Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information 
.
| Link |
Info |
Name |
Rel. |
Birth |
Death |
Gender |
|
Manager |
Marriage |
Status |
Stewart-3827
 H   |
8 May 1630 |
Alexander Stewart aka Steward |
|
certain 1635 certain Perthshire, Scotland |
certain 1731 certain Marlborough, Middlesex, Massachusetts Bay |
Male |
 |
Stewart-47649
|
|
|
| 145536064 |
Alexander Stewart |
|
8 May 1630 Scotland |
6 Apr 1731 Marlboro, Essex County, Massachusetts, USA |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
20.05.2020 07:53:33 |
Comment |
message sent to PM |
| Carruth-363 |
08.06.2020 03:00:10 |
Merge proposed |
Unmatched Merge proposed with comment left on both profiles |
| Langsdorf-34 |
15.11.2023 21:04:18 |
False suggestion |
no source on findagrave |
|
Rattray-36
H |
4 Apr 1779 |
John Rattray |
|
uncertain Jan 1757 certain Kirkmichael, Perth, Scotland |
uncertain 13 Mar 1831 uncertain Blairgowrie, Perthshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Rattray-277
|
|
|
| 151701937 |
Jean Rattray Duff |
|
4 Apr 1779 |
31 Aug 1853 |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Stewart-39100 |
01.08.2022 05:53:28 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Wemyss-186
H |
1466 |
Isobell Elizabeth, Margaret, Isabel Wemyss |
|
1468 Aberdeen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
after 16 Aug 1524 Perthshire, Scotland |
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| 133010893 |
Margaret Isobel Wemyss Forbes |
|
1466 Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
16 Aug 1524 |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| anderson-23510 |
01.10.2019 18:59:47 |
False suggestion |
DoB is unsourced |
|
Kennedy-10283
H |
27 May 1769 |
Alexander Kennedy |
|
before 1 Jan 1761 Dull, Perthshire, Scotland |
1852 Hadley, Saratoga, New York, United States |
Male |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| 73080050 |
Alexander Kennedy |
|
27 May 1769 Edinburgh, City of Edinburgh, Scotland |
1852 |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| willhite-329 |
01.04.2017 00:30:35 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree birth date is correct; FindAGrave no source |
|
McEwen-766
H |
14 Feb 1770 |
Jean Jane Kennedy (McEwen) |
|
24 Oct 1777 Muthill, Perthshire, Scotland |
1856 Hadley, Saratoga, New York, United States |
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| 73080089 |
Jane McEwan Kennedy |
|
14 Feb 1770 Edinburgh, City of Edinburgh, Scotland |
1856 Hadley, Saratoga County, New York, USA |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| willhite-329 |
01.04.2017 00:31:16 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree birth date is correct; FindAGrave no source |
|
Penny-1241
H |
15 May 1857 |
William Penny II |
|
certain 20 May 1781 certain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland, |
uncertain 21 Sep 1897 certain Colombo, Western, Sri Lanka |
Male |
|
Pennie-22
|
|
|
| 216105299 |
William Woodman Penny |
|
15 May 1857 Crimond, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
21 Sep 1897 Colombo, Colombo District, Western, Sri Lanka |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
15.12.2022 07:38:10 |
Comment |
sent message to PM to add template and explain why it is on both profiles. |
| Pennie-22 |
07.03.2023 21:48:54 |
Corrected |
|
| pENNIE-22 |
07.03.2023 21:58:50 |
False suggestion |
ot same person in find a grave birth date not same date or place |
| pENNIE-22 |
07.03.2023 21:59:34 |
Comment |
not same person |
|
Sword-120
H |
22 Jun 1842 |
Thomas Robertson Sword aka Robertson |
|
before 21 Jun 1843 Forgandenny, near Methven, Perthshire, Scotland |
8 May 1927 Fairview, Rollette, North Dakota, USA |
Male |
|
Smith-123128
|
|
|
| 114855322 |
Thomas Stuart Robertson |
|
22 Jun 1842 Perth and Kinross, Scotland |
8 May 1927 Rolette County, North Dakota, USA |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Smith-123128 |
12.11.2020 17:57:57 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree birth date is correct as per Scottish birth records. The memorial stone is incorrect, but notice how close it is to the date in the Scottish records. This is somewhat discussed on the profile. |
|
Menzies-1928
H |
24 Jan 1831 |
Andrew McLaren Menzies Snr |
|
certain 18 Feb 1829 certain 'Kineldon', Snuffy Butts, Airntully, Perthshire, Scotland |
