Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information .

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
Hickman-994 H	2 Aug 1875	Albert Edgar Hickman		certain 2 Aug 1874 certain Grand Bank, Newfoundland	certain 9 Feb 1943 St. John's, Newfoundland	Male		WikiTree-58 Jewett-369
Q4710465		Albert Hickman (Canadian politician)		2 Aug 1875 Grand Bank Canada	9 Feb 1943 St. John's Canada	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Jewett-369 30.08.2023 17:23:07 False suggestion Jewett-369 30.08.2023 17:23:19 False suggestion
Campbell-10319 H	12 Jan 1933	Alexander Bradshaw Campbell		1 Dec 1933 Summerside, Prince Edward Island, Canada	not living	Male		WikiTree-58 Jewett-369
Q2832907		Alex Campbell (Canadian politician)		12 Jan 1933 Summerside Canada		male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment ID2283849 03.12.2016 18:16:04 False suggestion Old False error
Bobak-22 H	27 Dec 1923	Bronislaw Bruno Josephus Bobak CM RCA		28 Dec 1923 Wawelowska, Poland	24 Sep 2012 Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada	Male		Butler-21232 WikiTree-58
Q2926650		Bruno Bobak (Canadian artist (1923-2012))		27 Dec 1923 Poland Poland	24 Sep 2012 Fredericton Canada	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cruthers-29 19.08.2017 04:25:04 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong
Greene-2592 H	1850	Daniel Joseph Greene		13 Sep 1849 St. John's, Newfoundland	12 Dec 1911 St. John's, Newfoundland	Male		WikiTree-58 Jewett-369
Q5217721		Daniel Joseph Greene (Newfoundland politician)		1850 St. John's Canada	12 Dec 1911 St. John's Canada	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Jewett-369 13.03.2023 20:07:38 False suggestion Jewett-369 13.03.2023 20:07:50 False suggestion
Alderdice-8 H	10 Nov 1872	Frederick Charles Munro Alderdice		10 Nov 1871 Belfast, Ireland	26 Feb 1936 St. John's, Newfoundland	Male		WikiTree-58 Jewett-369
Q5497454		Frederick C. Alderdice (Canadian politician (1872-1936))		10 Nov 1872 Belfast United Kingdom	26 Feb 1936 Canada Canada	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Jewett-369 05.04.2019 03:56:30 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Mullin-1272 H	15 Aug 1892	George Harry Mullin VC		certain 15 Aug 1891 certain Portland, Multnomah, Oregon, United States	certain 5 Apr 1963 certain Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada	Male		WikiTree-58 Thompson-40998
Q3101781		George Mullin (Canadian recipient of the Victoria Cross (1892-1963))		15 Aug 1892 Portland United States of America	5 Apr 1963 Regina Canada	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Thompson-40998 27.11.2019 18:37:34 False suggestion
Greenfield-505 H	25 Nov 1869	Herbert Greenfield		certain 25 Nov 1865 certain Winchester, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom	certain 23 Aug 1949 certain Calgary, Alberta, Canada	Male		WikiTree-58
Q1000799		Herbert Greenfield (Canadian politician (1869-1949))		25 Nov 1869 Winchester United Kingdom	23 Aug 1949 Calgary Canada	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Jewett-369 20.03.2023 19:59:10 Corrected Jewett-369 20.03.2023 19:59:52 Corrected Jewett-369 30.03.2023 17:42:48 Corrected Jewett-369 04.04.2023 21:23:41 False suggestion
Tait-1997 H	27 May 1888	Lt James Edward Tait VC MC		certain 27 May 1886 Dumfries, Dumfriesshire, Scotland	11 Aug 1918 Amiens, Somme, Picardie, France	Male		WikiTree-58 Templeton-1883
Q6133382		James Edward Tait (Recipient of the Victoria Cross (1888-1918))		27 May 1888 Dumfries United Kingdom	11 Aug 1918 Amiens France	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Templeton-1883 26.03.2020 15:57:01 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
