Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 575: FindAGrave - Different birth date Help Video (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Randolph-3
H 		24 Feb 1687 Colonel Isham Randolph certain 24 Feb 1685 certain Turkey Island, Henrico County, Virginia certain 2 Nov 1742 certain Dungeness, Goochland County, Virginia Male WikiTree-6
16714439 Isham Randolph 24 Feb 1687 Henrico County, Virginia, USA 2 Nov 1742 Goochland County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 05.01.2022 20:40:13 False suggestion headstone clearly indicates death date and age at death
Walker-421
H 		11 Jun 1874 George Herbert Walker 11 Jun 1875 St Louis, St Louis, Missouri, USA 24 Jun 1953 New York, New York, New York, USA Male Hirsch-65

WikiTree-6
121153997 George Herbert “Bert” Walker Sr. 11 Jun 1874 Saint Louis, St. Louis City, Missouri, USA 24 Jun 1953 New York, New York County, New York, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 15.05.2019 01:57:39 False suggestion inscription is in error
Allerton-5
H 		1628 Col Isaac Allerton uncertain 1630 certain Plymouth, Plymouth Colony before 30 Dec 1702 certain Westmoreland, Colony of Virginia Male WikiTree-9

WikiTree-6
132411294 COL Isaac Allerton II 1628 Plymouth, Plymouth County, Massachusetts, USA 1702 Westmoreland County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Taylor-25258 22.04.2017 22:48:13 Corrected changed to match f-a-g/ needs sources
Lee-5956 12.09.2018 00:57:52 False suggestion DoB is unsourced
Taylor-679
H 		12 Feb 1634 James Taylor I uncertain 1635 uncertain England certain 30 Apr 1698 uncertain King and Queen County, Colony of Virginia Male Heierle-1

Wolfe-522

WikiTree-24

WikiTree-6
18538665 James “The Elder” Taylor I 12 Feb 1634 Carlisle, City of Carlisle, Cumbria, England 30 Apr 1698 Bowling Green, Caroline County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 01.04.2017 19:08:59 False suggestion There are NO SOURCES for his birth as many, many genealogists indicate. His birth is merely a GUESS. With the birth year on FindAGrave, his age at the birth of his children seems old, whereas the estimate on the profile seems to be more likely. I am posting that if anyone wants to change the data on the profile, this is acceptable, as no dates are proven.
Smith-3323
H 		24 Mar 1666 Captain William Smith 24 Mar 1667 Charlestown, Suffolk County, Massachusetts 3 Jun 1730 Charlestown, Suffolk County, Massachusetts Male Smith-83380

WikiTree-6
51164225 Capt William Smith 24 Mar 1666 Charlestown, Suffolk County, Massachusetts, USA 3 Jun 1730 Charlestown, Suffolk County, Massachusetts, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 14.05.2018 23:15:29 Corrected
Lee-5956 28.09.2022 02:29:18 False suggestion actual birth record has different date
Randolph-94
H 		Nov 1651 Col. William Randolph uncertain 7 Nov 1650 certain Moreton-Morrell, Warwickshire, England certain 21 Apr 1711 certain Turkey Island, Henrico County, Colony of Virginia Male WikiTree-6

WikiTree-36

Draper-310

Myers-2401
16714316 Col William Randolph Nov 1651 Moreton Morrell, Stratford-on-Avon District, Warwickshire, England 21 Apr 1711 Henrico County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Spradley-150 17.04.2018 05:10:15 Corrected corrected date
Noland-165 17.09.2018 19:39:33 False suggestion WikiTree (sourced) date is for baptism.
Noland-165 18.09.2019 09:36:37 False suggestion 7 Nov. 1650 baptism is supported in WikiTree profile's text
Truman-35
H 		25 Jun 1763 Jonathan Truman certain 17 Aug 1763 New London, New London, Connecticut certain 28 Oct 1833 Preston, New London, Connecticut, United States Male WikiTree-6

Turley-30
18639016 Jonathan Truman Jr. 25 Jun 1763 New London, New London County, Connecticut, USA 28 Oct 1833 Connecticut, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 03.08.2021 20:11:59 False suggestion old style vs new style dates per source attached to profile
Salter-100
H 		1665 Richard Salter uncertain 1660 England after 1728 Freehold, Monmouth, New Jersey Male Wendt-138

