Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Warning 565: Wikidata - Possible duplicate by mother Help (Difficulty: Advanced)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Borthwick-2
H
Compare Agnes Borthwick Wikitree Mother before 1440 certain Borthwick. Midlothian, Scotland not living uncertain Edinburghshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Stuart-326
H
Christian Cristina Stewart Lady Dundas (Stuart) Wikidata Mother uncertain certain Innermeath, Perthshire, Scotland before Nov 1451 certain Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Burke-1801
Q75662345 Beatrix Dundas (Peerage person ID=278558) 1405 1459 female
Q75268599 Christian Stewart (Peerage person ID=25154) female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 03.06.2022 05:32:21 False suggestion Mother is unknown.
Keith-3956
H
Compare Lady Barbara Keith aka Forbes Wikitree Mother uncertain 1540 certain Scotland not living certain Scotland Female Orphan
Mackintosh-49
H
Margaret Sutherland (Mackintosh) aka Grant, Forbes, Gordon Wikidata Mother uncertain 1542 uncertain Inverness-shire, Scotland after 1627 Duffus, Moray, Scotland Female Dallas-250

Fitzmaurice-131

Mac Rae-4

Parker-10195

Cummings-1573
Q75543204 Sir John Forbes, 8th of Pitsligo (Peerage person ID=204466) 1562 Sep 1625 male
Q75404359 Margaret Mackintosh (Peerage person ID=120853) 1542 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 17.05.2021 04:33:15 False suggestion Wikidata match is not the correct person
Hamilton-1710
H
Compare Catherine Hamilton Wikitree Mother before 1403 certain Cadzow, Lanarkshire, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Seton-9
H
Marion Baillie (Seton) aka Seaton Wikidata Mother uncertain 1390 Seton, East Lothian, Scotland 1467 England Female Hare-1576
Q75250370 Margaret Baillie (Peerage person ID=11073) 1510 female
Q75521611 Marian Seton (Peerage person ID=192127) 1380 1467 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hare-1576 11.12.2021 17:54:46 False suggestion Not a match!!!
Hamilton-1710
H
Compare Catherine Hamilton Wikitree Mother before 1403 certain Cadzow, Lanarkshire, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Home-437
H
Marion Hume Lady Lamington (Home) Wikidata Mother after 1476 certain Polwarth, Berwickshire, Scotland uncertain 1545 uncertain Scotland Female Hare-1576
Q75389582 Marion Baillie (Peerage person ID=109272) female
Q76294761 Marion Home (Peerage person ID=669366) 1465 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hare-1576 12.04.2022 21:29:36 Comment PROTECTED PROFILE THAT I AM UNABLE TO MERGE!!!!!!! IT HAS BEEN THIS WAY FOR 6 MONTHS NOW!
Hare-1576 12.04.2022 21:30:09 False suggestion Merge proposed
Downie-1079
H
Compare Christian Christina Marshall Colville (Downie) Wikitree Mother 10 Apr 1852 Copley, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom 7 Jan 1936 Female Colville-218
Brown-76795
H
Janet Colville (Brown) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1850 Dalkeith, Midlothian, Scotland 23 Jul 1883 Scotland Female Colville-218
Q6226788 John Colville, 1st Baron Clydesmuir (British politician (1894-1954)) 13 Feb 1894 31 Oct 1954 male
Q75609717 Janet Brown ((died 1883)) 1850 23 Jul 1883 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
colville-218 01.02.2023 20:27:58 Comment Anyone is welcome to make a profile
colville-218 14.02.2023 18:20:16 False suggestion Um. These are two different people. It's pretty obvious.
Hay-135
H
Compare Lady Elizabeth Gordon (Hay) aka Countess of Huntly Wikitree Mother uncertain 1450 Huntly, Aberdeenshire, Scotland 27 Jun 1509 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Stewart-1854
H
Annabella Princess of Scotland de Savoie (Stewart) aka Gordon Wikidata Mother 1435 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Jun 1509 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q361092 Alexander Gordon, 3rd Earl of Huntly (Earl of Huntly) 14cen 1524 Perth United Kingdom male
Q2912335 Annabella of Scotland (Scottish princess; youngest child of James I of Scotland and Joan Beaufort) 1430s 1509 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
thomas-10705 15.03.2019 16:43:23 False suggestion Completely different people
Irvine-725
H
Compare Lady Elizabeth Irvine Lady Meldrum (Irvine) aka Seton Wikitree Mother uncertain 1536 certain Oldmeldrum, Aberdeenshire, Scotland not living certain Oldmeldrum, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Female Urquhart-93
Gordon-4313
H
Lady Janet Seton (Gordon) Wikidata Mother certain 1519 Lesmoir Scotland after 1532 Omeldrum, Aberdeen, Scotland Female Gordon-7317
Q76164238 Janet Gordon (Peerage person ID=574533) 1519 female
Q76198180 Alexander Seton of Meldrum, younger (Peerage person ID=597996) 1562 1595 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 27.02.2021 03:11:45 False suggestion Completely different people
Keith-2533
H
Compare Elizabeth Keith Lady Drum (Keith) aka Irvine Wikitree Mother after 1379 Scotland uncertain 1456 uncertain Drum, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Irving-332
Forbes-124
H
Elizabeth Forbes Lady Irvine (Forbes) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1430 uncertain Forbes, Aberdeenshire, Scotland uncertain 1497 uncertain Scotland Female Urquhart-93
Q75935695 Agnes Irvine (Peerage person ID=413655) 1420 1450 female
Q75982709 Elizabeth Forbes (Peerage person ID=447446) 1430 1497 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 13.09.2020 01:10:25 False suggestion wikidata not sourced
Forrester-410
H
Compare Elizabeth Menzies (Forrester) aka Carden Forrester Wikitree Mother certain 1570 certain Carden, Alves, Aberdeenshire, Scotland certain 11 Nov 1613 certain Scotland Female Howard-18870
Campbell-20730
H
Marjory Lady Weem Menzies (Campbell) Wikidata Mother after 1579 certain Brechin, Forfarshire, Scotland uncertain 1640 certain Perthshire, Scotland Female Hare-1576
Q76309680 Helen Menzies (Peerage person ID=679010) 1604 female
Q76309841 Marjory Campbell (Peerage person ID=679110) 1640 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Howard-18870 22.02.2024 23:28:07 False suggestion
Seton-88
H
Compare Elizabeth Seton Lady Saltoun (Seton) aka Urquhart Fraser Wikitree Mother uncertain 1592 certain Oldmeldrum, Aberdeenshire, Scotland not living certain Aberdeenshire, Scotland Female Urquhart-93
Forbes-2216
H
Isabel Fraser (Forbes) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1612 Scotland before 1634 Scotland Female Browne-2174
Q75275362 Alexander Fraser, Master of Saltoun (Peerage person ID=30835) 1630 Nov 1682 male
Q76159334 Isabel Forbes (Peerage person ID=571276) 1612 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 13.05.2021 06:53:05 Not corrected unsourced, not correct connection
Urquhart-93 14.07.2021 03:33:10 False suggestion Completely different people. Seton-88 is his mother.
Troup-261
H
Compare Heiress of Troup (Troup) Wikitree Mother 1363 Troup, Banffshire, Scotland 1442 Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Hamilton-1712
H
Mary Keith (Hamilton) Wikidata Mother before 1402 Cadzow, Lanarkshire, Scotland 1442 Female Hamilton-4105