McLaughlin-2115 H	3 Mar 1865	John Jack James McLaughlin		2 Mar 1865 Enniskillen, Durham, Canada West	28 Jan 1914 Toronto, York, Ontario, Canada	Male		WikiTree-58 Henderson-4785
Q19666399		John J. McLaughlin (Canadian pharmacist)		3 Mar 1865 Enniskillen Canada	28 Jan 1914 Toronto Canada	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Henderson-4785 19.09.2018 20:48:51 Not corrected conflict between sources - but source of March 3 date uses source of March 2 date as its source. Cruthers-29 09.02.2023 01:10:31 False suggestion
Robson-546 H	14 Mar 1824	John Robson		15 Mar 1824 Perth, Lanark County, Upper Canada	29 Jun 1892 Strand, London, England	Male		WikiTree-58 Jewett-369
Q361267		John Robson (Premier of British Columbia (1824-1892))		14 Mar 1824 Perth Canada	29 Jun 1892 London United Kingdom	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Jewett-369 24.10.2017 17:39:22 Not corrected conflict between sources Jewett-369 01.11.2017 20:55:58 Not corrected conflict between sources Jewett-369 07.11.2017 17:37:12 Not corrected conflict between sources Jewett-369 14.11.2017 05:51:17 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Geoffrion-51 H	14 Feb 1931	Joseph Bernie André Bernard Boom Boom Geoffrion		certain 16 Feb 1931 certain Montréal, Québec, Canada	certain 11 Mar 2006 certain Marietta, Cobb, Géorgie, États-Unis d'Amérique	Male		WikiTree-58
Q826558		Bernie Geoffrion (Canadian ice hockey player)		14 Feb 1931 Montreal Canada	11 Mar 2006 Atlanta United States of America	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Bourque-573 04.12.2018 06:23:46 Corrected wikipedia page has already been corrected Bourque-573 02.02.2019 10:47:34 False suggestion Dates match now.
Mills-9822 H	21 Oct 1910	Pauline Emily McGibbon (Mills)		20 Oct 1910 Sarnia, Ontario, Canada	14 Dec 2001 Toronto, Ontario, Canada	Female		WikiTree-58 Cruthers-29
Q7155057		Pauline Mills McGibbon (Lieutenant Governor of Ontario)		21 Oct 1910 Sarnia Canada	14 Dec 2001 Toronto Canada	female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment ID2478430 13.02.2017 03:12:49 False suggestion Old False error
Dickey-289 H	10 Nov 1800	Hon Robert Barry Dickey QC		10 Nov 1811 Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia	14 Jul 1903 Amherst, Cumberland, Nova Scotia, Canada	Male		WikiTree-58 Jewett-369
Q4161515		Robert B. Dickey (Canadian politician)		10 Nov 1800 Amherst Canada	14 Jul 1903 Amherst Canada	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment rutherford-448 24.04.2020 04:18:25 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Champlain-10 H	13 Aug 1567	Samuel de Champlain (Champlain)		certain 13 Aug 1574 certain Hiers-Brouage, Aunis, France	certain 25 Dec 1635 certain Québec, Canada, Nouvelle-France	Male		WikiTree-58 WikiTree-18 Blanchard-1459
Q68529		Samuel de Champlain (16/17th-century French explorer of North America)		13 Aug 1567 Hiers-Brouage France	25 Dec 1635 Quebec City Canada	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Bourque-573 12.11.2018 06:43:15 False suggestion Birth date is estimate in all sources. Liard-1 01.04.2020 21:45:42 Comment Liard-1 01.04.2020 21:47:03 False suggestion Can not connect on Wikidata. Not a member, don't want to be.
Beers-1468 H	5 May 1843	Dr. William George Father of Modern Lacrosse Beers		5 May 1841 Montreal, Lower Canada	26 Dec 1900 Montréal, Québec, Canada	Male		Butler-21232 WikiTree-58
Q3568653		William George Beers (Dentist and codifier of lacrosse (1843-1900))		5 May 1843 Montreal Canada	26 Dec 1900 Montreal Canada	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Bourque-573 20.12.2018 03:17:19 False suggestion Wikitree source is reliable.