Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 210: Father was dead before birth Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Smitt-13
H
Richard Smitt Father after 1872 Male Povey-138
Schmidt-9844
H
Hector Ferdinand Schmidt Child uncertain 1874 Victoria, Australia Male Povey-138
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Povey-138 07.08.2018 02:25:08 False suggestion both dates are correct as per records - notes made regarding suspicion of NPE
Fardy-30
H
Patritius Patrick Fardy Father uncertain 1818 certain Wexford, Ireland certain 11 Apr 1852 certain Louisa Creek, New South Wales, Australia Male Hackett-970
Fardy-67
H
Richard Fardy Child uncertain 1856 certain Bathurst, New South Wales, Australia certain 3 May 1918 certain Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia Male McCarron-898
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McCarron-858 08.02.2019 02:40:34 False suggestion Not biological father but was known as his son. See DC
Webster-8567
H
James Webster Father uncertain 1837 uncertain Liverpool, Lancashire, England uncertain 1873 Victoria Male Rosser-226
Webster-8569
H
Jane Webster Child uncertain 1875 certain Wodonga, Victoria uncertain 1876 certain Victoria Female Rosser-226
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Darcy-578 28.03.2018 08:29:19 False suggestion 'about' date only
Hynes-493
H
Hugh Hynes Father certain 9 Apr 1845 certain Yass, New South Wales, Australia certain 20 Jan 1882 certain Gunagie Lake, Hillston, New South Wales, Australia Male Hannan-457
Hines-3596
H
Hannah Nora O'Neill Moran (Hines) Child uncertain 3 Jun 1884 uncertain Hillston, New South Wales, Australia certain 7 Nov 1964 certain Miranda, New South Wales, Australia Female Hannan-457
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jones-36835 19.03.2019 07:47:01 Comment Added research note and changed father to 'uncertain'
Hannan-457 26.09.2019 05:09:08 Comment DOD is correct, Research note is confirmed.
Hannan-457 02.10.2019 23:02:54 False suggestion It is recognised that Hugh Hynes could not have been the father of Hannah Nora O'Neill Moran (Hines) but BDM records reflect her claim.
Jackson-50133
H
William Robert Jackson Father 1859 Great Western, Victoria, Australia 18 Jun 1885 Casterton, Victoria, Australia Male Wickham-1317
Jackson-50153
H
James Jackson Child 1887 Carlton, Victoria, Australia 1888 Prahran, Victoria, Australia Male Wickham-1317
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Wickham-1317 24.05.2023 07:54:13 False suggestion Discrepency noted in profile
Sullivan-10531
H
Thomas Sullivan Father uncertain 1861 uncertain certain 25 Jan 1894 certain Sydney, New South Wales, Australia Male Orphan
Sullivan-10536
H
Walter James James Joseph Sullivan Child uncertain Jun 1895 certain Sydney, New South Wales, Australia certain 19 Jul 1916 certain Fromelles, Nord-Pas-de-Calais, France Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Fowler-5882 22.11.2018 14:36:49 False suggestion Well researched article with the discrepancy noted and possible reasons for it