Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Warning 563: Wikidata - Possible duplicate by father Help (Difficulty: Advanced)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Robertson-10181
H
Compare Sir Alexander 9th of Glenerochie Robertson aka 5th of Struan Wikitree Father 1440 Male Orphan
Robertson-3055
H
Alexander Robertson IXth of Glenerochie Vth Chief (Robertson) of Strowan Wikidata Father uncertain 1420 certain Scotland 26 Mar 1505 Scotland Male Orphan
Q76141900 Mary Robertson (Peerage person ID=560312) 1464 female
Q76141885 Alexander Robertson, 9th of Glenerochie, 5th Chief of Clan Donnachaidh (Peerage person ID=560301) male
Q76141885 Alexander Robertson, 9th of Glenerochie, 5th Chief of Clan Donnachaidh (Peerage person ID=560301) male
Chisholm-2657
H
Compare Alexander of Kinrossie Chisholm Wikitree Father uncertain 1402 Kinrossie, Perthshire Scotland uncertain 1435 Kinrossie, Perthshire, Scotland Male Blair-3347
Chisholm-1850
H
Alexander de Chisholm VIIIth Chisholm of Chisholm (Chisholm) Wikidata Father uncertain 1380 uncertain 1440 Male Sutherland-Fisher-1

Stratman-17
Q75570865 Alexander de Chisholme of Chisholm (Peerage person ID=218975) 1380 1440 male
Q75388360 Katherine Chisholme (Peerage person ID=108140) 1418 1456 female
Robertson-3055
H
Compare Alexander Robertson IXth of Glenerochie Vth Chief (Robertson) of Strowan Wikitree Father uncertain 1420 certain Scotland 26 Mar 1505 Scotland Male Orphan
Robertson-10181
H
Sir Alexander 9th of Glenerochie Robertson aka 5th of Struan Wikidata Father 1440 Male Orphan
Q76141885 Alexander Robertson, 9th of Glenerochie, 5th Chief of Clan Donnachaidh (Peerage person ID=560301) male
Q75269954 Margaret Robertson (Peerage person ID=26291) 1573 female
Q76141885 Alexander Robertson, 9th of Glenerochie, 5th Chief of Clan Donnachaidh (Peerage person ID=560301) male
Robertson-3055
H
Compare Alexander Robertson IXth of Glenerochie Vth Chief (Robertson) of Strowan Wikitree Father uncertain 1420 certain Scotland 26 Mar 1505 Scotland Male Orphan
Robertson-10181
H
Sir Alexander 9th of Glenerochie Robertson aka 5th of Struan Wikidata Father 1440 Male Orphan
Q76141885 Alexander Robertson, 9th of Glenerochie, 5th Chief of Clan Donnachaidh (Peerage person ID=560301) male
Q76141894 Robert Robertson (Peerage person ID=560307) 1450 male
Q76141885 Alexander Robertson, 9th of Glenerochie, 5th Chief of Clan Donnachaidh (Peerage person ID=560301) male
Robertson-5310
H
Compare Alexander Robertson of Strowan (Robertson) Wikitree Father uncertain 1466 Scotland uncertain 1520 Scotland Male Orphan
Robertson-3055
H
Alexander Robertson IXth of Glenerochie Vth Chief (Robertson) of Strowan Wikidata Father uncertain 1420 certain Scotland 26 Mar 1505 Scotland Male Orphan
Q76141885 Alexander Robertson, 9th of Glenerochie, 5th Chief of Clan Donnachaidh (Peerage person ID=560301) male
Q76141906 John Robertson (Peerage person ID=560316) 1498 1540 male
Q76141885 Alexander Robertson, 9th of Glenerochie, 5th Chief of Clan Donnachaidh (Peerage person ID=560301) male
Dunkeld-9
H
Compare Crinan Crínán Abbot of Dunkeld (Dunkeld) Wikitree Father uncertain 975 Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland certain 1045 Dunkeld, Perthshire, Scotland Male Perkins-11750

WikiTree-65
Dunkeld-90
H
Maldred Lord of Allerdale and Carlisle of Scotland (Dunkeld) Wikidata Father uncertain 1003 certain Carlisle, Cumberland, Scotland after 1051 uncertain Winlaton, Durham, England Male WikiTree-65

