Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 578: FindAGrave - Different death date Help Video (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Stewart-587
H
20 Feb 1562 Lady Janet la Belle Écossaise Stewart Lady Fleming (Stewart) uncertain 17 Jul 1502 uncertain Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland certain 5 Oct 1562 uncertain Boghall Castle, Biggar, Lanarkshire, Scotland Female Sanchez-1765

Heinzelmann-5

Dickerson-52
118808430 Lady Janet Stewart Fleming 17 Jul 1502 Edinburgh, City of Edinburgh, Scotland 20 Feb 1562 Richmond, London Borough of Richmond upon Thames, Greater London, England
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 12.09.2023 03:26:10 False suggestion no source on findagrave
Melville-160
H
1 Apr 1912 Helen Ellen Telford (Melville) certain 5 Sep 1855 certain Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 1 Apr 1914 certain Rocklyn, Lincoln, Washington, United States Female Larson-751
14262522 Hellen “Ellen” Melville Telford 5 Sep 1855 Glasgow City, Scotland 1 Apr 1912 Washington, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Larson-751 28.02.2018 17:55:23 False suggestion DoD is correct per Washington death certificate
Carmichael-583
H
17 Nov 1889 Richard Carmichael 29 Aug 1819 Carnwath, Lanark, Scotland 17 Nov 1898 Carnwath, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Henderson-4785
162155491 Richard Carmichael 1810 17 Nov 1889
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Henderson-4785 02.12.2020 20:39:46 False suggestion death correct per death record - FindAGrave incorrect
Wilson-34249
H
9 Aug 1897 John Wilson certain 11 Mar 1804 certain Avondale, Lanarkshire, Scotland certain 9 Aug 1887 certain Sydenham, Grey, Ontario, Canada Male Carlson-1933
206949090 John Wilson 11 Mar 1804 Strathaven, South Lanarkshire, Scotland 9 Aug 1897 Sydenham Township, Grey County, Ontario, Canada
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carlson-1933 21.02.2023 14:12:33 False suggestion death correct per death record - FindAGrave incorrect
Kinnard-111
H
3 Nov 1898 George Kinnard certain 19 Nov 1840 Glasgow, Scotland certain 3 Apr 1898 certain Esterville, Emmet County, Iowa Male Paulson-507
60244670 George Kinnard Sr. 19 Nov 1840 Scotland 3 Nov 1898 Emmet County, Iowa, USA
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Paulson-507 20.09.2018 00:29:08 False suggestion date of death identical on both profile and FindAGrave headstone source. If discrepancy is town mentioned in these records, subject's residence is the reason, not the sources.
Dunlop-1853
H
11 Oct 1886 John Dunlop certain 19 Feb 1831 certain Galston, Ayrshire, Scotland certain 11 Oct 1887 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Sharp-7578
133995846 John Dunlop 1829 11 Oct 1886
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Sharp-7578 14.07.2020 01:53:02 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong
Neely-1576
H
10 Oct 1948 Margaret Ann Maggie Wason (Neely) certain 25 Jun 1876 certain Dromore, Letterkenny, County Donegal, Ireland certain 14 Aug 1948 certain Coatbridge, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Female Stent-34
135207860 Margaret Neely Wason 22 Jun 1874 10 Oct 1948 Old Monkland, North Lanarkshire, Scotland
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stent-34 28.03.2020 05:27:32 False suggestion
Taggart-1513
H
9 Sep 1954 Ethel Letitia Menzies (Taggart) aka Best 7 May 1884 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland 14 Oct 1972 King George Private Hospital, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada Female Howard-18870
101889016 Ethel Best Menzies 1 Jan 1889 Haney, Greater Vancouver Regional District, British Columbia, Canada 9 Sep 1954 New Westminster, Greater Vancouver Regional District, British Columbia, Canada
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Howard-18870 05.12.2020 09:28:17 False suggestion Not the same person as suggested. Different person.
Rennie-1157
H
6 Aug 1912 James Rennie 6 Aug 1824 Barony, Lanarkshire, Scotland 23 Feb 1912 Cardiff, Glamorgan, Wales, United Kingdom Male Colville-218
171193141 James Rennie 1824 Glasgow City, Scotland 6 Aug 1912 Cardiff, Wales
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Colville-218 17.02.2021 22:22:12 False suggestion
Colville-905
H
4 Jul 1865 John Colville 14 Feb 1836 Campbeltown, Argyll, Scotland 17 Mar 1865 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Colville-218
158186199 John Colville 1836 4 Jul 1865
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Colville-218 16.06.2021 12:49:10 False suggestion death correct per death record - FindAGrave incorrect
Lindsay-6462
H
Oct 1846 Alexander Lindsay Sep 1845 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland Aug 1846 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Colville-218
205396040 Alexander Lindsay Sep 1845 Glasgow City, Scotland Oct 1846 Glasgow City, Scotland
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
colville-218 27.07.2021 21:58:05 False suggestion FindAGrave transcription is in error
Dewar-1525
H
12 Dec 1889 Katherine Mary Maxwell (Dewar) uncertain 1824 certain Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 12 Dec 1886 certain Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, England, United Kingdom Female Graham-17201
141183969 Katherine Mary Dewar Maxwell 12 Dec 1889
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Graham-17201 16.10.2021 18:59:54 False suggestion Date incorrectly transcribed form monument
Norval-297
H
1921 Rev. William Norval certain 8 Apr 1809 certain Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom after 1872 England, United Kingdom Male Maeder-84
198645482 William Norval 1844 Canada 1921
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Maeder-84 25.05.2022 19:49:11 Not corrected research note
Maeder-84 03.06.2022 18:58:22 False suggestion research note
Elliot-4374
H
26 Jun 1900 Janet Fortune (Elliot) uncertain 1847 certain Mauchline, Ayrshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 26 Jun 1909 certain Dalserf, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Female Thomson-8303
136386262 Janet Elliot Fortune 1848 Mauchline, East Ayrshire, Scotland 26 Jun 1900
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomson-8303 08.11.2022 18:41:09 False suggestion death correct per death record - FindAGrave incorrect
Thomson-13785
H
2 Nov 1905 Marion Seaton (Thomson) 1821 Denny, Stirlingshire, Scotland, United Kingdom 11 Feb 1905 Portobello, Otago, New Zealand Female Orphan
146055425 Marion Seaton 1821 Scotland 2 Nov 1905 Dunedin, Dunedin City, Otago, New Zealand
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Kellett-33 11.03.2024 19:41:23 False suggestion FindAGrave is wrong
McArthur-3720
H
14 Apr 1931 Margaret Maggie Lang (McArthur) 14 Aug 1871 Campbeltown, Argyll, Scotland 14 Aug 1931 Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom Female Colville-218
178304735 Margaret McArthur Lang 14 Aug 1871 Campbeltown, Argyll and Bute, Scotland 14 Apr 1931 Glasgow City, Scotland
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Colville-218 27.01.2024 15:10:05 False suggestion death correct per death record - FindAGrave incorrect