Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information 
.
| Link |
Info |
Name |
Rel. |
Birth |
Death |
Gender |
|
Manager |
Marriage |
Status |
Davidson-3743
 H   |
1680 |
Alexander 10th Laird of Gight Gordon of Gight (Davidson) aka ygr of Newton |
|
uncertain 15 Jun 1683 certain St Nicholas, Aberdeen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1716 certain Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
 |
Gordon-7317
|
|
|
| Q75502960 |
Alexander Davidson (Peerage person ID=180998) |
|
1680 |
1731 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 09:17:45 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Duff-1054
H |
5 Jan 1687 |
Alexander Duff Ist of Hatton (Duff) |
|
certain 5 Jan 1688 certain Hatton, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
certain 27 Dec 1753 uncertain Keithmore, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Rowe-6599
|
|
|
| Q75501883 |
Alexander Duff, 1st of Hatton ((1687-1753)) |
|
5 Jan 1687 |
1753 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Rowe-6599 |
01.04.2020 14:32:41 |
False suggestion |
Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity |
|
Seton-179
H |
14cen |
Sir Alexander Gordon First Earl of Huntly (Seton) |
|
uncertain 1410 uncertain Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
15 Jul 1470 certain Huntly, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
 |
WikiTree-65
WikiTree-36
|
|
|
| Q495612 |
Alexander Gordon, 1st Earl of Huntly (Scottish magnate) |
|
14cen
1409
14cen
1409
14cen
14cen |
15 Jul 1470 Huntly United Kingdom |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| thomas-10705 |
17.03.2019 17:18:03 |
Corrected |
Fixed incorrect Wikidata date |
| Noland-165 |
30.03.2020 05:43:47 |
Comment |
neither date has solid support - left a comment |
| Cayley-55 |
30.03.2020 08:11:22 |
False suggestion |
Wikidata is unsourced |
|
Jaffray-78
H |
1510 |
Alexander Jaffray aka Joffray |
|
uncertain 1515 Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1569 Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Browne-2174
|
|
|
| Q75734913 |
Alexander Jaffray (Peerage person ID=307942) |
|
1510 |
1569 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 09:20:33 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Gill-5617
H |
1833 |
Alexander Ogston Gill |
|
certain 13 Nov 1832 Aberdeen, Scotland |
certain 8 Apr 1908 certain Aberdeen, Scotland |
Male |
|
Whitaker-808
|
|
|
| Q75381518 |
Alexander Ogston Gill ((1833-1908)) |
|
1833 |
1908 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Tough-78 |
13.03.2024 15:06:25 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Shepherd-5394
H |
1797 |
Alexander Sandy Shepherd |
|
certain 4 Jun 1798 certain Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
certain 20 Jul 1859 certain Auckland, New Zealand |
Male |
|
Ledger-534
|
|
|
| Q4720078 |
Alexander Shepherd (New Zealand public servant) |
|
1797 Aberdeen United Kingdom |
20 Jul 1859 Auckland New Zealand |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Shelley-714 |
14.12.2018 21:49:01 |
Corrected |
|
| Ledger-534 |
12.12.2022 19:36:14 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Gordon-736
H |
1599 |
Lady Anne Countess of Huntley Stewart (Gordon) |
|
1590 Huntly, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
1674 Dyke, Moray, Scotland |
Female |
|
Gordon-7317
|
|
|
| Q75268488 |
Lady Anne Gordon (Peerage person ID=25071) |
|
1599 |
1674 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 09:22:55 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Macpherson-1746
H |
1818 |
Christina Edgeworth (Macpherson) |
|
certain 31 Jan 1819 certain Aberdeen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
certain 11 Apr 1882 certain Bournemouth, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Smith-245546
|
|
|
| Q76332716 |
Christina Macpherson (Peerage person ID=695358) |
|
1818 |
1881 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 18:06:03 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is not reliable |
|
Black-20635
H |
27 Feb 1890 |
Dorothy Delius Allan MacLeish (Black) |
|
certain 27 Mar 1890 Bradford, Yorkshire West Riding, United Kingdom |
certain 12 Feb 1977 Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Bates-10490
|
|
|
| Q5298314 |
Dorothy Black (British journalist and novelist) |
|
27 Feb 1890 Bradford United Kingdom |
1977 Scotland United Kingdom |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Bates-10490 |
26.04.2022 17:37:52 |
False suggestion |
WikiData is wrong |
|
Keith-210
H |
Jan 1522 |
Elizabeth Keith of Inverugie (Keith) aka Forbes |
|
uncertain 1514 uncertain Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
uncertain 13 Nov 1604 uncertain Forbes, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Female |
|
Thomas-10705
Carson-514
|
|
|
| Q75273925 |
Elizabeth Keith (Peerage person ID=29748) |
|
Jan 1522 |
13 Nov 1604 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
06.12.2023 04:26:33 |
False suggestion |
peerage is unreliable |
|
Sinclair-389
H |
1500 |
Elizabeth Sinclair |
