Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information 
.
| Link |
Info |
Name |
Rel. |
Birth |
Death |
Gender |
|
Manager |
Marriage |
Status |
Borthwick-2
 H   |
1432 |
Agnes Borthwick |
|
before 1440 certain Borthwick. Midlothian, Scotland |
not living uncertain Edinburghshire, Scotland |
Female |
 |
Orphan |
|
|
| Q75902595 |
Agnes Borthwick (Peerage person ID=392687) |
|
1432 |
|
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 22:54:09 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is unreliable |
|
Forrester-686
H |
1490 |
Agnes Forrester |
|
uncertain 1499 uncertain Turnhouse, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
uncertain 1547 uncertain Auchnoul, Midlothian, Scotland |
Female |
|
Ratliff-242
|
|
|
| Q75510388 |
Agnes Forrester (Peerage person ID=185117) |
|
1490 |
1547 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 23:03:43 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is unreliable |
|
Elliot-1289
H |
16 Dec 1763 |
Agnes Murray Carnegie (Elliot) |
|
certain 10 Feb 1764 Midlothian, Scotland |
9 Jun 1860 Leamington, Warwickshire, England |
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q75405198 |
Agnes Murray Elliot ((died 1860)) |
|
16 Dec 1763 |
9 Jun 1860 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Babington-Smith-1 |
20.05.2022 23:50:27 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Douglas-402
H |
1198 |
Sir Archibald Douglas IInd of Douglas (Douglas) |
|
before 1175 Hermiston, Edinburghshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1240 Douglas, Lanarkshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
| Q4170054 |
Archibald I, Lord of Douglas (Scottish knight) |
|
1198 |
1238 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
27.06.2021 00:53:58 |
False suggestion |
both dates are unsourced, 1198 is date mentioned in charter, not birth |
|
Rutherfurd-30
H |
1694 |
Lady Barbara of Bowland Montgomery (Rutherfurd) aka Rutherfoord |
|
before 19 Jul 1697 Stow, Midlothian, Scotland |
|
Female |
|
Wiegand-310
|
|
|
| Q75637336 |
Barbara Rutherford (Peerage person ID=262481) |
|
1694 |
|
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 09:26:08 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Pitcairn-229
H |
1673 |
Rev. David Pitcairn |
|
uncertain 9 May 1689 Carrington, Midlothian, Scotland |
certain 18 Apr 1757 |
Male |
|
Stratman-17
|
|
|
| Q75544255 |
David Pitcairn (Peerage person ID=205042) |
|
1673 |
18 Jul 1757 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 17:48:28 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is not reliable |
|
Gregory-9283
H |
13 Apr 1813 |
Duncan Farquharson Gregory MD |
|
certain 14 Apr 1813 certain Edinburgh, Edinburghshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
certain 23 Feb 1844 certain Edinburgh, Edinburghshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Male |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q1891614 |
Duncan Farquharson Gregory (British mathematician) |
|
13 Apr 1813 Edinburgh
Aberdeen United Kingdom
United Kingdom |
23 Feb 1844 Edinburgh United Kingdom |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Urquhart-93 |
31.03.2020 23:32:35 |
False suggestion |
Wikidata is unsourced |
|
Hosie-199
H |
3 Jun 1741 |
Fletcher Hosie |
|
certain 1 Jun 1741 Leith, Midlothian, Scotland |
before 1841 |
Female |
|
Crooks-1416
|
|
|
| Q76252506 |
Fletcher Hosie ((born 1741)) |
|
3 Jun 1741 |
|
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Crooks-1416 |
24.04.2021 07:46:32 |
False suggestion |
Family records indicate female gender |
|
Douglas-4255
H |
1561 |
Sir George Douglas of Mordington (Douglas) |
|
uncertain 1560 Lochleven Castle, Midlothian, Scotland |
uncertain 9 Dec 1609 uncertain Kirkness, Scotland |
Male |
|
Stoddard-791
Douglas-3089
|
|
|
| Q75863815 |
Sir George Douglas of Mordington (Peerage person ID=364322) |
|
1561 |
|
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 09:57:04 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Gordon-3514
H |
1490 |
George Gordon of Cairnbarrow (Gordon) |
|
uncertain 1495 certain Scotland |
certain 10 Sep 1547 certain Pinkie Cleugh, Inveresk, Midlothian, Scotland |
Male |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q76153359 |
George Gordon, 2nd of Cairnborrow (Peerage person ID=567463) |
|
1490 |
