Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
White-50707
H
31 Mar 1902 Ada Jessamine Shumate (White) certain 30 Mar 1902 Preston, Henry County, Virginia certain 16 Dec 1990 Greenville, Pitt County, North Carolina Female Rhodes-4150
Q6186059 Jessamine Shumate (Virginia Artist) 31 Mar 1902 16 Dec 1990 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Coltrane-45 17.03.2022 21:04:13 False suggestion dates are the same for birth
Neale-2508
H
5 Nov 1891 Alfred Earle Greasy Neale certain 6 Nov 1892 Parkersburg, Wood, West Virginia, United States certain 2 Nov 1973 Palm Beach County, Florida, United States Male Stewart-763
Q1544191 Greasy Neale (American football and baseball player and coach (1891–1973)) 5 Nov 1891 Parkersburg United States of America 2 Nov 1973 Lake Worth Beach United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
payne-15730 14.12.2023 12:53:41 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Jackson-1298
H
28 Feb 1737 Andrew Jackson certain 1730 uncertain Carrickfergus, County Antrim, Ireland uncertain 1 Mar 1767 Waxhaw, Union, Province of North Carolina Male WikiTree-6

Brooks-5834

Clements-425
Q20767859 Andrew Jackson (father of US president Andrew Jackson) 28 Feb 1737 1738 Northern Ireland United Kingdom Feb 1767 5 Mar 1769 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 07.08.2018 17:14:41 False suggestion Wikidata has no sources for information
Smiley-1320
H
17 May 1925 Arthur Lee Red Smiley Jr 17 May 1924 Asheville, Buncombe County, North Carolina, USA 2 Jan 1972 Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania, USA Male WikiTree-130

Hoff-1617

Ditty-86
Q4799471 Arthur Lee "Red" Smiley (American musician (1925-1972)) 17 May 1925 Asheville United States of America 2 Jan 1972 Philadelphia United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hoff-1617 10.06.2023 20:36:32 False suggestion This is an error on the Wikipedia page which is ex
Stedman-1196
H
29 Jan 1841 Maj. Charles Manly Stedman certain 21 Jan 1841 Pittsboro, Chatham, North Carolina, United States 23 Sep 1930 Fayetteville, Cumberland, North Carolina, United States Male Schmehl-58
Q1065436 Charles Manly Stedman (Confederate Army officer (1841-1930)) 29 Jan 1841 Pittsboro United States of America 23 Sep 1930 Washington, D.C. United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Schmehl-58 20.02.2022 06:40:05 False suggestion Wikidata ignores prefixes
Boone-34
H
2 Nov 1734 Col Daniel Boone certain 22 Oct 1734 certain Exeter, Berks County, Province of Pennsylvania certain 26 Sep 1820 certain Defiance, St. Charles, Missouri Territory, United States Male WikiTree-35
Q316661 Daniel Boone (American settler (1734-1820)) 2 Nov 1734 Birdsboro United States of America 26 Sep 1820 Daniel Boone Home United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
jump-307 03.12.2020 17:21:28 Comment 22 Oct O.S.
jump-307 03.12.2020 17:22:40 Comment birth [22 Oct 1734 O.S.]
Schwartz-2715 22.01.2022 23:22:07 Corrected
Carruth-363 27.01.2022 06:48:06 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
LeFevre-60
H
1726 Elizabeth Robinett (LeFevre) uncertain 1729 Chester, Pennsylvania uncertain 1806 certain Surry, North Carolina, United States Female Green-16402

Kinman-87

Niblett-17
Q105806288 Elizabeth ((1726-1806)) 1726 1806 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kinman-87 16.01.2024 23:39:47 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Hughes-31111
H
1840 Hanson Truman Hughes uncertain 1836 certain Granville, North Carolina, United States uncertain Apr 1909 certain North Carolina, United States Male WikiTree-112
Q115697094 Hanson Truman Hughes (North Carolinian state legislator (c. 1840–after 1890s)) 1840 Greensboro United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Head-5589 11.07.2023 15:40:07 False suggestion
Reed-7277
H
26 Aug 1813 Harrison Jackson Reed 26 Aug 1815 Littleton, Middlesex, Massachusetts, United States 25 May 1899 Jacksonville, Duval, Florida, United States Male Ankrum-44
Q885639 Harrison Reed (9th Governor of Florida (1813-1899)) 26 Aug 1813 Littleton United States of America 25 May 1899 25 Mar 1899 Jacksonville United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ankrum-44 14.05.2022 02:52:55 False suggestion
Iredell-6
H
5 Oct 1751 Hon. James Iredell Sr. certain 5 Oct 1750 certain Lewes, East Sussex, England certain 20 Oct 1799 certain Edenton, Chowan County, North Carolina, United States Male WikiTree-13

