Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 558: Wikidata - Different death date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
MacAlpin-18
H 		1058 Boete Bodhe McAlpin (MacAlpin) uncertain 990 Atholl, Perth, Scotland after 1033 Male Perkins-11750

WikiTree-65
Q335885 Boite mac Cináeda (11th-century Scottish prince) 985 1058 male
Stewart-966
H 		1386 David Stewart Earl Palatine of Strathern and Caithness (Stewart) 1357 Dundonald, Ayrshire, Scotland uncertain 5 Mar 1389 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Stewart-6071
Q4444832 David Stewart, Earl of Strathearn (Scottish Earl) 1357 1386 male
Mar-35
H 		11 Aug 1332 Domhnall Domhnall II Donald, Earl of Mar, Regent of Scotland Mar uncertain 1294 Saline, Fifeshire, Scotland 12 Aug 1332 Dupplin Moor, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q1237391 Domhnall II, Earl of Mar (14th-century Scottish nobleman) 1302 11 Aug 1332 11 Aug 1332 male
Dunkeld-78
H 		8 Jan 1107 Edgar Edgar I King of Scots (Dunkeld) uncertain 1074 Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland certain 6 Jan 1107 certain Edinburgh Castle, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q332140 Edgar (King of Scotland (1074-1107)) 1074 8 Jan 1107 8 Jan 1107 Edinburgh United Kingdom male
Douglas-421
H 		12 Mar 1463 George Fourth Earl of Angus (Douglas) uncertain 1427 Mar, Aberdeenshire, Scotland 14 Nov 1462 Abernethy, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q359632 George Douglas, 4th Earl of Angus (Scottish earl and diplomat) 1417 12 Mar 1463 male
Stewart-1203
H 		26 Oct 1460 Isabel Murray (Stewart) aka Oliphant uncertain 1393 Scotland after 1445 Tullibardine, Blackford, Perthshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
Q75268603 Isabel Stewart (Peerage person ID=25156) 1388 26 Oct 1460 female
Stewart-13721
H 		1329 Sir John de Menteith (Stewart) uncertain 1265 Kerse, Renfrewshire, Scotland after 1323 Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q12858658 John de Menteith (Scottish nobleman) 1275 Perthshire United Kingdom 1329 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 26.03.2020 14:01:16 Corrected
Drummond-52
H 		1518 Sir John Drummond Ist Lord Drummond (Drummond) after 1445 Stobhall, Perthshire, Scotland 18 Dec 1519 uncertain Drummond Castle, Strathearn, Scotland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q6230177 John Drummond, 1st Lord Drummond (Scottish statesman) 1518 male
Plantagenet-586
H 		13 Sep 1336 Prince John Earl of Cornwall of Eltham (Plantagenet) 15 Aug 1316 Eltham Palace, Kent, England 14 Sep 1336 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-113
Q561807 John of Eltham, Earl of Cornwall (English prince and earl) 15 Aug 1316 London United Kingdom 13 Sep 1336 Perth United Kingdom male
Oliphant-74
H 		1498 Laurence 1st Lord Oliphant Oliphant 1439 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland 8 Apr 1500 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Q16863398 Laurence Oliphant, 1st Lord Oliphant (Scottish peer) 1434 1498 male
Earl of Atholl-2
H 		1151 Maddad Maddad Atholl (Earl of Atholl) aka Earl of Atholl uncertain 1103 Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland after 1142 Atholl, Perthshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Q3298174 Matad, Earl of Atholl (Mormaer of Atholl) 1151 male
Strathearn-32
H 		1329 Sir Malise Seventh Earl of Strathearn (Strathearn) uncertain 1278 Strathearn, Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 1327 Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q6753645 Maol Íosa IV (Mormaer of Strathearn) 12cen 1329 male
Huntingdon-28
H 		1130 Maud Queen Maud of Scotland, Maud of Northumberland of Scotland (Huntingdon) aka de Senlis uncertain 1074 certain Huntingdonshire, England uncertain 1131 certain Scone, Perthshire, Scotland Female Wright-7062

WikiTree-65

Fields-574

Lee-759
Q2327302 Maud, Countess of Huntingdon (Queen consort of Scotland) 1074 1130 Kingdom of Scotland Kingdom of Scotland female
Keith-393
H 		11 Aug 1332 Sir Robert Marischal of Scotland Keith uncertain 1274 uncertain Scotland uncertain 1343 certain Dupplin, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q7345780 Robert II Keith, Marischal of Scotland (Scottish noble) 11 Aug 1332 Battle of Dupplin Moor Kingdom of Scotland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lohbeck-3 16.06.2021 04:34:33 Not corrected Keith's d.o.d. is disputed among historians. It is known that he did not die in 1332. These discrepancies are addressed in the bio.
Lohbeck-3 04.07.2021 00:21:57 Not corrected Through extensive research, Wikidata appears incorrect.
Comyn-46
H 		Dec 1258 Walter Lord of Badenoch, 4th Earl of Menteith Comyn 1190 Buchan, Aberdeenshire, , Scotland uncertain Nov 1258 Perth, Perthshire, , Scotland Male WikiTree-65
Q2543918 Walter Comyn, Lord of Badenoch (Scottish noble (died 1258)) 12000101 Dec 1258 male
Stewart-3634
H 		1500 William 1st of Lettir and Royal Bailie of Balquhidder Stewart IIIrd of Baldorran (Stewart) uncertain 1455 Baldorran, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland before Apr 1513 Scotland Male Stuart-531
Q8018842 William Stewart (Scottish landowner, founder of the Balquhidder Stewart clan) 1440 Scotland United Kingdom 1500 Scotland United Kingdom male
De la Haye-59
H 		1437 Sir William Hay First Lord Hay and Eighth Baron Erroll (de la Haye) uncertain 1374 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland 1436 Turriff, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Shelton-1487
Q19325866 Sir William de la Haye, 1st Lord Hay (Scottish nobleman, died 1437) 1437 male
Murray-575
H 		15 Jun 1452 Sir William Murray VIIIth of Tullibardine (Murray) certain 1432 Tullibardine Castle, Blackford, Perth, Perthshire, Scotland uncertain 1459 Tullibardine Castle, Perth, Perthshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Sutherland-Fisher-1
Q75267242 Sir William Murray of Tullibardine (Peerage person ID=24076) 1432 15 Jun 1452 male