Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Wangal-2
H
1764 Bennelong Woollarawarre Wangal uncertain 1762 Parramatta River, New South Wales, Australia 3 Jan 1813 Kissing Point, New South Wales (Australia) Male Thomas-7679

WikiTree-37
Q817828 Bennelong (Eora interlocutor with the British in Australia and the United Kingdom) 1764 Australia Australia 3 Jan 1813 Sydney Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 13.09.2021 17:47:55 False suggestion It's approximate
Kingsford-89
H
5 May 1857 Catherine Mary Kingsford Smith (Kingsford) 5 Jul 1857 Moreton Bay, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia 18 Mar 1938 North Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Female Thomas-7679
Q107305891 Catherine Mary Kingsford (5 May 1857 Brisbane, Qld - 18 Mar 1938 North Sydney, NSW) 5 May 1857 18 Mar 1938 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hayes-14615 21.11.2023 23:21:53 False suggestion WikiData is wrong. 5 July on birth certificate.
Cudmore-299
H
13 Jun 1885 Sir Collier Robert Cudmore certain 4 Jun 1885 Wentworth, Colony of New South Wales certain 16 May 1971 North Adelaide, South Australia, Australia Male Champion de Crespigny-8
Q1803028 Collier Cudmore (Australian politician and rower (1885-1971)) 13 Jun 1885 Avoca Australia 16 May 1971 North Adelaide Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Champion de Crespigny-8 24.04.2021 12:24:06 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography - comes from Australian Dictionary of Biography
Donnithorne-92
H
1826 Eliza Emily Donnithorne certain 8 Jul 1821 Cape Good Hope, South Africa 20 May 1886 Newtown, New South Wales, Australia Female Ragland-785
Q21537250 Eliza Emily Donnithorne ((1826-1886) recluse and eccentric) 1826 Cape of Good Hope South Africa 1886 Newtown Australia female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 01.12.2020 10:32:39 False suggestion Last week you wanted me to change DOB based on F-A-G. This week change it again due to Wikidata. Make up your mind.
Smith-281639
H
22 Apr 1892 Grace Cossington Smith OA OBE 20 Apr 1892 Neutral Bay, New South Wales 20 Dec 1984 Roseville, New South Wales, Australia Female Thomas-7679
Q3112987 Grace Cossington Smith (Australian artist (1892–1984)) 22 Apr 1892 Neutral Bay Australia 10 Dec 1984 20 Dec 1984 Roseville Australia female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 23.08.2022 09:22:55 False suggestion Birth date of 20 Apr 1892 is sourced
Cottee-24
H
22 Aug 1898 Harold Warnock Cottee OBE certain 22 Sep 1898 certain Lismore, New South Wales (Australia) 7 Dec 1973 certain Strathfield, New South Wales, Australia Male Bowden-5225
Q18715708 Harold Warnock Cottee (Australian businessman) 22 Aug 1898 Lismore Australia Dec 1973 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rogers-4360 07.08.2018 13:45:36 Corrected AIF Service record has DOB as 20 Sep 1898, but 22 is a correction written in pencil, so probably correct
Rogers-4360 24.01.2019 05:24:11 False suggestion Corrected 5 months ago - why is this still here
Jackson-21196
H
17 Mar 1843 Henrietta Priscilla Selfe (Jackson) aka Dyson-Holland, Martelli certain 23 Feb 1843 certain Selby, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 1906 certain Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Female Bates-10490
Q76334164 Henrietta Priscilla Jackson ((born 1843)) 17 Mar 1843 1906 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bates-10490 31.12.2019 15:49:38 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Frend-13
H
22 Jun 1891 Henry Christopher Blackett Frend 21 Jun 1891 Borrisafarney, Ireland 27 Jul 1964 Gulargambone , New South Wales, Australia Male Richardson-5769
Q75898978 Henry Christopher Blackett Frend ((1891-1964)) 22 Jun 1891 1964 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-5769 20.08.2020 03:03:09 False suggestion not dealing with that, not my relative.
Bate-1503
H
5 May 1906 Henry Jefferson Percival Bate certain 5 Mar 1906 Moruya, New South Wales, Australia certain 15 Apr 1984 Canberra, Australian Capital Territory, Australia Male Homburg-82
Q6173310 Jeff Bate (Australian politician (1906-1984)) 5 May 1906 Tilba Australia 15 Apr 1984 Canberra Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Homburg-82 03.05.2023 06:38:11 False suggestion
Alt-40
H
1731 Herman Augustus Theodore Augustus Alt certain 26 Aug 1734 certain London, England certain 9 Jan 1815 certain Parramatta, New South Wales, Australia Male Stevens-18395
Q4821367 Augustus Alt (British soldier and engineer) 1731 9 Jan 1815 City of Parramatta Council Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 20.02.2021 21:24:28 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
James-16982
H
1829 Humphrey Frederick Frederick Whirlpool Whirlpool (James) VC certain 17 Jul 1831 certain Dundalk, County Louth, Ireland certain 24 Jun 1899 certain McGrath's Hill, New South Wales (Australia) Male Evans-20927
Q5499026 Frederick Whirlpool (English recipient of the Victoria Cross) 1829 Liverpool United Kingdom 24 Jun 1899 New South Wales Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 21.09.2019 20:55:32 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Croft-1996
H
6 Apr 1911 Isabel McLeod Bea Croft certain 15 Apr 1911 Armidale, New South Wales, Australia 1 May 2008 Queensland, Australia Female Wickham-1317
Q75352095 Isabel McLeod Croft ((born 1911)) 6 Apr 1911 1 May 2008 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wickham-1317 26.12.2021 12:38:29 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Macarthur-289
H
1 Jan 1798 James Macarthur certain 15 Dec 1798 certain Parramatta, New South Wales, Australia certain 21 Apr 1867 certain Camden, New South Wales, Australia Male Orphan
Q6138667 James Macarthur (pastoralist and politician in New South Wales, Australia (1798–1867)) 1 Jan 1798 Parramatta Australia 21 Apr 1867 New South Wales Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 20.12.2018 19:17:05 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Rogers-25928
H
2 Jun 1875 James Rogers VC certain 4 Jul 1873 certain Moama, New South Wales (Australia) certain 28 Oct 1961 certain Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Male Evans-20927
Q6142359 James Rogers (recipient of the Victoria Cross) 2 Jun 1875 Echuca Australia 28 Oct 1961 Sydney Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 21.09.2019 20:58:55 False suggestion Not the same person
Kingsmill-62
H
1793 John Allen Kingsmill certain 1794 certain Ireland certain 7 Jul 1869 certain Maitland, New South Wales, Australia Male Gilbert-5441

