Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 210: Father was dead before birth (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information .

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender	Manager
Atkins-7359 H	Alexander Atkins	Father	10 Jul 1802 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	10 Jul 1852 Clyde Township, St. Clair, Michigan, United States	Male	Sheldon-4720
Atkins-7369 H	Elzaria Atkins	Child	1854 Clyde Township, St. Clair, Michigan, United States		Female	Sheldon-4720
Herbertson-34 H	Hugh Herbertson	Father	uncertain 1811 Ireland	after 1841 Scotland	Male	Migalski-2
Herbertson-33 H	Hughminia Herbertson	Child	certain 12 Nov 1852 Kilbirnie, Ayrshire, Scotland	certain 6 Apr 1909 Crawford County, Kansas	Female	Migalski-2
McMillan-1000 H	John Russell McMillan	Father	17 Apr 1811 Dalserf, Lanarkshire, Scotland	1851	Male	Orphan
McMillan-1001 H	Jane McMillan	Child	1853 Dalserf, Lanarkshire, Scotland		Female	Orphan
Fowler-9605 H	John Fowler	Father	1814 Lanarkshire, Scotland	1865 Scotland	Male	Orphan
Fowler-9614 H	Thomas Fowler	Child	uncertain 29 May 1868 Scotland, United Kingdom	2 Oct 1941 Wilkinsburg, Allegheny, Pennsylvania, USA	Male	Orphan
Fowler-9605 H	John Fowler	Father	1814 Lanarkshire, Scotland	1865 Scotland	Male	Orphan
Fowler-9612 H	Alexander Fowler	Child	uncertain 1867 Scotland	4 Jan 1916 Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom	Male	Orphan
Reid-6693 H	James Reid	Father	certain 8 Feb 1822	certain 3 Jun 1855	Male	Macphail-42
Reid-13501 H	Margaret Jane Kinnon (Reid)	Child	1871	4 May 1948 Glasgow, Scotland	Female	Macphail-42
Marshall-6371 H	James John Marshall	Father	uncertain 1830	after 1830	Male	Wilson-21458
Marshall-6175 H	Janet Couper (Marshall)	Child	certain 1865 Scotland	certain 13 Feb 1926 Philadelphia	Female	Wilson-21458
Lundy-1894 H	Robert Lundy	Father	1833 Ireland	1870 Old Monkland, Lanarkshire	Male	Conn-693
Leyden-56 H	Margaret Irvine (Leyden) aka Lundie	Child	certain 3 Feb 1875 Rosehall, Lanarkshire, Scotland	certain 10 Jan 1918 Bellshill, Lanarkshire	Female	Conn-693
Irvine-5872 H	James Irvine	Father	uncertain 1836 Scotland, United Kingdom	1866 Airth, Stirlingshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Male	Orphan
Irvine-5876 H	Euphemia Livingston Patterson (Irvine)	Child	22 May 1872 Airth, Stirlingshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	1 Feb 1940 Bellshill, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Female	Nass-24
McCosh-82 H	James McCosh	Father	uncertain 1840 certain County Antrim, Ireland	uncertain 1870	Male	Orphan
McCosh-86 H	Elizabeth McKechnie (McCosh)	Child	certain 13 Feb 1873 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Sep 1958 Brisbane, Queensland, Australia	Female	Orphan
Ross-9484 H	William Scott Ross	Father	uncertain 1840 Scotland	uncertain 1870	Male	Cooke-3359
Ross-9483 H	James Ross	Child	uncertain 1876 Cambusnethan, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 13 Nov 1911 Carluke, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Male	Cooke-3359
Singer-1884 H	William Singer	Father	1840 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland	21 Mar 1893 Queensland, Australia	Male	Petersen-639
Singer-1891 H	Robert Singer	Child	19 Oct 1894 Brisbane, Queensland, Australia		Male	Petersen-639
Mckinley-2650 H	mr Peter Mckinley	Father	certain 12 Feb 1840 Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 28 Feb 1878 Allegany, Maryland, United States	Male	Mckinley-2545
Mckinley-2649 H	mr James Robert Robert Burns Mckinley	Child	certain 21 Mar 1879 Lonaconing, Allegany, Maryland, United States	12 Dec 1935 Wheeling, Ohio, West Virginia, United States	Male	Mckinley-2545
Glasgow-938 H	Robert Glasgow	Father	certain 6 Nov 1840 certain Rasharkin, County Antrim, Ireland	certain 27 Nov 1902 certain 58 East Rose St, Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom	Male	Glasgow-933
Glasgow-2887 H	Robert Glasgow	Child	8 Dec 1908 88 Elcho St, Glasgow.	uncertain 10 Dec 1973 35 Ardlochan Rd, Maidens, Ayrshire.	Male	Glasgow-933
Boak-68 H	Mr William Boak	Father	certain 1 Aug 1843 Cadder Lanarkshire Scotland	certain 31 Dec 1874 Cadder Lanark Scotland	Male	Watts-4114
Boak-67 H	Annie Atkinson (Boak)	Child	certain 24 Jun 1887 Glenboig, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 17 Oct 1959 Palmerston North, Manawatu-Wanganui, New Zealand	Female	Watts-4114
Rosenthal-1036 H	Daniel Rosenthal	Father	uncertain 1845 uncertain Poland	uncertain 1891 uncertain	Male	Fern-261
Rosenthal-1094 H	Daniel Rosenthal	Child	certain 1894 49 McNeil Street, Glasgow, Scotland		Male	Fern-261
Carty-401 H	Patrick Carty	Father	uncertain 1846 County Sligo, Ireland	after 1876 Lanarkshire, Scotland	Male	McMahon-2055
Carty-408 H	Bridget Carty	Child	1881 Glasgow, Scotland	after	Female	McMahon-2055
Carty-401 H	Patrick Carty	Father	uncertain 1846 County Sligo, Ireland	after 1876 Lanarkshire, Scotland	Male	McMahon-2055
Carty-405 H	Maryanne Carty	Child	after 1878 Glasgow, Scotland		Female	McMahon-2055
Carty-401 H	Patrick Carty	Father	uncertain 1846 County Sligo, Ireland	after 1876 Lanarkshire, Scotland	Male	McMahon-2055
Carty-406 H	Margaret Carty	Child	after 1879 Glasgow, Scotland		Female	McMahon-2055
Carty-401 H	Patrick Carty	Father	uncertain 1846 County Sligo, Ireland	after 1876 Lanarkshire, Scotland	Male	McMahon-2055
Carty-407 H	Thomas Carty	Child	after 1880 Glasgow, Scotland		Male	McMahon-2055

