Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 578: FindAGrave - Different death date Help Video (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Shaw-84
H
2 Nov 1638 Abraham Shaw aka Shawe uncertain 1590 Yorkshire, England before 25 Mar 1639 Dedham, Massachusetts Bay Colony Male Smith-32867

WikiTree-30

Quigley-173

Scoullar-4

Draper-310
16195670 Abraham “Shawe” Shaw 2 Jan 1590 Metropolitan Borough of Calderdale, West Yorkshire, England 2 Nov 1638 Dedham, Norfolk County, Massachusetts, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Smith-32867 03.02.2019 01:35:18 False suggestion Wikitree profile is sourced
Swan-19
H
11 Feb 1697 Robert Swan before 26 Feb 1626 certain Gilberdyke, Eastrington, Yorkshire, England certain 11 Feb 1698 certain Haverhill, Essex County, Province of Massachusetts Bay Male Wendt-138

WikiTree-30

Vierson-2

Swindells-2

Stevens-2498
18014039 Robert Swan Sr. 22 Feb 1623 England 11 Feb 1697 Haverhill, Essex County, Massachusetts, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cole-12288 11.05.2021 18:50:40 False suggestion Old Style/New Style calendar difference
Gale-26
H
1591 Ursula Mallory (Gale) uncertain 1531 Yorkshire, England after 1586 Yorkshire, England Female Watts-4767

WikiTree-57

Bradshaw-1276

Ross-1334

Hanson-1698
202200958 Lady Ursula Gale Mallory 1531 1591
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Fitz-Henry-9 18.06.2020 17:03:21 False suggestion There is no evidence for a date of death or being buried in Ripon Cathedral
Waln-4
H
4 Feb 1721 Nicholas Waln aka Walne 1650 Burholme, Bolland District, West Riding, Yorkshire, England certain 4 Feb 1722 certain Northern Liberties, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Male WikiTree-15

Stevens-2498
38222846 Nicholas Waln 1650 West Yorkshire, England 4 Feb 1721 Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rice-5349 26.03.2022 21:31:48 False suggestion
Brigham-89
H
8 Dec 1653 Thomas Brigham uncertain 21 May 1575 certain Holme-on-Spalding-Moor, Yorkshire, England before 19 Mar 1633 certain Holme-on-Spalding-Moor, Yorkshire, England Male Hill-11959
38419321 Thomas Brigham 1603 Holme-on-Spalding-Moor, East Riding of Yorkshire Unitary Authority, East Riding of Yorkshire, England 8 Dec 1653 Cambridge, Middlesex County, Massachusetts, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Smith-32867 07.04.2017 04:05:37 False suggestion different man entirely
Scofield-69
H
Jan 1670 Daniel Scofield before 10 Apr 1614 uncertain Hipperholme, Yorkshire, England after 4 Sep 1669 Stamford, Fairfield, Connecticut Colony Male WikiTree-30

Keniston-36

Vargas-60
62713264 Daniel Scofield I 1614 Hipperholme, Metropolitan Borough of Calderdale, West Yorkshire, England Jan 1670 Stamford, Fairfield County, Connecticut, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 04.04.2024 21:54:35 False suggestion FG doesn't supply a source for death date, no gs., WT date is based on inventory
Piper-208
H
13 Dec 1937 Sarah Jessie Jessie Brighouse (Piper) certain 20 Aug 1867 certain Stonehouse, Plymouth, Devon, England certain 12 Dec 1927 certain Bellingham, Washington, United States Female Brighouse-1
7299556 Jessie Sarah Brighouse 1878 13 Dec 1937
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Brighouse-1 17.03.2020 00:42:12 False suggestion Correct death date is 12 Dec 1927 in Bellingham, WA
Brighouse-1 17.03.2020 00:43:01 Comment Correct death date is 12 Dec 1927 in Bellingham, WA
Brighouse-1 17.03.2020 01:01:59 Comment WikiTree death date is correct.
Rogers-2932
H
1595 Sarah Taylor (Rogers) certain 16 Feb 1560 Bryanston, Dorset, England 1585 certain Bradford, West Riding, Yorkshire, England Female Thompson-57858

