Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
McLemore-714
H
23 May 1869 Colonel Albert Sidney McLemore 3 May 1869 Murfreesboro, Rutherford, Tennessee, United States 13 Jul 1921 Vallejo, Solano, California, United States Male Jones-116753
Q4711164 Albert Sidney McLemore (United States Marine Corps Brevet Medal recipient) 23 May 1869 Murfreesboro United States of America 13 Jul 1921 Mare Island United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jones-116753 12.01.2024 05:35:30 False suggestion
Roane-100
H
1775 Archibald Roane certain 7 Jan 1759 Derry Township, Lancaster County, Province of Pennsylvania certain 4 Jan 1819 Knox, Tennessee, United States Male Johnson-83568
Q358264 Archibald Roane (Governor of Tennessee) 1775 Lancaster County United States of America 18 Jan 1819 4 Jan 1819 Knox County United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Johnson-83568 19.11.2023 13:05:53 Comment Wikidata date is incorrect
Johnson-83568 22.11.2023 21:16:24 Corrected
Lee-5956 16.12.2023 21:41:27 False suggestion
Payne-15298
H
1799 Buckner Harrison Payne uncertain 9 Dec 1800 certain Kentucky, United States certain 7 Jun 1883 certain Davidson County, Tennessee, United States Male Orphan
Q22020471 Buckner H. Payne (American clergyman and pamphleteer) 1799 1 Jun 1883 1889 Davidson County United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Payne-15730 14.01.2024 11:04:10 False suggestion not precise
Akeman-21
H
17 Jun 1916 David Stringbean Akeman certain 17 Jun 1915 Annville, Jackson, Kentucky, United States certain 10 Nov 1973 Ridgetop, Robertson County, Tennessee, USA Male WikiTree-130

Compton-2184
Q3398247 David "Stringbean" Akeman (Banjo player) 17 Jun 1916 Annville United States of America 10 Nov 1973 11 Nov 1973 Ridgetop United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 12.06.2023 23:59:14 Corrected Corrected
Craig-4574 20.09.2023 12:48:47 False suggestion This was corrected previously.
Aldrich-1412
H
30 Nov 1809 Elias Taft Aldrich certain 30 Nov 1807 certain Livermore, Oxford, Massachusetts, United States certain 6 Oct 1849 certain Memphis, Shelby, Tennessee, United States Male Norway-114
Q108061024 Elias Taft Aldrich (1810-) 30 Nov 1809 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Norway-114 03.11.2023 20:33:27 False suggestion
Shelby-49
H
1720 General Evan Shelby Jr certain 23 Oct 1719 certain Tregaron, Cardiganshire, Wales certain 4 Dec 1794 certain Kings Meadow, Sullivan County, Tennessee, United States Male Murray-10306

Vincent-18
Q23855448 Evan Shelby (Colonial-era American General) 1720 4 Dec 1794 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cushing-1054 19.07.2018 14:51:26 False suggestion Wikidata has no source for birthrate. I see no reason to alter our profile.
Cage-168
H
5 May 1795 Henry Harry Cage certain 5 Apr 1795 Sumner, Tennessee, United States certain 31 Dec 1858 New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, United States Male Thompson-52533
Q1250644 Harry Cage (American politician (1795-1858)) 5 May 1795 31 Dec 1858 New Orleans United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Burch-2229 01.11.2019 00:38:35 False suggestion why doesn't wikidata agree with wikipedia?
Allen-43097
H
13 Aug 1932 Howard Pistol Richard Allen uncertain 12 Aug 1932 certain Memphis, Shelby, Tennessee, United States certain 30 Jun 2002 uncertain Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, United States Male WikiTree-112
Q7323525 Richard "Pistol" Allen (African-American soul drummer) 13 Aug 1932 Memphis United States of America 30 Jun 2002 Detroit United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cooper-28960 22.10.2022 16:54:52 False suggestion Birth record lists 12 Aug 1932
Jones-30505
H
20 Apr 1809 James Chamberlain Lean Jimmy Jones certain 7 Jun 1809 Davidson County, Tennessee, USA certain 29 Oct 1859 Memphis, Tennessee, USA Male Noland-165
Q358277 James C. Jones (American politician (1809-1859)) 20 Apr 1809 Davidson County United States of America 29 Oct 1859 Memphis United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID2486865 11.11.2016 03:49:30 False suggestion Old False error
Noland-165 29.09.2017 07:12:00 False suggestion set comments on profile - tombstone and TN State website support WikiTree birth date, not Wikidata's
Luttrell-469
H
3 Mar 1813 James Churchwell Luttrell certain 2 Mar 1813 certain Knox County, Tennessee, USA certain 6 Jul 1878 certain Nashville, Davidson County, Tennessee, USA Male Witt-1888
Q6130755 James C. Luttrell (Mayor of Knoxville) 3 Mar 1813 Knox County United States of America 6 Jul 1878 Nashville United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID1352259 22.03.2017 17:52:20 False suggestion Wikipedia has incorrect birth date; see sources on profile
Conway-296
H
9 Dec 1798 Gov James Sevier Conway uncertain 4 Dec 1796 certain Greene County, Tennessee, United States certain 3 Mar 1855 certain Walnut Hill, Lafayette County, Arkansas, United States Male Logan-1629
Q881532 James Sevier Conway (1st governor of Arkansas) 9 Dec 1798 Greene County United States of America 3 Mar 1855 Lafayette County United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Weston-1852 26.04.2019 16:57:05 Corrected
Jester-173 16.12.2021 09:13:10 False suggestion Encyclopedia of Arkansas has 4 Dec 1796
Logue-288
H
5 Feb 1813 Bishop Jarm Jermain Wesley Loguen (Logue) certain 5 Feb 1809 certain Nashville, Davidson, Tennessee, United States certain 30 Sep 1872 certain Saratoga Springs, Saratoga, New York, United States Male WikiTree-112