Allen-12086
Q54721185 John Allen Kingsmill (New South Wales settler, b. 1793, d. 7 July 1869) 1793 7 Jul 1869 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Olney-518 07.06.2019 09:44:57 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Lynch-6451
H
2 Jun 1875 John Patrick Lynch certain 6 Feb 1875 certain Parkes, New South Wales, Australia certain 2 Jun 1944 certain Saint Leonards, New South Wales, Australia Male Lynch-2474
Q18385372 John Lynch (politician in New South Wales, Australia (1875–1944)) 2 Jun 1875 Parkes Australia 2 Jun 1944 St Leonards Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lynch-2474 11.03.2020 12:19:08 False suggestion Wikidata entry (Q18385372) is incorrect - ignore
Lavenu-2
H
1818 Lewis Henry Lavenu 7 Jan 1817 London, England, United Kingdom 1859 Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Male Orphan
Q6536683 Lewis Henry Lavenu (British musician) 1818 London United Kingdom 1859 Sydney Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 03.04.2021 23:48:57 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Cooper-20413
H
1903 Lynch Cooper uncertain 1905 Tocumwal, New South Wales, Australia 30 Jul 1971 Wangaratta, Victoria, Australia Male Whitworth-1421
Q27680839 Lynch Cooper (Australian sprinter) 1903 1971 Wangaratta Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 10.02.2021 22:15:16 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Wade-1931
H
5 Oct 1777 Mary Brooker (Wade) aka Harrigan before 10 May 1777 Westminister, London, England certain 17 Dec 1859 certain Fairy Meadow, Wollongong, New South Wales, Australia Female Caldwell-4836
Q6780901 Mary Wade (British criminal (1777-1859)) 5 Oct 1777 Southwark United Kingdom 17 Dec 1859 Fairy Meadow Australia female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jones-36835 30.05.2021 08:51:58 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Selfe-88
H
16 Feb 1845 Maybanke Susannah Anderson (Selfe) aka Wolstenholme 4 Feb 1845 Kingston upon Thames, Surrey, England 15 Apr 1927 St Germain-en-Laye, Paris, France Female Orphan
Q6796901 Maybanke Anderson (Sydney reformer (1845-1927)) 16 Feb 1845 Kingston upon Thames United Kingdom 15 Apr 1927 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 02.07.2017 18:08:10 Not corrected The date is from her baptism record, which might be incorrect since she was baptized after several months.
Ford-7139 04.01.2022 22:03:47 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Storkey-70
H
7 Dec 1891 Percy Valentine Storkey VC LLB certain 9 Sep 1893 certain Napier, Hawkes Bay, New Zealand certain 3 Oct 1969 certain Teddington, Middlesex, England, United Kingdom Male Evans-20927
Q7167598 Percy Storkey (recipient of the Victoria Cross) 7 Dec 1891 Napier New Zealand 3 Oct 1969 Teddington United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 21.09.2019 21:00:50 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Rattey-7
H
28 Mar 1918 Reginald Roy Rattey VC certain 28 Mar 1917 certain Barmedman, New South Wales, Australia certain 10 Jan 1986 certain West Wyalong, New South Wales, Australia Male Evans-20927
Q7307848 Reg Rattey (recipient of the Victoria Cross) 28 Mar 1918 Barmedman Australia 10 Jan 1986 West Wyalong Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 21.09.2019 21:02:57 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Marsden-349
H
28 Jul 1764 Reverend Samuel Marsden uncertain 25 Jun 1765 certain Farsley, Yorkshire, England certain 12 May 1838 certain Windsor, New South Wales (Australia) Male Evans-20927

WikiTree-37
Q1702147 Samuel Marsden (Church of England chaplain, missionary, agriculturalist, magistrate.) 28 Jul 1764 28 Jun 1764 24 Jun 1765 Farsley United Kingdom 12 May 1838 Windsor Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 20.12.2018 19:16:39 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Smith-178808
H
9 May 1913 Adm Sir Victor Alfred Trumper Smith KBE AC CB certain 3 May 1913 certain Chatswood, New South Wales, Australia certain 10 Jul 1998 certain Australian Capital Territory, Australia Male Evans-20927
Q7926351 Victor Smith (Australian admiral, Chief of Naval Staff, Chairman, Chiefs of Staff Committee (1913-1998)) 9 May 1913 Chatswood Australia 10 Jul 1998 Canberra Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 07.07.2019 16:31:23 Not corrected conflict between sources
evans-20927 21.09.2019 21:02:29 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Cooper-20371
H
1861 William Cooper uncertain 18 Dec 1860 Echuca, Victoria, Australia 29 Mar 1941 Mooroopna, Victoria, Australia Male Whitworth-1421
Q2578317 William Cooper (Australian Aboriginal activist) 1861 Victoria Australia 29 Mar 1941 Mooroopna Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 30.01.2021 18:46:27 False suggestion