Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Warning 563: Wikidata - Possible duplicate by father Help (Difficulty: Advanced)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
MacDuff-19
H 		Compare Duncan 1st Earl of Fife MacDuff Wikitree Father uncertain 1118 1154 Male WikiTree-65
MacDuff-15
H 		Gillemichael MacDuff Mórmaer of Fife (MacDuff) Wikidata Father uncertain 1098 Methil, Fifeshire, Scotland before Jul 1136 Methil, Fifeshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75387783 Afrika Macduff (Peerage person ID=107696) 1130 female
Q5561994 Gille Míchéil, Earl of Fife (Scottish noble) 11000101 1130s male
Macduff-7
H 		Compare Duncan Macduff Wikitree Father 1262 Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland 25 Sep 1288 Argyll, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Shelton-1487
Macduff-42
H 		Colbran Colban 5th Earl of Fife Macduff Wikidata Father uncertain 1245 Methil, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1270 Male WikiTree-65
Q5142054 Colbán, Earl of Fife (Scottish noble) 12cen 1270s male
Q6078030 Isabella MacDuff, Countess of Buchan (Scottish noblewoman, figure in the Wars of Scottish Independence) 12cen 1313 1313 1310 1310 1310 1313 1313 1310 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McCallum-662 21.04.2018 18:34:57 Comment Left a comment on the profile.
Melville-34
H 		Compare John the Younger Melville Wikitree Father uncertain 1460 uncertain Raith, Fife, Scotland Jun 1494 uncertain Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Melville-38
H 		Sir John 4th of Raith Melville Wikidata Father before 11 Aug 1482 Raith, Fife, Scotland 13 Dec 1548 Stirling, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75853913 Janet Melville (Peerage person ID=357073) 1565 female
Q6248448 John Melville (Scottish courtier executed for his support of the Protestant cause) 13 Dec 1548 1548 male
Scott-2497
H 		Compare Sir Michael Scott VIth of Balwearie (Scott) Wikitree Father uncertain 1372 uncertain Kirkcaldy, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1449 uncertain Baleweary Castle, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Scott-2002
H 		Sir William Scott Vth of Balwearie (Scott) Wikidata Father uncertain 1350 certain Balweary, Fifeshire, Scotland uncertain 1406 uncertain Baleweary Castle, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q76303319 Margaret Scott (Peerage person ID=675044) female
Q76297649 Sir William Scott, 5th of Balwearie (Peerage person ID=670969) 1350 1406 male
Lindsay-322
H 		Compare Sir Patrick Lindsay Fourth Lord Lindsay of the Byres (Lindsay) Wikitree Father uncertain 1439 certain Byres, Haddington, Haddingtonshire, Scotland 8 Mar 1526 St Andrews, Fifeshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Lindsay-1904
H 		Sir John Master of Lindsay Lindsay of Pitcruvie (Lindsay) Wikidata Father certain 1482 Byres, Haddington, East Lothian, Scotland certain 28 Aug 1525 Pitcruvie Castle, Fifeshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75263399 Sir John Lindsay, Master of Lindsay (Peerage person ID=21180) 1482 28 Aug 1525 male
Q75866461 Janet Lindsay (Peerage person ID=366363) 1499 female
Lundie-64
H 		Compare Sir Robert Lord High Treasurer of Scotland Lundie aka Lundy, Lundin Wikitree Father uncertain 1450 Balgonie, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1502 Scotland Male Orphan
Lundy-310
H 		Robert of Balgonie Lundie (Lundy) aka Lundin Wikidata Father uncertain 1437 Fife, Scotland Markinch, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75263402 Sir Robert Lundie of Balgonie (Peerage person ID=21182) 1445 1502 male
Q75263401 Elizabeth Lundie (Peerage person ID=21181) female
Lundie-64
H 		Compare Sir Robert Lord High Treasurer of Scotland Lundie aka Lundy, Lundin Wikitree Father uncertain 1450 Balgonie, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1502 Scotland Male Orphan
Lundy-310
H 		Robert of Balgonie Lundie (Lundy) aka Lundin Wikidata Father uncertain 1437 Fife, Scotland Markinch, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q76303306 Andrew Lundie of Carnbo and Balgonie (Peerage person ID=675039) 1470 9 Sep 1513 male
Q75263402 Sir Robert Lundie of Balgonie (Peerage person ID=21182) 1445 1502 male
Lundie-64
H 		Compare Sir Robert Lord High Treasurer of Scotland Lundie aka Lundy, Lundin Wikitree Father uncertain 1450 Balgonie, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1502 Scotland Male Orphan
Lundy-310
H 		Robert of Balgonie Lundie (Lundy) aka Lundin Wikidata Father uncertain 1437 Fife, Scotland Markinch, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q76069920 Janet Lundie (Peerage person ID=509347) 1488 female
Q75263402 Sir Robert Lundie of Balgonie (Peerage person ID=21182) 1445 1502 male
Lundie-64
H 		Compare Sir Robert Lord High Treasurer of Scotland Lundie aka Lundy, Lundin Wikitree Father uncertain 1450 Balgonie, Fife, Scotland uncertain 1502 Scotland Male Orphan
Lundy-310
H 		Robert of Balgonie Lundie (Lundy) aka Lundin Wikidata Father uncertain 1437 Fife, Scotland Markinch, Fife, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75263402 Sir Robert Lundie of Balgonie (Peerage person ID=21182) 1445 1502 male
Q75262461 Isobel Lundie (Peerage person ID=20482) female
Keith-1159
H 		Compare Sir Robert of Dunnottar Keith Marischal of Scotland (Keith) Wikitree Father uncertain 1363 certain Kincardineshire, Scotland uncertain 1430 certain Kincardineshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Ratliff-242
Keith-313
H 		Sir William Keith Earl of Marischal (Keith) Wikidata Father 1389 Dunottar, Kincardineshire, Scotland before 16 Mar 1464 uncertain Dunottar Castle, Stonehaven, Kincardineshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q73756835 William Keith (Peerage person ID=109265) 13cen 1444 Oct 1444 male
Q76037912 Elizabeth Keith (Peerage person ID=485892) 1456 female