Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Goodsell-211
H
1843 Almira Geraldine Rockefeller (Goodsell) 19 Mar 1844 New York City, New York, United States uncertain 17 Jan 1920 Jekyll Island, Glynn, Georgia, United States Female Nilsen-785
Q96078974 Almira Geraldine Goodsell ((1843-1920)) 1843 1920 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Nilsen-785 12.11.2022 09:57:57 False suggestion
Samples-1289
H
10 Apr 1926 Alvin Junior Monroe Samples Jr. 10 Aug 1926 Cumming, Forsyth, Georgia, United States 13 Nov 1983 Cumming, Forsyth, Georgia, United States Male Gilbert-5219
Q6313445 Junior Samples (American comedian (1926-1983)) 10 Apr 1926 Cumming United States of America 13 Nov 1983 Cumming United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gilbert-5219 10.05.2023 05:53:14 False suggestion False suggestions Went by Junior DOB is per FAG and Military records WikiData is incorrect
Pinckney-910
H
26 Sep 1939 Barbara Callan Pfeiffer Pinckney certain 29 Sep 1939 certain Oregon, USA certain 1 Mar 2012 certain Savannah, Chatham County, Georgia, USA Female Stuewe-5
Q5021750 Callan Pinckney (American fitness professional (1939-2012)) 26 Sep 1939 Savannah United States of America 1 Mar 2012 Savannah United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stuewe-5 16.05.2023 17:03:57 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Handley-478
H
29 Feb 1752 George Handley Sr. 9 Feb 1752 Sheffield, Yorkshire, England 17 Sep 1793 Savannah, Georgia Male Nesmith-408
Q992739 George Handley (American politician (1752-1793)) 29 Feb 1752 Sheffield United Kingdom 17 Sep 1793 Savannah United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stuewe-5 11.05.2018 04:52:30 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Nesmith-408 23.06.2019 21:25:21 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
McDuffie-190
H
10 Aug 1790 George McDuffie certain 12 Aug 1790 uncertain Columbia County, Georgia certain 11 Mar 1851 uncertain Sumter County, South Carolina Male Whitaker-1484
Q884415 George McDuffie (American politician (1790-1851)) 10 Aug 1790 Columbia County United States of America 11 Mar 1851 Sumter County United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stuewe-5 11.05.2018 04:54:28 False suggestion All 3 Wikidata references are not actual birthdate sources but general links including one circular link.
Mitchell-9217
H
1760 Sergeant Henry Mitchell certain 8 Feb 1761 Albermarle Parish, Sussex County, Virginia certain 17 May 1839 Sparta, Hancock, Georgia, USA Male WikiTree-24
Q96942474 Henry Mitchell (general in the American Revolutionary War (1760-1839)) 1760 1839 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 14.11.2021 10:56:49 False suggestion wikidata source is SAR that says 'about 1760'; profile cites parish records for christening 8 Feb 1761
Richardson-7161 14.11.2021 14:02:19 False suggestion I do not use Wikidata, use sources
Lee-22088
H
16 Jul 1875 Ivy Ledbetter Lee certain 16 Jul 1877 certain Cedartown, Polk, Georgia, United States certain 9 Nov 1934 certain New York City, New York, United States Male Burch-2229
Q1345412 Ivy Lee (American businessman (1877-1934)) 16 Jul 1875 Cedartown United States of America 9 Nov 1934 New York City United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Burch-2229 10.04.2024 01:29:11 False suggestion
burch-2229 10.04.2024 01:30:25 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Shellman-4
H
5 May 1756 1st Lt Johannes John Shellman Sr. aka Schellman uncertain Jan 1757 certain Middletown, Frederick, Province of Maryland certain 12 May 1838 certain Savannah, Chatham, Georgia, United States Male Taylor-25258

Tidwell-1228
Q75765023 John Shellman ((1756-1838)) 5 May 1756 17 Apr 1838 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Taylor-25258 29.01.2021 22:43:51 Corrected removed American Revolution sticker
Taylor-25258 26.09.2021 01:36:20 False suggestion the headstone says '12th May 1838'
Winder-550
H
7 Feb 1800 Brig Gen John Henry Winder 21 Feb 1800 Somerset, Maryland, United States 7 Feb 1865 Florence, South Carolina, United States Male Jones-116753
Q1678817 John H. Winder (Confederate Army general) 7 Feb 1800 Somerset County United States of America 7 Feb 1865 21 Feb 1865 Florence United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jones-116753 07.10.2023 11:55:05 False suggestion Find a Grave and Virginia Encyclopedia have a diff
Carson-214
H
23 Mar 1868 John William Fiddlin' John Carson 23 Mar 1873 Blue Ridge, Fannin, Georgia, United States 11 Dec 1949 DeKalb, Georgia, United States Male Ditty-86

