Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 558: Wikidata - Different death date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Gray-4674
H
1583 Hon Agnes Lyon (Gray) aka Logan, Home uncertain 1540 certain Buttergask, Perthshire, Scotland certain 9 Jan 1580 uncertain Fetteresso, Kincardineshire, Scotland Female Miles-436
Q75272068 Agnes Gray (Peerage person ID=28106) 1540 1583 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:41:25 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Campbell-20729
H
Feb 1608 Bishop Alexander Campbell certain 1555 certain Argyll, Scotland certain 24 Jun 1608 certain Kinclaven, Perthshire, Scotland Male Howard-18870
Q4718522 Alexander Campbell (Scottish bishop) 15cen Feb 1608 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Howard-18870 27.03.2022 03:42:54 Not corrected Wikidata is unsourced Refer to sources in profile Nos.5,6,7.
Howard-18870 27.04.2023 03:06:42 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect - please remove this sugggestion Thank you
Howard-18870 27.04.2023 03:06:55 Comment Wikidata needs to be corrected
Howard-18870 27.04.2023 03:07:06 False suggestion
Duncan-6256
H
May 1777 Alexander Duncan before 10 Feb 1703 Lundie, Forfarshire, Scotland certain 19 Oct 1771 Lundie, Forfarshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75536012 Alexander Duncan, 3rd of Lundie (Peerage person ID=200574) 1703 May 1777 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:13:15 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Murray-5704
H
5 Oct 1332 Sir Andrew Murray IInd of Tullibardin (Murray) aka Moray, de Moravia before 1284 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 7 Oct 1332 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Perkins-11750
Q75388003 Sir Andrew Moray of Bothwell (Peerage person ID=107876) 5 Oct 1332 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:24:36 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Mackay-1976
H
17 Nov 1807 Captain Aneas Mackay certain 1749 Scotstoun, Renfrewshire, Scotland certain 17 Nov 1809 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Male Casey-2231
Q75270967 Æneas Mackay (Peerage person ID=27121) 1749 17 Nov 1807 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:16:04 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Stewart-Alston-1
H
29 Apr 1878 Lady Ann Annie Balcarres Menzies (Stewart-Alston) certain 10 Nov 1822 certain Auchenbreck, Linlithgow, Scotland certain 27 Apr 1878 certain 'Farlayer House', Weem, Perthshire, Scotland Female Howard-18870

Hare-1576
Q76266604 Annie Balcarres Stewart ((died 1878)) 10 Nov 1822 29 Apr 1878 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Howard-18870 29.11.2020 09:03:54 Not corrected conflict between sources Wikipedia gives different date of death.
Howard-18870 24.01.2021 05:34:48 False suggestion Wikidata date is incorrect the 29 Apr 1878 is burial date - death date is correct.
Drummond-27
H
1571 David Drummond Second Lord Drummond (Drummond) uncertain 1515 Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 1572 Perthshire, Scotland Male Blair-3347

Walker-2526
Q61467026 David Drummond, 2nd Lord Drummond ((c. 1516-1571)) 1516 Perthshire United Kingdom 1571 Perthshire United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:36:30 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Nairn-227
H
26 Jul 1764 David Nairn IIIrd of Drumkilbo (Nairn) aka Nairne uncertain 1715 uncertain Meigle, Perthshire, Scotland before 29 Aug 1764 uncertain Meigle, Perthshire, Scotland Male Perkins-11750
Q76149913 David Nairne of Drumkilbo (Peerage person ID=565458) 1720 26 Jul 1764 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:14:30 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Stewart-9491
H
1605 Lady Dorothea Countess of Tullibardine Murray (Stewart) uncertain 1581 Atholl, Scotland after 1610 uncertain Tullibardine, Perthshire, Scotland Female Foster-5383

