Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Warning 566: Wikidata - Possible mother Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Douglas-1895
H
Agnes Hamilton (Douglas) Child uncertain not living Female Hamilton-4105
Boswell-605
H
Elizabeth Boswell Lady Lochleven (Boswell) aka Douglas Possible Mother uncertain 1429 certain Scotland before 1479 certain Scotland Female Boswell-455

Urquhart-93
Q76193178 Agnes Douglas (Peerage person ID=594655) female
Q76193117 Elizabeth Boswell (Peerage person ID=594608) 1429 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 13.09.2020 01:02:53 False suggestion peerage data not sourced
Menteith-8
H
Alan 3rd Earl of Menteith Menteith Child uncertain 1270 Menteith, Perthshire, Scotland before 13 Mar 1309 Male WikiTree-65
Strathearn-54
H
Matilda Maud Strathearn Countess of Menteith (Strathearn) Possible Mother before 1245 Scotland not living Scotland Female Athey-67
Q68104787 Matilda of Strathearn (1245) female
Q4706028 Alan, Earl of Menteith (British aristocrat) 13cen 1300s male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 26.11.2022 05:06:35 False suggestion Mother Matilda is not sourced, possibly should be unknown
Sitricsson-3
H
Amlaíb Cuarán Olaf Sigtryggsson (Sitricsson) Child uncertain 920 England 981 Iona, Inner Hebrides, Argyle and Bute, Scotland Male Devlin-670
Wessex-1
H
St Edith Eadgyth, Orgive, St Edith of Polesworth, St Edith of Tamworth Wessex Possible Mother 895 Wessex 937 Female WikiTree-113

Cayley-55

Day-1904
Q259114 Amlaíb Cuarán (10th century Norse king of Northumbria and Dublin) 10cen York United Kingdom 981 Dublin Republic of Ireland male
Q2162436 Edith of Polesworth (Anglo-Saxon abbess) 8cen 960s female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 23.04.2021 10:08:51 False suggestion Wrong
Monteith-392
H
Anne Dundas (Monteith) Child uncertain 1570 uncertain 1650 Female Stratman-17
Bruce-755
H
Marion Bruce Lady Kerse (Bruce) aka Menteith Possible Mother uncertain 1560 certain Airth, Stirlingshire, Scotland uncertain 1650 certain Airth, Stirlingshire, Scotland Female Cunningham-14348

Urquhart-93
Q76293079 Marion Bruce (Peerage person ID=668355) 1560 1650 female
Q75902943 Anne Monteith (Peerage person ID=392891) 1570 1650 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 01.04.2020 00:02:09 False suggestion
Mure-8
H
Sir Archibald Mure IInd of Rowallan (Mure) Child uncertain 1231 Rowallan Castle, Kilmarnock, Ayrshire, Scotland 30 Mar 1296 Berwickshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Russell-4691
H
Isabella Hastings (Russell) aka Comyn Possible Mother uncertain 1259 England after 1306 Female Stevens-17832

WikiTree-65
Q75242567 Sir Archibald Mure of Rowallan (Peerage person ID=4661) 1231 1289 male
Q75242569 Isabel Comyn (Peerage person ID=4663) female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stevens-17832 09.01.2022 23:15:17 False suggestion
Unknown-590596
H
Beatrix Leslie (Unknown) Child uncertain 1040 Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland 1121 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Gray-14994
Unknown-275536
H
Sybilla Suthen Sybil, Bjornsdatter, Siwardsdatter Dunkeld (Unknown) aka FitzSiward Possible Mother uncertain 1010 uncertain Northumbria, England 1050 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Fields-574
Q56285208 Suthen (Peerage person ID=102880) female
Q76320892 Beatrix (?) (Peerage person ID=687072) 1030 1121 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Perkins-11750 06.08.2022 16:25:26 False suggestion
Sigurdsson-106
H
Brúsi Bruse Jarl of Orkney Sigurdsson aka Sigurðarson Child uncertain 980 uncertain Orkney Islands, Norway before 1035 uncertain Orkney Islands, Norway Male WikiTree-97
MacAlpin-13
H
Unknown MacAlpin Possible Mother uncertain 979 Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland Orkney Islands, Orkney, Scotland Female Perkins-11750

WikiTree-65
Q16726148 Olith (970-1034) 25 Nov 1034 female