10 Sep 1547 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
06.12.2023 04:27:32 |
False suggestion |
peerage is unreliable |
|
Lockhart-2327
H |
1673 |
Sir George Lockhart IInd of Carnwath (Lockhart) Esq. |
|
uncertain 1681 uncertain Edinburgh, Edinburghshire, Scotland |
certain 17 Dec 1731 Edinburgh, Edinburghshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Gordon-7317
|
|
|
| Q5541793 |
George Lockhart (Scottish writer, spy and politician) |
|
1673 |
17 Dec 1731 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Boenisch-2 |
05.03.2022 01:21:59 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Cadell-214
H |
1820 |
Georgina Cadell |
|
20 Jul 1838 |
19 Apr 1924 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Webber-4005
|
|
|
| Q76261946 |
Georgina Cadell ((1820-1924)) |
|
1820 |
1924 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Webber-4005 |
15.09.2020 18:29:41 |
False suggestion |
Information on the peerage is incorrect and does not match birth and census records |
|
Studd-80
H |
14 Mar 1819 |
Henrietta Anne MacKinnon (Studd) |
|
before 26 Jun 1818 Calcutta, West Bengal, India |
18 Feb 1856 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Quigley-173
|
|
|
| Q76146111 |
Henrietta Studd ((born 1819)) |
|
14 Mar 1819 |
18 Feb 1856 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Spradley-150 |
13.01.2020 22:16:08 |
Corrected |
connected and added sources |
| Spradley-150 |
20.02.2020 19:15:00 |
False suggestion |
WikiData is wrong |
|
Petrie-365
H |
1600 |
Isabel Robertson (Petrie) |
|
uncertain 1530 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
after 21 Feb 1594 in Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
Female |
|
Robertson-16141
Ramsey-1224
Maggard-299
|
|
|
| Q76153793 |
Isabel Petrie (Peerage person ID=567774) |
|
1600 |
|
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 10:01:43 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Anderson-2468
H |
23 May 1739 |
James Anderson |
|
certain 5 Feb 1739 certain Currie, Midlothian, Scotland |
certain 15 Oct 1808 certain London, England |
Male |
|
Trotter-1177
|
|
|
| Q617109 |
James Anderson (Scottish economist) |
|
23 May 1739 Edinburgh United Kingdom |
15 Oct 1808 West Ham United Kingdom |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Trotter-1177 |
18.02.2019 03:24:19 |
False suggestion |
WikiData is wrong |
|
Wedderburn-32
H |
28 Aug 1739 |
James Wedderburn-Colvile (Wedderburn) |
|
certain 28 Aug 1730 Blackness House, via Dundee, Forfarshire, Scotland |
certain 14 Dec 1807 Inveresk, Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Male |
|
Simms-302
|
|
|
| Q51598466 |
James Wedderburn (West Indian planter and slave owner) |
|
28 Aug 1739 |
14 Dec 1807 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Davison-2360 |
05.04.2022 23:10:40 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Rennie-816
H |
2 Dec 1954 |
Janet Cockburn (Rennie) |
|
certain 26 Sep 1743 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
uncertain Mar 1835 |
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q76014199 |
Janet Rennie (Peerage person ID=468047) |
|
2 Dec 1954 |
|
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
06.12.2023 04:51:45 |
False suggestion |
peerage is unreliable |
|
Douglas-588
H |
1379 |
Janet Jacoba Janet Hamilton (Douglas) |
|
before Oct 1378 Dalkeith, Midlothian, Scotland |
after 1410 Cadzow, Lanarkshire, Scotland |
Female |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
| Q75268189 |
Janet Douglas (Peerage person ID=24828) |
|
1379 |
|
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 22:48:54 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is unreliable |
|
Skene-27
H |
1588 |
Jean Skene Lady Adross (Skene) |
|
before 1583 certain Currie, Midlothian, Scotland |
not living uncertain Scotland |
Female |
|
Wolfe-522
|
|
|
| Q75273746 |
Jean Skene (Peerage person ID=29594) |
|
1588 |
|
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 10:12:58 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Bonar-290
H |
4 Nov 1722 |
Rev John Bonar |
|
certain 4 Nov 1721 Clackmannan, Clackmannanshire, Scotland |
21 Dec 1761 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q16206831 |
John Bonar (Scottish minister (1722-1761)) |
|
4 Nov 1722 |
21 Dec 1761 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Templeton-1883 |
07.10.2019 16:47:10 |
False suggestion |
