Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 310: Mother was dead before birth Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Roulhac-20
H
Mary Jane Gregoire Ely (Roulhac) Mother after 21 Jan 1805 Female Sharpless-254
Ely-4079
H
Francis R. Ely Child 1 Sep 1812 North Carolina, United States 5 Jan 1858 Jackson, Florida, United States Male Sharpless-254
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
payne-15730 01.01.2024 13:35:38 False suggestion Mothers DOD is After date given; relationships are from father's will
Hamrick-918
H
Hannah Scruggs (Hamrick) Mother uncertain certain 10 Dec 1882 North Carolina Female Mason-13750
Scruggs-1004
H
Aquilla Emma Brooks (Scruggs) Child certain 14 May 1893 Cleveland Co. NC certain 27 Dec 1982 Shelby, NC Female Mason-13750
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mason-13750 13.01.2019 16:52:45 Not corrected
Mason-13750 13.01.2019 16:53:20 False suggestion
Mason-13750 13.01.2019 16:54:56 Comment Dates taken from graves in Shelby NC. Not sure which wife is mother.
Bridges-1765
H
Margery Pike (Bridges) Mother certain 16 Mar 1599 certain Suffolk, England uncertain 1645 certain Limerick, Ireland Female Pike-2301
Pike-279
H
Gabriel Pike Child uncertain 1650 certain Ireland not living uncertain North Carolina Male Pike-2301
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Doss-1813 15.06.2023 15:50:07 False suggestion
Coghill-1
H
Margaret Powell (Coghill) Mother before 1665 Essex, Colony of Virginia uncertain 1698 Essex, Colony of Virginia Female Hyler-60

Dukes-285
Powell-111
H
John Powell Child uncertain 31 Mar 1712 uncertain Virginia uncertain 21 Jan 1793 certain Burke, North Carolina, United States Male Hatton-1045

Hyler-60

McCraw-22

Melton-1300

Clipper-15

Giles-3059
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McCraw-22 21.11.2023 04:22:37 False suggestion
Ott-376
H
Anna Christina Bidebaugh (Ott) Mother 1667 Ungstein, Bad Durkheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany 1725 Ungstein, Bad Durkheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany Female Orphan
Bidebaugh-1
H
Eva Catherina Catherine Lingel (Bidebaugh) Child uncertain 1734 uncertain Ungstein, Bad Dürkheim, Kurfürstentum Pfalz, Heiliges Römisches Reich 1800 Rowan, North Carolina, United States Female Wiseman-3278

Bostian-197
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wiseman-3278 13.03.2023 21:55:39 False suggestion
Lowe-3840
H
Alice Lowe Mother uncertain 1687 Abington, Montgomery, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America after 1739 North Carolina Female Johnston-6268