Q2927059 Brusi Sigurdsson (Norwegian Earl of Orkney) 980 Orkney Islands United Kingdom 1030 Orkney Islands United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Andersson-4409 30.11.2021 14:33:17 False suggestion
Andersson-4409 30.11.2021 14:47:03 False suggestion No sources at all for these suggested mothers
Graham-3647
H
David Graham Child after 1368 Male WikiTree-65
Stewart-6424
H
Egidia Giles Stewart Possible Mother 1358 Scotland Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q76132519 Eupheme Stewart (Peerage person ID=547615) female
Q76113329 David Graham (Peerage person ID=540153) male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stevens-17832 01.01.2022 17:11:09 False suggestion
Sigurdsson-131
H
Einar Vrangmunn Wrymouth, Rangmund, co-Jarl of Orkney Sigurdsson Child uncertain 989 Orkney Islands, Scotland uncertain 1020 Sandvik, Orkney Islands, Scotland Male WikiTree-97
MacAlpin-13
H
Unknown MacAlpin Possible Mother uncertain 979 Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland Orkney Islands, Orkney, Scotland Female Perkins-11750

WikiTree-65
Q3049450 Einar Sigurdsson (Norwegian Earl of Orkney) 989 Orkney Islands United Kingdom 1020 Orkney Islands United Kingdom male
Q16726148 Olith (970-1034) 25 Nov 1034 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Andersson-4409 30.11.2021 14:47:02 False suggestion No sources at all for these suggested mothers
Hepburn-1670
H
Elizabeth Hepburn Child before 1512 Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Stewart-589
H
Lady Agnes Stewart Dowager Countess of Bothwell (Stewart) aka Home Maxwell Ramsay Possible Mother uncertain 1469 certain Traquhair, Peeblesshire, Scotland certain 20 Feb 1557 certain Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q76301081 Elizabeth Hepburn (Peerage person ID=673479) female
Q6469914 Agnes Stewart (Scottish noble) Feb 1557 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 29.04.2021 04:08:58 False suggestion peerage data not sourced
Haldane-406
H
Elizabeth Nisbet (Haldane) Child uncertain 1560 Female Tennant-1217
Lundin-76
H
Lady Elizabeth Haldane (Lundin) Possible Mother certain 17 Aug 1534 Lundin, Fife, Scotland certain 27 Aug 1584 Gleneagles, Scotland Female Wiegand-310
Q75740954 Elizabeth Haldane (Peerage person ID=310840) 1555 female
Q75740921 Elizabeth Lundie (Peerage person ID=310826) 17 Aug 1534 27 Aug 1584 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
tennant-1217 16.08.2023 05:20:06 False suggestion Wikidata is Unsourced
Somerville-165
H
Elizabeth Somerville Child uncertain 1511 Female Gleason Gleeson-1
Carmichael-133
H
Elizabeth Cambusnethan (Carmichael) aka Somerville Possible Mother 1473 Balmedie, Lanarkshire, Scotland 1540 Scotland Female Shelton-1487
Q75388612 Elizabeth Carmichael (Mistress of James V, king of Scotland) female
Q76367001 Elizabeth Somerville (Peerage person ID=714729) 1511 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 10.08.2023 03:25:10 False suggestion Wikidata is Unsourced
Unknown-291870
H
Ellen Ferrers (Unknown) Child after Jan 1317 Female Orphan
Strathearn-54
H
Matilda Maud Strathearn Countess of Menteith (Strathearn) Possible Mother before 1245 Scotland not living Scotland Female Athey-67
Q68104787 Matilda of Strathearn (1245) female
Q68104471 Ellen, lady Ferrers (1317) female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 26.11.2022 05:09:28 False suggestion comments on Unknown-291870 explain that there is no proof of Matilda being mother
Kennedy-2017
H
Helen Kennedy Child 1545 Dailly, Ayrshire, Scotland before 1568 Female Cunniffe-1
Stewart-3518
H
Lady Janet Stewart Lady Ruthven (Stewart) Possible Mother 1505 Athol, Perth, Scotland 13 May 1566 Dunrobin, Sutherland, Scotland Female Macintosh-96
Q61466995 Janet Stewart (Scottish aristocrat) female
Q76322189 Helen Kennedy (Peerage person ID=688102) 1545 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 13.09.2020 01:06:20 False suggestion peerage data not sourced
Graham-8885
H
Isabella Graham Child before 1447 certain Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Douglas-742