Link	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender	Manager
Miller-89655 H	James Miller	Father	before 1848	after 1848	Male	Shelberg-1
Miller-89654 H	James Miller	Child	certain 13 Apr 1853 Milnathort, Perth and Kinross, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 6 Jul 1917 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Male	Shelberg-1
Barclay-973 H	James Barclay	Father	1853 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland	30 May 1877 Renfrew, Ontario, Canada	Male	Barclay-969
Barclay-979 H	Alice Barclay	Child	Nov 1881 Illinois, United States		Female	Barclay-969
Barclay-973 H	James Barclay	Father	1853 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland	30 May 1877 Renfrew, Ontario, Canada	Male	Barclay-969
Barclay-978 H	Frances L Barclay	Child	Dec 1885 Nebraska, United States	1943 Melbourne, Marshall, Iowa, United States	Female	Barclay-969
Faulkner-5040 H	William Faulkner	Father	uncertain 1855 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 1 Dec 1876	Male	Robinson-48269
Faulkner-5039 H	Jack John Faulkner aka Lightbody	Child	certain 13 Aug 1887 Hulme, Lancashire, England	not living	Male	Robinson-48269
Girvan-28 H	Joseph Girvan	Father	uncertain 1856	before 1885	Male	Thayne-37
Girvan-25 H	John Girvan	Child	certain 25 Dec 1889 11 Fountainwell Road, Springburn, Glasgow	certain 5 Apr 1969 certain Ruchill Hospital, Glasgow	Male	Thayne-37
Collins-3329 H	Michael Collins	Father	1862	18 Feb 1883 Govan, Lanarkshire, Scotland	Male	Morrison-2327
Collins-3331 H	Elizabeth Forrester Hughes Collins	Child	17 Mar 1890 DUNDEE Angus Scotland		Female	Morrison-2327
Fox-23737 H	Hugh Fox	Father	before 1863	after 1863	Male	Gielen-6
Fox-24278 H	John Fox	Child	certain 1866	after 1866	Male	Gielen-6
Carruth-131 H	Alexander Carruth Jr.	Father	29 Jul 1866 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	after 1910 uncertain United States	Male	Rockwell-390
Carruth-140 H	Marian B Carruth	Child	1 Dec 1912 Kern, California		Female	Rockwell-390
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79051 H	Mary Taylor	Child	certain 27 Mar 1903 West Maryston Swinton Glasgow Scotland	certain 9 Dec 1908 Swinton Glasgow Scotland	Female	Tait-2350
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79053 H	Robina Taylor	Child	certain 11 Apr 1906 West Maryston Glasgow Scotland	not living	Female	Tait-2350
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79052 H	Jane Taylor	Child	certain 24 Jun 1904 West Maryston Swinton Glasgow Scotland	not living	Female	Tait-2350
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79055 H	James Taylor	Child	certain 25 Jan 1908 Swinton, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 10 Sep 1908 Swinton, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79059 H	Annie Taylor	Child	certain 3 Apr 1913 Easterhouse, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 2 May 1913 Swinton, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Female	Tait-2350
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79057 H	Margaret Taylor	Child	certain 19 Jan 1911 Swinton, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	not living	Female	Tait-2350
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79050 H	Robert Taylor	Child	certain 28 Mar 1902 West Maryston Swinton Glasgow Scotland	certain 1 Apr 1905 West Maryston Glasgow Scotland	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79060 H	Martha Taylor	Child	certain 17 Aug 1914 Long Row Swinton Glasgow Scotland	not living	Female	Tait-2350
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79058 H	Mary Taylor	Child	certain 5 Mar 1912 Swinton, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 3 Oct 1912 Swinton, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Female	Tait-2350
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79054 H	Agnes Taylor	Child	certain 10 Apr 1907 Swinton, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	not living	Female	Tait-2350
Taylor-68842 H	Robert Taylor	Father	uncertain 1873	uncertain 1900	Male	Tait-2350
Taylor-79056 H	Robert Taylor	Child	certain 7 Jan 1910 Swinton, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 20 Mar 1911 Swinton, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Male	Tait-2350
Scullion-95 H	John Scullion	Father	certain 8 Jan 1885 certain Maryhill, Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 23 Sep 1921 certain Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom	Male	Medlow-5
Scullion-97 H	Josephine Mail Scullion	Child	uncertain Jul 1923 Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 12 Aug 1923 certain Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom	Female	Medlow-5

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status