Lee-759
Q18123097 Maldred (Peerage person ID=106641) 1045 male
Q75387765 unknown daughter of Scotland (Peerage person ID=107687) female
Murray-351
H
Compare Sir David Murray VIIth of Tullibardine (Murray) Wikitree Father 1400 Tullibardine, Blackford, Perthshire, Scotland before 15 Jun 1452 Tullibardine Castle, Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Murray-575
H
Sir William Murray VIIIth of Tullibardine (Murray) Wikidata Father certain 1432 Tullibardine Castle, Blackford, Perth, Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 1459 Tullibardine Castle, Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q75267242 Sir William Murray of Tullibardine (Peerage person ID=24076) 1432 15 Jun 1452 male
Q75637545 Christian Murray (Peerage person ID=262637) 1436 female
Murray-352
H
Compare Sir David Murray VIth of Tullibardine (Murray) Wikitree Father 1359 Tullibardine, Blackford, Perthshire, Scotland 1446 Tullibardine, Blackford, Perthshire, Scotland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Murray-351
H
Sir David Murray VIIth of Tullibardine (Murray) Wikidata Father 1400 Tullibardine, Blackford, Perthshire, Scotland before 15 Jun 1452 Tullibardine Castle, Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q75267248 Sir David Murray of Tullibardine (Peerage person ID=24080) 1400 male
Q75662335 Elna Murray (Peerage person ID=278554) 1458 female
Hay-3116
H
Compare Sir Gilbert de Haya Vth of Errol (Hay) aka de la Haye Wikitree Father uncertain 1266 uncertain Errol, Perthshire, Scotland certain Apr 1333 certain Aberdeen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Keith-1290
H
Sir John Keith of Innerpeffer (Keith) Wikidata Father uncertain 1294 uncertain Scotland certain 1324 certain Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75662160 unknown daughter Keith (Peerage person ID=278491) 1316 female
Q75518783 Sir John Keith of Innerpeffer (Peerage person ID=190148) male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 17.03.2022 23:33:14 Corrected Bio/sources currently being updated.
Moncreiffe-1
H
Compare Sir John of that ilk, 9th of Moncreiffe Moncreiffe Wikitree Father uncertain 1475 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland certain 9 Sep 1513 certain Flodden Field, Northumberland, England Male Orphan
Moncreiffe-18
H
John Ninth of that ilk Moncreiffe Wikidata Father uncertain 1510 9 Sep 1513 Male Thomas-10705
Q75544099 William Moncreiffe, 10th of that Ilk (Peerage person ID=204957) 1500 15 Dec 1579 male
Q75662180 Sir John Moncreiffe, 9th of that Ilk (Peerage person ID=278501) 1510 9 Sep 1513 male
Moncreiffe-1
H
Compare Sir John of that ilk, 9th of Moncreiffe Moncreiffe Wikitree Father uncertain 1475 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland certain 9 Sep 1513 certain Flodden Field, Northumberland, England Male Orphan
Moncreiffe-18
H
John Ninth of that ilk Moncreiffe Wikidata Father uncertain 1510 9 Sep 1513 Male Thomas-10705
Q76178101 Agnes Moncreiffe (Peerage person ID=584422) 1525 female
Q75662180 Sir John Moncreiffe, 9th of that Ilk (Peerage person ID=278501) 1510 9 Sep 1513 male
Moncreiffe-1
H
Compare Sir John of that ilk, 9th of Moncreiffe Moncreiffe Wikitree Father uncertain 1475 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland certain 9 Sep 1513 certain Flodden Field, Northumberland, England Male Orphan
Moncreiffe-18
H
John Ninth of that ilk Moncreiffe Wikidata Father uncertain 1510 9 Sep 1513 Male Thomas-10705
Q76364508 Elizabeth Moncreiffe (Peerage person ID=713209) 1500 16 Jun 1570 female
Q75662180 Sir John Moncreiffe, 9th of that Ilk (Peerage person ID=278501) 1510 9 Sep 1513 male
Russell-4692
H
Compare Sir John Russell Wikitree Father uncertain 1200 Male Orphan
Comyn-46
H
Walter Lord of Badenoch, 4th Earl of Menteith Comyn Wikidata Father 1190 Buchan, Aberdeenshire, , Scotland uncertain Nov 1258 Perth, Perthshire, , Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75242569 Isabel Comyn (Peerage person ID=4663) female
Q2543918 Walter Comyn, Lord of Badenoch (Scottish noble (died 1258)) 12000101 Dec 1258 male
Gray-4943
H
Compare Patrick Gray Third Lord Gray (Gray) Wikitree Father after 1463 certain Scotland certain Apr 1541 certain Castle Huntly, Dundee, Forfarshire, Scotland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Gray-13159
H
Patrick Gray IVth of Buttergask (Gray) Wikidata Father uncertain Feb 1508 certain Buttergask, Perthshire, Scotland certain 1584 certain Buttergask, Perthshire, Scotland Male Carson-514

Miles-436

Thexton-103

Henderson-5558
Q75581021 Janet Gray (Peerage person ID=224720) 1580 female
Q7146599 Patrick Gray, 4th Lord Gray (Scottish landowner) 1518 1584 male
Ogilvy-417
H
Compare Sir Patrick Ogilvy IVth of Inchmartine (Ogilvy) Wikitree Father uncertain 1487 certain Scotland uncertain 1555 Scotland Male Blair-3347
Ogilvy-419
H
Patrick Ogilvy VIth of Inchmartine (Ogilvy) Wikidata Father uncertain 1546 Inchture, Perthshire, Scotland before 24 May 1623 Perthshire, Scotland Male Blair-3347
Q76306537 Janet Ogilvy (Peerage person ID=676746) 1525 1570 female
Q75580813 Patrick Ogilvy of Inchmartine (Peerage person ID=224601) 1546 male
Crichton-65
H
Compare Sir Robert Crichton Second Lord of Sanquhar (Crichton) Wikitree Father before 1472 certain Sanquhar, Dumfriesshire, Scotland certain 9 Sep 1513 certain Battle of Flodden, Branxton, Northumberland, England Male Orphan
Crichton-6
H
Robert Crichton of Kinnoull (Crichton) Wikidata Father uncertain 1457 uncertain Riccanton, West Lothian, Scotland uncertain 1491 uncertain Kinnoull, Perthshire, Scotland Male Nilsen-785
Q76307693 Margaret Crichton (Peerage person ID=677601) 1474 1520 female
Q75243254 Robert Crichton of Kinnoull (Peerage person ID=5237) 1457 1491 male
Haliburton-6
H
Compare Walter Halburton (Haliburton) aka Halyburton Wikitree Father before 1389 Dirleton Castle, Haddingtonshire, Scotland before 10 May 1447 uncertain Gask, Perthshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Haliburton-7
H
Sir Walter Haliburton Knt. aka of Dirletoun Wikidata Father 1364 Scotland before 10 May 1447 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q75388144 Walter Haliburton (Peerage person ID=107985) 1364 male
Q75388148 Christian Haliburton (Peerage person ID=107989) 1508 female