Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Boyd-2539
H
1322 Alan Boyd Younger of Kilmarnock (Boyd) uncertain 1300 Scotland uncertain Aug 1339 certain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q76213178 Alan Boyd (Peerage person ID=608931) 1322 1339 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:24:03 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Stewart-18315
H
1380 Alexander Stewart IInd of Grandtully (Stewart) uncertain 1396 Innermeath, Perthshire, Scotland before 10 Jul 1449 Male Stuart-531

WikiTree-65
Q76143405 Alexander Stewart (Peerage person ID=561422) 1380 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:50:18 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Hay-294
H
1620 Andrew Hay uncertain 1610 certain Longforgan, Perth, Scotland before 1672 uncertain Scotland Male Brodie-302
Q75274094 Sir Andrew Hay (Peerage person ID=29882) 1620 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:21:17 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Colville-275
H
1671 Beatrix Colville uncertain 1655 Kinross-shire, Scotland after 1689 Perthshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Q76172064 Beatrix Colville (Peerage person ID=580093) 1671 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:26:29 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Unknown-590596
H
1030 Beatrix Leslie (Unknown) uncertain 1040 Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland 1121 Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Gray-14994
Q76320892 Beatrix (?) (Peerage person ID=687072) 1030 1121 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 23:04:34 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Drummond-27
H
1516 David Drummond Second Lord Drummond (Drummond) uncertain 1515 Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 1572 Perthshire, Scotland Male Blair-3347

Walker-2526
Q61467026 David Drummond, 2nd Lord Drummond ((c. 1516-1571)) 1516 Perthshire United Kingdom 1571 Perthshire United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 21:36:30 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Nairn-227
H
1720 David Nairn IIIrd of Drumkilbo (Nairn) aka Nairne uncertain 1715 uncertain Meigle, Perthshire, Scotland before 29 Aug 1764 uncertain Meigle, Perthshire, Scotland Male Perkins-11750
Q76149913 David Nairne of Drumkilbo (Peerage person ID=565458) 1720 26 Jul 1764 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:25:39 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
McIntyre-4045
H
23 Dec 1834 Duncan McIntyre 20 Dec 1834 Callander, Perthshire, Scotland 13 Jun 1894 Montreal, Quebec, Canada Male Stamper-1306
Q5314506 Duncan McIntyre (Scottish businessman) 23 Dec 1834 Callander United Kingdom 13 Jun 1894 Montreal Canada male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rocca-43 04.06.2019 20:49:03 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Chisholm-844
H
1453 Sir Edmund Chisholm Ist of Cromlix (Chisholm) before 1436 certain Scotland before 15 Mar 1518 uncertain Male Shelton-1487
Q76112499 Edmund Chisholm, 1st of Cromlix (Peerage person ID=539513) 1453 1500 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 20:53:38 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Stewart-217
H
1549 Lady Elizabeth Fraser (Stewart) uncertain 1550 certain Atholl, Perth, Scotland certain Sep 1595 Female Parker-10195
Q75243276 Elizabeth Stewart (noblewoman; Peerage person ID=5252) 1549 Sep 1595 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:53:02 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
De la Haye-61
H
1350 Elizabeth Leslie (de la Haye) uncertain 1377 Erroll, Perthshire, Scotland before Feb 1397 England Female WikiTree-65

Thompson-14289

Shelton-1487
Q75388227 Elizabeth de la Haye (Peerage person ID=108046) 1350 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:26:43 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Woodford-421
H
1583 Countess Elizabeth Ruthven (Woodford) uncertain 1590 Brightwell, Berkshire, England 1 Jan 1627 Perthshire, Scotland Female Crum-2235
Q75544050 Elizabeth Woodford (Peerage person ID=204929) 1583 1624 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:54:14 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Stewart-1622
H
1465 Elizabeth Stewart uncertain 1450 certain Traquhair, Peeblesshire, Scotland uncertain 9 Dec 1529 uncertain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Q75389499 Lady Elizabeth Stuart (Peerage person ID=109206) 1465 9 Dec 1529 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:55:31 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Wallace-17440
H
1663 Euphemia Drummond (Wallace) of Craigie uncertain 1653 certain Craigie, Ayrshire, Scotland certain 1743 certain Paris, Île-de-France, France Female Jones-43207