|
before 8 May 1519 Newburgh, Foveran, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
2 Jan 1562 Airlie, Angus, Scotland |
Female |
|
Middleton-955
|
|
|
| Q76296424 |
Elizabeth Helen Sinclair (Peerage person ID=670210) |
|
1500 |
1562 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 09:55:10 |
Comment |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 17:50:43 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is not reliable |
|
Berkeley-81
H |
1167 |
Sir Humphrey de Berkeley (Berkeley) |
|
uncertain 1160 Glenfarquharln, Kincardineshire, Scotland |
before 1226 Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Lee-759
|
|
|
| Q75244911 |
Sir Humphrey Berkeley (Peerage person ID=6610) |
|
1167 |
|
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
06.12.2023 04:28:24 |
False suggestion |
peerage is unreliable |
|
Cheyne-444
H |
1575 |
Isabel Cheyne |
|
uncertain 1573 certain Esselmont, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1630 uncertain Perthshire, Scotland |
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q75274092 |
Isabel Cheyne (Peerage person ID=29880) |
|
1575 |
1630 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 17:28:19 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is unreliable |
|
Arbuthnot-250
H |
1557 |
Sir James Arbuthnott (Arbuthnot) |
|
uncertain 1559 certain Arbuthnott, Kincardineshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1606 certain North Esk, Scotland |
Male |
|
Simmons-11603
|
|
|
| Q75257375 |
James Arbuthnott of Arrat ((died 1606)) |
|
1557 |
1606 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Simmons-11603 |
28.11.2023 16:53:54 |
False suggestion |
Wikidata date is approximate |
|
Gordon-6226
H |
1395 |
James Gordon Ist of Haddo IIIrd of Methlic (Gordon) |
|
before 1422 certain Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1480 certain Methlick, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Urquhart-93
|
|
|
| Q75404296 |
James Gordon of Methlic and Haddo (Peerage person ID=120820) |
|
1395 |
1480 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 22:52:20 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is unreliable |
|
Dunbar-1162
H |
1416 |
Janet Dunbar |
|
uncertain 1427 certain Huntley, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
before 19 Jan 1506 uncertain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland |
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q75902169 |
Lady Janet Dunbar (Peerage person ID=392399) |
|
1416 |
1506 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
06.12.2023 04:29:40 |
False suggestion |
peerage is unreliable |
|
Meldrum-792
H |
1680 |
Jean Grant (Meldrum) |
|
uncertain 1675 Meldrum, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
8 Aug 1708 Edinburgh, Scotland |
Female |
|
Butler-12579
|
|
|
| Q75951582 |
Jean Meldrum (Peerage person ID=425154) |
|
1680 |
|
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 10:11:27 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Duff-1275
H |
14 Jan 1726 |
John Duff of Hatton (Duff) |
|
14 Jan 1727 |
certain 2 Aug 1787 certain Hatton Castle, Turriff, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Rowe-6599
|
|
|
| Q75501895 |
John Duff ((1726-1787)) |
|
14 Jan 1726 |
2 Aug 1787 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Rowe-6599 |
01.04.2020 15:09:42 |
False suggestion |
Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity |
|
Erskine-423
H |
1217 |
Sir John Erskine |
|
before 1246 certain Mar, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
after 14 May 1271 uncertain Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q76080809 |
Sir John Erskine of that Ilk (Peerage person ID=516815) |
|
1217 |
1271 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 22:42:07 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is unreliable |
|
Duff-2981
H |
6 Nov 1866 |
Katharine Stevens (Duff) aka Duff-Stevens |
|
certain 6 Dec 1866 Turriff, Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
certain 22 Dec 1927 Gibraltar |
Female |
|
Rowe-6599
|
|
|
| Q75502345 |
Katherine Duff ((1866-1927)) |
|
6 Nov 1866 |
22 Dec 1927 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Rowe-6599 |
05.02.2020 19:33:26 |
Comment |
Wikidata is incorrect - see birth date source on profile |
| Urquhart-93 |
28.10.2022 03:21:38 |
False suggestion |
|
|
| Link |
Info |
Name |
Rel. |
Birth |
Death |
Gender |
|
Manager |
Marriage |
Status |
Harvey-9233
H |
1786 |
Katherine Catherine Crombie (Harvey) |
|
uncertain 1787 Newmachar, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
30 Jul 1864 Old Manse, Cothal Mills, Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Whitaker-808
|
|
|
| Q75779345 |
Catherine Harvey (Peerage person ID=329877) |
|
1786 |
1864 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
06.12.2023 04:52:18 |
False suggestion |
peerage is unreliable |
|
Menzies-331
H |
1510 |
Katherine Fraser (Menzies) |
|
uncertain 1505 uncertain Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
|
Female |
|
Howard-18870
Hare-1576
