Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 310: Mother was dead before birth (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information .

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
Hume-2749 H		Jane Hume	Mother	before 1800 scotland	after 1800	Female		Knight-26029
Scott-58552 H		Francis Scott	Child	uncertain 27 Jul 1834 certain Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 28 Mar 1915 East Lismore, New South Wales, Australia	Male		Knight-26029
Mckean-624 H		Margaret Mckean	Mother	uncertain 1800	uncertain 1850	Female		Orphan
Wilson-17889 H		Margaret Meffen (Wilson)	Child	25 Apr 1857 Scotland	9 Dec 1893 Scotland	Female		Orphan
Monroe-2133 H		Jane Monroe	Mother	uncertain 1800 Scotland	uncertain 1850 Scotland	Female		Claine-3
Garrity-178 H		James John Garrity	Child	uncertain 1881 Dundee, Scotland	Dundee, Scotland	Male		Claine-3
Gillie-235 H		Jean Durie (Gillie)	Mother	uncertain 1801	uncertain 1830 uncertain	Female		Durie-268
Durie-321 H		David Durie	Child	uncertain 11 Jan 1839	not living	Male		Hendrikse-103
Gillie-235 H		Jean Durie (Gillie)	Mother	uncertain 1801	uncertain 1830 uncertain	Female		Durie-268
Durie-320 H		James Durie	Child	uncertain 7 Apr 1834	not living	Male		Hendrikse-103
Gillie-235 H		Jean Durie (Gillie)	Mother	uncertain 1801	uncertain 1830 uncertain	Female		Durie-268
Durie-323 H		Helen Durie	Child	certain 9 May 1846	not living	Female		Hendrikse-103
Gillie-235 H		Jean Durie (Gillie)	Mother	uncertain 1801	uncertain 1830 uncertain	Female		Durie-268
Durie-322 H		Elizabeth Durie	Child	certain 27 Apr 1836	not living	Female		Hendrikse-103
Gillie-235 H		Jean Durie (Gillie)	Mother	uncertain 1801	uncertain 1830 uncertain	Female		Durie-268
Durie-326 H		Ann Durie	Child	uncertain 1831	not living	Female		Hendrikse-103
Gillie-235 H		Jean Durie (Gillie)	Mother	uncertain 1801	uncertain 1830 uncertain	Female		Durie-268
Durie-327 H		Alexander Durie	Child	uncertain 1842	not living	Male		Hendrikse-103
McGee-2845 H		Elizabeth McGee	Mother	certain 1 Jul 1807 Paisley, Renfrewshire, Scotland	uncertain 1843 Paisley, Renfrewshire, Scotland	Female		McFadyen-146
McFadyen-304 H		Ann McFadyen	Child	1848 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland		Female		McFadyen-146
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Taylor-53997 16.02.2019 19:07:42 Corrected
Algie-111 H		Mary Smith (Algie)	Mother	uncertain 1810	after 1810	Female		Wilson-21458
Smith-71404 H		Agnes Marshall (Smith)	Child	certain 1832 certain Crossmyloof Village, Scotland	after 1832	Female		Wilson-21458
MacRae-333 H		Anne McPherson (MacRae)	Mother	before 1810	after 1821	Female		Pike-1658
McPherson-1455 H		John McPherson	Child	certain 23 Oct 1823 certain Arinacrinachd, Ross-shire, Scotland	certain 23 Nov 1903 certain Applecross, Ross-shire, Scotland	Male		Pike-1658
Kennedy-11296 H		Helen Kennedy	Mother	1810 Kingussie, Invernesse, Scotland	1840 Scotland	Female		Prs-1
McPherson-2921 H		James P McPherson	Child	1842		Male		Prs-1
Greig-2299 H		Margaret Hogg (Greig)	Mother	uncertain 1811 Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 1840	Female		Forster-2323
Hogg-4690 H		Alexander Hogg	Child	28 Feb 1846 St Andrews, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 1899	Male		Forster-2323
Stewart-6429 H		Margaret Stewart	Mother	1811 Scotland	17 Feb 1844 Kilsyth, Stirling, Scotland	Female		Orphan
Stirling-228 H		Stewart Stirling	Child	17 Mar 1844 Kilsyth, Stirling, Scotland		Male		Orphan
Grierson-801 H		Elizabeth Dickson (Grierson)	Mother	uncertain 1812	after 1831	Female		Kruse-2474