Wikidata incorrect - Scotland moved new year to 1 January in 1600 |
|
| Link |
Info |
Name |
Rel. |
Birth |
Death |
Gender |
|
Manager |
Marriage |
Status |
Bruce-3673
H |
1500 |
John Bruce of Fingask (Bruce) |
|
before 1520 certain Fingask Scotland |
certain 10 Sep 1547 certain Pinkie Cleugh, Inveresk, Midlothian, Scotland |
Male |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q76257754 |
John Bruce of Fingask (Peerage person ID=642456) |
|
1500 |
|
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 17:30:11 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is unreliable |
|
Macdowall-3
H |
1522 |
John Macdowall IXth of Garthland (Macdowall) |
|
uncertain 1520 certain Galloway, Scotland |
certain 10 Sep 1547 certain Musselburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
Male |
|
Caton-80
|
|
|
| Q75994905 |
John Macdowall, 9th of Garthland (Peerage person ID=455458) |
|
1522 |
10 Sep 1547 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 10:18:31 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Dalmahoy-1
H |
1624 |
Sir John of that Ilk Dalmahoy |
|
before 1593 certain Dalmahoy, Midlothian, Scotland |
after 1636 |
Male |
|
Masterson-50
|
|
|
| Q75969842 |
John Dalmahoy (Peerage person ID=438439) |
|
1624 |
|
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 10:20:37 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Ramsay-329
H |
1 Sep 1806 |
Lauderdale Burnett (Ramsay) |
|
27 Aug 1806 Fettercairn, Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
4 Nov 1888 Edinburgh, Edinburghshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q75518988 |
Lauderdale Ramsay ((1806-1888)) |
|
1 Sep 1806 |
4 Nov 1888 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Creighton-890 |
11.04.2020 18:30:39 |
False suggestion |
WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile |
|
Craig-2279
H |
1640 |
Sir Lewis Craig IIIrd of Riccarton (Craig) |
|
uncertain 1641 certain Riccarton, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
before 15 Apr 1681 uncertain Riccarton, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
Male |
|
Johnston-18436
Buck-3683
Ratliff-242
|
|
|
| Q75944027 |
Lewis Craig, 4th of Riccarton (Peerage person ID=419498) |
|
1640 |
28 Jun 1681 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 10:21:32 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Sinclair-1564
H |
1455 |
Lady Margaret Boswell (Sinclair) |
|
uncertain 1460 Roslin, Midlothian, Scotland |
|
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q76259154 |
Margaret Sinclair (Peerage person ID=643513) |
|
1455 |
|
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
02.12.2023 22:56:41 |
False suggestion |
ThePeerage is unreliable |
|
Borthwick-43
H |
1430 |
Margaret Maxwell (Borthwick) |
|
before 4 Dec 1438 Borthwick Castle, Midlothian, Scotland |
1464 Newark Castle Port, Renfrewshire, Scotland |
Female |
|
Sutherland-Fisher-1
|
|
|
| Q75444442 |
Margaret Borthwick (Peerage person ID=145419) |
|
1430 |
1464 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
06.12.2023 04:33:31 |
False suggestion |
peerage is unreliable |
|
Sinclair-95
H |
1344 |
Margaret Sinclair Countess of Angus (Sinclair) |
|
uncertain 1330 Roslin, Edinburghshire, Scotland |
not living Scotland |
Female |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
| Q75268377 |
Margaret Sinclair (Peerage person ID=24984) |
|
1344 |
1361 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
06.12.2023 04:41:00 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Cadell-215
H |
18 Jun 1823 |
Mary Anne Cadell |
|
18 Jul 1823 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom |
5 Feb 1905 Scotland |
Female |
|
Webber-4005
|
|
|
| Q75303485 |
Mary Anne Cadell ((1823-1905)) |
|
18 Jun 1823 |
5 Feb 1905 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Webber-4005 |
04.11.2020 05:17:52 |
False suggestion |
Wikidata information is incorrect |
|
Douglas-2040
H |
1600 |
Mary Douglas Countess of Buchan (Douglas) aka Erskine |
|
certain 1601 Scotland |
20 Aug 1628 Holyrood, Midlothian, Scotland |
Female |
|
Orphan |
|
|
| Q17325081 |
Mary Douglas, Countess of Buchan (Peerage person ID=28286) |
|
1600 |
1628 |
female |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 10:34:09 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Menzies-1075
H |
16 Aug 1780 |