WikiTree-6

Harris-1220

Hamilton-1467
48919219 Richard Saltar 1665 England 1730 Middletown, Monmouth County, New Jersey, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Starr-1220 24.07.2017 13:48:11 Corrected updated profile
Lee-5956 16.02.2019 20:47:20 False suggestion FindAGrave is estimate
Fletcher-378
H 		22 Feb 1656 William Fletcher Jr. certain 22 Feb 1657 certain Chelmsford, Middlesex, Massachusetts Bay certain 23 May 1712 certain Chelmsford, Middlesex, Massachusetts Bay Male Nichol-198

WikiTree-6

Rockwell-390

Seaver-15

Felch-7
18168440 Lieut. William Fletcher 22 Feb 1656 Chelmsford, Middlesex County, Massachusetts, USA 23 May 1712 Chelmsford, Middlesex County, Massachusetts, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 12.09.2018 01:01:14 Corrected
Lee-5956 31.03.2021 22:59:57 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Harrison-899
H 		13 Dec 1730 Gov Benjamin Harrison V certain 5 Apr 1726 certain Berkley Plantation, Charles City County, Virginia 24 Apr 1791 certain Berkeley Plantation, Charles City County, Virginia, United States Male WikiTree-6

Oldershaw-4
2784 COL Benjamin Harrison V 13 Dec 1730 Berkeley, Charles City County, Virginia, USA 24 Apr 1791 Berkeley, Charles City County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 08.11.2018 19:30:28 Corrected Notified FindAGrave of its error
Lee-5956 13.11.2018 20:45:54 False suggestion
Strother-64
H 		1 Aug 1700 Lt. Col. Francis Strother uncertain 1695 certain King George, King George County, Colony of Virginia uncertain 1752 certain Culpeper County, Colony of Virginia Male WikiTree-24

WikiTree-6
98657597 Francis Strother Sr. 1 Aug 1700 King George County, Virginia, USA 17 Apr 1751 Culpeper County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 08.11.2018 18:21:24 False suggestion There are no records proving his birth, this is an estimate
Dabney-32
H 		1702 Susannah Strother (Dabney) uncertain 1692 certain Pamunkey River Area, King and Queen County, Colony of Virginia uncertain 1752 certain Culpeper County, Colony of Virginia Female Elliott-4170

Gómez Rossi-1

WikiTree-24

WikiTree-6
121220971 Susannah Dabney Strother 1702 Hanover County, Virginia, USA 1752
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 11.08.2020 02:15:53 False suggestion Profile addresses all the incorrect parents out there
Strother-135
H 		1 Nov 1653 William Strother III uncertain 1652 certain Virginia certain 26 Jul 1726 certain King George County, Virginia Colony Male WikiTree-6

McGill-1911

Moody-618

Ramer-34
51026216 William B Strother III 1 Nov 1653 Northumberland, England 26 Jul 1726 King George County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 09.04.2021 01:46:37 False suggestion no source on findagrave, all sources indicate birth is estimated
Catlett-52
H 		12 Jan 1622 Colonel John Catlett IV after 19 Jul 1625 Sittingbourne, Kent, England 18 Apr 1670 Port Royal, Caroline County, Colony of Virginia Male WikiTree-6

Hunter-5770

Lee-5956
86108560 Col John Catlett IV 12 Jan 1622 Sittingbourne, Swale Borough, Kent, England 18 Apr 1670 Port Royal, Caroline County, Virginia, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 08.07.2022 01:04:13 False suggestion no source on findagrave, date on WikiTree is baptism date with source
Richardson-1768
H 		25 Mar 1659 Sarah Fletcher (Richardson) certain 25 Mar 1660 certain Chelmsford, Middlesex, Massachusetts Bay Colony certain 30 Jan 1748 certain Dunstable, Middlesex, Province of Massachusetts Bay Female Felch-7

WikiTree-6

Rockwell-390
52993056 Sarah Richardson Fletcher 25 Mar 1659 Chelmsford, Middlesex County, Massachusetts, USA 30 Jan 1748 Dunstable, Middlesex County, Massachusetts, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 09.04.2021 02:10:35 False suggestion ambiguity with data 1659/60
Biden-5
H 		31 Oct 1866 George T. Biden Oct 1867 Maryland, United States 31 Jan 1933 Lakeland, Polk, Florida, United States Male Fuller-5853