Dickson-6738 H		Mary Dickson	Child	uncertain 1832 Scotland	uncertain 1906	Female		Kruse-2474
Carmichael-329 H		Janet Carmichael	Mother	1819 , , Scotland	uncertain 1861 Beckwith, Lanark, Ontario, Canada	Female		Orphan
McTavish-7 H		Robert McTavish	Child	uncertain 1863 Beckwith, Lanark County, Ontario, Canada	29 Nov 1920 Perth, Ontario, Canada	Male		Orphan
Miller-5984 H		Helen Ross (Miller)	Mother	8 Feb 1819 Bankfoot, Perth, Scotland	17 Nov 1858 Salt Lake City, Salt Lake, Utah	Female		Orphan
Ross-8987 H		John L. Ross	Child	1859 Salt Lake City, Utah, United States	1900 Salt Lake City, Salt Lake, Utah, United States	Male		Orphan
Spence-1814 H		Mary Drummond (Spence)	Mother	uncertain 1820	uncertain 1850	Female		Macdonald-4153
Drummond-1243 H		Mary Drummond	Child	certain 29 Nov 1856 Greenock, Renfrew, Scotland	uncertain 1910	Female		Macdonald-4153
McNiel-134 H		Catherine Farnham (McNiel)	Mother	1820 Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 1852 Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, United States	Female		Orphan
Farnham-1369 H		Jeanette Farnham aka Anderson	Child	uncertain 1875 New Brunswick, Canada	1954 Lapeer, Michigan, United States	Female		Orphan

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
Hamilton-10090 H		Jane White (Hamilton)	Mother	certain 29 Jun 1820 Headshaw, Channelkirk, Selkirkshire, Scotland	certain 28 Apr 1877 Galashiels, Selkirkshire, Scotland	Female		Finkeldey-1
White-20980 H		Walter Anderson White	Child	certain 26 Feb 1886 Boston, MA	certain 31 Mar 1938 Norwood, MA	Male		Finkeldey-1
Murray-13783 H		Elizabeth Murray	Mother	certain 15 May 1823 Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 12 Jun 1860 Connecticut, United States	Female		Orphan
Hutcheon-147 H		William Hutcheon	Child	certain 31 May 1861 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 30 Nov 1909 Edingburgh Scotland	Male		Leonard-11166
McClinton-39 H		Mary McClinton	Mother	uncertain 1824 Scotland	1851 Texas, USA	Female		Weick-29
Brown-41073 H		Josephine Elvira Brown	Child	21 Jul 1858 Titus, Texas, United States	31 Jul 1933 Jefferson County, Kansas, USA	Female		Weick-29
Scott-9871 H		Beatrice Thomson (Scott)	Mother	uncertain 1824 Castteton, Roxburgh	certain 15 Jan 1878 Kirkton, Roxburghshire, Scotland	Female		Thomson-3350
Thomson-15315 H		Wilhelmina mina Scott (Thomson) aka Thomson	Child	uncertain 1880 uncertain Castleton, Scottish Borders, Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 7 Oct 1967 uncertain Castleton, Scottish Borders, Scotland, United Kingdom	Female		Devenish-531
Anderson-16940 H		Elizabeth Bessie Newton (Anderson)	Mother	28 Apr 1825 Renfrew, Scotland	9 Nov 1896 Ladysmith, Natal, South Africa	Female		Doidge-137 Collier-1443
Newton-9651 H		Isabella Newton	Child	uncertain 1916 Ladysmith, South Africa	uncertain 1932	Female		Paul-3679
McIntosh-7996 H		Christine McKenzie (McIntosh)	Mother	18 May 1826 Killearnan, Ross-shire, Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 5 Apr 1895 Urray, Ross-shire, Scotland	Female		Botha-5861
McKenzie-10862 H		Catherine Quinn (McKenzie)	Child	certain 14 Feb 1905 Scotland	certain 14 Mar 1925 Manhattan, New York City, New York, United States	Female		Botha-5861
Craig-3707 H		Marion Mann (Craig)	Mother	1827	uncertain 1844 uncertain Scotland	Female		Dalziel-133
Mann-3772 H		Jane Dalziel (Mann)	Child	4 Nov 1845	1903 uncertain Cambuslang, South Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Female		Dalziel-133
McLeaod-1 H		Julia McLennan (McLeaod)	Mother	uncertain 1827 Isle of Fladda	certain 13 Mar 1857 Isle of Fladda, Raasay, Scotland	Female		Pike-1658
