Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Warning 563: Wikidata - Possible duplicate by father Help (Difficulty: Advanced)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Hulton-169
H
Compare Sir Edward George Warris Hulton Wikitree Father certain 29 Nov 1906 Harrogate, Yorkshire, England certain 8 Oct 1988 London, England, United Kingdom Male Shelley-714
Hulton-168
H
Sir Edward George Stephen Hulton Bt Wikidata Father certain 3 Mar 1869 Hulme, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom certain 23 May 1925 Downside, Surrey, England, United Kingdom Male Orphan
Q76274839 Betty Hulton (Peerage person ID=655479) Feb 1932 female
Q7526572 Sir Edward Hulton, 1st Baronet (British newspaper proprietor (1869-1925)) 3 Mar 1869 Hulme United Kingdom 23 May 1925 Downside United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parker-41651 01.02.2022 22:30:43 False suggestion Different people
Percy-23
H
Compare Sir Henry 5th Lord Percy, 2nd Earl of Northumberland, Constable of England Warden of the Marches of Scotland Percy Wikitree Father certain 3 Feb 1392 certain Warkworth, Northumberland, England certain 22 May 1455 St. Albans, Hertfordshire, England Male Lockwood-1016
Percy-44
H
Sir Henry 3rd Earl of Northumberland, 6th Lord Percy Percy Wikidata Father certain 25 Jul 1421 certain Leconfield, Yorkshire, England certain 29 Mar 1461 certain Battle of Towton, Towton, Yorkshire, England Male Stewart-6071

WikiTree-113
Q2521911 Henry Percy, 3rd Earl of Northumberland (English noble) 25 Jul 1421 Leconfield United Kingdom 29 Mar 1461 Battle of Towton Kingdom of England male
Q75446916 Lady Anne Percy (Peerage person ID=147159) 1436 5 Jul 1522 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 15.09.2021 14:20:09 False suggestion Those are two different profiles.
Pickering-174
H
Compare Sir James Pickering Wikitree Father certain 29 Aug 1413 uncertain England certain 30 Dec 1460 certain Wakefield, Yorkshire, England Male Morgan-33325
Pickering-171
H
James Pickering Wikidata Father England before Dec 1460 certain England Male Snow-7645

Haskins-471
Q106508157 Sir James Pickering, of Killington (- Abt 3 Dec 1461) male
Q104799484 Margaret Pickering (- 1474) 1444 1474 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Morgan-33325 28.08.2023 20:57:55 Comment
Morgan-33325 28.08.2023 21:00:07 Corrected
Morgan-33325 28.08.2023 21:01:34 False suggestion Different people
Darcy-223
H
Compare John 5th Lord Darcy of Knaith and 4th Lord Meinell Darcy Wikitree Father 1377 England 9 Dec 1411 England Male WikiTree-36
Darcy-225
H
Philip 4th Lord Darcy of Knaith Darcy Wikidata Father certain 21 May 1352 York, Yorkshire, England certain 24 Apr 1399 England Male WikiTree-36
Q18576825 Philip Darcy (English nobleman and soldier) 1352 1399 male
Q105820769 Joan Darcy (Est 1400 -) 1398 May 1436 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 30.05.2023 11:46:07 False suggestion Different people
Rhodes-7887
H
Compare John Rhodes Wikitree Father certain 29 Jul 1784 Hempstead, Queens, New York, United States certain 12 Apr 1866 uncertain Hempstead, Queens, New York, United States Male Rhodes-7876
Rhodes-6010
H
William Rhodes Wikidata Father 7 May 1781 Aberford, Yorkshire, England certain 3 Dec 1869 Balby, Yorkshire, England Male Orphan
Q75627762 William Rhodes ((1781-1869)) 7 May 1781 3 Dec 1869 male
Q75627826 Mary Ann Rhodes ((born 1817)) 26 Sep 1817 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Selinger-52 01.05.2022 20:15:27 False suggestion Definitely not the same person.
Selinger-52 01.05.2022 20:15:41 Comment merge proposed 16 Jan
Tempest-389
H
Compare Nicholas of Stanley Tempest Wikitree Father uncertain 1484 uncertain Holmside, Durham, England certain 20 Nov 1538 uncertain Durham, England Male Weston-987
Tempest-74
H
Nicholas Tempest Wikidata Father 1478 Bracewell, Yorkshire, England 25 May 1537 Fleet Prison, London, England Male Orphan
Q108913068 Alice Tempest (- 1588) 1530 1588 female
Q108913069 Nicholas Tempest, of Stella, Durham (1478 - 25 May 1537) 1478 25 May 1537 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Weston-987 29.11.2023 08:41:03 False suggestion Suggested relationship is wrong.
