Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 305: Mother too young or not born Help Video (Difficulty: Advanced)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Prat-1
H
Margaret Prat Mother before 1187 uncertain Libberton, Lanarkshire, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Melville-42
H
William Melville Child after 1189 uncertain Libberton, Lanarkshire, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 20.07.2021 19:01:16 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Ogilvy-131
H
Margaret Oliphant (Ogilvy) Mother uncertain 1420 uncertain Auchterhouse, Forfarshire, Scotland after 1471 uncertain Female Orphan
Oliphant-70
H
Margaret Maggie Oliphant Child before 1424 certain Torrie, Fifeshire, Scotland uncertain 1491 Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 17.05.2021 05:16:22 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Borthwick-2
H
Agnes Borthwick Mother before 1440 certain Borthwick. Midlothian, Scotland not living uncertain Edinburghshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Dundas-13
H
Janet Dundas Child uncertain 1445 Scotland Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 03.06.2022 05:32:54 False suggestion Her mother is unknown. Not the dau of the 2nd wif
Borthwick-2
H
Agnes Borthwick Mother before 1440 certain Borthwick. Midlothian, Scotland not living uncertain Edinburghshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Dundas-24
H
Beatrix Moncreiffe (Dundas) Child uncertain 1430 Dundas, West Lothian, Scotland uncertain 1459 Calder, West Lothian, Scotland Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 03.06.2022 05:32:58 False suggestion Her mother is unknown. Not the dau of the 2nd wif
Stewart-1515
H
Isabel Stewart Mother before Apr 1453 certain Lorn, Argyllshire, Scotland certain 26 Oct 1510 certain Dunbarton, Dunbartonshire, Scotland Female Felch-7
Campbell-2324
H
Lady Margaret Seton (Campbell) Child uncertain 1457 certain Scotland 1530 Seton Manor, East Lothian, Scotland Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 21.07.2023 02:56:03 Corrected Corrected
Anderson-23510 26.07.2023 04:59:53 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Accarson-1
H
Marion Maclellan (Accarson) aka Gordon Mother 1478 Kirkcudbrightshire, Scotland 7 Aug 1538 Kirkcudbrightshire, Scotland Female Cochoit-2
Gordon-3186
H
Katherine Gordon Child uncertain 1480 Lochinvar, Scotland Female Cochoit-2
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Douglas-3089 01.02.2022 21:20:53 False suggestion
MacDonald-375
H
Catherine MacDonald Mother 1492 Castle Tioram, Inverness-shire, Scotland Female Orphan
Macdonald-2104
H
Donald Donald Gorm Macdonald of Sleat (Macdonald) Child after 1500 1539 Eilean Donan, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 28.03.2020 15:39:33 False suggestion
Francis-9129
H
Lady Elizabeth Montgomerie (Francis) of Stane Mother before 1500 uncertain Scotland after 1554 uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Montgomerie-463
H
Arthur Montgomerie aka of Grenefield and Stane Child after 1508 Ayrshire, Scotland before 3 Sep 1546 Male Penman-567
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Penman-567 06.06.2022 12:46:14 False suggestion Birth year is before 1752.No source for correct year
Urquhart-476
H
Janet Urquhart aka Rose Mother uncertain 1535 Scotland uncertain 1600 certain Kilravock, Morayshire, Scotland Female Thomas-10705

Urquhart-93
Rose-787
H
John Rose Child uncertain 1540 Morayshire, Scotland Male McDonald-6970
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 24.03.2020 21:27:31 False suggestion already fixed
Hamilton-29211
H
Jean Hamilton Mother uncertain 1539 certain Preston, Berwick, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Hamilton-25124
H
James Hamilton IIIrd of Stonehouse (Hamilton) Child after 1548 certain Scotland before 1589 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 11.02.2022 04:04:36 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
MacLeod-753
H
Margaret MacDonald (MacLeod) Mother before 1539 Lewis, Scotland Female Orphan
Macdonald-1921
H
Donald Gormeson Macdonald of Sleat (Macdonald) Child 1522 Sleat, Skye, Inverness-Shire, Scotland 1585 Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Parker-10195
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McFeaters-9 21.12.2023 05:54:12 False suggestion not helpful
MacLeod-753
H
Margaret MacDonald (MacLeod) Mother before 1539 Lewis, Scotland Female Orphan
MacDonald-1971
H
Alexander Alexander Og MacDonald Child before 1539 Sleat, Isle of Skye, Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McFeaters-9 21.12.2023 05:54:12 False suggestion not helpful
Fleming-5445
H
Margaret Fleming Lady Silvieland (Fleming) Mother before 1550 Barrochan, Renfrewshire, Scotland after 1550 Silvieland, Renfrewshire, Scotland Female Kopriva-31
Knox-640
H
William Knox IInd of Silvieland (Knox) Child uncertain 1539 certain Renfrewshire, Scotland certain 5 Dec 1592 uncertain Male Kopriva-31