Rogers-4991
192655821 Sarah Rogers Taylor 16 Feb 1560 Bradford, Metropolitan Borough of Bradford, West Yorkshire, England 1595 Bradford, Metropolitan Borough of Bradford, West Yorkshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jewett-369 06.07.2023 23:54:19 False suggestion
Trenholme-111
H
17 Sep 1916 Albert Trenholme Apr 1894 Oswaldkirk, Yorkshire, England 16 Jul 1916 Dernancourt, Somme, Picardie, France Male Orphan
56588171 PRIVATE Arthur Trenholme 17 Sep 1916
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hutton-2752 05.11.2020 07:54:25 False suggestion Nathional Military Archives has correct date, not FindAGrave
Seller-22
H
20 Dec 1884 Mary Elizabeth Toombs (Seller) certain 13 Apr 1800 certain Malton, Yorkshire, England uncertain 1880 certain North Rustico, Prince Edward Island, Canada Female Smith-33969
103804814 Mary Seller Toombs 13 Apr 1800 Malton, Ryedale District, North Yorkshire, England 20 Dec 1884 Rusticoville, Queens County, Prince Edward Island, Canada
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lawrence-17722 20.08.2023 22:08:32 False suggestion
lawrence-17722 20.08.2023 22:08:55 False suggestion
Wilson-11136
H
12 Oct 1848 George Wilson before 1800 before 1851 Male Orme-81
193928134 George Wilson 12 Oct 1848
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Orme-81 22.05.2020 11:52:27 False suggestion no source on findagrave. As I have explained in Research Notes, this is not the correct memorial.
Jowett-65
H
17 Feb 1665 Sarah Nelson (Jowett) aka Jewett before 3 Jan 1636 uncertain Bradford, West Riding, Yorkshire, England before 17 Feb 1666 certain Rowley, Essex County, Massachusetts Bay Colony Female Jewett-369
83953096 Sarah Jewett Nelson 3 Jan 1636 Bradford, Metropolitan Borough of Bradford, West Yorkshire, England 17 Feb 1665 Rowley, Essex County, Massachusetts, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cole-12288 31.03.2020 21:26:24 Comment FindAGrave is incorrect. Edit submit
Cole-12288 31.03.2020 21:26:37 False suggestion
Waddilove-93
H
27 Jul 1835 Mary Waddilove certain 1813 certain Hebden, Yorkshire, England certain 1890 certain Hebden, Yorkshire, England Female Orphan
216909316 Mary “Polly” Dean Waddilove 1785 Linton, Craven District, North Yorkshire, England 27 Jul 1835 Hebden, Craven District, North Yorkshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Machell-121 05.04.2023 12:18:17 Comment False error. The Find a grave dates are for Mary's mother not Mary
Machell-121 05.04.2023 12:23:09 False suggestion
Kaye-364
H
Dec 1618 Robert Kaye Esq uncertain 1545 Woodsome, Yorkshire, England 1620 Almondbury, Yorkshire, England Male WikiTree-36

Keniston-36
190931371 Robert Kaye 1550 Almondbury, Metropolitan Borough of Kirklees, West Yorkshire, England Dec 1618 Almondbury, Metropolitan Borough of Kirklees, West Yorkshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
thiessen-117 26.11.2020 03:55:49 False suggestion FindAGrave is estimate
Womack-1178
H
12 Mar 1686 Bishop Laurence Womack DD certain 12 May 1612 North Lopham, Norfolk, England certain 12 Mar 1685 Westminster, London, England Male Lee-759
138789564 Dr Laurence Womack 1612 12 Mar 1686
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Templeton-4285 17.02.2023 03:00:05 False suggestion It was 1685
Beilby-98
H
3 Jun 1860 Robert Beilby aka Bielby before 13 Aug 1813 certain Sculcoates, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 3 Jan 1860 certain Sailors Gully, Victoria, Australia Male Potter-10870

