Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information 
.
| Link |
Info |
Name |
Rel. |
Birth |
Death |
Gender |
|
Manager |
Marriage |
Status |
Hardie-56
 H   |
3 Aug 1832 |
Oswald Hardie |
|
uncertain 3 Aug 1835 Leslie, Fife, , Scotland |
18 Feb 1917 Placerville, El Dorado, California, United States |
Male |
 |
Tryon-2537
|
|
|
| 67576277 |
Oswald Hardie |
|
3 Aug 1832 Scotland |
18 Feb 1917 Placerville, El Dorado County, California, USA |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Tryon-2537 |
09.08.2019 02:56:51 |
False suggestion |
Death Cert states a birth year of 1832 but all other documents indicate 1835. All state Aug 3. I'm going with 1835 because it dominates the evidence. FindAGrave doesn't source and is therefore unreliable. |
|
Mentiplay-6
H |
11 Dec 1831 |
Janet Falconer (Mentiplay) |
|
certain 4 Mar 1810 certain Carnbee, Fife, Scotland |
certain 8 Feb 1898 certain Williamstown, Victoria, Australia |
Female |
|
Gray-8215
|
|
|
| 153403290 |
Janet Mentiplay Falconer |
|
11 Dec 1831 Pittenweem, Fife, Scotland |
8 Feb 1898 Williamstown, Hobsons Bay City, Victoria, Australia |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Gray-8215 |
05.11.2022 11:09:20 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree birth date is correct. Advised FindAGrave. |
|
Saunders-5815
H |
1838 |
Janet Jessie Kinnear (Saunders) |
|
1836 Couper Angus, Fife, Scotland |
before 6 May 1876 Christchurch, Canterbury, New Zealand |
Female |
|
Rose-1785
|
|
|
| 137088116 |
Jessie Saunders Kinnear |
|
1838 Scotland |
5 May 1876 Christchurch City, Canterbury, New Zealand |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Rose-1785 |
03.01.2024 01:46:55 |
False suggestion |
Earlier sources are likely to be more accurate than memorial |
|
Anderson-37258
H |
5 Nov 1822 |
Jessie Cameron (Anderson) |
|
uncertain 1827 Ceres, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom |
24 Feb 1906 Victoria, British Columbia, Canada |
Female |
|
Mutter-136
|
|
|
| 117739134 |
Jessie Anderson Cameron |
|
5 Nov 1822 Ceres, Fife, Scotland |
24 Feb 1906 Victoria, Capital Regional District, British Columbia, Canada |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Mutter-136 |
05.10.2021 21:59:12 |
False suggestion |
No evidence presented to support DoB stated on FindAGrave. |
|
Bonella-22
H |
28 Jul 1885 |
James Bonella |
|
certain 1884 Auchtermuchty, Fife, Scotland |
certain 16 Feb 1921 Meckering, Western Australia, Australia |
Male |
|
Bews-37
|
|
|
| 131831018 |
James Bonella |
|
28 Jul 1885 Auchtermuchty, Fife, Scotland |
16 Feb 1921 Meckering, Cunderdin Shire, Western Australia, Australia |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Bews-37 |
02.07.2023 02:24:51 |
False suggestion |
National Records of Scotland show birth was regist |
|
Turpie-634
H |
1 May 1832 |
John Turpie |
|
certain 3 Jun 1832 certain Cults, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom |
certain 31 Jul 1915 certain Bathgate, West Lothian, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Male |
|
Turpy-1
|
|
|
| 142585066 |
John Turpie |
|
1 May 1832 Fife, Scotland |
31 Jul 1915 Bathgate, West Lothian, Scotland |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Turpy-1 |
02.08.2023 16:59:02 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree birth date is correct; FindAGrave no source |
|
Inglis-2054
H |
17 Apr 1801 |
David Inglis |
|
19 Apr 1802 Dairsie, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom |
7 Sep 1868 Loch Lee, Forfarshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Male |
|
Officer-241
|
|
|
| 129985708 |
David Inglis |
|
17 Apr 1801 |
7 Sep 1868 Angus, Scotland |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Officer-241 |
20.01.2024 16:58:13 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Sharp-12807
H |
15 Jul 1884 |
William Sharp |
|
uncertain Feb 1884 certain Larkhall, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
certain 12 Sep 1917 certain Cowdenbeath, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Male |
|
Thomson-8303
|
|
|
| 135891790 |
LCpl William Sharp |
|
15 Jul 1884 Larkhall, South Lanarkshire, Scotland |
12 Sep 1917 Cowdenbeath, Fife, Scotland |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Thomson-8303 |
21.02.2023 18:44:14 |
False suggestion |
no source on findagrave, month calculated from military attestation. |
|
McPherson-6575
H |
15 Mar 1854 |
Christina Drylie (McPherson) |
|
14 Mar 1855 Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom |
27 Jun 1932 Pitcairn, Allegheny, Pennsylvania, United States |
Female |
|
Fremmerlid-1
|
|
|
| 67143900 |
Christina “Muddie” McPherson Drylie |
|
15 Mar 1854 Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland |
27 Jun 1932 Irwin, Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania, USA |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Fremmerlid-1 |
09.06.2022 00:39:58 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree birth date is correct. |
|
Peebles-2451
H |
1871 |
Robert Carstairs Peebles |
|
certain 1869 certain Pittenweem, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom |
certain 22 Mar 1936 certain Anstruther or Kilrenny, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Male |
|
Turpy-1
|
|
|
| 194696366 |
Robert C. Peebles |
|
1871 |
22 Mar 1936 |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Turpy-1 |
02.08.2023 17:00:36 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree birth date is correct; FindAGrave no source |
|
Bain-4670
H |
5 Feb 1833 |
Margaret Fleming Turpie (Bain) |
|
certain 5 Feb 1831 certain Newburgh, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom |
certain 7 Dec 1913 certain Newborough, Oamaru, Otago, New Zealand |
Female |
|
Turpy-1
|
|
|
| 183805109 |
Margaret Fleming Bain Turpie |
|
5 Feb 1833 Scotland |
7 Dec 1913 Ōamaru, Waitaki District, Otago, New Zealand |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Turpy-1 |
02.08.2023 16:58:39 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree birth date is correct; FindAGrave no source |
|
(Difficulty: Intermediate)