H
Helen Elene Douglas Lady Graham (Douglas) Possible Mother uncertain 1436 certain Scotland after 20 Nov 1486 uncertain Scotland Female WikiTree-36
Q75389894 Elene Douglas (Peerage person ID=109612) 1435 1490 female
Q76112863 Isabella Graham (Peerage person ID=539815) 1443 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 21.11.2023 13:45:45 False suggestion WikiTree has them connected appropriately
Hay-840
H
Jane Agnew (Hay) Child uncertain 1630 Lochnaw, Wigtownshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Hamilton-7017
H
Jean Hay (Hamilton) Possible Mother uncertain 1616 Scotland Female Orphan
Q75405167 Jane Hay (Peerage person ID=121325) 1630 female
Q75406265 Jean Hamilton (Peerage person ID=121976) 1616 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thiessen-117 10.10.2020 23:45:42 False suggestion parents are correct as is
Innes-924
H
Janet Innes Lady Hallhead (Innes) Child certain 1547 Scotland after 1574 Hallhead, Aberdeen Scotland Female Parker-6645
Urquhart-156
H
Agnes Urquhart Lady Touch (Urquhart) aka Innes Possible Mother uncertain 1516 certain Cromarty, Cromartyshire, Scotland not living certain Scotland Female Urquhart-93
Q75913876 Janet Innes (Peerage person ID=399962) 1547 female
Q75933741 Agnes Urquhart (Peerage person ID=412292) 1516 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 13.09.2020 01:11:23 False suggestion wikidata not sourced
Cranstoun-7
H
Janet Seton (Cranstoun) Child 1555 Female Wiegand-310
Cranstoun-15
H
Lady Sarah Cranstoun Possible Mother uncertain 1562 certain Crailing, Roxburghshire, Scotland certain 11 Mar 1619 certain Scotland Female Orphan
Q76164003 Janet Cranstoun (Peerage person ID=574364) 1555 female
Q76316092 Sarah Cranstoun (Peerage person ID=683301) 1562 11 Mar 1619 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stokes-6649 17.05.2022 06:35:52 False suggestion
Gordon-5517
H
Sir John Gordon Child 1382 certain 1407 Male Orphan
Keith-230
H
Lady Elizabeth Somerville (Keith) aka Gordon, Aboyne Possible Mother 1361 Dunnottar, Kincardineshire, Scotland uncertain 1436 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Q75778462 John Gordon (Peerage person ID=329406) 1382 1407 male
Q75778451 Elizabeth Keith (Peerage person ID=329401) 1361 1436 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
thiessen-117 04.07.2021 20:36:26 False suggestion parents are connected properly
MacGregor-143
H
John MacGregor Child 1763 18 Aug 1847 Newington, Kent, England Male Orphan
MacNiven-4
H
Beatrix MacNiven Possible Mother uncertain 1720 Scotland Female Orphan
Q76062313 Beatrix MacNiven (Peerage person ID=504161) 1720 female
Q76267568 John MacGregor ((died 1847)) 1763 18 Aug 1847 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
x-8644 27.02.2020 16:25:28 False suggestion Not related
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Campbell-11970
H
Katherine Campbell aka Jenkinson Child uncertain 1780 Shawfield, Rutherglen, Lanarkshire, Scotland 14 Feb 1855 Hawksbury, Gloucestershire, England Female Orphan
Kerr-889
H
Eleonora Kerr Possible Mother before 17 Jan 1745 certain Irvine, Ayrshire, Scotland 4 Jul 1785 Female Orphan
Q76104728 Eleanora Kerr ((died 1785)) 4 Jul 1785 female
Q75939594 Katherine Campbell (Peerage person ID=416323) 1780 14 Feb 1855 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-5769 21.01.2020 01:21:59 False suggestion not dealing with that, not my relative.
Stewart-2107
H
Margaret Elinor Stewart Child 1370 Scotland Female Orphan
MacDougall-301
H
Isabel Stewart (MacDougall) aka of Lorn, de Ergadia Possible Mother uncertain 1364 uncertain Argyll, Scotland certain 21 Dec 1439 uncertain Scotland Female WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Q75853883 unknown daughter Stewart (Peerage person ID=357051) 1370 female
Q75268350 Isabella Macdougall (Peerage person ID=24962) 21 Dec 1439 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 27.03.2020 15:10:41 False suggestion Ridiculous!