Freeman-4727
Todd-3246
H
John Todd Child 1753 Putnam, Georgia 1813 Putnam, Georgia, United States Male Johnston-6268
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Miller-79136 22.10.2021 01:16:53 False suggestion
Hartmann-274
H
Anna Margarete Hartmann Mother certain 22 May 1694 uncertain Rohrbach, Bergstrasse, Hessen, Germany uncertain 26 Oct 1718 uncertain North Carolina Female Orphan
Troutman-434
H
Johann Melchoir Melchior Troutman Child certain 24 Apr 1729 uncertain Gumpen, Odenwaldkreis, Hessen, Germany uncertain 9 Nov 1778 certain Rowan, North Carolina, United States Male Powers-3928
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Johnson-61091 30.10.2021 18:25:00 Not corrected left message for profile manager, mother death date in question. More Sources: *Anna Margaretha Fogger Hartmann discovered in Mainz, Germany, Births, Marriages and Deaths, 1798-1875 - https://www.ancestry.com/sharing/26314838?h=b38ffd * Hesse, Germany, Lutheran Baptisms, Marriages, and Burials, 1661-1957 NameAnna Margaretha HartmannEvent TypeBeerdigung (Burial)Death Date1845Burial Date26. Mrz 1845 (26 Mar 1845)Burial PlaceReichelsheim in der Wetterau, Hessen (Hesse), Deutschland (Germany)SpouseJohannes Trautmann *Germany, Select Marriages, 1558-1929 NameAnna TreuschGenderFemaleMarriage Date4. Aug 1712 (4 Aug 1712)Marriage PlaceEvangelisch, Reichelsheim Odenwald, Starkenburg, Hesse-DarmstadtFatherPhilipp Jacob TreuschSpouseJohann Adam Trautmann * Germany, Select Births and Baptisms, 1558-1898 NameAnna TreuscheGenderFemaleBaptism Age0Birth Date11. Okt 1695 (11 Oct 1695)Baptism Date13. Okt 1695 (13 Oct 1695)Baptism PlaceEvangelisch, Reichelsheim Odenwald, Starkenburg, Hesse-DarmstadtResidence PlaceReichelsheim (Kr. Friedberg), Hessen, GermanyFatherPhilipp Jacob TreuscheMotherEvaFHL Film Number1195016 * What I have on my ancestry page. https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/5508516/person/-1444545712/facts?msg=ntm&msgParams=3%7c3%7c6%7cUGhpbGlwcCBKYWNvYiBUcmV1c2NofCBFdmEgR3JvbGwgVHJldXNjaA2&mpid=-1444545712&nec=0 Let me know your thoughts, she is my 7th great Grandmother.
Johnson-61091 03.11.2021 19:17:58 False suggestion Hartmann is his Step-Mother
Darwell-2
H
Susannah Cole (Darwell) Mother uncertain 1696 uncertain Baltimore, Baltimore, Province of Maryland after 13 Mar 1720 uncertain Baltimore, Baltimore, Province of Maryland Female York-818
Cole-13859
H
Susannah Susanna Cole Child certain 18 Mar 1720 Baltimore, Baltimore, Province of Maryland uncertain 1753 Orange, Colony of North Carolina Female Murphy-4346
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
adams-16917 01.10.2017 20:21:27 False suggestion
adams-16917 01.10.2017 21:21:19 Comment
Gregg-33
H
Amy Hadley (Gregg) Mother uncertain 25 Aug 1698 New Castle, New Castle, Delaware 1738 New Castle, New Castle, Delaware Female Black-3287

Walsh-8
Hadley-352
H
Deborah Hadley Child 29 Dec 1747 New Castle, New Castle, Delaware 1768 Cane Creek, Orange, North Carolina Female Gordon-7317
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Barry-1264 21.04.2018 09:53:23 Corrected
Sigh-1 17.04.2022 22:33:54 False suggestion
James-17773
H
Sarah Eiland (James) Mother certain 1717 after 1750 North Carolina Female Orphan
Eiland-82
H
Isaiah Eiland Child uncertain 1752 uncertain 1807 Georgia, United States Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Athey-67 24.04.2020 15:53:15 False suggestion date of death is marked 'after', not exact, so there's no conflict
Willson-2044
H
Rebecca McCalvey (Willson) aka Woods Mother 1721 Taunton, Bristol, Massachusetts 19 Sep 1756 Morristown, Morris, New Jersey Female Caudill-375
Woods-6260
H
Sarah Sally Highsmith (Woods) Child certain 1758 certain Morristown, Morris, New Jersey certain 1830 certain Flat Rock, Crawford, Illinois, United States Female Frazier-1689

