Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Fowler-13208
H
Nov 1887 Alan Arthur Fowler 27 Feb 1887 Lochbroom, Ross and Cromarty, Scotland, United Kingdom 28 Apr 1915 Hill 60, Flanders, France Male Shelley-714
Q75647826 Alan Arthur Fowler (Peerage person ID=269992) Nov 1887 28 Apr 1915 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:09:37 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Minchin-327
H
7 Nov 1863 Charles Frederick Minchin CE 29 Nov 1863 uncertain Bengal, India before 1925 uncertain Male Groom-187
Q75800150 Charles Frederick Minchin ((born 1863)) 7 Nov 1863 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Groom-187 22.12.2022 21:32:01 False suggestion
Dawkins-742
H
10 Jun 1882 Clinton George Evelyn Dawkins certain 16 Jun 1882 uncertain Dwyran, Anglesey, Wales certain 4 Dec 1966 certain Over Norton, Oxfordshire, England, United Kingdom Male Cantwell-383
Q76287726 Clinton George Evelyn Dawkins ((1882-1966)) 10 Jun 1882 1966 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hardy-7997 29.07.2022 14:58:44 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Hardy-7997 29.07.2022 14:58:59 False suggestion Data Doctor - Error 555: Wikidata - Different birt
Underwood-8525
H
30 Aug 1876 Edward Arthur Ted Underwood 21 Aug 1876 Madras, India Male Wickham-1317
Q75751422 Edward Arthur Underwood ((born 1876)) 30 Aug 1876 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wickham-1317 11.04.2023 06:36:08 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Wahab-36
H
1851 Emma Louisa Wahab 20 Aug 1850 Madras, Tamil Nādu, India 16 Jul 1920 Beldornie, Bexhill-on-Sea, Sussex, England, United Kingdom Female Webber-4005
Q76280337 Emma L. Wahab ((born 1851)) 1851 16 Jul 1920 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Webber-4005 17.12.2020 03:05:57 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Arbuthnot-801
H
1843 Frances Fanny Kennaway (Arbuthnot) certain 31 May 1842 India 23 Oct 1922 Devon, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
Q75410691 Frances Arbuthnot ((1843-1922)) 1843 23 Oct 1922 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Arbuthnot-53 14.02.2020 12:47:31 False suggestion
Fulton-1957
H
1 Jun 1859 Frederick Fulton certain 1 Jun 1850 certain Alīgarh, Uttar Pradesh, India certain 3 Aug 1923 certain Napier, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand Male Shelley-714
Q24203372 Frederick Fulton (cricketer (1859-1923)) 1 Jun 1859 Aligarh India 3 Aug 1923 Napier New Zealand male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 05.11.2017 18:59:59 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong
Lumsden-1366
H
14 Dec 1872 Brig Gen Frederick William Lumsden VC CB DSO certain 14 Dec 1871 Fyzābād, Andhra Pradesh, India certain 4 Jun 1918 certain Blairville, Pas-de-Calais, France Male Ledger-534
Q5499092 Frederick William Lumsden (British officer in the Royal Marine Artillery (1872-1918)) 14 Dec 1872 Faizabad India 4 Jun 1918 Arras France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ledger-534 10.01.2024 18:05:31 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Ledger-534 10.01.2024 18:05:47 Comment Baptised March 1872
Harris-31596
H
31 Aug 1812 George Anstruther Harris 3 Aug 1812 St. George Fort, Madras, India 24 Aug 1891 Axbridge, Somerset, England, United Kingdom Male Coup-34
Q75831465 George Anstruther Harris ((1812-1891)) 31 Aug 1812 24 Aug 1891 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Coup-34 20.11.2021 05:37:23 False suggestion
Begbie-151
H
7 Feb 1842 Gertrude Emma Master (Begbie) certain 20 Feb 1842 Meerut, Bengal, India certain 1924 certain Richmond, Surrey, England, United Kingdom Female Orphan
Q75524685 Gertrude Emma Begbie ((born 1842)) 7 Feb 1842 1924 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Darcy-578 12.12.2019 06:32:49 False suggestion WikiData is wrong the source on the profile is correct
Darcy-578 12.12.2019 06:40:39 False suggestion connected appropriately in WIkiTree
Studd-80
H
14 Mar 1819 Henrietta Anne MacKinnon (Studd) before 26 Jun 1818 Calcutta, West Bengal, India 18 Feb 1856 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom Female Quigley-173
Q76146111 Henrietta Studd ((born 1819)) 14 Mar 1819 18 Feb 1856 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Spradley-150 13.01.2020 22:16:08 Corrected connected and added sources
Spradley-150 20.02.2020 19:15:00 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Babington Smith-2
H
19 Jan 1863 Sir Henry Babington Smith GBE CH KCB 29 Jan 1863 Riverbank, Putney, London 29 Sep 1923 Saffron Waldren, Essex, England Male Babington-Smith-1
Q5717662 Henry Babington Smith (British civil servant (1863-1923)) 19 Jan 1863 29 Sep 1923 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Babington-Smith-1 27.03.2022 16:46:56 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Parker-19603
H
25 Feb 1714 Admiral Hyde 5th Baronet Parker certain 1 Feb 1714 certain Tredington, Warwickshire, England after 12 Dec 1782 uncertain Malabar Coast, India Male Urquhart-93
Q1363958 Sir Hyde Parker, 5th Baronet (Royal Navy vice admiral (1714-1782)) 25 Feb 1714 Worcestershire United Kingdom 1782 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 24.01.2020 06:08:52 Corrected Changed DOB