Williams-42141
Q75274923 Euphemia Wallace (Peerage person ID=30510) 1663 1743 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:56:06 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Kinnaird-112
H
1622 Lord George Kinnaird First Lord Kinnaird (Kinnaird) uncertain 1620 Inchture, Perth, Scotland certain 29 Dec 1689 Inchture, Perth, Scotland Male Champion de Crespigny-8
Q5541349 George Kinnaird, 1st Lord Kinnaird (Scottish aristocrat) 1622 29 Dec 1689 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Champion de Crespigny-8 03.06.2022 04:32:02 False suggestion
Ogilvy-577
H
1605 Captain George Ogilvy uncertain 1600 Smiddiehill, Coupar Angus, Perthshire, Scotland Jan 1661 Brunn, Lower Austria, Austria Male Blair-3347
Q76007762 George Ogilvy of Muirtown (Peerage person ID=463592) 1605 7 Jun 1661 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:57:39 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Preston-1455
H
1614 Sir George Preston of Valleyfield (Preston) 1st Bt uncertain 1612 certain Valleyfield, Perthshire, Scotland certain 26 Nov 1679 uncertain Scotland Male Lauder-514
Q75615054 Sir George Preston of Valleyfield, 1st Bt. (Peerage person ID=246291) 1614 26 Nov 1679 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:57:57 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Preston-6136
H
17 Jun 1666 Sir George Preston of Valleyfield (Preston) 3rd Bt uncertain 1670 Culross, Perthshire, Scotland certain 14 Sep 1741 Culross, Perthshire, Scotland Male Lauder-514
Q76373616 Sir George Preston, 3rd Bt. (Peerage person ID=719686) 17 Jun 1666 1741 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 09:58:06 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Stuart-3552
H
1719 Gilbert Stuart 1718 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Saunderstown, Washington, Rhode Island Male Meehan-411
Q109336045 Gilbert Stuart, Sr. (father of painter Gilbert Stuart) 1719 1793 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Meehan-411 02.11.2021 23:45:30 Comment unsourced junk
Meehan-411 03.11.2021 00:13:48 False suggestion
Menzies-497
H
1604 Lady Helen Campbell (Menzies) certain 1605 uncertain Weem, Perthshire, Scotland certain 1670 certain East Ayrshire, Scotland Female Howard-18870