Stewart-7399
H
Margaret Stewart Lady Glenorchy (Stewart) aka Graham Child uncertain 1510 Moray, Scotland after Scotland Female Whitaker-808
Stewart-2306
H
Margaret Lady Gordon Drummond (Stewart) Possible Mother uncertain 1497 certain Scotland after 1562 Scotland Female Douglass-990
Q75388569 Margaret Stewart (born c. 1510) 1510 female
Q16747640 Margaret Stewart (1498-) 1498 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lenover-1 23.07.2021 23:28:06 Comment There are two siblings named Margaret. The relationship is correct
Lenover-1 23.07.2021 23:28:13 False suggestion There are two siblings named Margaret. The relationship is correct
Dalzell-133
H
Mary Erskine (Dalzell) Child uncertain 1647 Scotland after 1677 Scotland Female Orphan
Nisbet-572
H
Agnes Dalzell (Nisbet) Possible Mother uncertain 1601 Scotland Scotland Female Tennant-1217
Q75552361 Mary Dalzell (Peerage person ID=208854) 1647 female
Q75552325 Agnes Nisbet (Peerage person ID=208832) 1601 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Tennant-1217 13.10.2020 19:55:37 False suggestion Nisbet-1189
Edmonstone-16
H
Mary Isabell Cunningham (Edmonstone) Child before 1462 certain Duntreath, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Stewart-1638
H
Mary Marion Stewart Countess Angus (Stewart) Possible Mother before 1381 Scotland after 20 Mar 1458 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Q75385107 Lady Mary Stewart ((abt. 1380-1457); daughter of Robert III of Scotland and Anabella Drummond) 1458 female
Q76141948 Mary Edmondstone (Peerage person ID=560348) 1460 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cooke-7654 23.09.2023 12:56:00 False suggestion
Kennedy-7202
H
Mary Kennedy Child 1400 Scotland Female Orphan
Stewart-1638
H
Mary Marion Stewart Countess Angus (Stewart) Possible Mother before 1381 Scotland after 20 Mar 1458 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Q75508698 Mary Kennedy (Peerage person ID=184222) 1400 female
Q75385107 Lady Mary Stewart ((abt. 1380-1457); daughter of Robert III of Scotland and Anabella Drummond) 1458 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 14.11.2023 10:18:08 False suggestion peerage data not sourced
Campbell-7015
H
Capt. Matthew Campbell VIth of Skipness (Campbell) Child after 1645 certain Skipness, Argyll, Scotland before 1670 uncertain Scotland Male Snow-1857
Campbell-44766
H
Jean Campbell Possible Mother after 1552 certain Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Baker-24987
Q76104736 Jane Campbell (Peerage person ID=533912) female
Q76104742 Matthew Campbell, 4th of Skipness (Peerage person ID=533917) male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 16.02.2022 02:49:49 False suggestion
Crichton-236
H
Robert Crichton Eighth Lord Crichton of Sanquhar (Crichton) Child uncertain 1568 certain Scotland certain 29 Jun 1612 certain Westminster Gate, London, England Male Baker-29071
Douglas-5669
H
Margaret Countess of Menteith Douglas Possible Mother 1538 Female Baker-57185
Q75266499 Margaret Douglas (Peerage person ID=23484) 1538 female
Q7343192 Robert Crichton, 8th Lord Crichton of Sanquhar (Scottish peer executed for murder) 1568 29 Jun 1612 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Baker-29071 29.12.2021 19:29:41 False suggestion
Sinclair-4074
H
Sir Robert Sinclair 5th Bt Child 1754 Male Orphan
Lockhart-6062
H
Martha Lockhart Lady Castlehill (Lockhart) Possible Mother after 1666 certain Scotland certain 15 May 1752 certain Stevenson, Haddington, Haddingtonshire, Scotland Female Boenisch-2

Turpy-1
Q76168737 Sir Robert Sinclair of Stevenson, 5th Bt. ((died 1754)) 1754 male
Q76168735 Martha Lockhart ((died 1752)) 15 May 1752 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Turpy-1 10.11.2023 11:22:02 False suggestion Mother exact style is uncertain.