Thomas-10705
Q75264893 Lady Dorothea Stewart (Peerage person ID=22303) 1581 1605 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gray-8215 22.11.2023 02:13:45 Corrected Fixed incorrect Wikidata date
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:57:30 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Stewart-4608
H
1605 Dorothea Stewart Countess of Gowrie (Stewart) after 1541 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland 1 Jan 1627 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Female Gordon-7317
Q61466985 Dorothea Stewart (Peerage person ID=109227) 1605 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:50:16 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Chisholm-844
H
1500 Sir Edmund Chisholm Ist of Cromlix (Chisholm) before 1436 certain Scotland before 15 Mar 1518 uncertain Male Shelton-1487
Q76112499 Edmund Chisholm, 1st of Cromlix (Peerage person ID=539513) 1453 1500 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 20:53:38 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Woodford-421
H
1624 Countess Elizabeth Ruthven (Woodford) uncertain 1590 Brightwell, Berkshire, England 1 Jan 1627 Perthshire, Scotland Female Crum-2235
Q75544050 Elizabeth Woodford (Peerage person ID=204929) 1583 1624 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:59:27 Comment Thepeerage is not reliable
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:26:43 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Drummond-39
H
1501 Eupheme Euphame Drummond Lady Fleming (Drummond) uncertain 1470 Innerpeffray, Crief, Perthshire, Scotland certain May 1502 Cumbernauld, Lanarkshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Q75431800 Euphemia Drummond (Peerage person ID=137692) 1470 1501 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:23:40 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Buchanan-283
H
Jan 1571 George Buchanan 1546 Jan 1599 Luss, Dunbartonshire, , Scotland Male Langford-501
Q75273063 Sir George Buchanan of that Ilk (Peerage person ID=29002) 1546 Jan 1571 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:51:48 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Hay-298
H
1573 Sir George Hay Seventh Earl of Erroll (Hay) 1508 Perthshire, Scotland certain 30 Jan 1574 Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Thomas-10705
Q983215 George Hay, 7th Earl of Erroll (Scottish Earl (1508-1573)) 1508 Errol United Kingdom 1573 Perth United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 29.03.2020 03:07:30 False suggestion
Ogilvy-577
H
7 Jun 1661 Captain George Ogilvy uncertain 1600 Smiddiehill, Coupar Angus, Perthshire, Scotland Jan 1661 Brunn, Lower Austria, Austria Male Blair-3347
Q76007762 George Ogilvy of Muirtown (Peerage person ID=463592) 1605 7 Jun 1661 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:00:48 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Haldane-180
H
May 1777 Helen Haldane uncertain 1706 Gleneagles Scotland certain 15 Jan 1778 Lundie, Angus Scotland Female Wiegand-310
Q75536014 Helen Haldane (Peerage person ID=200575) 1702 May 1777 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:15:32 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Shepherd-4861
H
15 May 1903 James Shepherd uncertain 1822 Clackmannan, Clackmannanshire, Scotland, United Kingdom 16 May 1903 Rangiora, Canterbury, New Zealand Male Doig-176
Q75691616 James Shepherd ((1822-1903)) 2 Dec 1822 15 May 1903 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Doig-176 21.10.2022 10:47:29 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Stewart-2652
H
1605 Janet Kennedy (Stewart) aka Stuart uncertain 1566 Ochiltree, Perth, Scotland 29 Mar 1627 Scotland Female Smith-165384
Q75090921 Jean Stewart, Lady Bargany (Peerage person ID=465155) 1605 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:55:00 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Oliphant-73
H
23 Jan 1446 Sir John Oliphant 1416 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland 23 Jan 1445 Arbroath, Angus, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75556749 Sir John Oliphant of Aberdalgie (Peerage person ID=210871) 1416 23 Jan 1446 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 20:48:23 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Cuninghame-19
H
1604 Lady Katherine Cuninghame aka Fergusson before 1558 Glencairn, Dumfries, Scotland uncertain 1610 uncertain Gleneagles Manor, Auchterarder, Perthshire, Scotland Female Cepulis-1