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 02.08.2023 15:20:13 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
MacLeod-1557
H
Mary MacNeil (MacLeod) Mother uncertain 1576 certain Isle of Barra, Iverness, Scotland uncertain 1609 certain Isle of Barra, Iverness, Scotland Female McFeaters-9
MacNeil-162
H
Neil Og MacNeil Child uncertain 1583 certain Barra, Inverness-shire, Scotland after 1651 certain Scotland Male Hanrahan-317
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID2430056 05.12.2016 15:22:49 False suggestion Old False error
MacLeod-1557
H
Mary MacNeil (MacLeod) Mother uncertain 1576 certain Isle of Barra, Iverness, Scotland uncertain 1609 certain Isle of Barra, Iverness, Scotland Female McFeaters-9
Macneil-210
H
John Og Macneil Child uncertain 1584 Scotland uncertain 1624 Scotland Male McFeaters-9
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID2430056 05.12.2016 15:22:45 False suggestion Old False error
Grant-21070
H
Elizabeth Grant Mother before 1576 certain Scotland uncertain 1630 uncertain Glen Moriston, Inverness-shire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Trowbridge-764
Grant-5696
H
John Grant Tutor of Glenmoriston (Grant) Child uncertain 1584 uncertain Glenmoriston, Inverness-shire, Scotland after 1648 uncertain Glenmoriston, Inverness-shire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 30.11.2022 05:15:58 False suggestion all dates are estimates
Grant-21070
H
Elizabeth Grant Mother before 1576 certain Scotland uncertain 1630 uncertain Glen Moriston, Inverness-shire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Trowbridge-764
Grant-5690
H
Patrick Grant IVth of Glenmoriston (Grant) Child uncertain 1573 certain Glenmoriston, Urquhart Parish, Inverness-Shire, Scotland after 1643 uncertain Glenmoriston, Urquhart Parish, Inverness-Shire, Scotland Male Trowbridge-764
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 30.11.2022 05:15:56 False suggestion all dates are estimates
Glen-564
H
Sibella of Barr Sempill (Glen) Mother before 1582 Female Orphan
Sempill-138
H
Robert of Millbank Sempill Child uncertain 1590 Renfrewshire, Scotland certain 1663 Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 30.06.2020 11:06:03 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
anderson-23510 30.06.2020 17:20:57 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Orr-4094
H
Janet Whitefoord (Orr) aka Whiteford Mother before 7 Dec 1693 Kilbirnie, Ayrshire, Scotland Female Colson-341
Whitefoord-29
H
Janet Whitefoord Child before 5 Dec 1703 Mossend, Ayrshire, Scotland before 1707 Scotland Female Colson-341
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Colson-341 24.07.2019 08:44:11 False suggestion mother's birth is before 1693
Maiden-102
H
Unknown Maiden Mother 1704 Scotland Female Henning-520
Scott-11111
H
Andrew Scott Child after 1706 Scotland not living Colerain, Lancaster, Pennsylvania Male Henning-520
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID2478858 09.06.2016 03:33:30 False suggestion Old False error
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Holland-799
H
Sarah Walker (Holland) Mother 1773 14 Jul 1817 Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom Female Lavoie-802

Walker-2526
Walker-2910
H
Abigail Smith Haig (Walker) Child uncertain 1780 Scotland certain 15 Aug 1849 Clackmannanshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Female Walker-2526
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dyment-55 08.10.2023 21:18:49 False suggestion
Shirrald-1
H
Katharine Taylor (Shirrald) Mother before 1775 Female McNaughton-340
Taylor-21815
H
Elisabeth Skinner (Taylor) Child uncertain 1775 Midmar, Aberdeenshire, Scotland uncertain 1855 Banchory Ternan, Kincardineshire Female McNaughton-340
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 03.10.2023 18:31:46 Corrected changed possible birth year
McIntosh-5576 03.10.2023 18:41:53 False suggestion
Henderson-10748
H
Sophia Woodman Penny (Henderson) Mother after Apr 1835 Strichen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland certain 20 Apr 1899 Cowbog, New Pitsligo, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Female Pennie-22
Penny-1241
H
William Penny II Child certain 20 May 1781 certain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland, uncertain 21 Sep 1897 certain Colombo, Western, Sri Lanka Male Pennie-22
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
pENNIE-22 14.09.2023 12:10:38 False suggestion Birth year is before 1752.No source for correct year
McQuean-1
H
Elizabeth Rhind (McQuean) Mother uncertain 1870 Aberdeenshire, Scotland. Female Sim-219
Rhind-50
H
Christian Bisset (Rhind) Child certain 1792 certain Strichen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland. uncertain 1856 uncertain Strichen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland. Female Sim-219
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Murray-20099 14.08.2022 05:11:10 False suggestion