Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Neville-176
H
1221 Agnes Deincourt (Neville) aka de Neville, de Percy uncertain 1220 Raby, Durham, England uncertain 20 Jul 1293 Blankney, Lincolnshire, England Female Hunt-2329
Q109853129 Agnes Neville (- Bef 20 Jul 1293) 1221 20 Jul 1293 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hunt-2329 24.01.2024 11:08:51 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Simpson-20544
H
1 Jan 1860 Alice Mabel Pickering (Simpson) before 18 Nov 1860 Ledsham, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 18 Feb 1939 certain Doncaster, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
Q945432 Alice Pickering (British tennis player) 1 Jan 1860 18 Feb 1939 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 07.12.2021 12:15:45 False suggestion No reliable source for Wikidata date
Riddell-1553
H
1698 Edward Horsley Widdrington Riddell uncertain 23 Jun 1766 Swinburn, Northumberland, England. certain 26 Jan 1793 certain Durham, England Male Orphan
Q75486091 Edward Horsley Widdrington ((1698-1762)) 1698 1762 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
haddock-479 01.04.2020 13:16:53 False suggestion Completely different people
haddock-479 27.05.2020 08:09:51 False suggestion Wikidata is a different person
Neville-49
H
1398 Eleanor Percy (Neville) aka le Despencer uncertain 1400 uncertain England before 6 Feb 1473 certain England Female WikiTree-36

Stewart-6071
Q5354354 Eleanor Percy, Countess of Northumberland (English countess) 1398 County Durham United Kingdom 1472 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Chittem-20 17.06.2017 11:45:18 False suggestion Protected project - Manager contacted
Elliot-3230
H
18 Mar 1814 Sir George Bonnie Geordie Elliot 18 Mar 1815 Gateshead, County Durham, England 23 Dec 1893 London, England Male Orphan
Q1314450 Sir George Elliot, 1st Baronet (British politician (1814–1893)) 18 Mar 1814 Gateshead United Kingdom 23 Dec 1893 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Humphrey-6461 15.02.2021 23:26:40 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Vane-226
H
10 May 1618 Sir George Vane Jul 1618 Shipbourne, Kent, England 1676 Long Newton, Durham, England Male Hacker-831
Q75392546 Sir George Vane ((born 1618)) 10 May 1618 1676 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hacker-831 01.09.2021 21:51:53 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Neville-58
H
1337 Sir John 3rd Lord Neville of Raby de Neville (Neville) KG uncertain 1329 uncertain Raby, Durham, England certain 17 Oct 1388 Newcastle Upon Tyne, Northumberland, England Male WikiTree-36

Athey-67
Q6250305 John Neville, 3rd Baron Neville de Raby (English peer and soldier) 1337 17 Oct 1388 Newcastle upon Tyne United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 16.09.2018 14:30:41 False suggestion see comments on WikiTree profile - it seems both are based on his age from the IPM at the time of his father's death (28-30 in 1368), which is apparently incorrect, being incompatible with the dates of his participation in battles/campaigns
Clifford-255
H
1388 Sir John 7th Lord Clifford, 7th Lord of the Honour of Skipton Clifford KG before 23 Apr 1389 Hart, Durham, England 13 Mar 1422 slain at the siege of Meaux, Seine-et-Marne, France Male WikiTree-36

Wood-2151
Q6226378 John Clifford, 7th Baron de Clifford (English peer) 1388 Appleby Castle United Kingdom 13 Mar 1422 Meaux France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 17.09.2018 19:14:19 False suggestion WikiTree date is sourced
Neville-349
H
12 Feb 1341 Margaret Percy (Neville) aka de Ros 12 Feb 1339 Raby Castle, Durham, England 13 May 1372 Warkworth Castle, Northumberland, England Female Orphan
Q68109318 Margaret Neville (countess d. 1372) 12 Feb 1341 May 1372 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 15.09.2020 11:34:30 Comment can't tell where WikiTree's date is from - not Richardson's RA NEVILLE 11
Noland-165 15.09.2020 11:42:11 Comment Russian wikidata cites Cawley but I couldn't find that birth date there either; Lewis has the 1339 date with no citation
Cayley-55 15.09.2020 12:53:40 False suggestion Usual Russian nonsense
Barclay-2846
H
20 Feb 1853 Thomas Barclay 20 Oct 1839 Bishopwearmouth, Durham, England, United Kingdom 1921 Bromsgrove, Worcestershire, England, United Kingdom Male Gardiner-1534
Q5565726 Thomas Barclay (British economic writer and politician (1853-1941)) 20 Feb 1853 20 Jan 1941 Versailles France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gardiner-1534 17.11.2020 18:44:06 False suggestion Two different Barclays. Not the same person.
Gardiner-1534 24.11.2020 13:51:44 False suggestion Different Barclay
Garth-292
H
1670 Lt Colonel Thomas Garth uncertain 1664 Gainford, Durham, England certain 7 Jan 1731 certain London, England Male Morgan-33325
Q76023451 Thomas Garth (Peerage person ID=475048) 1670 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Morgan-33325 03.12.2023 17:13:34 False suggestion source cited has no birth date
Neville-257
H
1410 William Lord Fauconberg, Earl of Kent Neville KG uncertain 1400 Raby, Durham, England 9 Jan 1463 Alnwick, Northumberland, England Male WikiTree-113
Q2364228 William Neville, Earl of Kent (English nobleman and soldier (c. 1405–1463)) 1410 9 Jan 1463 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 11.10.2020 17:36:32 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source