Sir Neil Menzies 6th Bt aka of that Ilk |
|
certain 16 Aug 1778 certain Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
certain 20 Aug 1844 certain Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
Male |
|
Cain-4345
|
|
|
| Q75280595 |
Sir Neil Menzies, 6th Baronet ((1780-1844)) |
|
16 Aug 1780 |
20 Aug 1844 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Howard-18870 |
29.11.2022 02:04:08 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Hosie-197
H |
27 Feb 1737 |
Patrick Hosie |
|
certain 25 Feb 1737 Leith, Midlothian, Scotland |
before 1837 |
Male |
|
Crooks-1416
|
|
|
| Q76252503 |
Patrick Hosie ((born 1737)) |
|
27 Feb 1737 |
|
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Crooks-1416 |
25.04.2021 12:19:23 |
False suggestion |
Wikidata date is christening date |
|
Sealy-102
H |
15 Aug 1853 |
Patrick Persse Sealy ISO |
|
certain 25 Aug 1853 certain Dublin, County Dublin, Ireland |
certain 12 Dec 1938 certain Portobello, Midlothian, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Male |
|
Sealy-94
|
|
|
| Q76091741 |
Patrick Persse Sealy ((1853-1938)) |
|
15 Aug 1853 |
12 Dec 1938 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Phillips-20591 |
08.02.2024 01:59:06 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Anstruther-44
H |
1666 |
Sir Philip Anstruther |
|
uncertain 1661 certain Anstruther, Fife, Scotland |
certain 1722 Scotland |
Male |
|
Lowry-3068
|
|
|
| Q75279954 |
Sir Philip Anstruther ((died 1722)) |
|
1666 |
1722 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Lowry-3068 |
06.12.2023 19:48:21 |
Corrected |
|
| Lowry-3068 |
06.12.2023 19:48:47 |
Comment |
Corrected |
| Lowry-3068 |
06.12.2023 19:48:50 |
Corrected |
|
| Lowry-3068 |
21.12.2023 06:02:04 |
Corrected |
Adjusted birth date |
| Lowry-3068 |
31.01.2024 23:18:46 |
False suggestion |
wikidate is using wikitree as a source....then changing the date. |
|
Macdowall-4
H |
1484 |
Uchtred Macdowall VIIIth of Garthland (Macdowall) |
|
before 1512 certain Garthland, Machermore, Scotland |
certain 10 Sep 1547 certain Musselburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
Male |
|
Hughey-105
|
|
|
| Q75994902 |
Uchtred Macdowall, 8th of Garthland (Peerage person ID=455455) |
|
1484 |
1531 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McIntosh-5576 |
02.12.2023 10:49:56 |
False suggestion |
The Peerage is not a reliable source |
|
Geikie-8
H |
10 Nov 1795 |
Walter Geikie |
|
certain 9 Nov 1795 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland |
1 Aug 1837 Edinburgh, Edinburghshire, Scotland, United Kingdom |
Male |
|
McEvoy-527
|
|
|
| Q7964924 |
Walter Geikie (British artist (1795-1837)) |
|
10 Nov 1795 Edinburgh United Kingdom |
1 Aug 1837 Edinburgh United Kingdom |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| McEvoy-527 |
11.03.2018 00:20:58 |
False suggestion |
Date of birth source attached in biography |
|
Borthwick-128
H |
1385 |
Sir William Borthwick IInd of Borthwick (Borthwick) Knt. |
|
after 1390 certain Scotland |
before 1450 uncertain Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
Lauder-Frost-1
|
|
|
| Q27229724 |
Sir William Borthwick of that ilk (Scottish landowner and administrator) |
|
1385 |
1449 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Anderson-23510 |
10.04.2022 23:11:22 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Hay-472
H |
1330 |
Sir William Hay of Locherworth (Hay) aka de Hay |
|
before 1325 Lochorwart Castle, Gorebridge, Midlothian, Scotland |
certain 1380 uncertain Lochorwart Castle, Gorebridge, Midlothian, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
| Q75964925 |
Sir William Haya of Lochorwart (Peerage person ID=434840) |
|
1330 |
29 Aug 1392 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
06.12.2023 04:38:29 |
False suggestion |
peerage is unreliable |
|
Sinclair-144
H |
1410 |
William Sinclair Third Earl of Orkney First Earl of Caithness (Sinclair) |
|
uncertain 1404 certain Roslin, Edinburghshire, Scotland |
before Mar 1480 certain Kirkcaldy, Fife, Scotland |
Male |
 |
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
| Q3568958 |
William Sinclair, 1st Earl of Caithness (Scottish nobleman, last Jarl of Orkney; Lord Chancellor of Scotland) |
|
1410 |
1484 |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
22.11.2020 21:39:54 |
False suggestion |
dates are uncertain and not sourced |
|