Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Stewart-18649
H
1440 Alexander Stewart VIIIth of Castlemilk (Stewart) uncertain 1475 Castlemilk, Lanarkshire, Scotland certain 1524 Castlemilk Scotland Male Stuart-531
Q76312809 Alexander Stewart of Castlemilk (Peerage person ID=680921) 1440 1524 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:59:36 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Douglas-402
H
1198 Sir Archibald Douglas IInd of Douglas (Douglas) before 1175 Hermiston, Edinburghshire, Scotland uncertain 1240 Douglas, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q4170054 Archibald I, Lord of Douglas (Scottish knight) 1198 1238 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 27.06.2021 00:53:58 False suggestion both dates are unsourced, 1198 is date mentioned in charter, not birth
Henderson-9701
H
13 Sep 1863 Arthur Henderson certain 20 Sep 1863 certain Anderston, Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 20 Oct 1935 certain London, England, United Kingdom Male Fretwell-188
Q208665 Arthur Henderson (British politician (1863-1935)) 13 Sep 1863 Glasgow United Kingdom 20 Oct 1935 London United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Fretwell-188 06.09.2018 16:17:44 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Campbell-17524
H
1671 Daniel Donald Great Daniel Campbell before 1672 uncertain Skipness Scotland certain 8 Jun 1753 certain Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Male Orphan
Q5216741 Daniel Campbell (Scottish politician and noble (d. 1753)) 1671 1753 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Murray-20099 23.03.2022 06:06:47 False suggestion
Penman-567 03.07.2023 00:00:12 Not corrected No source available currently for exact DOB
Carruth-363 09.07.2023 00:42:26 False suggestion different people, different dates and fathers
Colville-338
H
1812 David Colville certain 15 Feb 1813 Campbeltown, Argyll, Scotland certain 29 Oct 1898 Claremont Terrace, Glasgow, Lanarkshire Scotland Male Colville-218
Q18821768 David Colville (Scottish ironmaster) 1812 1898 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Colville-218 19.06.2018 16:50:54 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Hamilton-4175
H
1333 Sir David Hamilton IIIrd of Cadzow (Hamilton) 1335 Lanarkshire, Scotland 14 Apr 1392 Paisley, Renfrewshire, Scotland Male Wright-7062

WikiTree-65

Hamilton-4105
Q5234685 David Hamilton of Cadzow (Scottish nobleman) 1333 South Lanarkshire United Kingdom 1392 Scotland United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 20.03.2024 05:32:27 Merge proposed Merge already proposed.
Hardie-775
H
1870 David Hardie certain 27 Jan 1871 certain Hamilton, Lanarkshire, Scotland certain 8 Apr 1939 certain Rutherglen, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Q5234715 David Hardie (British politician (1870-1939)) 1870 8 Apr 1939 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Sharp-7578 25.09.2019 23:42:55 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Fairweather-1386
H
1891 Captain Douglas Keith Fairweather 1890 Plantation, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom 3 Apr 1944 Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Fairweather-583
Q76322403 Douglas Keith Fairweather (Peerage person ID=688265) 1891 Apr 1944 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:10:21 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Maxwell-947
H
1405 Edward Tinwald Maxwell uncertain 1420 Scotland 1481 Calderwood, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q76266090 Sir Edward Maxwell (Peerage person ID=648838) 1405 1481 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:42:24 False suggestion
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:42:29 Comment peerage is unreliable
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:42:34 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Gibson-21694
H
30 Nov 1868 Elizabeth Scott Smith (Gibson) certain 1869 Prestonpans, Haddingtonshire, Scotland certain 16 Mar 1941 Tranent, East Lothian, Scotland Female Thomson-8303
Q96316446 Elizabeth Gibson ((1869-1941)) 30 Nov 1868 16 Mar 1941 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomson-8303 29.09.2021 09:34:28 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Somerville-24
H
1413 Elizabeth Somerville after Mar 1447 Cowthally Castle, Carnwath, Lanarkshire, Scotland not living Lochow, Argyllshire, Scotland Female Felch-7
Q75388182 Elizabeth Somerville (Peerage person ID=108015) 1413 1447 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:26:55 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Ross-5616
H
19 Apr 1891 Francis Frank Mackenzie Ross CMG MC OD 14 Apr 1891 Glasgow, Scotland 11 Dec 1971 Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada Male Jewett-369
Q1443716 Frank Mackenzie Ross (Canadian Lieutenant Governor (1891-1971)) 19 Apr 1891 Glasgow United Kingdom 11 Dec 1971 Vancouver Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jewett-369 04.03.2019 21:31:05 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Colville-709
H
26 May 1861 Georgina Emory (Colville) 30 May 1861 Hamilton, Lanarkshire, Scotland 15 Jun 1941 Woodbury, Orange, New York, United States Female Colville-218
Q75609710 Georgina Colville ((1861-1941)) 26 May 1861 15 Jun 1941 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Colville-218 31.03.2020 23:32:18 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Blackburn-4850
H
1746 Isabella Wedderburn (Blackburn) certain 4 Feb 1756 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland 14 Jan 1821 Female Orphan
Q75390123 Isabella Blackburn ((died 1821)) 1746 14 Jan 1821 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Schaffer-615 09.09.2020 16:56:15 Corrected Changed DOB
Schaffer-615 21.10.2022 16:43:31 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Hamilton-1233
H
1516 Sir James Hamilton Duke of Châtellerault (Hamilton) uncertain 1519 certain Hamilton, Lanarkshire, Scotland after 22 Jan 1575 certain Hamilton, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Wright-7062