Harriss-104
Q956007 James Iredell (Justice on the US Supreme Court) 5 Oct 1751 Lewes Lewes Kingdom of England United Kingdom 20 Oct 1799 Edenton United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Meehan-411 20.10.2021 23:53:17 False suggestion
Winder-550
H
7 Feb 1800 Brig Gen John Henry Winder 21 Feb 1800 Somerset, Maryland, United States 7 Feb 1865 Florence, South Carolina, United States Male Jones-116753
Q1678817 John H. Winder (Confederate Army general) 7 Feb 1800 Somerset County United States of America 7 Feb 1865 21 Feb 1865 Florence United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jones-116753 07.10.2023 11:55:05 False suggestion Find a Grave and Virginia Encyclopedia have a diff
Montgomery-5889
H
1750 John Montgomery uncertain 1756 uncertain Pennsylvania certain 13 May 1840 certain Guilford, North Carolina, United States Male Garrett-6780
Q6249212 John Montgomery (American soldier, settler and explorer) 1750 1794 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
montgomery-5710 01.06.2017 11:39:12 Corrected Adjusted birth date
montgomery-5710 05.12.2018 01:45:06 Corrected corrected
montgomery-5710 12.03.2019 19:13:48 Corrected Corrected
Garrett-6780 04.08.2021 21:46:18 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Devereaux-195
H
11 Mar 1761 John Shirley Devereaux uncertain 12 Mar 1761 Ferns, County Wexford, Ireland 7 Jul 1844 Raleigh, Wake, North Carolina, United States Male Kinman-87
Q96076512 John Devereux (merchant, planter 11 Mar. 1761–1 July 1844) 11 Mar 1761 1 Jul 1844 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kinman-87 11.09.2020 21:48:33 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Aiken-1074
H
19 Mar 1894 Loretta Mary Jackie, Moms Mabley Mabley (Aiken) uncertain 19 Mar 1897 certain Brevard, Transylvania, North Carolina, United States certain 23 May 1975 certain White Plains, Westchester, New York, United States Female WikiTree-112
Q6897510 Moms Mabley (American comedian and actress) 19 Mar 1894 Brevard United States of America 23 May 1975 White Plains United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cooper-28960 11.02.2023 03:59:16 False suggestion No conclusive date for birth; if 1900 census corre
Hinton-696
H
1766 Mary Lane (Hinton) uncertain 1745 certain Wake County, North Carolina 3 Apr 1795 certain Wake, North Carolina, United States Female Downs-977
Q96076781 Mary Hinton ((abt. 1745 - 1795)) 1766 1803 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Down-977 26.07.2022 16:56:43 Not corrected Mother-in-law to daughter-in-law
Down-977 26.07.2022 16:56:55 False suggestion
McDonough-136
H
1783 Mary Polly Johnson (McDonough) certain 17 Jul 1782 certain Beaufort County, NC certain 13 Feb 1856 certain Greene County, Tennessee, United States Female WikiTree-6

Pearson-3638
Q75766081 Mary McDonough ((1783-1856)) 1783 1856 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 11.12.2019 21:04:42 Merge proposed Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced
Lee-5956 15.01.2020 22:54:11 False suggestion WikiData/the peerage is unsourced, see source on WikiTree profile
Patterson-6240
H
1835 Mary Sampson Langston (Patterson) aka Leary uncertain 1837 certain Fayetteville, Cumberland, North Carolina, United States certain 8 Apr 1915 certain Lawrence, Douglas, Kansas, United States Female WikiTree-112
Q96311869 Mary Sampson Leary (abolitionist and grandmother of Langston Hughes (est. 1837 - certain 8 Apr 1915)) 1835 North Carolina United States of America 1915 Lawrence United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Díaz-2569 07.09.2023 07:15:11 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced and we say 'uncertain' anyway.
Coles-42
H
1745 Mary Winston Payne (Coles) certain 14 Oct 1743 certain Coles Hill, Pittsylvania, Virginia certain 8 Feb 1807 certain Clarksburg, Harrison, Virginia, United States Female WikiTree-32

