Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Dunkeld-32
H
1078 Alexander Alexander I King of Scots (Dunkeld) 1077 Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland 23 Apr 1124 Stirling, Stirlingshire, Scotland Male Perkins-11750

WikiTree-65
Q60843 Alexander I of Scotland (King of the Scots (1078-1124)) 1078 Dunfermline United Kingdom 23 Apr 1124 Stirling Castle United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Perkins-11750 08.07.2022 19:24:49 False suggestion Not signifiant difference
Henderson-1500
H
21 Dec 1567 Anne Henderson uncertain 20 Dec 1567 Fordell, Fife, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Henderson-6191
Q75968537 Anne Henderson (Peerage person ID=437449) 21 Dec 1567 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:24:23 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Kennedy-1517
H
1650 Sir Archibald Kennedy of Culzean (Kennedy) Bt after 1653 Culzean, Ayrshire, Scotland certain 1710 Culzean, Ayrshire, Scotland Male Ross-1334
Q75263889 Sir Archibald Kennedy of Culzean, 1st Bt. (Peerage person ID=21545) 1650 1710 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:25:10 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Leslie-633
H
1638 Catherine Melville (Leslie) uncertain 1640 certain 2 Apr 1713 Melville House, Monimail, Fife, Scotland Female Straiton-4
Q75329703 Catharine Leslie (Peerage person ID=67259) 1638 2 Apr 1713 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:42:51 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Maitland-978
H
26 Dec 1769 Charles of Rankeilour Maitland certain 26 Nov 1769 Newburgh, Fife, Scotland 1820 Male Orphan
Q75280106 Charles Maitland ((1769-1820)) 26 Dec 1769 1820 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hall-53737 15.10.2023 22:33:12 False suggestion wikidata date is baptism date
Clephane-15
H
1638 David Clephane XVIth of Carslogie (Clephane) uncertain 1648 uncertain Scotland uncertain 1717 Scotland Male Orphan
Q76296202 David Clephane of Carslogie (Peerage person ID=670105) 1638 1715 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 17:45:41 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Wemyss-65
H
12 Aug 1721 David Lord Elcho Wemyss 30 Jul 1721 Wemyss, Fife, Scotland 29 Apr 1787 Paris, France Male Orphan
Q5240964 David Wemyss, Lord Elcho (Scottish Earl (1721-1787)) 12 Aug 1721 Wemyss Castle United Kingdom 29 Apr 1787 Paris France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Templeton-1883 22.05.2019 19:05:53 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Pitcairn-142
H
1496 David Twelfth of Pitcairn Pitcairn certain 1505 Fife, Scotland uncertain 10 May 1569 Fife, Scotland Male Babyak-6
Q75904918 David Pitcairn, 12th of Pitcairn (Peerage person ID=394110) 1496 1592 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:25:55 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Dunkeld-79
H
1080 Eadgith Matilda Maud, Edith of Scotland (Dunkeld) aka Caenmor, Canmore, Atheling, Beauclerk uncertain 1079 certain Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland certain 1 May 1118 certain Palace of Westminster, London, England Female WikiTree-113

Athey-67
Q232761 Matilda of Scotland (Queen consort of England) 1080 1080 1080 1080 Dunfermline United Kingdom 1118 1 May 1118 Palace of Westminster United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 18.06.2021 14:58:24 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Melville-31
H
1475 Egidia Gelis Pitcairn (Melville) uncertain 1485 Raith, Fife, Scotland 1535 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Female Orphan
Q76193150 Egidia Melville (Peerage person ID=594632) 1475 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:48:54 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Keith-210
H
Jan 1522 Elizabeth Keith of Inverugie (Keith) aka Forbes uncertain 1514 uncertain Aberdeenshire, Scotland uncertain 13 Nov 1604 uncertain Forbes, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Female Thomas-10705

