Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Hint 542: WikiData - Possible Father on WikiData Help (Difficulty: Advanced)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Melvill-78
H 		Sir James Cosmo Melvill KCB FRS Child 8 Jun 1792 England 23 Jul 1861 England Male Orphan
Melvill-115
H 		Capt Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1760 Dunbar, Haddingtonshire, Scotland 27 Oct 1811 Cornwall, England, United Kingdom Male Cranston-623
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 1 Jan 1762 , 1 Jan 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1762 , 1 Jan 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1762 , 27 Oct 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 1 Jan 1762 , 27 Oct 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1762 , 1 Jan 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1762 , 27 Oct 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1762 , 27 Oct 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 1 Jan 1762 , 1 Jan 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 1 Jan 1762 , 27 Oct 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 1 Jan 1762 , 1 Jan 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1762 , 1 Jan 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1762 , 27 Oct 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1762 , 1 Jan 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 1 Jan 1762 , 1 Jan 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1762 , 1 Jan 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 1 Jan 1762 , 1 Jan 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 7 Apr 1762 , 27 Oct 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 1 Jan 1762 , 27 Oct 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 1 Jan 1762 , 27 Oct 1811 , male
Q15454701 Philip Melvill Father 1 Jan 1762 , 27 Oct 1811 , male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cranston-623 02.09.2020 02:00:56 False suggestion Wikidata wrong
Haliburton-5
H 		Jean Halyburton (Haliburton) Child uncertain 1350 Dirleton, East Lothian, Scotland 1400 Midlothian, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Haliburton-8
H 		Sir John Haliburton aka Halyburton Father before Apr 1356 certain Haliburton, Berwickshire, Scotland after 1402 uncertain Male Orphan
Q75532206 Sir William Halyburton of Dirletoun Father , , male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 09.06.2021 23:35:47 False suggestion Disputed parentage
Stewart-17222
H 		Margaret Gordon (Stewart) Child uncertain 1732 Scotland after 1776 Halleaths, Dumfries Scotland Female Miller-44426
Coltrane-83
H 		John Stewart (Coltrane) Father certain 11 Mar 1703 certain Wigtown, Scotland certain 21 Sep 1745 certain Prestonpans, East Lothian, Scotland Male Coltrane-45

Reckmeyer-6
Q75949318 unknown Stewart Father , , male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Coltrane-45 21.12.2021 13:53:01 False suggestion
Ros-149
H 		Robert de Ros (Ros) aka de Roos Child uncertain 1170 England uncertain 1227 England Male WikiTree-36

Dellinger-332
Ros-76
H 		Everard Baron Wark of Helmsley or Hamlake de Ros (Ros) Father uncertain 1155 Yorkshire, England 1183 Helmsley, North Riding, Yorkshire, England Male Athey-67
Q5416915 Everard de Ros Father 1 Jan 1144 , 1 Jan 1186 , male
Q5416915 Everard de Ros Father 1 Jan 1144 , 1 Jan 1186 , male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 07.03.2020 17:20:39 False suggestion connected appropriately in WIkiTree