Taylor-25258
Q6182278 Jermain Wesley Loguen (American bishop) 5 Feb 1813 Davidson County United States of America 30 Sep 1872 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Taylor-25258 18.04.2017 01:06:28 False suggestion Feb 5, 1809 is f-a-g
Chisholm-449
H
1806 Jesse Chisholm uncertain 1805 Tennessee 4 Apr 1868 Cherokee Nation, Indian Territory Male Ledbetter-258

Parks-2399

Mahar-89
Q1688146 Jesse Chisholm (American merchant and fur trader) 1806 4 Mar 1868 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parks-2399 13.11.2018 02:43:02 False suggestion Birthdate estimated, most sources use 1805
Parks-2399 16.12.2018 16:36:35 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Parks-2399 16.12.2018 16:37:05 False suggestion Date is approximate and only 1 year off
Crockett-318
H
1754 John Crockett certain 10 Aug 1759 uncertain Frederick County, Colony of Virginia uncertain Sep 1834 Gibson, Tennessee, United States Male WikiTree-40

Matlock-107
Q6227668 John Crockett (American frontiersman) 1754 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 01.05.2023 01:09:20 False suggestion unsourced
Kelly-19992
H
31 Mar 1840 Brig Gen John Herbert Kelly certain 31 Mar 1841 certain Carrollton, Pickens, Alabama, United States certain 20 Aug 1864 certain Franklin, Williamson, Tennessee, United States Male Driskell-217
Q3181660 John H. Kelly (Confederate Army general (1840-1864)) 31 Mar 1840 Carrollton United States of America 4 Sep 1864 Franklin United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Floyd-1923 15.10.2022 04:06:40 False suggestion
Matthews-4925
H
1812 Joseph Warren Matthews aka Mathews uncertain 3 Aug 1807 Laurens County, South Carolina, United States 27 Aug 1862 Palmetto, Fulton, Georgia, United States Male Kolze-7
Q767415 Joseph Warren Matthews (American politician (1812-1862)) 1812 Huntsville United States of America 27 Aug 1862 Palmetto United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
kolze-7 21.05.2019 19:10:33 Not corrected Death monument shows 1812, but it was erected in 1919, 55 years after death. 1807 date is in-line with 1840, 1850, 1860 census and other sources.
kolze-7 28.01.2021 10:48:43 False suggestion Grave monument is wrong. Noted in research notes.
Randolph-3770
H
1914 Lillian Castello McKee (Randolph) aka Briddell, Short, Lott, Chase, Sanders certain 14 Dec 1898 certain Knoxville, Knox, Tennessee, United States certain 12 Sep 1980 certain Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, United States Female Craig-4574