McLennan-764 H		Christy McPherson (McLennan)	Child	certain 3 Dec 1862 Raasay, Scotland	certain 21 Feb 1946 Applecross, Scotland	Female		Pike-1658
Smith-220186 H		Mary McMillan (Smith)	Mother	uncertain 1827 Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 1869 Oro-Medonte, Simcoe County, Ontario, Canada	Female		McCormack-709
McMillan-1818 H		John Allan McMillan	Child	1 Apr 1870 Finch, Ontario, Canada		Male		McCormack-709
Dunlop-259 H		Margaret Tuite (Dunlop)	Mother	certain 1829 Scotland	after 1854 Belleville, Ontario, Canada	Female		Graham-4034
Tuite-35 H		Robert Tuite	Child	certain 1857 Belleville, Ontario, Canada	certain 1921 Belleville, Ontario, Canada	Male		Graham-4034
Dunlop-259 H		Margaret Tuite (Dunlop)	Mother	certain 1829 Scotland	after 1854 Belleville, Ontario, Canada	Female		Graham-4034
Tuite-63 H		Christopher Tuite	Child	certain 14 Apr 1866 Canada West	28 Jul 1918 Cleveland, Ohio, United States	Male		Locke-2058
Morgan-34938 H		Charlotte Stewart (Morgan)	Mother	uncertain 1830 Scotland, United Kingdom	after 1854 Scotland, United Kingdom	Female		Spence-5787
Stewart-48907 H		Jane Gray (Stewart)	Child	uncertain 1855 Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 1899 Scotland, United Kingdom	Female		Spence-5787
Wright-906 H		Elizabeth Mitchell (Wright)	Mother	uncertain 1830 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 1855 Kaukauna, Outagamie, Wisconsin, USA	Female		Robinson-11703
Mitchell-7672 H		William William Alexander Alexander Mitchell	Child	uncertain May 1856 certain Scotland	certain 11 Oct 1943 certain Maple Hill, Wabaunsee, Kansas, USA	Male		Robinson-11703 Steele-2775
Biglie-4 H		Ann Hanvidge (Biglie)	Mother	uncertain 1830 Thornliebank. Glasgow, Scotland	certain 4 Dec 1877 Thornliebank, Glasgow, Scotland	Female		Rossborough-8
Hanvidge-1 H		Sarah Todd Sadie Rossborough (Hanvidge)	Child	certain 1 Feb 1900 Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom	uncertain 1976 Braintree, Norfolk, Massachusetts, United States	Female		Rossborough-8
Smith-71404 H		Agnes Marshall (Smith)	Mother	certain 1832 certain Crossmyloof Village, Scotland	after 1832	Female		Wilson-21458
Marshall-6175 H		Janet Couper (Marshall)	Child	certain 1865 Scotland	certain 13 Feb 1926 Philadelphia	Female		Wilson-21458
Anderson-23358 H		Margaret Anderson	Mother	1832 Scotland	18 Dec 1854 Guelph, Wellington Co., Ontario, Canada	Female		Orphan
Bruce-3857 H		Elizabeth Bruce	Child	2 Jun 1859 Guelph, Wellington Co., Ontario, Canada	16 Jul 1881 Guelph, Wellington Co., Ontario, Canada	Female		Orphan
Anderson-23358 H		Margaret Anderson	Mother	1832 Scotland	18 Dec 1854 Guelph, Wellington Co., Ontario, Canada	Female		Orphan
Bruce-3854 H		Ann Jane Isabella Bruce	Child	1866 Wellington, Ontario, Canada	13 Jun 1894 Guelph, Wellington, Ontario, Canada	Female		Orphan
Anderson-23358 H		Margaret Anderson	Mother	1832 Scotland	18 Dec 1854 Guelph, Wellington Co., Ontario, Canada	Female		Orphan
Bruce-3855 H		John Baxter Bruce	Child	20 Dec 1867 Wellington, , Ontario, Canada	20 Jan 1892 Guelph, Wellington Co., Ontario, Canada	Male		Orphan
Anderson-23358 H		Margaret Anderson	Mother	1832 Scotland	18 Dec 1854 Guelph, Wellington Co., Ontario, Canada	Female		Orphan
Bruce-3859 H		Alexander Rawer Bruce	Child	20 Dec 1867 Wellington, , Ontario, Canada	22 Jan 1892 Guelph, Wellington Co., Ontario, Canada	Male		Orphan
Anderson-23358 H		Margaret Anderson	Mother	1832 Scotland	18 Dec 1854 Guelph, Wellington Co., Ontario, Canada	Female		Orphan