Urquhart-93 06.03.2020 00:50:16 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Carnac-1
H
1716 Brig. Gen. John Carnac certain 1721 certain Ireland certain 29 Nov 1800 certain Mangalore, Karnātaka, India Male Rivett-Carnac-9
Q6225224 John Carnac (British East India Company general) 1716 29 Nov 1800 Mangaluru India male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rivett-Carnac-9 09.08.2022 15:13:57 False suggestion
Playfair-62
H
1 May 1818 Rt Hon Sir Lyon 1st Baron Playfair Playfair KCB MP 21 May 1818 India 29 May 1898 Kensington, Middlesex, England, United Kingdom Male Wickham-1317
Q333737 Lyon Playfair, 1st Baron Playfair (British politician and chemist (1818-1898)) 1 May 1818 Haiti Haiti 29 May 1898 South Kensington United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wickham-1153 28.03.2021 13:37:33 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Ryan-12154
H
26 Nov 1880 Mary Catherine Ryan 26 Dec 1880 Bengal, India 9 Apr 1881 Bengal, India Female Wickham-1317
Q76252008 Mary Catherine Ryan ((1880-1881)) 26 Nov 1880 9 Apr 1881 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wickham-1153 03.06.2020 11:25:50 False suggestion WikiTree profiles connected appropriately
Francis-10944
H
1840 Mary May Caroline Stirling (Francis) uncertain 6 Jun 1850 Madras, India certain 16 Apr 1931 Kingston dist., Surrey, England, United Kingdom Female Milledge-96
Q76178405 May Caroline Francis (Peerage person ID=584650) 1840 1910 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Milledge-96 18.12.2023 17:59:18 Comment Wikidata needs to be corrected
Milledge-96 28.12.2023 02:30:13 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Master-103
H
1884 Mildred Estelle Sybella Assheton (Master) CBE certain 12 Apr 1876 Bellary, Madras, India certain 18 Aug 1949 Clitheroe, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom Female Shelley-714
Q75512046 Mildred Estelle Sybella Master ((1884-1949)) 1884 18 Aug 1949 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelley-714 02.01.2020 00:22:56 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Wyndham-315
H
22 Sep 1833 Col. Percy Henry Wyndham certain 5 Feb 1833 certain At Sea (on board the Arab) 25 Jan 1879 certain Rangoon, Burma, India Male Hobbs-1709
Q16859237 Percy Wyndham (American soldier) 22 Sep 1833 The Downs United Kingdom 27 Jan 1879 Yangon Myanmar male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
hobbs-1709 09.09.2021 10:11:26 False suggestion I've documentation/evidence advising birth on board the Arab 05/02/1833. Source required as proof of 22/09/1833 birth!
Aitken-1622
H
14 Apr 1828 Robert Hope Moncrieff Aitken VC before 8 Feb 1828 Cupar, Fife, Scotland 18 Sep 1887 St Andrews, Fife, Scotland Male Templeton-1883
Q7345608 Robert Hope Moncrieff Aitken (Victoria Cross recipient) 14 Apr 1828 Cupar United Kingdom 18 Sep 1887 St Andrews United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Templeton-1883 07.10.2019 16:48:32 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Swinton-263
H
2 Aug 1773 Samuel Swinton 11 Oct 1771 Swinton, Berwickshire, Scotland 24 Apr 1839 Male Webber-4005
Q76186452 Samuel Swinton ((1773-1839)) 2 Aug 1773 1839 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Webber-4005 11.02.2022 18:20:45 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Gopalan-13
H
7 Apr 1938 Shyamala Harris (Gopalan) 7 Dec 1938 Madras, Madras, India 11 Feb 2009 certain Oakland, Alameda, California, USA Female WikiTree-6
Q60844968 Shyamala Gopalan (Indian-American cancer researcher and civil rights activist) 7 Apr 1938 Chennai India 11 Feb 2009 Oakland United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 16.04.2021 01:12:56 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Brydon-177
H
10 Oct 1811 William Brydon certain 9 Oct 1811 certain London, England, United Kingdom certain 20 Mar 1873 certain Nigg, Ross-shire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Cronin-Wojdat-1
Q3181102 William Brydon (assistant surgeon in the British East India Company Army (1811-1873)) 10 Oct 1811 London United Kingdom 20 Mar 1873 Scotland United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
cronin-wojdat-1 25.01.2021 11:47:02 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Blythe-406
H
1818 William Edward Blythe aka Blyth certain 1 Dec 1823 Calcutta, West Bengal, India 31 Aug 1873 London, England, United Kingdom Male Trimbee-2
Q51136009 William Edward Blythe (British surveyor) 1818 1873 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Willis-3607 27.12.2022 11:20:47 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Willis-3607 27.12.2022 11:21:11 Comment
Twentymann-4
H
1794 William Henry Twentymann 8 Nov 1793 London, London, England 20 Apr 1842 Calcutta, West Bengal, India Male Lancashire-42
Q108351218 William Henry Twentyman (8 Nov 1793 - 20 Apr 1842) 1794 20 Apr 1842 Kolkata India male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lancashire-42 22.12.2021 17:31:14 Not corrected Wikidata is sourced with FindAGrave which is unsourced
Lancashire-42 11.07.2022 19:01:49 False suggestion Wikidata is sourced with FindAGrave which is unsourced