Carson-514
Q75273925 Elizabeth Keith (Peerage person ID=29748) Jan 1522 13 Nov 1604 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:26:33 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Lundie-11
H
1424 Euphemia Melville (Lundie) uncertain 1465 Balgonie Castle, Glenrothes, Fife, Scotland after 20 Apr 1506 Scotland Female Orphan
Q76303311 Euphemia Lundie (Peerage person ID=675041) 1424 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:58:16 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Pitcairn-10
H
1435 George 9th of Pitcairn Pitcairn uncertain 1428 Pitcairn, Leslie, Fifeshire, Scotland uncertain 1480 Fife, Scotland Male Blair-3347
Q76083789 George Pitcairn, 9th of Pitcairn and Forthar (Peerage person ID=519066) 1435 1479 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 20:51:56 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Henderson-1439
H
1496 George Henderson IInd of Fordell (Henderson) aka Burgess Henrysoun after 1499 Fordell Castle, Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland certain 10 Sep 1547 Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75968495 George Henderson, 2nd of Fordell (Peerage person ID=437418) 1496 10 Sep 1547 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 23:07:31 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Leslie-167
H
1417 George Leslie First Earl of Rothes (Leslie) 2 Sep 1416 Fythkill, now Leslie, Fife, Scotland 24 May 1490 Leslie, Fife, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Straiton-4
Q5541683 George Leslie, 1st Earl of Rothes (Scottish nobleman) 1417 1490 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 28.03.2020 23:10:56 False suggestion
Preston-1455
H
1614 Sir George Preston of Valleyfield (Preston) 1st Bt uncertain 1612 certain Valleyfield, Perthshire, Scotland certain 26 Nov 1679 uncertain Scotland Male Lauder-514
Q75615054 Sir George Preston of Valleyfield, 1st Bt. (Peerage person ID=246291) 1614 26 Nov 1679 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:57:57 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Chisholm-989
H
22 Apr 1822 Henry Chisholm certain 27 Apr 1822 Lochgelly, Fife, Scotland certain 9 May 1881 Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio Male Wilson-20714
Q40629995 Henry Chisholm (American businessman) 22 Apr 1822 Lochgelly United Kingdom 9 May 1881 Cleveland United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Penman-567 16.04.2024 05:13:31 False suggestion
Pitcairn-8
H
1435 Henry Henry of Forthar 10th of Pitcairn Pitcairn uncertain 1443 Pitcairn, Leslie, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1484 Pitcairn, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75266303 Henry Pitcairn, 10th of Pitcairn and Forthar (Peerage person ID=23332) 1435 1484 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:54:36 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Lindsay-319
H
1490 Isabel Lindsay before 1472 uncertain Byres, Haddington, East Lothian, Scotland uncertain 1550 uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Q76041363 Isabel Lindsay (Peerage person ID=488500) 1490 1550 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:59:25 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Craik-71
H
1802 Rev James Craik DD certain 11 Sep 1801 Kennoway, Fife, Scotland certain 20 Aug 1870 Glasgow, Lanark, Scotland Male Orphan
Q45401320 James Craik (Scottish minister) 1802 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Christmas-476 17.09.2023 18:15:38 False suggestion
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Dick-2369
H
21 Dec 1726 Ensign James Dick certain 12 Dec 1726 Cupar, Fife, Scotland certain Oct 1750 Colluthie, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75280113 James Dick ((1726-1750)) 21 Dec 1726 Oct 1750 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hendry-1129 22.09.2023 09:10:36 False suggestion 21 Dec 1726 is christening date, not birth date
Stewart-16656
H
1600 James Steward XIth of Rosyth (Stewart) uncertain 1585 Rosyth, Fife, Scotland certain 1641 Rosyth, Fife, Scotland Male Hancock-3896

Stuart-531
Q76112585 James Steward, 11th of Rosyth (Peerage person ID=539587) 1600 1641 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:28:59 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Beaton-31
H
1486 Janet Countess of Arran Hamilton (Beaton) aka Bethune, Beatoun, Beaton before 1483 Creich, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1522 Bo'ness, West Lothian, Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Wright-7062
Q75382159 Janet Bethune (Peerage person ID=102133) 1486 1522 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 23:00:40 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Durie-218
H
1521 Janet Durie before 8 Jun 1520 certain Dunferline, Fife, Scotland certain 24 Nov 1623 uncertain Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland Female Orphan
Q75904902 Janet Durie (Peerage person ID=394102) 1521 24 Nov 1623 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:09:51 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Skene-27
H
1588 Jean Skene Lady Adross (Skene) before 1583 certain Currie, Midlothian, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Wolfe-522
Q75273746 Jean Skene (Peerage person ID=29594) 1588 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:12:58 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Clare-518
H
1264 Joan Clare aka de Clare 1260 Elmley Castle, Worcestershire, England 1322 Fife, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q15710785 Joan de Clare (Peerage person ID=103030) 1264 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McCallum-662 21.04.2018 19:56:34 Comment Left a comment on the profile.
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:42:53 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Pitcairn-141
H
1517 John 14th of Pitcairn Pitcairn uncertain 1530 Fife, Scotland certain 1593 Fife, Scotland Male Webber-4005