Caudill-375
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
smith-157141 11.11.2022 17:48:10 Not corrected Left note for PM to check data
Whitfield-2407 25.09.2023 01:28:29 False suggestion
Whitfield-2407 25.09.2023 01:28:58 False suggestion Mothers DOD is After date given
Goode-304
H
Hannah Dalton (Goode) Mother uncertain 7 Apr 1724 Virginia uncertain 1770 Rutherford, North Carolina, United States Female Sullivan-14361
Dalton-1522
H
Sally Halford (Dalton) Child 1772 Prince Edward, , Colony of Virginia Rutherford County, North Carolina USA Female Riddle-392
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Halford-162 29.08.2018 00:44:30 Comment corrected
Halford-162 29.08.2018 00:45:07 Comment
Adams-39063 15.05.2020 16:31:49 Not corrected Message left on profile for manager to correct error
Richards-7070 15.11.2021 15:18:02 False suggestion
Beasley-671
H
Frances Bass (Beasley) Mother uncertain 1730 Chesterfield County, Virginia after 1771 Female Hawk-401
Bass-1621
H
Christopher Bass Child 1773 Prince Edward County, Virginia 7 Jul 1829 Oglethorpe, Georgia, USA Male Hawk-401
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Athey-67 24.04.2020 16:26:42 False suggestion date of death is marked 'after', not exact, so there's no conflict
Coussens-22
H
Frances Stiles (Coussens) aka Cousins Mother 1730 Henrico, Virginia uncertain 1777 Mecklenburg County, Virginia, United States Female House-1900
Stiles-1891
H
John Stiles Child 1780 Laurens, Laurens County, Carolina Colony 3 Nov 1825 Huntlandd, Lincoln, Tennessee, USA Male House-1900
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richards-7070 04.03.2022 20:51:46 False suggestion
Waller-3073
H
Mary Johnston (Waller) Mother uncertain 1731 North Carolina uncertain 1756 South Carolina Female Johnston-11718
Johnston-9420
H
John Johnston Sr. Child uncertain 1765 Colleton, South Carolina certain 1807 Wayne County, Georgia, United States Male Bay-61
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Athey-67 24.04.2020 16:31:36 False suggestion DOD marked as uncertain
Barrington-460
H
Mary Aldridge (Barrington) Mother certain 1735 certain Northumberland, Colony of Virginia certain 1790 certain Glasgow, Columbiana, Ohio, United States Female Gebhardt-164
Aldridge-900
H
Thomas Aldridge Child 1811 Greene, North Carolina 1847 Greene, North Carolina Male Gebhardt-164
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Brunson-1754 10.10.2023 22:15:27 False suggestion
Portlock-111
H
Jamima Thompson (Portlock) Mother 7 Jan 1738 Norfolk, Colony of Virginia after 1776 Female Holt-966
Thompson-48437
H
Portlock Thompson Child certain 16 Aug 1794 uncertain Robeson, North Carolina, United States 11 Oct 1856 Dooly, Georgia, United States Male Barber-11549

Holt-966
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bridgham-36 05.04.2022 22:47:39 False suggestion
Reed-2468
H
Deborah Cobb (Reed) Mother uncertain 1745 certain Orange, North Carolina uncertain 1775 certain North Carolina Female White-8473

Michaud-221
Cobb-1227
H
William Cobb Child uncertain 1780 Orange, North Carolina 1858 uncertain Walker, Georgia, United States Male White-8473
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Michaud-221 11.08.2021 01:32:59 False suggestion 'about' date only
Unknown-393268
H
Mary Fulham (Unknown) Mother before 1755 after 1800 North Carolina Female McReynolds-216
Fulham-43
H
Isaac Fulham Child before 1803 before 1840 North Carolina Male McReynolds-216
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McReynolds-216 01.06.2018 00:21:06 False suggestion She died AFTER 1800, he was born BEFORE 1803....
Harkey-159
H
Elizabeth Eudy (Harkey) Mother uncertain 1757 Mecklenburg, North Carolina after 1788 North Carolina, United States Female Goodman-2577
Eudy-132
H
William R Eudy Child 25 Aug 1796 Stanly, North Carolina, United States 22 Mar 1881 Stanly, North Carolina, United States Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Simmons-11603 09.04.2024 22:41:17 False suggestion Her d.o.d. is unknown and written as 'after..' so still plausi
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Holt-37
H
Margaret Powell (Holt) Mother uncertain 1760 certain Orange, North Carolina uncertain 1793 Maury County, Tennessee, USA Female Clipper-15