Bruce-3856 H		Margaret Bruce	Child	1863 Wellington, , Ontario, Canada	29 Feb 1948 Seabrook, Harris Co., Texas	Female		Orphan

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
Anderson-23358 H		Margaret Anderson	Mother	1832 Scotland	18 Dec 1854 Guelph, Wellington Co., Ontario, Canada	Female		Orphan
Bruce-3858 H		Christina Bruce	Child	19 Jul 1861 Wellington, Ontario, Canada	4 Nov 1935 Seabrook, Harris, Texas, USA	Female		Orphan
Dick-963 H		Mrs Grace Hadden (Dick)	Mother	certain 10 Oct 1833 certain Campse, Stirling, Scotland	certain 10 Oct 1850 certain Glasgow Lanark Scotland	Female		Williams-20414
Hadden-234 H		Mrs Helen Mitchell Buchan (Hadden)	Child	certain 1 Sep 1868 certain Glasgow, Scotland	certain 26 May 1955 certain Salisbury, Mashonaland, Southern Rhodesia	Female		Williams-20414
Dick-963 H		Mrs Grace Hadden (Dick)	Mother	certain 10 Oct 1833 certain Campse, Stirling, Scotland	certain 10 Oct 1850 certain Glasgow Lanark Scotland	Female		Williams-20414
Hadden-235 H		Alexander Hadden	Child	certain 11 Aug 1870 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland	certain 20 Aug 1910 Chile, South America	Male		Williams-20414
Docherty-78 H		Catherine McCall (Docherty)	Mother	uncertain 1840 Scotland	uncertain 1890	Female		McCall-707
McCall-1146 H		John McCall	Child	1896		Male		McCall-707
Docherty-78 H		Catherine McCall (Docherty)	Mother	uncertain 1840 Scotland	uncertain 1890	Female		McCall-707
McCall-1148 H		Peter McCall	Child	1902	1969	Male		McCall-707
Docherty-78 H		Catherine McCall (Docherty)	Mother	uncertain 1840 Scotland	uncertain 1890	Female		McCall-707
McCall-1145 H		George D. McCall	Child	uncertain 1893	1962	Male		McCall-707
Docherty-78 H		Catherine McCall (Docherty)	Mother	uncertain 1840 Scotland	uncertain 1890	Female		McCall-707
McCall-1149 H		Ellen Mary McCall	Child	1906		Female		McCall-707
Docherty-78 H		Catherine McCall (Docherty)	Mother	uncertain 1840 Scotland	uncertain 1890	Female		McCall-707
McCall-1144 H		Mary Anne McCall	Child	uncertain 1891		Female		McCall-707
Docherty-78 H		Catherine McCall (Docherty)	Mother	uncertain 1840 Scotland	uncertain 1890	Female		McCall-707
McCall-1147 H		Catherine McCall	Child	uncertain 1899		Female		McCall-707
Docherty-78 H		Catherine McCall (Docherty)	Mother	uncertain 1840 Scotland	uncertain 1890	Female		McCall-707
McCall-741 H		Francis J McCall	Child	1900	24 Aug 1982 Bridgeport, Ct	Male		McCall-707
Mathieson-372 H		Elizabeth Mathieson	Mother	2 Jan 1840 Scotland	1899 Kimberley, Northern Cape, South Africa	Female		Thomas-25391
Bisset-556 H		Stuart Finley Bisset	Child	1904 Kimberley, Northern Cape, South Africa	9 Jul 1951 Johannesburg South Africa	Male		Thomas-25391
McCUTCHEN-193 H		Isabella McCUTCHEN	Mother	uncertain 1842 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 13 Jul 1886 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom	Female		Pilon-323
Duff-2618 H		John Duff	Child	certain 7 Jan 1891 West Port, Linlithgowshire, WLN, Scotland		Male		Pilon-323
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Carruth-363 09.06.2021 08:35:58 Corrected left comment on child profile Bain-1176 16.02.2023 04:41:34 Comment Contacted PM about both parents being dead before attached child was born
Watson-26315 H		Janet Watson	Mother	10 Mar 1842 Riccarton, Ayr, Scotland	2 May 1878 Hyde Park, Dutchess, New York	Female		Dickman-13
Hossack-368 H		Donald Hossack	Child	Feb 1881 Cromarty, Cromartyshire	1981	Male		Dickman-13
Morrison-5123 H		Isabella Morrison	Mother	uncertain 1843 Aberdeenshire County, Scotland, United Kingdom	1868 St. Nicholas, Aberdeen, Scotland	Female		Colverd-2