Bruce-1972

Akard-1
Q96083119 Mary Coles (1745-) 1745 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 08.09.2020 16:55:49 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Autry-158
H
1794 Micajah Autry certain 1793 certain Sampson, North Carolina, United States certain 6 Mar 1836 certain The Alamo, San Antonio, Bexar, Texas Male WikiTree-44

Richardson-7161
Q6827921 Micajah Autry (Alamo defender) 1794 6 Mar 1836 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-7161 25.03.2019 03:38:30 False suggestion Project protected I have 3 sources for each date. WikiData does not list a retrievable source
Alston-75
H
18 Feb 1740 Philip Alston 18 Feb 1741 Chowan, North Carolina 28 Oct 1791 Oconee River, Washington, Georgia, United States Male Sweatt-64
Q7183117 Philip Alston (American counterfeiter and outlaw, father of Peter Alston.) 18 Feb 1740 Province of South Carolina Kingdom of Great Britain New Madrid United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
kreutzer-114 26.04.2021 01:27:09 False suggestion Julian/Gregorian calendar ambiguity
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Jones-18268
H
1718 Priscilla Ransom (Jones) aka Macon 1729 certain Isle of Wight, Virginia 9 Mar 1802 certain Warren, North Carolina Female Harper-4096

Thomas-10705

Plummer-723
Q34563338 Priscilla Macon (mother of Nathaniel Macon) 1718 9 Mar 1802 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
thomas-10705 17.03.2019 17:11:28 Corrected Adjusted birth date
Lamoreaux-297 22.11.2019 00:09:37 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Blue-489
H
30 May 1868 Dr Rupert Lee Blue certain 30 May 1867 certain Richmond, North Carolina, United States certain 12 Apr 1948 certain Charleston, Charleston, South Carolina, United States Male Orphan
Q549814 Rupert Blue (Surgeon General of the United States) 30 May 1868 Richmond County United States of America 12 Apr 1948 Charleston United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID5703252 17.12.2016 11:05:23 False suggestion Old False error
Priest-412 24.09.2021 11:19:54 False suggestion YOB is documented to be '1867', regardless of what Wikidate misrepresents.
Jackson-48212
H
21 Jan 1824 Stonewall Jackson certain 6 Nov 1932 certain Tabor City, Columbus, North Carolina, United States certain 4 Dec 2021 certain Nashville, Davidson, Tennessee, United States Male Hinshaw-676
Q216124 Stonewall Jackson (general of the Confederate Army in the American Civil War) 21 Jan 1824 Clarksburg United States of America 10 May 1863 Guinea United States of America male
Q216124 Stonewall Jackson (general of the Confederate Army in the American Civil War) 21 Jan 1824 Clarksburg United States of America 10 May 1863 Guinea United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Caldwell-9804 31.03.2024 21:25:02 False suggestion different Stonewall
Devereux-317
H
17 Nov 1793 Thomas Pollock Devereux 17 Dec 1793 New Bern, Craven, North Carolina, United States 7 Mar 1869 Halifax, North Carolina, United States Male Kinman-87
Q61874947 Thomas Pollock Devereux (17 Nov. 1793–7 Mar. 1869; North Carolina) 17 Nov 1793 24 Mar 1869 7 Mar 1869 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kinman-87 07.07.2020 15:06:41 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Halyburton-49
H
2 Oct 1924 PhM2c William David Halyburton USN certain 2 Aug 1924 certain Canton, Haywood, North Carolina, United States certain 10 May 1945 certain Okinawa, Japan Male Sekel-2
Q8007468 William D. Halyburton, Jr. (United States Navy Medal of Honor recipient) 2 Oct 1924 Canton United States of America 10 May 1945 Okinawa Prefecture Japan male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
cochoit-2 08.06.2017 01:36:34 False suggestion Wikidata is incorrect; wikipedia has both birth dates on the page