Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Wolmarans-229
H
19 Sep 1857 Senator Andries Daniel Wynand Wolmarans certain 23 Sep 1857 certain Stompoorfontein, Potchefstroom, Zuid Afrikaansche Republiek certain 12 Jul 1928 certain Leeuwfontein, Pretoria, Transvaal, Union of South Africa Male Aucamp-175
Q18417310 Andries Daniël Wynand Wolmarans (South African politician (1857-1928)) 19 Sep 1857 Potchefstroom South Africa 12 Jul 1928 Pretoria South Africa male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Aucamp-175 16.11.2021 19:24:59 Comment Wikidata date is incorrect
Aucamp-175 16.11.2021 19:49:53 False suggestion I have changed the wikidata with the Baptism record source
Christian-4361
H
22 Feb 1808 Ann Helena Menzies (Christian) certain 26 Nov 1808 certain Isle of Wight, St Helens, Hampshire, England certain 29 Nov 1865 certain Isle of Wight, Hampshire, England Female Howard-18870
Q75459428 Ann Helena Christian ((1808-1865)) 22 Feb 1808 29 Nov 1865 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Howard-18870 27.06.2023 05:01:53 Comment Parent already connected. Wikidata not correct - Refer to sources proviced in profiles by Howard-18870
Howard-18870 20.08.2023 06:04:54 False suggestion
Chiappini-13
H
24 Jul 1834 Antonio Baldazar Melchior Gaspar Chiappini certain 25 Jul 1834 certain Cape Town, Cape Colony. South Africa certain 7 Aug 1887 certain Cape Town, Cape Colony, South Africa Male Evert-337
Q76200810 Antonio Beldazzar Melchior Gaspar Chiappini ((1834-1887)) 24 Jul 1834 17 Aug 1887 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Evert-337 11.02.2024 07:48:43 False suggestion
Higgs-1711
H
1917 Daphne Ralda Courtney McDermott (Higgs) aka Courtenay-Hicks certain 28 Jun 1916 certain Pretoria, South Africa not living Female Lusher-89
Q16082004 Daphne Courtney (actress) 1917 South Africa South Africa female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Thomson-8303 10.01.2022 09:13:44 False suggestion Baptism gives her birth year as 1916
Donnithorne-92
H
1826 Eliza Emily Donnithorne certain 8 Jul 1821 Cape Good Hope, South Africa 20 May 1886 Newtown, New South Wales, Australia Female Ragland-785
Q21537250 Eliza Emily Donnithorne ((1826-1886) recluse and eccentric) 1826 Cape of Good Hope South Africa 1886 Newtown Australia female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ford-7139 01.12.2020 10:32:39 False suggestion Last week you wanted me to change DOB based on F-A-G. This week change it again due to Wikidata. Make up your mind.
Brooke-2804
H
1851 Rt Hon Francis Frank Theophilius Brooke PC certain 1854 certain County Fermanagh, Ireland certain 30 Jul 1920 certain Dublin, Ireland Male Lowry-3068
Q5485489 Frank Brooke (Royal Navy officer) 1851 30 Jul 1920 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lowry-3068 22.01.2024 05:58:44 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Lewis-14369
H
1854 Joesph Lewis uncertain 1872 uncertain 1928 South Africa Male Richardson-5769
Q75350690 Joseph Lewis (South African diamond merchant) 1854 1928 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-5769 01.03.2022 02:48:55 False suggestion DIFERENT PERSON
Rhenius-135
H
Sep 1750 Johannes Isak Rhenius before 4 Oct 1750 Cabo de Goede Hoop uncertain 27 Jul 1808 uncertain German Empire Male Marais-3116

WikiTree-16
Q98541994 Johan Isaac Rhenius (politician) Sep 1750 Dutch Cape Colony South Africa 27 Jul 1808 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Marais-3116 09.11.2023 12:14:55 False suggestion
Blenkins-1
H
14 Jul 1852 William Bazett Goodwin Blenkins uncertain 22 Jun 1809 Saint Helena uncertain 1852 Male Jasper-730
Q19661449 William Blenkins (1820 -) 14 Jul 1852 4 Jul 1852 Mumbai India 21 May 1942 Cape Town South Africa male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Milton-1294 08.08.2023 11:00:10 False suggestion WikiTree has them connected appropriately, they also have a son with the same name.
Smith-171934
H
1798 William Mein Smith certain 7 Sep 1799 Capetown, Cape Colony, South Africa certain 3 Jan 1869 Greytown, Wellington, New Zealand Male Orphan
Q8015537 William Mein Smith (artist, surveyor, and New Zealand politician (1798-1869)) 1798 Cape Town South Africa 3 Jan 1869 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Bethune-87 09.05.2019 15:28:30 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Makeba-1
H
3 Mar 1932 Zenzile Miriam Miriam Makeba certain 4 Mar 1932 Prospect Township, Johannesburg, Union of South Africa certain 9 Nov 2008 Castel Volturno, Caserta, Campania, Italy Female Burch-2229
Q146256 Miriam Makeba (South African singer and civil rights activist (1932–2008)) 3 Mar 1932 Johannesburg South Africa 9 Nov 2008 Castel Volturno Italy female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
burch-2229 29.03.2023 23:02:52 False suggestion wikipedia and f.a.g say 4 march