Cantlay-14 H		John Cantlay	Child	uncertain 1870		Male		Colverd-2
Morgan-11556 H		Jane Sly (Morgan)	Mother	15 Jan 1849 Scotland, United Kingdom	18 Jan 1889	Female		Sly-215
Sly-217 H		Gealding D. Sly	Child	certain 1920s	certain 1980s	Male		Sly-215
Ford-4467 H		Jemima Ford	Mother	uncertain 1850	after 1870	Female		Doyle-1868
Beattie-347 H		James Beattie	Child	uncertain 1900 Bannock, Scotland	not living	Male		Doyle-1868
Bradley-7819 H		Mary Ann Alma Bradley	Mother	1855 Skelmorlie, North Ayrshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	1892 Largs, Ayrshire, Scotland	Female		Bradley-3869
Bradley-7825 H		Edward Bradley	Child	Dec 1899	20 Mar 1900 Largs	Male		Bradley-3869
Storey-509 H		Alice Storey	Mother	certain 28 Mar 1859 Eyemouth	certain 30 Sep 1894 Banff, Scotland	Female		McIlveen-43
Mair-1007 H		William Watt Crawford Mair	Child	Sep 1895	2 Feb 1896	Male		McIlveen-43
Elborn-36 H		Margaret S Black (Elborn)	Mother	certain 15 Jul 1860 Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	after 1901 Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Female		Rodger-693 Harrison-17035
Black-17407 H		Mona Black	Child	1903	1991 Airdrie, Lanarkshire, Scotland	Female		Rodger-693
Keith-7647 H		Robina J. F. Walton (Keith)	Mother	1866 Scotland, United Kingdom	20 Jun 1901 Hamilton, Wentworth, Ontario, Canada	Female		Kennedy-11146
Walton-12468 H		Margaret Walton	Child	Dec 1905 Ontario, Canada		Female		Kennedy-11146

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
O'Neil-303 H		Janet Janette Cairns (O'Neil)	Mother	uncertain 10 Nov 1866 Dalry, Ayr, Scotland	certain 14 Nov 1893 Kansas	Female		Robinson-7162
Cairns-319 H		Agnes Aggie Cairns	Child	certain 5 Jun 1895 Parsons, Kansas	uncertain Aug 1975 Portland, OR	Female		Robinson-7162
McCallum-255 H		Catherine Kate Cook Shanks (McCallum)	Mother	1868 Scotland	1894 certain Barrhead, Scotland	Female		James-1992
Shanks-494 H		William Willie Shanks	Child	uncertain 1897 Barrhead Scotland	not living Barrhead Scotland	Male		James-1992
Faulkner-2215 H		Margaret Faulkner	Mother	1869 Scotland	after 1902	Female		Hopkins-6886
Hopkins-7764 H		Nellie Gladys Hopkins	Child	certain 17 Sep 1907 Lambeth	1985 Hertford	Female		Hopkins-6886
Faulkner-2215 H		Margaret Faulkner	Mother	1869 Scotland	after 1902	Female		Hopkins-6886
Hopkins-7763 H		Margaret Hopkins	Child	1906 Camberwell	after 1920	Female		Hopkins-6886
McGill-1614 H		Mary McGill	Mother	uncertain 1869 Scotland, UK	uncertain 23 May 1907 Toronto, Ontario, Canada	Female		Cadeau-98
Montone-18 H		Felicia Montone	Child	uncertain 1910s	uncertain 1980s	Female		Cadeau-98
McDonald-20679 H		Jannie Jennie B. Runchey (McDonald)	Mother	26 Aug 1874 Scotland	25 Apr 1907	Female		Nellis-1011 Milne-333
Runchey-83 H		Earl Runchey	Child	1910 South Dakota, USA		Male		Milne-333
Panton-151 H		Annie I Hambleton (Panton)	Mother	uncertain 1876 Scotland	after 4 Aug 1914	Female		Orphan
Hambleton-170 H		Stanley Alexander Hambleton	Child	certain 5 Aug 1914 New Jersey, United States	after 15 Oct 1957	Male		Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Ellerbrock-2 11.08.2017 04:19:21 Corrected
Dougal-157 H		Catherine Barr (Dougal)	Mother	certain 17 Dec 1880 Wishaw, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 22 Jun 1907 Overtown, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Female		Barr-4678
Barr-4680 H		Peter Dougal Barr	Child	certain 16 Apr 1909 Cambusnethan, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	certain 20 Jul 1971 Larkhall, South Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom	Male		Barr-4678