WikiTree-112
Q2340500 Lillian Randolph (American actress) 1914 Knoxville United States of America 12 Sep 1980 1980 Los Angeles United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Craig-4574 17.02.2022 19:20:38 False suggestion Sourced per 1900 Census + SSDeath Index. Tombstone, Find A Grave are incorrect.
Craig-4574 17.02.2022 19:23:36 Comment
Craig-4574 17.02.2022 19:23:47 Corrected Updated
Craig-4574 20.01.2023 17:00:23 False suggestion Not Sourced
Gaines-269
H
1763 Mary Polly Finley (Gaines) 1765 Augusta, Albemarle County, Virginia certain 18 Oct 1830 certain Lebanon, Wilson, Tennessee Female Gaines-587
Q96290910 Mary 'Polly' Gaines (1763 - 1830) 1763 1830 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Noland-165 12.11.2021 04:41:38 False suggestion genealogics (cited by wikidata) cites an online tree that the link doesn't work for; WikiTree's 1765 date is from grandson's bible record (died 1830, age 65) & memorial stone erected by son
McDonough-136
H
1783 Mary Polly Johnson (McDonough) certain 17 Jul 1782 certain Beaufort County, NC certain 13 Feb 1856 certain Greene County, Tennessee, United States Female WikiTree-6

Pearson-3638
Q75766081 Mary McDonough ((1783-1856)) 1783 1856 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lee-5956 11.12.2019 21:04:42 Merge proposed Wikidata/ThePeerage is unsourced
Lee-5956 15.01.2020 22:54:11 False suggestion WikiData/the peerage is unsourced, see source on WikiTree profile
Autry-158
H
1794 Micajah Autry certain 1793 certain Sampson, North Carolina, United States certain 6 Mar 1836 certain The Alamo, San Antonio, Bexar, Texas Male WikiTree-44

Richardson-7161
Q6827921 Micajah Autry (Alamo defender) 1794 6 Mar 1836 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-7161 25.03.2019 03:38:30 False suggestion Project protected I have 3 sources for each date. WikiData does not list a retrievable source
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Cherokee-59
H
1738 Ghigau Nan-Ye-Hi Nancy Ward (Cherokee) uncertain 1736 Chota, Cherokee Nation (East) 1822 Cherokee Nation (East) Female WikiTree-12

Thornton-1836

Vargas-60
Q292814 Nancy Ward (Cherokee Ghighau, or Beloved Woman, and warrior, introduced dairying to the Cherokee and advocating for the return of matriarchy) 1738 Chota United States of America 1822 1824 Tennessee United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parks-2399 18.08.2020 15:14:00 False suggestion her birthdate is unknown
Parks-2399 10.08.2021 20:43:48 False suggestion Birthdate is estimate only
Cherokee-320
H
1703 Ostenaco Outacite, Mankiller, Judd's Friend Cherokee uncertain 1720 Cherokee Nation (East) uncertain 1780 Oolteewah Creek, now Hamilton, Tennessee Male Connell-254

WikiTree-12
Q49311 Ostenaco (Cherokee Indian warrior) 1703 United States of America United States of America 1780 United States of America United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parks-2399 01.08.2023 19:49:42 False suggestion birthdate unknown
Turney-453
H
27 Sep 1827 Peter Pete Turney 22 Sep 1827 Jasper, Marion, Tennessee, United States 19 Oct 1903 Winchester, Franklin, Tennessee, United States Male Irwin-3811
Q605998 Peter Turney (American politician) 27 Sep 1827 Jasper United States of America 28 Oct 1903 Winchester United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Irwin-3811 29.06.2023 14:50:33 False suggestion
Boyd-21565
H
1831 Rufus King Boyd uncertain 6 Oct 1830 certain Williamson, Tennessee, United States certain 10 May 1883 certain Guntersville, Marshall, Alabama, United States Male Rounsefell-5
Q45394688 Rufus King Boyd (American politician) 1831 Williamson County United States of America 10 May 1883 Guntersville United States of America male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rounsefell-5 28.01.2024 02:25:20 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Blair-10509
H
1852 Sarah Eva Sallie Bickford (Blair) aka Jones, Gammon, Brown certain 25 Dec 1856 certain Jonesborough, Washington, Tennessee, United States certain 19 Jul 1931 certain Virginia City, Madison, Montana, United States Female WikiTree-112
Q23035328 Sarah Bickford (American business woman) 1852 Jonesborough United States of America 1931 Virginia City United States of America female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cooper-28960 18.12.2023 01:06:50 False suggestion Profile using birth date from death certificate
Fleming-1753
H
26 Dec 1867 Sarah Hazelhurst McAdoo (Fleming) 26 Dec 1866 Savannah, Chatham Co, Georgia 21 Feb 1912 Irvington-on-Hudson, Westchester Co, New York Female McAdoo-199
Q99178648 Sarah Houstoun Fleming (26 Dec 1867 Savannah, Ga. - 21 Feb 1912 Irvington, New York) 26 Dec 1867 21 Feb 1912 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McAdoo-199 23.02.2023 05:08:24 False suggestion Wikidata has no good source