Mansfield-764

Harper-11736
211243987 Robert Beilby 1815 3 Jun 1860
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Potter-10870 29.07.2021 07:06:30 Corrected Corrected - added FindAGrave Template
potter-10870 02.09.2021 13:47:25 False suggestion Shared headstone.
potter-10870 02.09.2021 13:47:37 Comment Shared Headstone.
Shearstone-18
H
1 Jan 1881 William Shearstone 1800 Tickhill, Yorkshire, England 30 Dec 1880 Wellington, New Zealand Male Winton-239
185440151 William Shearston 1 Jan 1881
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
winton-239 19.02.2021 21:25:37 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong, death cert shows date of death as 30 December
Horsman-148
H
1812 Christopher Horsman 1746 Marske By Richmond, Yorkshire, England 1815 Moncton, New Brunswick Male Orphan
253089960 Christopher Horsman 1746 England 1812
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ward-21155 14.04.2024 20:01:03 Corrected
Marshall-8583
H
13 Dec 1896 Anthony Marshall certain 4 Nov 1811 South Cliffe, Yorkshire, England after 1891 Yorkshire, England Male Marshall-8222
132494720 Anthony Marshall 4 Nov 1811 South Cliffe, East Riding of Yorkshire Unitary Authority, East Riding of Yorkshire, England 13 Dec 1896 North Cave, East Riding of Yorkshire Unitary Authority, East Riding of Yorkshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marshall-8222 03.08.2017 17:38:29 False suggestion DoD is unsourced - requested photo of headstone
Dodgson-132
H
6 May 1847 Thomas Dodgson certain 24 Jul 1793 Colton, Yorkshire, England, Great Britain certain 6 May 1842 certain Greene County, Illinois, United States of America Male Shea-923
56817139 Thomas Dodgson 24 Jul 1793 Colton, South Lakeland District, Cumbria, England 6 May 1847
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shea-923 01.03.2021 14:35:41 Not corrected FindAGrave memorial incorrect birth location and death year
Shea-923 01.03.2021 23:56:44 False suggestion FindAGrave transcription is in error
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Bulmer-442
H
1 May 1357 Sir Ralph de Bulmer (Bulmer) uncertain 1285 Bulmer, North Riding, Yorkshire, England before Jun 1356 certain Wilton, Yorkshire, England Male Kinman-87
118136774 Sir Ralph de Bulmer 1286 England 1 May 1357 England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kinman-87 17.06.2017 16:41:44 Not corrected Notified FindAGrave of its error
McBeth-165 16.08.2017 01:56:20 False suggestion FindAGrave has been updated to correct date
Paley-251
H
13 Sep 1812 Mary Paley uncertain 1745 Carlisle, Cumberland, England certain 13 Feb 1812 Giggleswick, Yorkshire, England Female Orphan
153696337 Mary Paley 1745 13 Sep 1812
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Woodhouse-314 01.09.2017 21:28:30 False suggestion
Clafton-4
H
10 May 1928 Joseph Berry Clafton uncertain Dec 1858 certain Ossett cum Gawthorpe, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 10 May 1926 certain Willoughby, New South Wales, Australia Male Clafton-1
178304496 Joseph Berry Clafton 1858 10 May 1928
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Clafton-1 23.08.2023 12:22:16 False suggestion
Linton-1583
H
20 Dec 1898 Isaac Linton uncertain 1804 Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom 20 Dec 1893 Claremont, Durham Regional Municipality, Ontario, Canada Male Linton-1582
80721706 Isaac Linton 1804 20 Dec 1898
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Philip-427 04.04.2017 23:21:18 False suggestion Death date discrepancy is addressed in the profile.
Carleton-464
H
24 Nov 1678 Edward Carleton before 20 Oct 1610 Beeford, Yorkshire, England after 22 May 1651 uncertain England Male WikiTree-36

WikiTree-30
153530321 CPT Edward Carleton 20 Oct 1610 East Riding of Yorkshire, England 24 Nov 1678
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 01.09.2021 10:54:02 False suggestion no source on findagrave
Affleck-248
H
14 Dec 1897 Harriet Elizabeth Molesworth (Affleck) aka Bridges uncertain 1807 certain Retford, Nottinghamshire, England, United Kingdom certain Oct 1897 certain Bradford, England, United Kingdom Female Childs-3654
67924029 Harriet Elizabeth Affleck Molesworth 5 Apr 1807 Retford, Bassetlaw District, Nottinghamshire, England 14 Dec 1897 Yattendon, West Berkshire Unitary Authority, Berkshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Watson-1411 16.03.2023 18:10:36 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong
Aldam-23
H
16 Apr 1660 Thomas Aldam uncertain 1616 Warmsworth, Yorkshire, England 16 Jun 1660 Balby, Yorkshire, England Male Thornton-5929

