Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 558: Wikidata - Different death date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Beaumont-2132
H
21 Sep 2004 Admiral Alan Lee Beaumont AC certain 24 Dec 1934 certain Boolaroo, New South Wales, Australia certain 21 Dec 2004 certain Australian Capital Territory, Australia Male Evans-20927
Q4706153 Alan Beaumont (Australian Navy officer (1934-2004)) 24 Dec 1934 Newcastle Australia 21 Sep 2004 Canberra Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 21.09.2019 21:03:16 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Rice-6157
H
1 Jun 1988 The Hon. Amelia Elizabeth Mary Millie Rygate (Rice) certain 27 Jan 1898 Canowindra, Colony of New South Wales certain 8 Jun 1988 Canowindra, New South Wales, Australia Female Doughman-1
Q4742300 Amelia Rygate (Australian politician (1898-1988)) 27 Jan 1898 1 Jun 1988 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 14:26:18 False suggestion WikiTree is correct as per sources
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 14:33:28 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 23:39:27 Comment Wikidata needs to be corrected
Summerbelle-1
H
1947 Annie May May Colette Senior (Summerbelle) aka Glasson certain 8 Nov 1867 certain Sydney, New South Wales (Australia) certain 31 Dec 1948 certain Marrickville, New South Wales, Australia Female Evans-20927
Q57293331 May Summerbelle (Australian composer (b. 1867, d. 1947)) 1867 Sydney Australia 1947 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 21.09.2019 20:56:53 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Macarthur-259
H
16 Mar 1871 Arthur Hannibal Macarthur certain 16 Mar 1830 certain Parramatta, New South Wales certain 6 Mar 1871 certain Gulgong, New South Wales Male Keillor-128
Q76239167 Arthur Hannibal MacArthur (Magistrate in New South Wales, Australia (1830-1871)) 16 Mar 1830 16 Mar 1871 Gulgong Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 14:54:50 False suggestion WikiTree is correct as per sources
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 23:40:55 Comment Wikidata needs to be corrected
Thorn-709
H
13 Jan 1905 George Henry Thorn certain 12 Oct 1838 certain Sydney, New South Wales, Australia certain 15 Jan 1905 certain Ipswich, Queensland, Australia Male Orphan
Q388741 George Thorn (Australian politician (1838-1905)) 12 Oct 1838 Sydney Australia 13 Jan 1905 Ipswich Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Willis-3076 30.12.2020 11:51:05 False suggestion birth date correct according to death cert.
Pearson-7063
H
21 May 1831 Hannah Laycock (Pearson) uncertain 1757 Bristol, Somerset, England certain 5 May 1831 Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Female Duncan-7561
Q76018915 Hannah Pearson ((1757-1831)) 1757 21 May 1831 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 12:55:08 False suggestion Wikitree date is sourced
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 23:35:03 Comment Wikidata needs to be corrected
Penrith-22
H
17 Aug 1997 Henry Burnum Burnum James Harry Penrith 10 Jan 1936 Wallaga Lake, New South Wales, Australia 18 Aug 1997 Woronora, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Male Ross-8691
Q446278 Burnum Burnum (Australian Aboriginal activist, actor and author (1936-1997)) 10 Jan 1936 Wallaga Lake National Park Australia 17 Aug 1997 Woronora Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 06.07.2023 07:11:44 False suggestion Death notice states death was 18 August 1997
Oakes-1804
H
5 Mar 1906 Herbert Hamilton Oakes certain 17 Jul 1859 certain Balmain, Colony of New South Wales certain 5 May 1906 certain Homebush, New South Wales, Australia Male Oaks-601
Q75478919 Herbert Hamilton Oakes ((1859-1906)) 17 Jul 1859 5 Mar 1906 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Oaks-601 03.03.2024 09:39:04 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect - sources verify May is correct
Clendon-4
H