Wright-7062
Q75778457 Mary Hamilton (Peerage person ID=329404) 1442 female
Q76037912 Elizabeth Keith (Peerage person ID=485892) 1456 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kinman-87 31.03.2020 21:46:31 False suggestion Completely different people
Low-2498
H
Compare Helen Nora Wilson Lorna Moon Moon (Low) aka Hebditch Wikitree Mother certain 16 Jun 1886 Strichen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland uncertain 1 May 1930 Albuquerque, New Mexico, United States Female Orphan
Adams-28344
H
Constance DeMille (Adams) Wikidata Mother 27 Apr 1874 East Orange, New Jersey, United States 17 Jul 1960 Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, United States Female Smith-165384
Q5163494 Constance Adams DeMille (American actress (1874-1960)) 27 Apr 1874 Orange United States of America 17 Jul 1960 Los Angeles United States of America female
Q7330198 Richard de Mille (American author) 12 Feb 1922 Monrovia United States of America 8 Apr 2009 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ebert-456 05.06.2021 13:29:14 Not corrected One is biological mother; the other is the adoptive mother.
Ebert-456 05.02.2022 18:45:05 False suggestion One is biological mother; the other is the adoptive mother.
Sempill-179
H
Compare Isabel Sempill Wikitree Mother uncertain 1485 certain Scotland uncertain 1509 uncertain Kilbirnie, Ayrshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Sempill-20
H
Margaret Sempill Wikidata Mother before 1471 certain Scotland after 18 Feb 1507 uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Q75507974 Laurence Crawfurd of Kilbirnie (Peerage person ID=183796) 4 Jun 1547 male
Q75764175 Margaret Sempill (Peerage person ID=321961) female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 02.11.2021 23:34:09 False suggestion Possibly conflated WT profile for father
Sutherland-306
H
Compare Isabel Sutherland Lady Kilravock (Sutherland) Wikitree Mother 1452 uncertain 1485 Scotland Female Sutherland-Fisher-1
Gordon-857
H
Margaret Rose (Gordon) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1450 Huntly, Aberdeenshire, Scotland uncertain 1506 Scotland Female Orphan
Q75778473 Margaret Gordon (Peerage person ID=329413) 1450 1506 female
Q75921987 Hugh Rose, 9th of Kilravock ((1475-1544)) 1475 1544 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Sutherland-Fisher-1 28.06.2023 19:10:03 False suggestion
Falconer-164
H
Compare Jean Falconer Wikitree Mother uncertain 1479 Kincardineshire, , Scotland certain 15 Oct 1584 Female Orphan
Sutherland-1973
H
Isobel Sutherland Lady Westfield (Sutherland) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1430 Duffus, Moray, Scotland 11 Nov 1505 Scotland Female Cochoit-2
Q75902180 Isobel Sutherland (Peerage person ID=392407) 1430 11 Nov 1505 female
Q75747269 Margaret Dunbar (Peerage person ID=313704) 1500 13 Apr 1552 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Everett-1730 18.06.2020 21:28:12 False suggestion Different generations
Stewart-968
H
Compare Lady Jean Johanna Stewart Lady of Glamis (Stewart) aka Keith, Lyon, Sandilands Wikitree Mother uncertain 1350 Dundonald, Ayrshire, Scotland uncertain 1404 certain Scotland Female WikiTree-36