certain 22 Jan 1901 certain 'Hyde Park', Kyabram East, Victoria, Australia |
Male |
|
Howard-18870
|
|
|
| 230813850 |
Andrew McLaren Menzies |
|
24 Jan 1831 Kinclaven, Perth and Kinross, Scotland |
22 Jan 1901 Kyabram, Campaspe Shire, Victoria, Australia |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Howard-18870 |
29.06.2023 01:16:16 |
False suggestion |
DoB is correct per birth record |
|
Salmond-259
H |
6 Jun 1824 |
Joseph Salmond |
|
19 Nov 1822 Auchtergaven, Perthshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
7 May 1902 Somenos, British Columbia, Canada |
Male |
|
Mutter-136
|
|
|
| 230125281 |
Joseph Salmond |
|
6 Jun 1824 |
7 May 1902 |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Mutter-136 |
24.05.2023 10:36:48 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Danner-1409
H |
1842 |
Caroline Blumenstein (Danner) |
|
uncertain 1839 Germany |
certain 4 Jul 1906 certain Aberfoyle, Perthshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Bates-10490
|
|
|
| 212605141 |
Caroline Danner Blumenstein |
|
1842 Germany |
4 Jul 1906 Aberfoyle, Stirling, Scotland |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Bates-10490 |
27.07.2021 20:17:49 |
False suggestion |
findagrave disagrees with 3 census returns |
|
Forbes-6832
H |
17 Aug 1840 |
Margaret Miller (Forbes) |
|
13 Oct 1840 Kilmadock, Perthshire, Scotland |
12 Jun 1869 Rockford, Winnebago, Illinois, United States |
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| 204661516 |
Margaret Forbes Miller |
|
17 Aug 1840 |
12 Jun 1869 Rockford, Winnebago County, Illinois, USA |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| colville-218 |
12.10.2021 20:42:06 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Saunders-12164
H |
28 Mar 1883 |
Charles Saunders |
|
6 Mar 1885 Muthill, Perthshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
19 Nov 1965 North Delta, British Columbia, Canada |
Male |
|
Fremmerlid-1
|
|
|
| 167370584 |
Charles Saunders |
|
28 Mar 1883 Crieff, Perth and Kinross, Scotland |
19 Nov 1965 North Delta, Greater Vancouver Regional District, British Columbia, Canada |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Fremmerlid-1 |
23.11.2021 19:23:02 |
False suggestion |
birth correct per birth record. |
|
Saunders-12170
H |
13 Aug 1889 |
John Burnett Saunders |
|
13 Aug 1890 Crieff, Perthshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
18 Dec 1956 Los Angeles, California, United States |
Male |
|
Fremmerlid-1
|
|
|
| 98690738 |
John Burnet Saunders |
|
13 Aug 1889 Perth and Kinross, Scotland |
18 Dec 1956 Los Angeles County, California, USA |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Fremmerlid-1 |
23.11.2021 19:24:48 |
False suggestion |
DoB is correct per birth record |
|
Patterson-23563
H |
1802 |
Helen Mitchell (Patterson) |
|
1805 Perthshire, Scotland |
Nov 1847 Perth, Ontario, Canada |
Female |
|
Smith-241759
|
|
|
| 169427231 |
Ellen Patterson Mitchell |
|
1802 |
Nov 1847 Ontario, Canada |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Smith-241759 |
27.10.2022 12:56:05 |
False suggestion |
inscription is in error |
|
Mcdonald-29646
H |
24 Nov 1829 |
Christian Menzies (Mcdonald) |
|
certain 20 Dec 1832 certain Auchlenie, Perthshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
certain 10 Aug 1923 certain Danbury, Fairfield, Connecticut, United States |
Female |
|
Howard-18870
|
|
|
| 34504263 |
Christine MacDonald Menzies |
|
24 Nov 1829 Aberfeldy, Perth and Kinross, Scotland |
10 Aug 1923 Danbury, Fairfield County, Connecticut, USA |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Howard-18870 |
29.06.2023 01:13:20 |
False suggestion |
inscription is in error. Refer to Research Notes on profile. |
| Howard-18870 |
29.06.2023 01:13:50 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree birth date is correct. |
|
Riach-242
H |
1794 |
Catherine Drysdale (Riach) |
|
1796 Auchtergaven, Perthshire, Scotland |
31 Jan 1855 Aberdeen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Bremford-24
|
|
|
| 124383828 |
Catherine Roach Drysdale |
|
1794 Aberdeen, Aberdeen City, Scotland |
31 Jan 1855 Aberdeen, Aberdeen City, Scotland |
|
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Bremford-24 |
22.01.2024 21:52:40 |
False suggestion |
FindAGrave is estimate |
|
(Difficulty: Intermediate)