|
|
|
| Q76328347 |
Catherine Menzies (Peerage person ID=691848) |
|
1510 |
|
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 10:20:56 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Ramsay-329
H |
1 Sep 1806 |
Lauderdale Burnett (Ramsay) |
|
27 Aug 1806 Fettercairn, Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
4 Nov 1888 Edinburgh, Edinburghshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q75518988 |
Lauderdale Ramsay ((1806-1888)) |
|
1 Sep 1806 |
4 Nov 1888 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Creighton-890 |
11.04.2020 18:30:39 |
False suggestion |
WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile |
|
MacRory-41
H |
1030 |
Lulach MacGilleomgain King of Scots (MacRory) |
|
uncertain 1032 Morayshire, Scotland |
certain 17 Mar 1058 Essie, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Perkins-11750
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
| Q117633 |
Lulach (Scottish king (1030-1058)) |
|
1030 Moray United Kingdom |
17 Mar 1058
17 Mar 1058 Aberdeenshire United Kingdom |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Perkins-11750 |
21.11.2022 15:19:11 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Duff-3041
H |
6 Dec 1871 |
Mabel Duff |
|
certain 15 Nov 1871 Kirktown of Auchterless, Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
certain 9 Apr 1908 Bournemouth, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Rowe-6599
|
|
|
| Q75502364 |
Mabel Duff ((1871-1908)) |
|
6 Dec 1871 |
9 Apr 1908 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Rowe-6599 |
15.02.2020 11:51:07 |
False suggestion |
Wikidata birthdate is incorrect. Birth reg at Scotland's People shows birth date on profile is correct |
|
Unknown-377584
H |
1830 |
May Smith Brown (Unknown) |
|
certain 5 Sep 1825 Cruden Bay, Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
16 Aug 1897 Cruden, Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Thomas-7679
|
|
|
| Q122380605 |
May Brown (1830 -) |
|
1830 |
|
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Thomas-7679 |
29.02.2024 12:20:02 |
False suggestion |
Wikidata source is wikitree, and the wikitree profile has now been updated with good sources. |
|
Hay-1186
H |
1292 |
Nicholas de la Hay (Hay) aka de la Haya |
|
uncertain 1288 uncertain Slains Castle, Buchan, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
before 1333 uncertain Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
| Q75662155 |
Nicholas de la Haye, younger of Erroll (Peerage person ID=278489) |
|
1292 |
1332 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 18:24:53 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is not reliable |
|
Gordon-4315
H |
1440 |
Sir Patrick of Methlic Gordon IInd of Haddo (Gordon) |
|
before 1443 certain Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
before 2 Mar 1534 uncertain Methlick, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q75404295 |
Patrick Gordon of Methlic and Haddo (Peerage person ID=120819) |
|
1440 |
1531 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
06.12.2023 04:37:20 |
False suggestion |
peerage is unreliable |
|
Ramsay-340
H |
23 Feb 1786 |
Captain Thomas Ramsay |
|
24 Feb 1786 Balmain, Kincardineshire, Scotland |
18 Dec 1857 |
Male |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q75518976 |
Thomas Ramsay ((1786-1857)) |
|
23 Feb 1786 |
17 Dec 1857 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Creighton-890 |
11.04.2020 18:28:01 |
False suggestion |
WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile |
|
Hay-1072
H |
21 Feb 1801 |
Sir William George Hay Eighteenth Earl of Erroll (Hay) KT GCH |
|
certain 21 Jan 1801 certain Cruden, Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
19 Apr 1846 certain London, England, United Kingdom |
Male |
|
Pettifer-45
|
|
|
| Q336411 |
William Hay, 18th Earl of Erroll (British Earl (1801-1846)) |
|
21 Feb 1801 |
19 Apr 1846 London United Kingdom |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Urquhart-93 |
19.12.2021 23:14:21 |
False suggestion |
date is incorrect |
|
Hay-306
H |
1423 |
William Hay First Earl of Errol (Hay) |
|
1412 Erroll, Perth, Scotland |
after 15 Nov 1461 Slains, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
| Q18821934 |
William Hay, 1st Earl of Erroll (Scottish nobleman, died 1462) |
|
1423 Errol United Kingdom |
15 Nov 1461 Old Slains Castle United Kingdom |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
22.11.2020 20:27:15 |
False suggestion |
birth date is unsourced |
|
Penny-1063
H |
12 Jul 1809 |
Mr William Penny |
|
certain 24 Jul 1808 certain Peterhead, Scotland |
certain 1 Feb 1892 certain 22 Springbank Terrace, Aberdeen, Scotland |
Male |
|
Pennie-22
|
|
|
| Q329291 |
William Penny (Scottish shipmaster, whaler and arctic explorer (1809-1892)) |
|
12 Jul 1809 Peterhead United Kingdom |
1 Feb 1892 Aberdeen United Kingdom |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Pennie-22 |
17.02.2019 06:40:03 |
False suggestion |
Date in wikitree is from his own records and from book writtten by hs wfe |
|