Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 210: Father was dead before birth (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information .

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
Dunkeld-86 H		Duncan Abbot of Dunkeld (Dunkeld)	Father	certain Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland	after 965 Perthshire, Scotland	Male		Perkins-11750 WikiTree-65
Macdonachadh-17 H		Duncan Macdonachadh	Child	980 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland	1045 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland	Male		WikiTree-65
Olafsson-112 H		Rögnvaldr Reginald Olafsson	Father	Isle of Man, Scotland	30 May 1249 Rushen, Isle of Man	Male		Lokken-3 Query-182 WikiTree-65
Fitzreginald-2 H		Mary Fitzreginald	Child	uncertain 1252 Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1293	Female		Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Willis-3076 30.04.2023 07:05:37 Corrected
De Atholia-12 H		Patrick 1st of Lude de Atholia	Father		after 1392	Male		Simms-302
Robertson-20246 H		Duncan of Pittarrach Robertson	Child	uncertain 1410 Blair Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland	uncertain 1474 Blair Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland	Male		Blair-3347
De Atholia-12 H		Patrick 1st of Lude de Atholia	Father		after 1392	Male		Simms-302
Reid-22142 H		Alexander Reid Ist of Straloch (Reid) aka Ruadh	Child	uncertain 1400 Straloch, Perthshire, Scotland	before 1498	Male		Orphan
Striveling-2 H		John de Striveling	Father		1408	Male		Straiton-4
Striveling-1 H		Sir William of Cadder and Regorton Stirling (Striveling)	Child	uncertain 1410 Cadder, Lanarkshire, Scotland	certain 6 May 1487 Cadder, Lanarkshire, Scotland	Male		Straiton-4
Robertson-3054 H		Duncan Robertson	Father	uncertain	after 1438 Scotland	Male		Simms-302
Robertson-3053 H		Robert Robertson	Child	before 1470	not living Scotland	Male		Orphan
MacLean-666 H		Neil Neil Mor MacLean	Father		1597 Isle of Mull, Argyllshire, Scotland	Male		Quigley-173
MacLean-668 H		Allan MacLean	Child	before 1615		Male		Quigley-173
Wyllie-51 H		John Wyllie	Father		May 1669	Male		Orphan
Wyllie-107 H		Alexander Wyllie	Child	before 1693 Over Castleton, Stewarton, Ayrshire, Scotland		Male		Orphan
Hamilton-8687 H		John Hamilton IVth of Grange (Hamilton)	Father	Scotland	Apr 1675 Scotland	Male		Trimbee-2
Hamilton-16500 H		Elizabeth Burton (Hamilton)	Child	uncertain 1693	uncertain 1747	Female		Roye-101
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Carruth-363 24.11.2023 05:34:51 Comment add comment on editor's profile
Robertson-2816 H		Colin Robertson III of Kindeace (Robertson)	Father	Scotland	after 1691 Scotland	Male		Simms-302
Robertson-2817 H		William Robertson IV of Kindeace (Robertson)	Child	before 1720		Male		Simms-302
Lillico-23 H		Thomas Lillico	Father	Scotland	uncertain 1729	Male		Postnikoff-1
Lillico-19 H		James Archibald Lillico	Child	uncertain 1757 Scotland	23 Jul 1843 Heatherslaw, Ford, Northumberland, England	Male		Cooper-8397
Gillespie-3097 H		John Gillespie	Father	Scotland	1734 Chester, PA	Male		Craig-4735
Gillespie-362 H		Robert Gillespie	Child	uncertain 1775 uncertain North Carolina	uncertain 1826 Pocahontas, Bond, Illinois, United States	Male		Jones-26015 Altic-1
Christie-974 H		Robert Christie	Father	uncertain	after 1755	Male		Orphan
Christie-973 H		Jean Harris (Christie)	Child	uncertain 1767 Fordoun, Kincardineshire, Scotland	certain 14 Mar 1857 Marykirk, Kincardineshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Female		Orphan
MacCalman-30 H		Dugald MacCalman	Father	Kilmore and Kilbride, Argyll, Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 1770	Male		Christie-4701
MacCalman-29 H		Alexander MacCalman	Child	1797 Muckairn, Argyll, Scotland	1855 Muckairn, Argyll, Scotland, United Kingdom	Male		Christie-4701
McKillop-138 H		Mr Charles McKillop	Father	private	uncertain 1780	Male		Lochrie-64
McKillop-137 H		Mrs Euphemia Hamilton (McKillop)	Child	certain 1810 Hamilton, Lanarkshire	not living	Female		Lochrie-64
Johnstone-1256 H		Archibald Johnstone	Father		10 Mar 1799	Male		Powell-8358
Johnstone-1247 H		Robert Johnstone	Child	14 Aug 1800 Glassary, Argyllshire, Scotland		Male		Powell-8358
Munro-1283 H		William Munro	Father	scotland	1820	Male		Flint-834
Munro-1267 H		Catherine Munro	Child	certain 1852 certain Tain, Scotland	uncertain 1920 Colorado	Female		Flint-834
MacDonald-4036 H		Alex MacDonald	Father	private Glenvig Isle of Skye Scotland	uncertain 1835	Male		Walker-17179
MacDonald-4035 H		Ronald Lamont MacDonald	Child	certain 16 Sep 1858 Scotland	certain 7 Feb 1937	Male		Walker-17179
Lamb-11997 H		Archibald Lamb	Father		uncertain 1839	Male		Campbell-20176
Lamb-9307 H		Agnes Burnett (Lamb) aka Burnet	Child	1841 Lasswade, Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 1905	Female		Campbell-20176
MacDonald-3653 H		Roderick MacDonald	Father	uncertain Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1840 Isle of Man, Scotland	Male		Connolly-836
MacDonald-3655 H		Archie MacDonald	Child	uncertain 1876 Isle of Man	after 1896	Male		Connolly-836

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
MacDonald-3653 H		Roderick MacDonald	Father	uncertain Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1840 Isle of Man, Scotland	Male		Connolly-836
MacDonald-3654 H		John MacDonald	Child	before 1855 Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1855	Male		Connolly-836
MacDonald-3653 H		Roderick MacDonald	Father	uncertain Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1840 Isle of Man, Scotland	Male		Connolly-836
MacDonald-3659 H		Annie MacDonald	Child	before 1855 certain Isle of Man	not living	Female		Connolly-836
MacDonald-3653 H		Roderick MacDonald	Father	uncertain Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1840 Isle of Man, Scotland	Male		Connolly-836
MacDonald-3658 H		Catherine MacDonald	Child	before 1855 Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1855	Female		Connolly-836
MacDonald-3653 H		Roderick MacDonald	Father	uncertain Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1840 Isle of Man, Scotland	Male		Connolly-836
MacDonald-3656 H		Alexander MacDonald	Child	before 1855 Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1855	Male		Connolly-836
MacDonald-3653 H		Roderick MacDonald	Father	uncertain Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1840 Isle of Man, Scotland	Male		Connolly-836
MacDonald-3657 H		Allan MacDonald	Child	before 1855 Isle of Man, Scotland	after 1855	Male		Connolly-836
Tippen-15 H		John Tippen	Father		30 Mar 1859	Male		Sinclair-1943
Tippen-13 H		Thomas Tippen	Child	13 May 1868 Old Monkland Coatbridge, Lanarkshire, Scotland	3 Feb 1947 Kirkcaldy	Male		Sinclair-1943