Normanville-32
H
Compare Ralph Normanville Wikitree Father uncertain 1215 Thrybergh, Yorkshire, England 4 Aug 1265 Evesham, Worcestershire, England Male Heathcote-126
Normanville-11
H
Ralph de Normanville (Normanville) Wikidata Father uncertain 1220 Rutland, England uncertain 1259 Santiago, Jaen, Andalucia, Spain Male Orphan
Q109853148 Ralph de Normanville, Lord of Thribergh (1220 - 1260) 1220 1260 male
Q109852940 Margery Normanville (1315) 1315 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Heathcote-126 01.08.2023 13:22:26 False suggestion Different people
Constable-913
H
Compare Robert Constable Wikitree Father uncertain 1460 Flamborough, Yorkshire, England certain 22 Nov 1501 North Cliff, Yorkshire, England Male Orphan
Constable-174
H
Sir Robert of Flamborough Constable Wikidata Father uncertain 1478 Yorkshire, England certain 6 Jul 1537 Hull, Yorkshire, England Male Orphan
Q76358266 Jane Constable (Peerage person ID=709871) 1500 female
Q7343072 Robert Constable (English insurgent of the Pilgrimage of Grace) 1478 6 Jul 1537 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hare-1576 26.11.2020 16:21:17 False suggestion Definitely not the same person.
Furnival-9
H
Compare Sir Thomas Thomas III de Furnival (Furnival) Wikitree Father after 1251 Nottinghamshire, England before 18 Apr 1332 Sheffield, Yorkshire, England Male Wood-2151
Furnival-15
H
Thomas Thomas IV 2nd Lord Furnival de Furnival (Furnival) Wikidata Father uncertain 1292 Nottinghamshire, England certain Oct 1339 Alton, Gloucestershire, England Male WikiTree-113
Q75922605 Thomas de Furnivalle, 2nd Baron Furnivalle (2nd Lord Furnival de Furnival (Furnival) (est. 1292 - certain Oct 1339) male
Q76298239 Maud de Furnivalle (Peerage person ID=671394) 1292 1360 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 14.10.2020 09:59:30 False suggestion Stupid
Beverley-387
H
Compare William Beverley Wikitree Father certain 1769 Kingston upon Hull St Mary, Yorkshire, England 1816 Hull, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom Male Moore-74658
Beverley-306
H
William Beverley Wikidata Father 27 Oct 1763 Blandfield, Essex, Virginia 1823 Paris, Seine, France Male Smith-243207
Q75955396 William Beverley (Peerage person ID=427977) 1763 1823 male
Q75955397 Maria Beverley ((died 1874)) 1795 27 Mar 1874 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Moore-74558 17.05.2023 15:52:22 False suggestion Different people
Dunkeld-65
H
Compare William FitzDuncan Moray (Dunkeld) aka Earl of Moray, Lord of Egremont Wikitree Father uncertain 1090 uncertain Scotland uncertain 1151 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Athey-67
MacWilliam-9
H
William the boy of Egremont de Egremont (MacWilliam) Wikidata Father after 1138 Egremont, Cumberland, England after 1163 Male Thompson-14289
Q3036054 Donald MacWilliam (Claimant to the Scottish throne) 11cen 1187 31 Jul 1187 male
Q75387801 William MacWilliam, Lord of Egremont (Peerage person ID=107706) 1155 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 01.12.2020 07:02:20 False suggestion wikidata is incorrect -has 2 fathers for Q3036054
Beckett-266
H
Compare Sir William Gervase Gervase Beckett Bt, MP Wikitree Father 14 Jan 1866 Meanwood, Yorkshire, England 24 Aug 1937 London, England Male Helton-512
Hart-Davis-1
H
Richard Vaughan Hart-Davis Wikidata Father certain 1 May 1878 certain Farnham, Surrey, England certain 1964 certain Westminster, London, England Male Orphan
Q75484988 Richard Vaughan Hart-Davis (Peerage person ID=170399) 1 May 1878 26 Aug 1964 male
Q7380298 Rupert Hart-Davis (British publisher and editor (1907–1999)) 28 Aug 1907 Kensington United Kingdom 8 Dec 1999 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parker-41651 01.02.2022 20:00:56 False suggestion Different people