Unknown-275536
H
Sybilla Suthen Sybil, Bjornsdatter, Siwardsdatter Dunkeld (Unknown) aka FitzSiward Child uncertain 1010 uncertain Northumbria, England 1050 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Fields-574
Bernicia-22
H
Ælfflæd Elfleda of Northumbria (Bernicia) Possible Mother uncertain 1010 1060 Northumbria, England Female Orphan
Q56285208 Suthen (Peerage person ID=102880) female
Q21155612 Ælfflæd (wife of Siward, Earl of Northumbria) female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Perkins-11750 06.08.2022 16:24:41 False suggestion
Stewart-16156
H
Unknown Stewart Child uncertain 1380 Innermeath, Perthshire, Scotland Female Orphan
MacDougall-301
H
Isabel Stewart (MacDougall) aka of Lorn, de Ergadia Possible Mother uncertain 1364 uncertain Argyll, Scotland certain 21 Dec 1439 uncertain Scotland Female WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Q75268350 Isabella Macdougall (Peerage person ID=24962) 21 Dec 1439 female
Q76060808 unknown daughter Stewart (Peerage person ID=503054) 1380 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 15.01.2020 05:48:37 False suggestion insufficient evidence to attached unnamed Steward as child of Isabel
Clephane-11
H
Lt-Col William Clephane Child uncertain 1643 Cupar, Fife, Scotland 1727 the Netherlands Male Croll-284
Duncan-10905
H
Mariotte Clephane (Duncan) Possible Mother uncertain 1616 uncertain Scotland uncertain 1676 uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Q76302004 Mariotte Duncan (Peerage person ID=674135) female
Q76144596 William Clephane (Peerage person ID=562128) 1646 1727 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 15.03.2022 13:37:12 Not corrected Tartan Trail profile, please leave for 'hiker' to fix
Madison-125 15.03.2022 13:38:02 Not corrected Tartan Trail, please leave for 'hiker' to fix
Madison-125 22.05.2022 05:40:55 False suggestion parents not proven by sources given in Wikidata
Lindsay-2243
H
William Lindsay Ist of Craigie (Lindsay) Child certain 1205 Luffness, Aberlady, East Lothian, Scotland uncertain 1247 certain Craigie Castle, Scotland Male Nilsen-785
Lancaster-2220
H
Avice Lindsay (Lancaster) Possible Mother uncertain 1187 England after 1205 Scotland Female Orphan
Q76308448 Avice de Lancaster (Peerage person ID=678175) 1187 female
Q75591899 William de Lindsay (Peerage person ID=231150) 1205 1247 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Nilsen-785 11.11.2023 16:38:17 False suggestion
Menteith-121
H
Sir William Menteith aka of Kerse Child uncertain 1376 Kerse, Stirlingshire, Scotland after 1446 Kerse, Stirlingshire, Scotland Male Orphan 1418 - 1446 Scotland
Livingston-638
H
Helen Menteith (Livingston) Possible Mother 1400 Stirlingshire, Scotland after 1446 Kerse, Stirlingshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Q75510369 Helen Livingston ((1400 - aft. 1446)) 1400 female
Q76325209 William Menteith of Kerse and Alva (Peerage person ID=689884) 1376 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 13.05.2020 02:55:19 False suggestion WikiTree has them connected appropriately
Carnegie-80
H
Lady Alexandra C. Etherington (Carnegie) Child certain 1950s living Female WikiTree-11
Dewar-775
H
Hon. Caroline Cecily Worsley (Dewar) aka Carnegie Possible Mother certain 12 Feb 1934 Bardowie Castle, Milngavie, Dunbartonshire, Scotland not living Female Hare-1576
Q5044946 Caroline Worsley, Lady Worsley (British noble; daughter of Henry Dewar, 3rd Baron Forteviot; ex-wife of James Carnegie, 3rd Duke of Fife) 12 Feb 1934 1934 Milngavie United Kingdom female
Q6469918 Alexandra Etherington (British noble; daughter of James Carnegie, 3rd Duke of Fife, and Caroline, Lady Worsley) 20 Jun 1959 London United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Trtnik-2 24.07.2021 02:26:14 Merge proposed Merge proposed
Hare-1576 02.11.2021 20:06:16 Corrected Merger removed
Hare-1576 14.11.2021 21:30:00 Comment unresponsive profile manager
Hare-1576 11.12.2021 17:56:07 Comment unresponsive profile manager
Hare-1576 11.12.2021 17:57:13 Merge proposed Unresponsive Profile Manager
Hare-1576 08.03.2022 15:01:42 Corrected Manager notified
Hare-1576 19.03.2022 18:58:18 False suggestion unresponsive profile manager
Carnegie-81
H
David C. Carnegie Child certain 1960s living Male WikiTree-11
Dewar-775
H
Hon. Caroline Cecily Worsley (Dewar) aka Carnegie Possible Mother certain 12 Feb 1934 Bardowie Castle, Milngavie, Dunbartonshire, Scotland not living Female Hare-1576
Q5044946 Caroline Worsley, Lady Worsley (British noble; daughter of Henry Dewar, 3rd Baron Forteviot; ex-wife of James Carnegie, 3rd Duke of Fife) 12 Feb 1934 1934 Milngavie United Kingdom female
Q5232170 David Carnegie, 4th Duke of Fife (Scottish duke) 3 Mar 1961 Marylebone United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hare-1576 31.07.2021 13:37:17 False suggestion Already added