Cayley-55

Killham-6
150211513 Thomas Aldam 1617 16 Apr 1660
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 03.12.2019 10:43:18 False suggestion FindAGrave is estimate
Willis-7347
H
10 Mar 1943 Hannah Nancie Stangoe McHarg (Willis) certain Oct 1880 certain Whitby, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 10 Mar 1949 certain Worth Valley, West Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
50146108 Hannah Stangoe Willis McHarg 1881 Whitby, Scarborough Borough, North Yorkshire, England 10 Mar 1943 Shipley, Metropolitan Borough of Bradford, West Yorkshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stent-34 16.07.2018 22:08:07 Not corrected findagrave bio incorrect-unable to contact contributor
Stent-34 16.07.2018 22:38:06 Comment
Stent-34 25.07.2018 22:04:21 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong
Harrison-15020
H
15 Jan 1605 Thomas Harrison aka Harryson uncertain 1530 uncertain Yorkshire, England Jan 1604 Yorkshire, England Male Cody-939
177672964 Thomas Harrison 3 Apr 1549 Acaster Selby, Selby District, North Yorkshire, England 15 Jan 1605 Knaresborough, Harrogate Borough, North Yorkshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cody-939 09.07.2022 03:31:08 False suggestion FindAGrave is unsourced. Sources support WikiTree. see Research Notes
Clarkson-1930
H
16 Dec 1853 Charles Foster Clarkson 12 May 1812 Holme upon Spalding Moor, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 16 Dec 1863 Ballarat, Victoria, Australia Male Scannell-33
217799053 Charles Foster Clarkson 12 May 1812 England 16 Dec 1853 Ballarat, Ballarat City, Victoria, Australia
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dorney-47 02.12.2022 01:54:00 False suggestion
Patchett-347
H
13 Dec 1870 George Patchett certain 22 Aug 1810 Hebden Bridge, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 13 Dec 1879 Glossop, Derbyshire, England, United Kingdom Male Mann-6886
164117139 George Patchett 13 Dec 1870
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
mann-6886 21.11.2020 22:52:59 False suggestion FindAGrave transcription is in error
Langdale-603
H
Dec 1894 John Wilkinson Langdale uncertain 1837 Guisborough, Yorkshire, England Jul 1891 Morpeth, Northumberland, England, United Kingdom Male Orphan
79479747 John Langdale 1834 Dec 1894
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Humphrey-6461 26.04.2021 08:56:37 False suggestion Death date on WikiTree sourced with death registration.
Hanson-8477
H
12 Nov 1948 Ahinoam Smith (Hanson) aka Frankland, Butterfield certain 1864 certain Keighley, West Riding of Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 12 Nov 1949 certain Keighley, West Riding of Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom Female Adamson-1058
79265336 Ahinoam Smith 1864 Keighley, Metropolitan Borough of Bradford, West Yorkshire, England 12 Nov 1948
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Adamson-1058 21.01.2022 17:50:53 False suggestion WikiTree death date is correct.
Sargent-4562
H
20 Apr 1972 Rev. Frank Leslie Sargent MA 8 Jan 1901 Sheffield, Yorkshire, England 20 Apr 1973 York, Yorkshire, England Male Heathcote-126
179270938 Rev Frank Leslie Sargent 8 Jan 1901 Sheffield, Metropolitan Borough of Sheffield, South Yorkshire, England 20 Apr 1972 York, York Unitary Authority, North Yorkshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Heathcote-126 01.06.2021 09:32:52 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong
Barr-5366
H
May 1966 Grace Charity (Barr) 10 Jun 1898 Hull, Yorkshire, England 20 Jul 1966 Derby, Derbyshire, England Female Heathcote-126
198966874 Grace Barr Charity 19 Jun 1898 May 1966 Derby Unitary Authority, Derbyshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Heathcote-126 22.06.2021 23:06:38 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong
Cutler-2696
H
26 Feb 1673 Elizabeth Edmunds (Cutler) aka Herbert certain 1637 certain Silkstone, Yorkshire, England certain 1696 certain Worsborough, Yorkshire, England Female Cody-939
167432237 Elizabeth Cutler Herbert 1637 26 Feb 1673
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cody-939 16.09.2021 08:48:20 False suggestion FindAGrave is unsourced. Sources support WikiTree.