26 Oct 1872 Captain James Reddy Clendon R.M. certain 1 Oct 1800 certain Deal, Kent, England certain 24 Oct 1872 certain Rawene, Bay of Islands, New Zealand Male Nixon-1915
Q6141896 James Reddy Clendon (New Zealand farmer) 1 Oct 1800 26 Oct 1872 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McClintock-715 10.05.2023 05:59:41 False suggestion wikidata is wrong, Wikipedia give the 24 or 26, I
Wright-37087
H
1852 Janet Snodgrass (Wright) 1790 Scotland 13 Feb 1845 Eagleton, New South Wales, Australia Female Gardiner-1534
Q76261063 Janet Wright ((1790-1852)) 1790 1852 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gardiner-1534 08.01.2020 05:27:03 Corrected corrected death date
Gardiner-1534 15.06.2023 01:27:47 False suggestion
Gardiner-1534 15.06.2023 01:28:02 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Antill-115
H
1 Mar 1937 MAJ GEN John Macquarie Antill CB CMG certain 26 Jan 1866 certain Jarvisfield, New South Wales (Australia) certain 4 Mar 1937 certain Newtown, New South Wales, Australia Male Evans-20927
Q6245682 John M. Antill (Australian Army officer (1866-1937)) 26 Jan 1866 Picton Australia 1 Mar 1937 Sydney Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
evans-20927 24.08.2019 18:25:39 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Partington-393
H
Mar 1954 Preston Pearce Partington certain 23 Oct 1891 Brighton, Tasmania, Australia certain 27 Nov 1954 Sydney, NSW, Australia Male Crooks-1416
Q76064467 Preston Pearce Partington ((1891-1954)) 23 Oct 1891 Mar 1954 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Crooks-1416 26.04.2021 09:55:01 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Harris-11886
H
17 Apr 1991 Rhona Pixie Olive Pixie O'Harris Pratt (Harris) MBE 15 Oct 1903 Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom 17 Nov 1991 Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Female WikiTree-37

Wright-7062
Q7199739 Pixie O'Harris (Australian artist (1903-1991)) 15 Oct 1903 Cardiff United Kingdom 17 Apr 1991 Sydney Australia female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 05.02.2023 08:09:33 False suggestion Wikitree date is correct
Leadbeater-49
H
14 Jul 1830 Sarah Lawson (Leadbeater) certain 22 Feb 1783 uncertain England certain 11 Jul 1830 certain Prospect, New South Wales, Australia Female Beddie-69

Wright-7062
Q76018920 Sarah Lawson (convict in New South Wales, Australia (1780-1830)) 28 Jan 1780 1783 14 Jul 1830 Prospect Australia female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 13:09:49 False suggestion Wikitree date is sourced
Thomas-7679 20.09.2020 23:35:43 Comment Wikidata needs to be corrected
Lucas-12079
H
28 Aug 1854 Sarah Tooth (Lucas) 1820 certain 18 Aug 1854 uncertain Darlinghurst, New South Wales, Australia Female Orphan
Q75746322 Sarah Lucas ((died 1854)) 1820 28 Aug 1854 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hardy-7997 11.08.2022 09:50:52 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Hardy-7997 11.08.2022 09:51:25 False suggestion Data Doctor - Error 558: Wikidata - Different deat
Davidson-5691
H
15 Sep 1923 Sir Walter Edward Davidson KCMG 20 Apr 1859 Valletta, Malta 16 Sep 1923 Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Male Orphan
Q3565744 Walter Edward Davidson (British Colonial governor) 20 Apr 1859 Valletta Malta 15 Sep 1923 Sydney Australia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 19.08.2023 07:47:30 False suggestion Sources confirm the date of death as 16 Sep 1923
Abbott-4249
H
8 Sep 1925 William Henry Abbott certain 1847 certain Dungog, New South Wales, Australia certain 8 Aug 1925 certain Dungog, New South Wales, Australia Male Orphan
Q75488622 William Henry Abbott (grazier in Australia, 1847-1925) 17 May 1847 8 Sep 1925 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomas-7679 23.09.2020 10:53:04 False suggestion Wikitree date is sourced and correct
Thomas-7679 23.09.2020 10:53:51 Comment Death date of 8 Aug 1925 is correct