Babyak-6
Q76365856 John Pitcairn, 14th of Pitcairn (Peerage person ID=714083) 1517 1593 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:14:20 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Arnott-81
H
26 Jul 1814 Sir John 1st Baronet Arnott, of Woodlands, Shandon, co. Cork Arnott 1st Bt. certain 26 Jul 1816 certain Auchtermuchty, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom 28 Mar 1898 certain Cork, Ireland Male Arnott-720
Q6219448 John Arnott (British politician) 26 Jul 1814 28 Mar 1898 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Luck-863 08.12.2021 18:53:23 False suggestion
Balfour-89
H
1396 John Balfour of Balgarvey (Balfour) before 1417 certain Burleigh, Kinross-shire, Scotland before 1486 uncertain Balfour, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75330181 Sir John Balfour (Peerage person ID=67615) 1396 1486 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:30:53 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Colville-285
H
1690 Sir John Sixth Lord Colville of Culross (Colville) certain 7 Feb 1688 Pittenweem, Fife, Scotland certain 20 Apr 1741 Cartagena, Murcia, Spain Male Orphan
Q62027561 John Colville, 6th Lord Colville of Culross (M, #246296, b. 1690, d. 20 April 1741) 1690 20 Apr 1741 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Colville-218 22.01.2023 13:22:01 False suggestion
Pitcairn-243
H
1760 Joseph Pitcairn certain 1 Nov 1764 Carnbee, Fife, Scotland certain 19 Jun 1844 49 Broadway, New York, USA Male McClintock-498
Q75850068 Joseph Pitcairn (Peerage person ID=354365) 1760 1831 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:17:19 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Bethune-167
H
7 Jun 1704 Margaret Lindsay (Bethune) certain 17 Jun 1704 certain Cupar, Fife, Scotland certain 23 Dec 1778 certain Wormiston, Fife, Scotland Female Orphan
Q75263509 Margaret Bethune ((1704-1778)) 7 Jun 1704 23 Dec 1778 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Flower-1158 24.06.2020 16:00:15 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Henderson-1650
H
1575 Margaret The Lady of Pittadro Echlin (Henderson) uncertain 1564 Fordell Castle, Fife, Scotland uncertain 5 Dec 1649 certain in the common jail , Tollbooth Prison, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Female Robertson-16141

Henderson-6191
Q75968550 Margaret Henderson (Peerage person ID=437460) 1575 Dec 1649 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:27:45 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
De Pitcarne-4
H
1410 Marion Seton (de Pitcarne) aka Pitcairn uncertain 1425 Fife, Scotland Scotland Female Orphan
Q76350467 Marion Pitcairn (Peerage person ID=706242) 1410 female male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:53:03 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Ramsay-2853
H
1626 Lady Marjory Ramsay Countess Buchan (Ramsay) aka Erskine, Campbell before 27 May 1625 Kirkcaldy, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1661 Scotland Female Orphan
Q75272282 Lady Marjory Ramsay (Peerage person ID=28290) 1626 1661 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:28:30 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Leslie-267
H
1620 Lady Mary Leslie Countess of Eglinton (Leslie) aka Montgomery certain 1 Jan 1618 certain Rothes, Moray, Scotland after 7 Jan 1661 Rothes, Morayshire, Scotland Female Gordon-7317
Q75263727 Lady Mary Leslie (born 1620, Countess Eglinton) 1620 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 16.01.2020 02:01:57 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Bruce-270
H
12 Jul 1303 Matilda Maud Bruce before 16 Oct 1321 uncertain Dunfermine, Fifeshire, Scotland certain 20 Jul 1353 certain Aberdeen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65