WikiTree-36
Q1680516 James Hamilton, Duke of Châtellerault (Scottish noble (1516-1575)) 1516 22 Jan 1575 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 18.08.2020 11:40:17 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Hamilton-29222
H
1475 James Hamilton IIIrd of Torrance (Hamilton) before 1479 certain Torrance, Lanarkshire, Scotland after 1494 uncertain Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Q76032879 James Hamilton, 3rd of Torrance (Peerage person ID=482092) 1475 1540 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:26:08 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
McCulloch-895
H
18 Mar 1819 Sir James McCulloch Tertius 19 Mar 1819 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom 31 Jan 1893 Garbrand Hall, Ewell, Surrey, England Male Rose-1785
Q3161265 James McCulloch (British-Australian politician; Premier of Victoria) 18 Mar 1819 Glasgow United Kingdom 31 Jan 1893 Epsom United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rose-1785 11.07.2023 01:04:00 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect
Somerville-59
H
1520 Sir James Velvet Eye Somerville IVth of Cambusnethan (Somerville) after 26 Nov 1526 certain Carnwath, Lanarkshire, Scotland uncertain 1594 uncertain Cowthally, Carnwath, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Wolfe-522
Q76094319 Sir James Somerville, 4th of Cambusnethan (Peerage person ID=526466) 1520 Sep 1613 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:08:16 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Forrester-132
H
1510 Janet Bruce (Forrester) after 1500 Carden, Scotland after 27 Jun 1527 Female Blackstone-170
Q75510389 Janet Forrester (Peerage person ID=185118) 1510 1610 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:09:38 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Aitcheson-100
H
1744 Janet Hunter (Aitcheson) 1730 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland 1787 Ayrshire Scotland Female Hunter-5770
Q76033068 Janet Aitcheson (Peerage person ID=482239) 1744 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:30:02 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Douglas-588
H
1379 Janet Jacoba Janet Hamilton (Douglas) before Oct 1378 Dalkeith, Midlothian, Scotland after 1410 Cadzow, Lanarkshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75268189 Janet Douglas (Peerage person ID=24828) 1379 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:48:54 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Colville-490
H
14 Aug 1849 Janet Jessie Lusk (Colville) 14 Oct 1849 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland 29 Oct 1929 Edinburgh, Scotland Female Colville-218
Q75612421 Janet Colville ((1849-1929)) 14 Aug 1849 29 Oct 1929 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Colville-218 05.12.2019 15:09:50 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Herries-1
H
1 Oct 1390 Janet Maxwell (Herries) uncertain 1400 certain Kirkcudbright, Dumfries-shire, Scotland certain 9 Mar 1439 certain Lanarkshire, Scotland Female Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q75240241 unknown daughter Herries (Peerage person ID=2439) 1 Oct 1390 9 Mar 1439 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:50:44 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Mowat-4
H
1388 Janet Morat Lady Sommerville (Mowat) before 1417 Stonehouse, Lanarkshire, Scotland 1458 Cowthally Castle, Carnwath, Lanarkshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75512503 Janet Mowat (Peerage person ID=186454) 1388 1458 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:42:17 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Arnott-81
H
26 Jul 1814 Sir John 1st Baronet Arnott, of Woodlands, Shandon, co. Cork Arnott 1st Bt. certain 26 Jul 1816 certain Auchtermuchty, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom 28 Mar 1898 certain Cork, Ireland Male Arnott-720
Q6219448 John Arnott (British politician) 26 Jul 1814 28 Mar 1898 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Luck-863 08.12.2021 18:53:23 False suggestion
Primrose-362
H
16 Oct 1847 Sir John Baronet of Redholme Dumbreck and Govan (Primrose) 22 Oct 1847 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland 29 Jun 1924 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Orphan
Q48660405 John Ure Primrose (Scottish merchant (1847-1924)) 16 Oct 1847 29 Jun 1924 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Colville-218 22.02.2022 20:10:57 False suggestion
Gladstone-43
H
1694 John Gladstone 1693 Toftcombes, Biggar, Lanarkshire, Scotland 1 Jun 1756 Biggar, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Wiegand-310
Q75567223 John Gladstones (Peerage person ID=216848) 1694 1 Jun 1757 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:17:06 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Glasfoord-1
H
1715 John Glasfoord before 23 Aug 1713 Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland certain 27 Aug 1783 98 Ingram Street, Glasgow, Scotland Male Templeton-1883
Q6235465 John Glassford (British businessman) 1715 27 Aug 1783 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Templeton-1883 27.07.2023 16:59:55 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Hamilton-1232
H
1537 Sir John Hamilton First Marquess of Hamilton (Hamilton) uncertain 1542 certain Scotland certain 26 Apr 1604 certain Hamilton Palace, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Stevens-17832

