Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 210: Father was dead before birth (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information .

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
CLEMENS-3042 H		William CLEMENS	Father	uncertain 1 Jan 1800	uncertain 1 Jan 1800	Male		Lindsey-6805
CLEMENS-3041 H		James CLEMENS	Child	uncertain 1864	uncertain 1910	Male		Lindsey-6805
Barry-2786 H		John Barry	Father	uncertain 1805 certain Ballybunnion, County Kerry, Ireland 1805	certain 19 Feb 1883 certain Bacchus Marsh, Victoria, Australia	Male		Connell-1911 Barry-2277
Barry-5458 H		Barbara Ethel Crawley (Barry)	Child	certain 1885 Warrnambool, Victoria, Australia		Female		Barry-2277
Elliott-13089 H		John Elliott	Father	1811	1869 Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Elliott-6339 H		Elizabeth Hannah Digby (Elliott)	Child	certain 1871 Forest Lodge, New South Wales, Australia	certain 1926 Liverpool, New South Wales, Australia	Female		Digby-255
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Murphy-4751 23.02.2019 07:06:32 Not corrected sent private message to profile manager - father's death may have been in NSW and not Victoria??
Wallis-2489 H		William John Wallis	Father	uncertain 1814 St. Just in Penwith, Cornwall, England	uncertain Aug 1869 Pendeen, Cornwall, England	Male		Parrott-1037
Wallis-2488 H		William David Wallis	Child	uncertain 1875 London, England	uncertain 19 Nov 1948 Nhill, Victoria, Australia	Male		Parrott-1037
Toll-252 H		William Toll	Father	uncertain 1817 South Creake, Norfolk, England, United Kingdom	3 Feb 1845 South Creake, Norfolk, England, United Kingdom	Male		Newton-7466
Toll-251 H		Eliza Pryke (Toll)	Child	uncertain 1849 Norfolk England	certain 23 May 1925 Morwell Victoria Australia	Female		Newton-7466
De Brito-18 H		Joao Soares de Brito	Father	uncertain 1818 Oporto, Portugal	certain 25 Mar 1851 Victoria	Male		De Bruto-1
De Brito-21 H		Joao Soares Frederik de Brito	Child	20 Nov 1852 Victoria-West		Male		De Bruto-1
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Murphy-4751 23.02.2019 07:11:22 Not corrected This is a South African matter not an Australian matter. Victoria West is a town in the central Karoo region of South Africa's Northern Cape province.
Cassidy-3757 H		William Cassidy	Father	uncertain 1819 certain Ramsbury, Wiltshire, England, United Kingdom	certain 1855 Newstead, Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Cassidy-3762 H		Thomas Cassidy	Child	uncertain 1857 uncertain	certain 15 Apr 1862 certain Captains Gully, Newstead, Victoria, Australia	Male		Thompson-72973
Lee-41901 H		John Lee	Father	uncertain 1821 England, United Kingdom	uncertain 1852 Tasmania, Australia	Male		Hudson-12616
Lee-32463 H		Elizabeth Robinson (Lee) aka Lee	Child	uncertain 1854 certain Tasmania, Australia	certain 1943 certain Victoria, Australia	Female		Hudson-12616
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Hawkins-5569 08.10.2023 03:11:08 Comment Left a comment on the profiles of father and daughter
Darby-2890 H		Tarlcoomba Tara Bobby Old Darby Darby	Father	1821	1860 Healesville, Victoria, Australia	Male		Darby-2163
Darby-2893 H		Albert Darby	Child	Apr 1862 South Gippsland, Victoria, Australia	24 Feb 1910 Healesville, Victoria, Australia	Male		Darby-2163
Leber-243 H		Johann Gottlob Leber	Father	27 Feb 1825 Metschkau, Striegau, Breslau, Silesia, Prussia, Germany	uncertain 14 Dec 1879 Nunawading, Victoria, Australia	Male		Harvey-14991
Leber-274 H		Helene Helena Leber	Child	8 Apr 1881 Doncaster, Victoria, Australia	10 Apr 1881 Doncaster, Victoria, Australia	Female		Harvey-14991
Kelly-25086 H		Mr Jeremiah Jermiah Kelly	Father	uncertain 1826 Bruff, County Limerick, Ireland	certain 1869 Eaglehawk, Victoria, Australia	Male		Black-18195
Kelly-25056 H		Catherine Maria Thomas (Kelly)	Child	certain 14 Feb 1886 California Gully, Victoria, Australia	certain 1942 certain Eaglehawk, Victoria, Australia	Female		Black-18195
Plant-1255 H		Richard Plant	Father	29 Jan 1826 Sibsey, Lincolnshire, England	certain 18 Jul 1878 certain Winchelsea, Victoria, Australia	Male		Miller-69842
Plant-2085 H		Florence Beatrice Patullo (Plant)	Child	1881 Victoria, Australia	1967 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	Female		Carpenter-13948
Morrissey-341 H		Michael Morrissey	Father	uncertain 1828 Tipperary, Ireland	certain 20 Nov 1862 Collingwood, Victoria, Australia	Male		Duffy-1021