WikiTree-130

Craft-30

Craig-4574
Q1411165 Fiddlin' John Carson (American musician) 23 Mar 1868 Fannin County United States of America 11 Dec 1949 Atlanta United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craft-30 15.08.2022 04:20:21 False suggestion
Matthews-4925
H
1812 Joseph Warren Matthews aka Mathews uncertain 3 Aug 1807 Laurens County, South Carolina, United States 27 Aug 1862 Palmetto, Fulton, Georgia, United States Male Kolze-7
Q767415 Joseph Warren Matthews (American politician (1812-1862)) 1812 Huntsville United States of America 27 Aug 1862 Palmetto United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
kolze-7 21.05.2019 19:10:33 Not corrected Death monument shows 1812, but it was erected in 1919, 55 years after death. 1807 date is in-line with 1840, 1850, 1860 census and other sources.
kolze-7 28.01.2021 10:48:43 False suggestion Grave monument is wrong. Noted in research notes.
Pulaski-2
H
6 Mar 1745 Brig Gen Kazimierz Michał Władysław Wiktor Casimir Pułaski (Pulaski) certain 6 Mar 1748 Warsaw, Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth certain 11 Oct 1779 certain Savannah, Chatham, Georgia, United States Male WikiTree-59

Kurdej-1
Q381854 Casimir Pulaski (Polish nobleman, general in the American Revolutionary War) 6 Mar 1745 Mar 1745 6 Mar 1745 6 Mar 1745 6 Mar 1745 Mar 1745 Mar 1745 Mar 1745 Warsaw Poland 11 Oct 1779 Thunderbolt United States of America intersex man
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stuewe-5 11.05.2018 04:56:15 False suggestion Wikidata gives multiple birth dates including the one on WikiTree.
McIntosh-1501
H
17 Mar 1725 Brig. Gen. Lachlan McIntosh certain 27 Jan 1726 certain Raitts, Alvie Parish, Scotland certain 19 Feb 1806 Savannah, Chatham County, Georgia, United States Male Miller-22094
Q3215815 Lachlan McIntosh (American general (1725–1806)) 17 Mar 1725 Kingussie United Kingdom 20 Feb 1806 Savannah United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stuewe-5 11.05.2018 04:58:27 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Unknown-461804
H
30 Nov 1819 Mary Ragland (Unknown) 1820 Georgia, United States uncertain 1870 Georgia, United States Female Ragland-785
Q96223884 Mary ((1820-1870)) 30 Nov 1819 30 Nov 1869 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ragland-785 09.05.2023 14:38:52 False suggestion
Talbot-1743
H
1762 Matthew Talbot 1767 Bedford County, Virginia 17 Sep 1827 Wilkes County, Georgia Male Kemp-4435
Q249531 Matthew Talbot (American politician (1762-1827)) 1762 Bedford County United States of America 17 Sep 1827 Washington United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stuewe-5 11.05.2018 04:46:26 False suggestion WikiData is incorrect. USA is used too early.
Alston-75
H
18 Feb 1740 Philip Alston 18 Feb 1741 Chowan, North Carolina 28 Oct 1791 Oconee River, Washington, Georgia, United States Male Sweatt-64
Q7183117 Philip Alston (American counterfeiter and outlaw, father of Peter Alston.) 18 Feb 1740 Province of South Carolina Kingdom of Great Britain New Madrid United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
kreutzer-114 26.04.2021 01:27:09 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Andrews-8264
H
1800 Richard Dick Andrews uncertain 1797 Sandersville, Georgia, USA 28 Oct 1835 certain San Antonio, Republic of Texas Male Orphan
Q3934758 Richard Andrews (first rebel killed during the Texas Revolution) 1800 28 Oct 1835 Battle of Concepción United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-7161 21.04.2021 05:31:51 False suggestion Sources listed list the Birthdate on profile. Wikidata is not used
Redding-1435
H
14 Apr 1890 Richard Dick Cannonball Redding certain 15 Apr 1890 Atlanta, Fulton, Georgia, United States certain 31 Oct 1948 Islip, Suffolk, New York, United States Male Meyer-5224
Q5273303 Dick Redding (American baseball player (1890-1948)) 14 Apr 1890 31 Oct 1948 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Meyer-5224 12.04.2024 22:31:40 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Meyer-5224 24.02.2023 22:27:14 False suggestion All baseball sources and Wikipedia list April 15th
Meyer-5224 24.02.2023 22:27:55 Not corrected Wikidata date is incorrect
Ragland-1213
H
30 Nov 1791 Richard Dick Ragland 1792 Georgia, United States not living East Point, Fulton, Georgia, United States Male Ragland-785