Melton-1300

Hatton-1045
Powell-100
H
Sarah Brown (Powell) Child uncertain 1795 uncertain North Carolina, United States Female Riley-636
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
DeMoss-341 14.04.2024 22:39:46 False suggestion
Reagan-1097
H
Elizabeth Cook (Reagan) Mother uncertain 1760 Province of Maryland 1813 Henry County, Georgia, United States Female Cook-22916
Cook-873
H
Sarah Ann Cowan (Cook) Child certain 7 Jun 1816 Abbeville, South Carolina, United States 4 Feb 1887 Clayton, Georgia, United States Female House-5936
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Leger-741 22.09.2022 11:08:33 False suggestion
Hahn-862
H
Rachel Icenhower (Hahn) Mother uncertain 18 Dec 1794 uncertain 16 Apr 1831 Female Lail-37
Icenhower-33
H
Mary Barbara Pope (Icenhower) Child 13 Jun 1831 3 Jun 1910 North Carolina, United States Female Laski-9
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Laski-9 03.01.2023 21:21:33 False suggestion
Ledbetter-292
H
Lucy Elizabeth Harris (Ledbetter) Mother certain 14 Dec 1814 certain Chatham County, North Carolina certain 11 Apr 1856 certain McNairy County, Tennessee Female Ledbetter-258
Harris-16324
H
Unknown Harris Child uncertain 1860 McNairy County, Tennessee uncertain 1860 McNairy County, Tennessee Male Ledbetter-258
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Tull-5 08.04.2023 18:43:57 False suggestion
Phillips-11950
H
Phoeby Munroe (Phillips) Mother uncertain 1820 uncertain 1841 North Carolina Female K-434
Munroe-352
H
Sarah Elizabeth Fincher (Munroe) Child uncertain Nov 1842 North Carolina certain 1 Dec 1876 certain Haralson County, Georgia, USA Female K-434
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
K-434 18.08.2017 19:04:26 Not corrected She died AFTER 1840. Exact date unknown at this time. This is a false error.
K-434 18.08.2017 19:05:33 Not corrected She died AFTER 1840; exact date is unknown at this time.
K-434 18.08.2017 19:08:07 Comment Mother died in 1841 or later; exact death unknown at this time.
K-434 18.08.2017 19:09:26 Comment She died AFTER 1840. Exact date unknown at this time. This is a false error.
K-434 19.08.2017 21:49:40 False suggestion The mother's death date says 'after' that date as the last source of her was on that date. Her exact date of death is unknown at this time.
Denson-143
H
Nancy Y. Hedgepeth (Denson) Mother 1833 North Carolina, United States 1858 Female Reese-1462
Hedgepeth-142
H
Juliana Hedgepeth Child uncertain 1859 Nash, North Carolina Female Reese-1462
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Oates-1811 18.07.2023 10:24:35 False suggestion
Hensley-4980
H
Lavenia Ferelda Caudill (Hensley) Mother certain 1846 certain North Carolina, United States certain 31 May 1871 certain Scott, Virginia, United States Female Whitt-1176
Caudill-2239
H
James Clinton Caudill Child certain 9 Mar 1878 certain Estillville, Scott, Virginia, United States certain 4 Feb 1919 certain Richmond, Wise, Virginia, United States Male Whitt-1176
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Whitt-1176 21.07.2023 07:18:28 Comment will have to research later
Whitt-1176 01.09.2023 06:18:15 Corrected
Whitt-1176 01.09.2023 06:21:40 False suggestion husband had 3 wives
Whitt-1176 01.09.2023 06:26:22 Comment Corrected DOB
Estep-1581
H
Ziney Luary Tinsey Barnett (Estep) Mother 29 Mar 1856 Wilkes County, North Carolina, USA 15 Jun 1897 Wilkes County, North Carolina, USA Female Orphan
Barnette-416
H
Ila Dorothy Johnson (Barnette) Child 9 Apr 1899 Wilkes County, North Carolina, USA 30 Sep 1981 Alexander County, North Carolina, USA Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Luker-573 23.11.2022 01:49:07 False suggestion
DeGraffenreid-15
H
Rosa Lee Morris (DeGraffenreid) Mother uncertain 1884 North Carolina, United States after 1910 Female Morris-9426
Morris-10037
H
Nona Croom (Morris) Child 2 Jun 1912 Kinston, Lenoir, North Carolina, United States 22 Dec 2009 Portsmouth, Virginia, United States Female Morris-9426
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ellerbrock-2 17.08.2017 03:27:44 Corrected
Michaud-221 13.09.2018 10:43:46 False suggestion 'about' date only
Stiles-821
H
Ellie Mae Stiles Mother 22 Feb 1892 Sylva, Jackson, North Carolina, United States 20 Oct 1918 Louisburg, Franklin, North Carolina, United States Female Orphan
Ammons-67
H
Gertrude Ammons Child uncertain 1919 Jackson, North Carolina, United States Jacksonville, Duval, Florida, United States Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
payne-15730 29.12.2023 16:16:28 False suggestion Dates are listed for before and after.
Stiles-821
H
Ellie Mae Stiles Mother 22 Feb 1892 Sylva, Jackson, North Carolina, United States 20 Oct 1918 Louisburg, Franklin, North Carolina, United States Female Orphan
Ammons-65
H
Bonnie Ammons Child uncertain 1920 Jackson, North Carolina, United States Jacksonville, Duval, Florida, United States Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
payne-15730 29.12.2023 16:16:30 False suggestion Dates are listed for before and after.