Bridge-801
Q76045741 Lady Jean Cuninghame (Peerage person ID=491797) 1604 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:53:56 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Menteith-110
H
21 Jul 1628 Margaret Bruce (Menteith) uncertain 1590 Kerse, Stirlingshire, Scotland uncertain 1650 Kinnaird, Perthshire, Scotland Female Stratman-17
Q76262243 Margaret Menteith (Peerage person ID=645845) 1590 21 Jul 1628 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:59:38 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Ruthven-29
H
1548 Margaret Countess of Buchan Erskine (Ruthven) aka Stewart, Wood uncertain 1483 uncertain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland certain 5 Aug 1540 certain Dun, Angus, Scotland Female Orphan
Q75268421 Margaret Ruthven (Peerage person ID=25018) 1483 1548 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:27:22 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Graham-1144
H
1546 Lady Margaret Graham Countess of Argyll (Graham) uncertain 1522 uncertain Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 18 Jul 1556 certain Falkland, Fife, Scotland Female Simmons-11603
Q75262506 Lady Margaret Graham (Peerage person ID=20516) 1522 1546 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Simmons-11603 28.11.2023 16:51:31 False suggestion Sent approximate
Campbell-189
H
Feb 1572 Lady Margaret Stewart (Campbell) uncertain 1546 Doune, Perth, Scotland after Feb 1592 Scotland Female Gordon-7317
Q75264606 Lady Margaret Campbell (Peerage person ID=22083) Feb 1572 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:27:18 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Stewart-3215
H
26 Jul 1524 Mariote Marjory Stewart aka Stuart uncertain 1490 Of, Balveny, Fifeshire, Scotland uncertain 26 Jul 1529 Island of Lochtay, Perthshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75451712 Lady Marjory Stewart (Peerage person ID=150490) 1490 26 Jul 1524 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 23.11.2020 07:03:38 False suggestion date not sourced
Graham-13967
H
Dec 1720 Mary Allardice (Graham) before 12 Dec 1641 certain Perthshire, Scotland certain Nov 1720 certain Kincardineshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75240924 Mary Graham (Peerage person ID=3053) Dec 1720 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Graham-17201 29.10.2022 21:25:39 False suggestion The Scots Peerage (Paul, p.142) gives the death as
Drummond-300
H
1600 Patrick Drummond Third Lord Drummond (Drummond) 1556 Drummond, Perthshire, Scotland 18 Dec 1611 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Ratliff-242
Q75264073 Patrick Drummond, 3rd Lord Drummond (Peerage person ID=21685) 1550 1500 1600 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:53:32 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Graham-3630
H
1536 Patrick Graham Ist of Inchbrakie and Aberuthven (Graham) uncertain 1508 certain Inchbrakie, Perthshire, Scotland certain 1538 certain Inchbrakie, Perthshire, Scotland Male Boone-1915
Q75388570 Patrick Graham, 1st of Inchbrakie and Aberuthven (Peerage person ID=108287) 1508 1536 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:33:42 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Gray-1566
H
1462 Patrick Master of Gray Gray uncertain 1410 Broxmouth, Roxburghshire, Scotland before 1 Sep 1464 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75272205 Patrick Gray, Master of Gray (Peerage person ID=28220) 1410 1462 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 20:42:15 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Hay-2537
H
Aug 1603 Patrick of Megginch Hay certain 19 Nov 1555 certain Errol, Perthshire, Scotland certain May 1603 uncertain Errol, Perthshire, Scotland Male Blair-3347
Q75662697 Patrick Hay, 5th of Megginch (Peerage person ID=278695) 19 Nov 1555 Aug 1603 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:53:20 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Hay-3456
H
27 Sep 1787 Thomas 9th Earl of Kinnoull, Viscount Dupplin Hay certain 4 Jul 1710 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland certain 27 Dec 1787 Male Orphan
Q965796 Thomas Hay, 9th Earl of Kinnoull (Scottish earl and British politician (1710-1787)) 4 Jul 1710 27 Sep 1787 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
moore-27439 24.07.2018 17:27:59 False suggestion Wikidata and wikitree dates are the same, I have no idea where 1787-09-27 is coming from
Drummond-54
H
1455 Sir Walter Drummond of Cargill and Stobhall (Drummond) uncertain 1380 certain Stobhill, Perth, Scotland uncertain 1445 uncertain Midlothian, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75275013 Sir Walter Drummond of Cargill and Stobhall (Peerage person ID=30589) 1380 1455 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 19:19:10 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Drummond-165
H
1503 William Drummond Master of Drummond (Drummond) uncertain 1460 Innerpeffray, Crief, Perthshire, Scotland before Jul 1504 uncertain Drummond Castle, Crieff, Perthshire, Scotland Male Kinman-87
Q75272106 William Drummond, Master of Drummond (Peerage person ID=28132) 1460 1503 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:15:56 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Oliphant-731
H
1329 Sir William of Aberdalgie Oliphant Knt. uncertain 1270 certain 5 Feb 1330 certain Aberdalgie, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Stevens-17832
Q8016335 William Oliphant, Lord of Aberdalgie (Scottish magnate and military leader) 1329 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stevens-17832 30.07.2020 00:57:16 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced, this profile is sourced
Preston-1457
H
14 Nov 1703 Sir William Preston of Valleyfield (Preston) 2nd Bt uncertain 1642 Valleyfield, Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 1704 uncertain Male Lauder-514
Q75408447 Sir William Preston, 2nd Bt. (Peerage person ID=123285) 1642 14 Nov 1703 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:07:25 False suggestion Thepeerage is not reliable
Murray-3654
H
1626 Sir William Second Earl of Tullibardine Murray after 1574 certain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland before 30 Jan 1628 uncertain London, England Male Thomas-10705

Foster-5383
Q75264695 William Murray, 2nd Earl of Tullibardine (Peerage person ID=22145) 1574 1626 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gray-8215 02.10.2023 14:14:36 False suggestion WikiData is wrong. Had issue in 1828