WikiTree-65
Fraser-71
H
Margaret Fraser Lady Marischal (Fraser) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1326 uncertain Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75388152 Margaret Fraser (Peerage person ID=107993) 1337 female
Q75778451 Elizabeth Keith (Peerage person ID=329401) 1361 1436 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 29.04.2020 19:08:52 False suggestion different wives of same man - mother of Keith-230 is Stewart-968
Stewart-7750
H
Compare Jean Stewart Lady Arbuthnot (Stewart) Wikitree Mother uncertain 1489 Scotland uncertain 19 Apr 1522 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Stewart-1627
H
Jean Stewart Wikidata Mother uncertain 1509 uncertain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland not living uncertain Female Thompson-9881
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q87780196 Isabel Arbuthnott ((Abt 1515-1558)) 1515 1558 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 19.03.2024 10:58:34 False suggestion False suggestion
Stewart-7750
H
Compare Jean Stewart Lady Arbuthnot (Stewart) Wikitree Mother uncertain 1489 Scotland uncertain 19 Apr 1522 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Stewart-36487
H
Jean Arbuthnott (Stewart) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1505 Female Smith-165384
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q87780196 Isabel Arbuthnott ((Abt 1515-1558)) 1515 1558 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 19.03.2024 10:58:57 False suggestion False
Stewart-7750
H
Compare Jean Stewart Lady Arbuthnot (Stewart) Wikitree Mother uncertain 1489 Scotland uncertain 19 Apr 1522 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Stewart-36487
H
Jean Arbuthnott (Stewart) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1505 Female Smith-165384
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257522 Robert Arbuthnott of that Ilk (Peerage person ID=16912) 1508 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 19.03.2024 10:58:57 False suggestion False
Stewart-7750
H
Compare Jean Stewart Lady Arbuthnot (Stewart) Wikitree Mother uncertain 1489 Scotland uncertain 19 Apr 1522 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Stewart-1627
H
Jean Stewart Wikidata Mother uncertain 1509 uncertain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland not living uncertain Female Thompson-9881
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257559 Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948) 1479 19 Apr 1522 female
Q75257522 Robert Arbuthnott of that Ilk (Peerage person ID=16912) 1508 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 19.03.2024 10:58:34 False suggestion False suggestion
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Dunbar-1669
H
Compare Margaret Dunbar Wikitree Mother uncertain 1460 certain Scotland certain 1483 Female Orphan
Stewart-3691
H
Janet Dunbar (Stewart) Wikidata Mother 1460 Garlies, Galloway, Scotland 1530 Mochrum, Wigtownshire, Scotland Female Shelton-1487
Q75811636 unknown Dunbar (Peerage person ID=343965) 1480 1513 male
Q75715052 Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=299352) 1460 1530 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelton-1487 30.01.2024 20:31:01 False suggestion
Forrester-1420
H
Compare Margaret Forrester Wikitree Mother uncertain 1520 certain Scotland after 22 Jan 1580 uncertain Scotland Female Short-3582