WikiTree-36
Q22110529 Maud Bruce (daughter of Robert I of Scotland and Elizabeth de Burgh) 12 Jul 1303 Turnberry Castle United Kingdom 20 Jul 1353 20 Jul 1353 1353 Fearn United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Caykey-55 27.12.2022 12:23:02 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Balfour-88
H
1422 Sir Michael Balfour Ist of Burleigh (Balfour) Kt uncertain 1442 certain Burleigh, Kinross-shire, Scotland after 1496 uncertain Balfour, Fife, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75330180 Michael Balfour (Peerage person ID=67614) 1422 1500 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:54:21 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Menzies-1075
H
16 Aug 1780 Sir Neil Menzies 6th Bt aka of that Ilk certain 16 Aug 1778 certain Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland certain 20 Aug 1844 certain Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Male Cain-4345
Q75280595 Sir Neil Menzies, 6th Baronet ((1780-1844)) 16 Aug 1780 20 Aug 1844 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Howard-18870 29.11.2022 02:04:08 False suggestion
Anstruther-44
H
1666 Sir Philip Anstruther uncertain 1661 certain Anstruther, Fife, Scotland certain 1722 Scotland Male Lowry-3068
Q75279954 Sir Philip Anstruther ((died 1722)) 1666 1722 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lowry-3068 06.12.2023 19:48:21 Corrected
Lowry-3068 06.12.2023 19:48:47 Comment Corrected
Lowry-3068 06.12.2023 19:48:50 Corrected
Lowry-3068 21.12.2023 06:02:04 Corrected Adjusted birth date
Lowry-3068 31.01.2024 23:18:46 False suggestion wikidate is using wikitree as a source....then changing the date.
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Anstruther-39
H
24 Sep 1658 Sir Robert Anstruther of Balcaskie (Anstruther) 1st Bt before 14 Sep 1658 certain Anstruther Easter, Fife, Scotland certain Mar 1737 certain Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Male Jones-43207
Q7528701 Sir Robert Anstruther, 1st Baronet (Scottish politician (1658-1737)) 24 Sep 1658 Mar 1737 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Graham-2838 09.11.2022 17:18:16 False suggestion
Bruce-408
H
1532 Sir Robert Bruce IInd of Blairhall (Bruce) aka Baron of Blairhall and Easter Kennet before 1545 certain Blairhall, Clackmannanshire, Scotland certain Sep 1617 certain Culross, Blairhall, Fife, Scotland Male Jeffrey-2525
Q75654106 Robert Bruce, 2nd of Blairhall (Peerage person ID=274595) 1532 1625 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:43:51 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Henderson-1469
H
1430 Robert Henderson Burgess of Edinburgh (Henderson) aka Henrysone uncertain 1423 Inverkeithing, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1499 certain Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75968485 Robert Henderson (Peerage person ID=437411) 1430 1499 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:42:43 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Aitken-1622
H
14 Apr 1828 Robert Hope Moncrieff Aitken VC before 8 Feb 1828 Cupar, Fife, Scotland 18 Sep 1887 St Andrews, Fife, Scotland Male Templeton-1883
Q7345608 Robert Hope Moncrieff Aitken (Victoria Cross recipient) 14 Apr 1828 Cupar United Kingdom 18 Sep 1887 St Andrews United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Templeton-1883 07.10.2019 16:48:32 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Lundy-310
H
1445 Robert of Balgonie Lundie (Lundy) aka Lundin uncertain 1437 Fife, Scotland Markinch, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75263402 Sir Robert Lundie of Balgonie (Peerage person ID=21182) 1445 1502 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:37:35 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Scott-7391
H
1490 Walter Scott IIIrd of Buccleuch (Scott) aka of Branxholme, uncertain 1480 Ettrick, Selkirkshire, Scotland certain 4 Oct 1552 certain Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Male Lauder-Frost-1
Q7966109 Walter Scott of Branxholme and Buccleuch (Nobleman of the Scottish Borders) 1490 4 Oct 1552 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Penman-567 10.10.2023 22:04:21 Not corrected Pre-1500 Authorization Needed
Carruth-363 11.10.2023 01:21:01 False suggestion date is not sourced, Wikidata is unreliable, especially for pre-1500
Clephane-11
H
1646 Lt-Col William Clephane uncertain 1643 Cupar, Fife, Scotland 1727 the Netherlands Male Croll-284
Q76144596 William Clephane (Peerage person ID=562128) 1646 1727 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:52:45 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Sinclair-144
H
1410 William Sinclair Third Earl of Orkney First Earl of Caithness (Sinclair) uncertain 1404 certain Roslin, Edinburghshire, Scotland before Mar 1480 certain Kirkcaldy, Fife, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q3568958 William Sinclair, 1st Earl of Caithness (Scottish nobleman, last Jarl of Orkney; Lord Chancellor of Scotland) 1410 1484 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 22.11.2020 21:39:54 False suggestion dates are uncertain and not sourced
Moncrieffe-5
H
1519 Sir William younger of Moncreiffe Moncreiffe (Moncrieffe) uncertain 1526 Gordonshall, Fifeshire, Scotland uncertain 1570 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Moncrief-207
Q75266274 William Moncreiffe of that Ilk, younger (Peerage person ID=23307) 1519 1570 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:53:51 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source