General of the United States) 30 May 1868 Richmond County United States of America 12 Apr 1948 Charleston United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID5703252 17.12.2016 11:05:23 False suggestion Old False error
Priest-412 24.09.2021 11:19:54 False suggestion YOB is documented to be '1867', regardless of what Wikidate misrepresents.
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Pruyn-112
H
1908 Ruth Field (Pruyn) aka Phipps certain 5 May 1907 New York City, New York, United States 25 Jan 1994 Beaufort, Beaufort, South Carolina, United States Female Cross-9591
Q75908327 Ruth Pruyn ((died 1994)) 1908 25 Jan 1994 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cross-9591 05.12.2023 18:19:24 Not corrected Wikidata date is incorrect
Cross-9591 05.12.2023 18:22:35 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Agnew-97
H
1783 Samuel Andrew Agnew II uncertain 1782 certain Abbeville County, South Carolina certain 20 Jul 1844 certain Abbeville County, South Carolina, United States Male Wilder-1162
Q75406048 Samuel Agnew ((born 1783)) 1783 20 Jul 1844 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wilder-1162 02.12.2022 03:02:38 False suggestion
Miller-28378
H
8 May 1787 Stephen Decatur Miller 10 May 1787 Waxhaw Settlement, South Carolina 8 Mar 1838 Raymond, Mississippi Male Sanders-14220

Thompson-34031

Miller-44426
Q883777 Stephen Decatur Miller (American politician (Nullifier Party) (1787-1838)) 8 May 1787 Waxhaws United States of America 8 Mar 1838 Raymond United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thompson-34031 02.02.2018 03:21:13 Corrected Corrected
Thompson-34031 19.02.2018 17:51:04 False suggestion Conflicting data