WikiTree-36
Bruce-407
H
Allison Colville (Bruce) Wikidata Mother 1506 Clackmannanshire, Scotland before 21 May 1536 Scotland Female Cohen-96
Q75615010 Alison Bruce (Peerage person ID=246260) 1506 female
Q18526377 Alexander Colville (Scottish judge) 1536 1597 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 03.10.2023 10:32:12 False suggestion Completely different people
Wallace-770
H
Compare Margaret Wallace Wikitree Mother before 18 Dec 1544 certain Kyle, Ayrshire, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Simpkinson-1
Wallace-7443
H
Margaret Wallace Wikidata Mother before 29 Dec 1537 uncertain Craigie, Ayrshire, Scotland before 1538 uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Q75553591 Margaret Wallace (Peerage person ID=209510) female
Q75553594 Alan Cathcart, Master of Cathcart ((1562-1602)) 1562 15 May 1602 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 02.02.2021 20:07:07 False suggestion Completely different people
Oliphant-411
H
Compare Mariot Graham (Oliphant) Wikitree Mother uncertain 1372 Aberdalgy, Scotland before 1404 Scotland Female Orphan
Stewart-6424
H
Egidia Giles Stewart Wikidata Mother 1358 Scotland Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75243150 Gille Stewart (Peerage person ID=5151) female
Q75388492 Alexander Graham (Peerage person ID=108233) male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stevens-17832 01.01.2022 17:11:11 False suggestion
Forbes-1252
H
Compare Mary Forbes Wikitree Mother before 1691 Pitsligo Aberdeenshire Scotland certain 1741 Pitsligo Aberdeenshire Scotland Female Orphan
Forbes-3727
H
Mary Forbes Wikidata Mother uncertain 1685 Female Shand-287
Q75517329 Mary Forbes (Peerage person ID=189310) 1685 female
Q16212261 James Forbes, 17th Lord Forbes (British politician) 29 Jul 1804 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Graham-2838 11.06.2021 15:43:58 False suggestion Wikidata match is not the correct person
Erskine-461
H
Compare Mary Oliphant (Erskine) Wikitree Mother 1328 Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland 1356 Renfrewshire, Scotland Female Lauder-Frost-1
Bruce-265
H
Princess Elizabeth de Brus (Bruce) aka Oliphant Wikidata Mother uncertain 1317 Scotland uncertain 1364 certain Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Shelton-1487
Q22119552 Elizabeth Bruce (daughter of Robert I of Scotland) 1317 Scotland United Kingdom 1364 female
Q75759666 Sir John Oliphant of Aberdalgie (Peerage person ID=319799) 1360 1420 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Shelton-1487 01.08.2020 18:40:54 Corrected Adjusted birth date
Madison-125 11.05.2023 02:46:35 False suggestion both are estimates
Menzies-641
H
Compare Lady Susanna Susan Campbell (Menzies) Wikitree Mother uncertain 1654 uncertain Weem, Perthshire, Scotland before 1717 uncertain Argyll, Scotland Female Green-16402

Hughey-105
Kerr-3929
H
Vere Campbell (Kerr) Wikidata Mother certain 24 Apr 1649 certain Newbattle, Midlothian, Scotland certain 17 Apr 1674 certain Scotland Female Orphan
Q76258893 Anna Campbell (Peerage person ID=643312) 1676 1760 female
Q75254939 Lady Vere Kerr ((1649-1674)) 24 Apr 1649 17 Apr 1674 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jones-43207 08.09.2020 20:52:30 False suggestion WikiTree profiles connected appropriately
Unknown-561034
H
Compare Unknown de Comyn (Unknown) Wikitree Mother before 1214 Scotland Female Stevens-17832
FitzHugh-498
H
Sarah Comyn (FitzHugh) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1167 Altyre, Elginshire, Scotland 1204 Badenoch, Inverness-shire, Scotland Female Stewart-6071

WikiTree-65
Q75242575 Joan Comyn (Peerage person ID=4671) 1274 female
Q61494032 Sarah FitzHugh (Peerage person ID=4674) 1167 1204 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 27.06.2021 00:34:50 False suggestion unsourced, see Research Notes in Comyn-4
Unknown-561034
H
Compare Unknown de Comyn (Unknown) Wikitree Mother before 1214 Scotland Female Stevens-17832
FitzHugh-498
H
Sarah Comyn (FitzHugh) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1167 Altyre, Elginshire, Scotland 1204 Badenoch, Inverness-shire, Scotland Female Stewart-6071

WikiTree-65
Q2543918 Walter Comyn, Lord of Badenoch (Scottish noble (died 1258)) 12000101 Dec 1258 male
Q61494032 Sarah FitzHugh (Peerage person ID=4674) 1167 1204 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 27.06.2021 00:34:50 False suggestion unsourced, see Research Notes in Comyn-4
Unknown-561034
H
Compare Unknown de Comyn (Unknown) Wikitree Mother before 1214 Scotland Female Stevens-17832
FitzHugh-498
H
Sarah Comyn (FitzHugh) Wikidata Mother uncertain 1167 Altyre, Elginshire, Scotland 1204 Badenoch, Inverness-shire, Scotland Female Stewart-6071

WikiTree-65
Q61495089 Richard Comyn (Peerage person ID=186980) 1190 male
Q61494032 Sarah FitzHugh (Peerage person ID=4674) 1167 1204 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 27.06.2021 00:34:50 False suggestion unsourced, see Research Notes in Comyn-4