WikiTree-36

Petersen-214

Wright-7062

Hamilton-4105
Q4735 John Hamilton (Scottish nobleman (1537-1604)) 1537 Isle of Arran United Kingdom 26 Apr 1604 Isle of Arran United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 18.08.2020 11:42:44 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Hamilton-4300
H
1520 John Hamilton Vth of Udston (Hamilton) after 1530 certain Udston, Lanarkshire, Scotland certain 13 May 1568 certain Battle of Langside, Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Hamilton-4105

Wright-7062
Q75284178 John Hamilton of Udston (Peerage person ID=37385) 1520 13 May 1568 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:18:05 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Tennant-877
H
1796 John Tennant certain 14 Sep 1797 certain Eastwood, Renfrewshire, Scotland certain 14 Apr 1878 certain Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Hylton-692
Q27825173 John Tennant (Person; male; Of St Rollox, Glasgow; father of Sir Charles Tennant, baronet; British; 1796-1878) 1796 1878 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hylton-692 08.09.2023 04:17:18 False suggestion
Weir-686
H
17 Jun 1780 John Weir uncertain 1798 certain Scotland certain 25 Dec 1885 certain Coatbridge, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Barry-582
Q76091732 John Weir (Peerage person ID=524636) 17 Jun 1780 25 Dec 1885 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:52:41 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Keith-105
H
1360 Margaret Keith Lady Crawford (Keith) uncertain 1350 Dunnottar Castle, Stonehaven, Kincardineshrie, Scotland 12 Jun 1397 Crawford, Clydesdale, Lanarkshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75263371 Margaret Keith (Peerage person ID=21161) 1360 12 Jun 1397 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:47:20 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Campbell-1219
H
1530 Margaret Macdowall (Campbell) uncertain 1500 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland certain 1547 Dundee, Angus, Scotland Female Hughey-105
Q75994911 Margaret Campbell (Peerage person ID=455462) 1530 1547 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:33:19 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Stewart-1165
H
1455 Princess Margaret Stewart 1460 Stirling, Stirlingshire, Scotland after 20 Dec 1503 Hamilton, Lanarkshire, Scotland Female Heinzelmann-5
Q4770490 Margaret Stewart (younger daughter of James II of Scotland and Mary of Guelders) 1455 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 13.07.2023 02:51:50 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source
Hamilton-6409
H
1515 Marion Hunter (Hamilton) aka Hambleton before 1514 certain Torrance Castle, Hamilton, Lanarkshire, Scotland certain 25 May 1596 certain Hunterston Castle, Ayrshire, Scotland Female Hunter-5770

Hunter-3749
Q76032881 Marion Hamilton (Peerage person ID=482093) 1515 25 May 1596 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:35:51 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Fleming-647
H
1451 Mariotta Beatrix Stirling (Fleming) before 1460 uncertain Biggar, Lanarkshire, Scotland before 1495 uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
Q76178084 Mariotta Fleming (Peerage person ID=584409) 1451 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:57:01 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Stewart-1157
H
1451 Lady Mary Hamilton Countess of Arran (Stewart) aka Boyd before May 1452 Stirling Castle, Stirlingshire, Scotland uncertain May 1488 Hamilton, Clydesdale, Lanarkshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Heinzelmann-5

Wright-7062

WikiTree-36
Q4652 Mary Stewart (Scottish princess) 1451 Stirling Castle United Kingdom May 1488 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
thiessen-117 17.11.2021 21:22:21 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Denniston-2
H
1360 Robert Denniston before 1378 certain Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland uncertain 1405 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Q75969604 Sir Robert Denniston of Denniston (Peerage person ID=438266) 1360 1405 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:48:41 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Baillie-198
H
1477 Sibylla Edmonstone (Baillie) after 1489 Lamington, Lanarkshire, Scotland 1545 Stirlingshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Q76294758 Sibylla Baillie (Peerage person ID=669364) 1477 1545 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:37:45 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Baillie-46
H
1375 Sir William Baillie of Lamington (Baillie) uncertain 1370 Lamington, Lanarkshire, Scotland 1432 Scotland Male Hare-1576
Q75260064 Sir William Baillie of Lamington (Peerage person ID=18793) 1375 1432 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:47:54 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Carslaw-7
H
17 Jun 1837 Dr. William Henderson Carslaw uncertain 17 Aug 1837 New Monkland, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom 20 Feb 1926 Helensburgh, Argyll and Bute, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Gardiner-1534
Q75583862 William Henderson Carslaw (Peerage person ID=226348) 17 Jun 1837 Airdrie United Kingdom 20 Feb 1926 Helensburgh United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:38:38 False suggestion peerage is unreliable