Barker-15066
H
28 May 1918 James Edward Barker certain 1896 certain Northallerton, Yorkshire, England certain 25 Mar 1918 certain Saint-Quentin, Aisne, Picardie, France Male Weston-987
56064331 James Barker 28 May 1918
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Weston-987 25.08.2021 21:36:17 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong
Weston-987 25.08.2021 21:37:08 False suggestion DoD is correct per death record
Newark-41
H
1627 Alice Herbert (Newark) aka Newarke uncertain 1570 certain Acomb, Yorkshire, England certain 1637 certain York, Yorkshire, England Female Cody-939
167432141 Alice Newarke Herbert 1627
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cody-939 16.09.2021 08:00:48 False suggestion FindAGrave unsourced, Burial register supports WikiTree.
Butterfield-2765
H
2 Jan 1977 Mary Gertrude Butterfield certain 8 Feb 1886 certain Bishop Monkton, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom certain 2 Jul 1977 certain Haxby, North Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom Female Adamson-1058
108244368 Mary Gertrude Butterfield 2 Jan 1977 Northamptonshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Adamson-1058 21.01.2022 17:53:45 False suggestion death correct per death record
Shiers-61
H
5 Sep 1725 George Shiers uncertain 1688 Grindleton, Yorkshire, England 5 Nov 1725 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Male Breland-212
177888381 George Shires 5 Sep 1725
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Breland-212 13.05.2022 00:04:03 Not corrected Notified FindAGrave of its error.
Breland-212 02.06.2022 11:18:09 False suggestion
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Trickett-302
H
21 Feb 1848 Elizabeth Trickett before 3 Jun 1849 Bradfield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom uncertain 1850 Bradfield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
234166154 Elizabeth Trickett 1847 21 Feb 1848
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hardman-1532 28.04.2022 12:22:56 False suggestion She can’t have died before she was christened so the death date is wrong
Bond-10698
H
14 Dec 1721 James Bond uncertain 1642 certain England certain 14 Feb 1721 certain Bradford, Yorkshire, England Male McPherson-5338
151836790 James Bond 7 Mar 1642 Metropolitan Borough of Bradford, West Yorkshire, England 14 Dec 1721 Brighouse, Metropolitan Borough of Calderdale, West Yorkshire, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McPherson-5338 06.05.2022 06:14:41 False suggestion Quaker rebdering of 12th mo is February.
Shenton-201
H
10 Jan 1841 Thomas Shenton uncertain 1798 Yorkshire, England 10 Jan 1842 Knottingley, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom Male Mann-6886
121926035 Thomas Shenton 10 Jan 1841
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mann-6886 25.11.2022 14:58:53 False suggestion Date on inscription is incorrect. Burial and death records confirms death in 1842
Longley-1371
H
11 Apr 1930 Robert Longley uncertain 1841 Sheffield, Yorkshire, England 4 Nov 1930 Cambridge, Waikato, New Zealand Male Niven-92
124484310 Robert Longley 11 Apr 1930
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Watson-1411 23.07.2022 19:15:37 False suggestion no source on findagrave
Newsome-1393
H
Feb 1744 George Newsome 11 Mar 1744 Leeds, Yorkshire, England Feb 1745 Leeds, Yorkshire, England Male Field-2250
236176154 George Newsom 11 Mar 1743 Feb 1744
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Field-2250 22.11.2023 23:06:33 False suggestion FindAGrave uses Julian calendar dates
Machell-430
H
9 Jan 1876 Robert Fletcher Machell certain 26 May 1833 certain Dewsbury, Yorkshire, England certain 26 Aug 1920 certain Harrogate, Yorkshire, England Male Machell-121
183365248 Robert Fletcher Machell 9 Jan 1876
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Machell-121 08.03.2024 15:02:37 False suggestion False suggestion - this is Roberts son who died yo
Machell-121 08.03.2024 15:03:58 False suggestion Not same person - this date refers to Roberts son (also Robert) who died young