WikiTree-6
34423037 George Thomas Biden 31 Oct 1866 Baltimore, Baltimore City, Maryland, USA 31 Jan 1933 Lakeland, Polk County, Florida, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 11.04.2021 01:17:16 False suggestion no source on findagrave
Fitzgerald-819
H 		1822 Thomas Fitzgerald uncertain 1829 certain Bruff, County Limerick, Ireland certain 19 May 1885 certain Boston, Suffolk, Massachusetts, United States Male WikiTree-6
86157586 Thomas Fitzgerald 1822 Bruff, County Limerick, Ireland 19 May 1885 Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 14.02.2018 21:05:01 False suggestion birth is unknown, conflicting information from tombstone erected long after his death and what he put on his marriage certificate.
Cox-2908
H 		1836 Rosanna Fitzgerald (Cox) 1834 County Cavan, Ireland 10 Mar 1879 Boston, Suffolk, Massachusetts, United States Female WikiTree-6
86157514 Rosanna Cox Fitzgerald 1836 County Fermanagh, Northern Ireland 12 Mar 1879 Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 16.04.2021 01:56:42 False suggestion DoB is unsourced
Filmore-3
H 		20 Mar 1739 Nathaniel Filmore Sr certain 20 Mar 1740 certain Norwich, New London, Connecticut, British Colonial America certain 7 Sep 1814 certain Bennington, Vermont, United States Male WikiTree-6
80868811 Lieut Nathaniel Fillmore 20 Mar 1739 Franklin, New London County, Connecticut, USA 7 Sep 1814 Bennington, Bennington County, Vermont, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 12.09.2018 01:02:13 False suggestion due to os vs ns in dates
Schuyler-188
H 		18 Oct 1735 Casparus Casper Schuyler 10 Dec 1735 Pompton Plains, New Jersey uncertain 1803 New Jersey, United States Male WikiTree-6
226709346 Casparus Schuyler 18 Oct 1735 1803
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 03.08.2021 19:17:05 False suggestion DoB is unsourced
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Burr-948
H 		1788 Louisa Webb (Burr) uncertain 1785 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States uncertain 1878 Female WikiTree-6
210963029 Louisa Charlotte Burr Webb Darius 1788 Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania, USA 1878 Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 22.07.2020 01:10:31 False suggestion both dates are estimates, WikiTree is based on articles on WikiPedia
Bomberger-62
H 		9 May 1844 Susan E. Liddell (Bomberger) uncertain 9 May 1843 Baltimore, Baltimore, Maryland, USA 25 Jul 1924 Baltimore, Baltimore, Maryland, USA Female Hegeman-288

WikiTree-6
140635362 Susan E. Bomberger Liddell 9 May 1844 Maryland, USA 25 Jul 1924 Baltimore City, Maryland, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 02.04.2021 01:36:49 Comment known discrepancy in death record and birth record, recorded at Find a Grave and WikiTree
Lee-5956 29.05.2021 00:01:54 False suggestion
Hanafee-4
H 		1815 John Hanafy (Hanafee) Sr uncertain 1820 uncertain Ballynacourty, Galway, Ireland certain 1878 West Union, Doddridge, West Virginia, United States Male Harrington-5286

Fuller-5853

WikiTree-6
64939164 John Hanafy 1815 Ireland 9 Aug 1878 Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 16.04.2021 01:17:17 False suggestion inscription is in error, it is modern, and oldest document has his birth as 1820
Reagan-554
H 		3 Sep 1829 Michael Reagan 1822 Ballyporeen, County Tipperary, Ireland 2 Mar 1884 Fair Haven, Carroll, Illinois, United States Male WikiTree-6
134816868 Michael Reagan 3 Sep 1829 Ballyporeen, County Tipperary, Ireland 10 Jan 1884 Fulton, Whiteside County, Illinois, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 17.04.2017 23:20:31 False suggestion FindAGrave is estimate
Phorson-1
H 		25 Oct 1830 Agnes Turnbull Cowan (Phorson) certain 25 Oct 1829 certain Roxburgh, Roxburghshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 17 Mar 1907 certain Paullina, O'Brien, Iowa, United States Female WikiTree-6
145331700 Agnes Phorson Cowan 25 Oct 1830 Roxburgh, Scottish Borders, Scotland 17 Mar 1907 Paullina, O'Brien County, Iowa, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 05.05.2021 00:03:58 False suggestion sources quote both dates, indicated on profile