Hare-1576
Q76309680 Helen Menzies (Peerage person ID=679010) 1604 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:27:52 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Haldane-180
H
1702 Helen Haldane uncertain 1706 Gleneagles Scotland certain 15 Jan 1778 Lundie, Angus Scotland Female Wiegand-310
Q75536014 Helen Haldane (Peerage person ID=200575) 1702 May 1777 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 18:15:32 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Cheyne-444
H
1575 Isabel Cheyne uncertain 1573 certain Esselmont, Aberdeenshire, Scotland uncertain 1630 uncertain Perthshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Q75274092 Isabel Cheyne (Peerage person ID=29880) 1575 1630 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 17:28:19 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Stewart-1203
H
1388 Isabel Murray (Stewart) aka Oliphant uncertain 1393 Scotland after 1445 Tullibardine, Blackford, Perthshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75268603 Isabel Stewart (Peerage person ID=25156) 1388 26 Oct 1460 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Perkins-11750 23.12.2023 20:22:12 False suggestion
Drummond-812
H
1531 Isabell Campbell (Drummond) before 12 Apr 1540 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland 1568 Kilmarnock, Ayrshire, Scotland Female Kittredge-46
Q75243310 Isabel Drummond (Peerage person ID=5277) 1531 1568 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:01:58 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Grant-13629
H
22 Jul 1808 General Si James Hope Grant KCB certain 21 Jul 1808 certain Dunbarney, Perthshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 7 Mar 1875 certain St George Hanover Square, London, England, United Kingdom Male Simmons-11603
Q1132618 James Hope Grant (British army general) 22 Jul 1808 Bridge of Earn United Kingdom 7 Mar 1875 London United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cameron-5666 28.06.2019 07:57:48 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced
Ross-11441
H
1520 James of Craigton Ross uncertain 1518 certain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 1543 certain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Blair-3347
Q76055225 James Ross of Craigie (Peerage person ID=498866) 1520 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:05:19 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Dunbar-1162
H
1416 Janet Dunbar uncertain 1427 certain Huntley, Aberdeenshire, Scotland before 19 Jan 1506 uncertain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Q75902169 Lady Janet Dunbar (Peerage person ID=392399) 1416 1506 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:29:40 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Gray-2078
H
1470 Lady Janet Gray Lady Wemyss (Gray) uncertain 1490 certain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland certain Oct 1539 uncertain Lovat, Inverness-shire, Scotland Female Orphan
Q75262380 Janet Gray (Peerage person ID=20416) 1470 Oct 1539 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:49:16 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Bonar-290
H
4 Nov 1722 Rev John Bonar certain 4 Nov 1721 Clackmannan, Clackmannanshire, Scotland 21 Dec 1761 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Q16206831 John Bonar (Scottish minister (1722-1761)) 4 Nov 1722 21 Dec 1761 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Templeton-1883 07.10.2019 16:47:10 False suggestion Wikidata incorrect - Scotland moved new year to 1 January in 1600
Carnegie-557
H
18 Aug 1690 John Carnegie certain 8 Aug 1690 certain Errol, Perthshire, Scotland not living uncertain Male Boal-186
Q76306566 John Carnegie (Peerage person ID=676761) 18 Aug 1690 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Boal-186 07.12.2021 18:28:12 Corrected
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:15:43 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
De Carnegy-2
H
1431 John Carnegy IIIrd of Kinnaird (De Carnegy) uncertain 1450 certain Kinnaird, Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 15 Apr 1508 certain Kinnaird, Perthshire, Scotland Male Nilsen-785
Q75679268 John de Carnegie of Kinnaird (Peerage person ID=285609) 1431 1508 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:55:04 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Drummond-1397
H
1550 John Drummond IVth of Lennoch (Drummond) before 1545 Lennoch, Perthshire, Scotland certain 1579 Lennoch, Perthshire, Scotland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q76310043 John Drummond, 4th of Lennoch (Peerage person ID=679229) 1550 1579 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:16:38 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Dunkeld-41
H
23 Apr 1141 Malcolm Malcolm IV King of Scots (Dunkeld) certain 20 Mar 1141 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland certain 9 Dec 1165 uncertain Jedburgh, Roxburghshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q122479 Malcolm IV of Scotland (Scottish king (1141-1165)) 23 Apr 1141 Kingdom of Scotland Kingdom of Scotland 9 Dec 1165 Jedburgh United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stevens-17832 14.09.2021 01:17:07 False suggestion
Scotland-495
H
1072 Malcolm of Scotland (Scotland) before 1070 Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland Oct 1094 Montacute Abbey, Somerset, England Male Orphan
Q75384545 Malcolm of Scotland (Peerage person ID=104736) 1072 Oct 1094 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:31:33 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Colquhoun-8
H
1410 Margaret Colquhoun Lady Tullibardine (Colquhoun) uncertain 1438 Tullibardine, Perth, Scotland after 1454 Tullibardine Castle, Blackford, Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Female Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q75267250 Margaret Colquhoun (Peerage person ID=24081) 1410 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:32:34 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Drummond-48
H
1475 Lady Margaret Drummond uncertain 1476 Innerpeffray, Crief, Perthshire, Scotland certain May 1502 Muthill, Perthshire, Scotland Female Orphan
Q13646786 Margaret Drummond (mistress of James IV of Scotland) 1475 Drummond Castle United Kingdom 1502 Drummond Castle United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 12.09.2023 18:53:31 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Ruthven-12
H
1577 Lady Margaret Ruthven Countess of Montrose (Ruthven) before 1570 uncertain Gowrie, Perthshire, Scotland before 15 Apr 1618 uncertain Auchterarder, Perthshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q61466913 Mary Rutwenn (Peerage person ID=28150) 1577 1618 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 01.12.2023 08:21:57 Comment Tartan Trail profile - updates to be done only by their team
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 17:32:39 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Stewart-1625
H
1524 Margaret Stewart before 19 Feb 1527 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland certain 1555 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Female Mac Rae-4