Q96223883 Richard Ragland (1792-) 30 Nov 1791 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ragland-785 09.05.2023 14:37:19 False suggestion
Ragland-785 09.05.2023 14:37:47 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Ligon-494
H
23 Dec 1823 Robert Fulwood Ligon 16 Dec 1823 Watkinsville, Oconee County, Georgia, USA 11 Oct 1901 Montgomery, Montgomery County, Alabama, USA Male Orphan
Q1771296 Robert F. Ligon (American politician (1823-1901)) 23 Dec 1823 Watkinsville United States of America 11 Oct 1901 Montgomery United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Tuck-697 31.05.2018 12:48:18 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Harris-31422
H
2 Jan 1896 Rufus Carrollton Harris certain 2 Jan 1897 Walton, Georgia, United States certain 18 Aug 1988 Bibb, Georgia, United States Male Armistead-1150
Q7378013 Rufus Carrollton Harris (American academic administrator (1896-1988)) 2 Jan 1896 Walton County United States of America 18 Aug 1988 Macon United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Armistead-1150 25.11.2023 20:13:35 False suggestion Date is approximate and only 1 year off
Williams-98175
H
12 Feb 1912 Rev. Samuel Woodrow Williams certain 20 Feb 1912 certain Sparkman, Dallas, Arkansas, United States certain 10 Oct 1970 certain Atlanta, Fulton, Georgia, United States Male WikiTree-112
Q27982168 Samuel Woodrow Williams (African American civil rights activist (1912–1970)) 12 Feb 1912 Sparkman United States of America 1970 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Graham-2838 03.07.2021 10:19:39 Not corrected unable to determine which is correct
Graham-2838 04.02.2022 15:14:09 False suggestion
Fleming-1753
H
26 Dec 1867 Sarah Hazelhurst McAdoo (Fleming) 26 Dec 1866 Savannah, Chatham Co, Georgia 21 Feb 1912 Irvington-on-Hudson, Westchester Co, New York Female McAdoo-199
Q99178648 Sarah Houstoun Fleming (26 Dec 1867 Savannah, Ga. - 21 Feb 1912 Irvington, New York) 26 Dec 1867 21 Feb 1912 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McAdoo-199 23.02.2023 05:08:24 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Root-2520
H
14 Mar 1824 Sidney Dwight Root 11 Mar 1824 Montague, Franklin, Massachusetts, United States 13 Feb 1897 Atlanta, Fulton, Georgia, United States Male Kemp-4435
Q7509313 Sidney Root (American businessman) 14 Mar 1824 1897 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thompson-34031 21.09.2018 20:05:04 False suggestion Wikipedia has two different dates. The date entered matches one of the Wikipedia dates and Find A Grave
Telfair-7
H
2 Mar 1780 Thomas Telfair 2 Mar 1786 Savannah, Chatham, Georgia, USA 18 Feb 1818 Savannah, Chatham, Georgia, USA Male Sharpless-254
Q587576 Thomas Telfair (American politician (1780-1818)) 2 Mar 1780 Savannah United States of America 18 Feb 1818 Savannah United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stuewe-5 11.05.2018 04:51:19 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced. Source link is not to profile of Thomas Telfair.
White-69209
H
25 Dec 1831 Reverend William Jefferson White certain 25 Dec 1832 certain Ruckersville, Elbert, Georgia, United States certain 17 Apr 1913 certain Augusta, Richmond, Georgia, United States Male Yaden-16

WikiTree-112
Q28709708 William J. White (American journalist) 25 Dec 1831 Ruckersville United States of America 17 Apr 1913 Augusta United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Yaden-16 09.12.2021 02:03:20 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Longstreet-117
H
1760 William Longstreet certain 6 Oct 1759 certain Upper Freehold Township, Monmouth County, New Jersey certain 1 Sep 1814 certain Augusta, Richmond County, Georgia Male Longstreet-30
Q8014684 William Longstreet (American inventor) 1760 1814 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Longstreet-30 06.11.2023 02:00:08 False suggestion the date is exact 1760 is too broad.
Of Kakheti-1
H
7 Nov 1700 King თეიმურაზ Teimuraz II of Kakheti 1680 Tbilisi, Georgia 8 Jan 1762 Saint Petersburg, Russia Male Jackson Williams-2
Q1993853 Teimuraz II of Kakheti (King of Kartli (1700–1762)) 7 Nov 1700 Tbilisi Georgia 8 Jan 1762 Saint Petersburg Russia male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stuewe-5 11.05.2018 05:13:56 False suggestion Wikidata's source has same birthdate at WikiTree. Wikidata's bd does not match source.