Parker-10195
Q75263657 Lady Margaret Stewart (Peerage person ID=21376) 1524 1555 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:27:25 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Stirling-553
H
1622 Mary Jane Stirling uncertain 1614 Kier, Perthshire, Scotland 12 Aug 1685 Blackhall, Renfrewshire, Scotland Female Hunter-5770
Q76092904 Mary Stirling (Peerage person ID=525487) 1622 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 17:44:00 False suggestion ThePeerage is not reliable
Montifex-1
H
1325 Mary Margaret Drummond (Montifex) aka Montefichet, Montefixo 1330 Stobhall, Cargill, Perth, Scotland 1424 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65

Wright-7062
Q75382394 Mary Montifex (Peerage person ID=102464) 1325 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 22:45:40 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Ross-3333
H
26 Dec 1688 Mary Ross Lady Tullibardine (Ross) certain 26 Jan 1688 certain Scotland uncertain 17 Jan 1767 certain Huntingtower, Perthshire, Scotland Female Ross-16829

Thomas-10705
Q75264531 Mary Ross ((1688-1767)) 26 Dec 1688 17 Jan 1767 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Gray-8215 30.11.2023 05:07:09 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, see source on WikiTree profile
Drummond-637
H
1554 Lady Mary Stirling (Drummond) uncertain 1570 Scotland before 1589 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Female Lee-37498

Hunter-5770

Ratliff-242
Q75431805 Mary Drummond (Peerage person ID=137696) 1554 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:35:01 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Graham-4040
H
1552 Nicola Murray (Graham) aka Graeme before 1538 Inchbrakie, Scotland certain Apr 1560 certain Ochertyre, Perth, Scotland Female Gordon-7317
Q76083801 Nicola Graham (Peerage person ID=519076) 1552 Apr 1560 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 06.12.2023 04:36:24 False suggestion peerage is unreliable
Drummond-300
H
1550 Patrick Drummond Third Lord Drummond (Drummond) 1556 Drummond, Perthshire, Scotland 18 Dec 1611 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Ratliff-242
Q75264073 Patrick Drummond, 3rd Lord Drummond (Peerage person ID=21685) 1550 1500 1600 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:35:23 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Hay-306
H
1423 William Hay First Earl of Errol (Hay) 1412 Erroll, Perth, Scotland after 15 Nov 1461 Slains, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q18821934 William Hay, 1st Earl of Erroll (Scottish nobleman, died 1462) 1423 Errol United Kingdom 15 Nov 1461 Old Slains Castle United Kingdom male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 22.11.2020 20:27:15 False suggestion birth date is unsourced
Menzies-1115
H
1740 William Menzies uncertain May 1733 certain Perthshire, Scotland certain 16 Jun 1793 certain Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Male Howard-18870

Hare-1576
Q76091050 William Menzies ((died 1793)) 1740 1793 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Howard-18870 04.02.2024 22:50:35 False suggestion
Murray-920
H
1510 Sir William of Tullibardine Earl of Montrose Murray uncertain 1495 uncertain Tullibardine, Perthshire, Scotland certain 30 Jan 1562 uncertain Tullibardine, Perthshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Q75264845 Sir William Murray, 10th of Tullibardine (Peerage person ID=22267) 1510 30 Jan 1562 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Carruth-363 02.12.2023 23:02:53 False suggestion ThePeerage is unreliable
Moncrieffe-5
H
1519 Sir William younger of Moncreiffe Moncreiffe (Moncrieffe) uncertain 1526 Gordonshall, Fifeshire, Scotland uncertain 1570 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Moncrief-207
Q75266274 William Moncreiffe of that Ilk, younger (Peerage person ID=23307) 1519 1570 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McIntosh-5576 02.12.2023 10:53:51 False suggestion The Peerage is not a reliable source
Dallas-Yorke-1
H
5 Sep 1863 Winifred Anna Cavendish-Bentinck (Dallas-Yorke) DBE JP 7 Sep 1863 Murthly Castle, Perthshire, Scotland, United Kingdom 30 Jul 1954 Nottinghamshire, England Female Trimbee-2
Q528836 Winifred Cavendish-Bentinck, Duchess of Portland (humanitarian, reformer, animal rights advocate) 5 Sep 1863 Perthshire United Kingdom 30 Jul 1954 Nottinghamshire United Kingdom female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Parker-41651 13.10.2021 12:03:31 False suggestion Wikidata is unsourced, sources confirm the date on wikitree