Morrissey-413 H		Bridget Jane Thomas (Morrissey)	Child	1865 Collingwood, Victoria, Australia	8 Feb 1943 Ivanhoe, Victoria, Australia	Female		Mansfield-764
Cashman-838 H		James Cashman	Father	certain 1829	certain 21 Aug 1854 Carlton, Victoria, Australia	Male		Cashman-311
Cashman-1531 H		William Cashman	Child	uncertain 1857 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	uncertain 1857 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	Male		Cashman-311
Hughes-33378 H		Hugh Charles Hughes	Father	uncertain 1830	certain 18 Oct 1864 certain Dunolly, Victoria, Australia	Male		Gallagher-4934
Hughes-33379 H		Jane Hayes (Hughes)	Child	certain 1867 certain Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	certain Jul 1919 certain Victoria, Australia	Female		Gallagher-4934
Stratford-1125 H		Charles Alexander Stratford	Father	1830 Tuscany, Italy	13 Nov 1892 Avon Plains, Victoria, Australia	Male		Bennett-16527
Stratford-642 H		Alice Robertson (Stratford)	Child	uncertain 1896	6 Mar 1980 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	Female		Bennett-16527
Rowland-13817 H		Alfred Rowland	Father	1831 Bassingbourn, Cambridgeshire, England, United Kingdom	29 Jan 1860 Ballarat, Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Cubis-118 H		William John Henry Cubis	Child	uncertain 1870 Ballarat, Victoria, Australia	uncertain 1918 New Zealand	Male		Orphan
Lear-382 H		Isaac Lear	Father	23 Dec 1833 Hobart, Tasmania	3 Nov 1878 Alberton, Victoria, Australia	Male		Piper-533
Lear-1702 H		Mabel Hannah Lear	Child	uncertain 1881	1899 Tarraville, Victoria, Australia	Female		Orphan
Williams-87846 H		Thomas Williams	Father	uncertain 1834	after 1873	Male		Wittick-13
Williams-92365 H		Gertrude May Williams	Child	certain 22 Jul 1876 Hawthorn, Victoria, Australia	10 Mar 1933 Camperdown, Victoria, Australia	Female		Wittick-13
Magnus-145 H		Edward Magnus	Father	1835 certain Berlin, Prussia	22 Aug 1892 certain His Residence, Bignell Street, Flemington, Victoria, Australia	Male		Smyth-733
Kay-1009 H		Hugh Hughie Charles Kay	Child	uncertain 1900	21 Jan 1915 Yarra River, Burnley, Victoria, Australia	Male		Smyth-733
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Murphy-4751 23.02.2019 09:33:09 Not corrected No change needed because Hugh Kay was an adopted child Smyth-733 29.12.2022 14:04:34 Corrected Child was a fostered child.

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
Wellington-736 H		Richard Wellington	Father	1838 certain Sancreed, Cornwall, England	certain 16 Dec 1875 certain Eldorado, Victoria, Australia	Male		Barton-3864
Wellington-448 H		John Roche Wellington	Child	certain 1 Dec 1877 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	certain 28 Feb 1943 Marrickville, New South Wales, Australia	Male		Wellington-831 Wright-21903
Stapleton-2824 H		James Stapleton	Father	uncertain 1838 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	certain 1 Jun 1883 South Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Stapleton-2823 H		William Henry Schiller Stapleton	Child	certain 1885 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	certain 28 Dec 1949 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Randall-8422 H		Austin Randall	Father	uncertain 1838	1903 Bendigo, Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Randall-9161 H		Nelly Comley (Randall)	Child	certain 1906 Kangaroo Flat, Victoria, Australia	1987 Bairnsdale, Victoria, Australia	Female		Connolly-2057
Fenaughty-5 H		Timothy Fenaughty	Father	uncertain 1840 County Limerick, Ireland	certain 28 Aug 1904 Tatura, Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Fenaughty-12 H		Frances Fenaughty	Child	certain 1912 Tatura, Victoria, Australia		Female		Orphan
Butters-453 H		William Benjamin Butters	Father	uncertain 1841 uncertain County Westmeath, Ireland	certain 1876 Victoria, Australia	Male		Brown-49888
Butters-581 H		Jean Wilson (Butters)	Child	uncertain 1878	certain 1949 Caversham, Western Australia, Australia	Female		Brown-49888
Danger-26 H		Samuel Danger	Father	certain 1844 Newton, Cambridgeshire, England	18 Oct 1880 Mt Moriac, Victoria, Australia	Male		Vincent-4753
Danger-33 H		William James Danger	Child	certain 1883	certain 1962	Male		Vincent-4753
Gaston-237 H		Joseph Gaston	Father	28 Jan 1844 Williamstown or Adelaide, South Australia, Australia	1864 Balrootan North, Victoria, Australia	Male		Wiltshire-219
Gaston-1821 H		Elsie Maud Smith (Gaston)	Child	certain 1885 Nhill, Victoria, Australia	certain 3 Nov 1965 Hopetoun, Victoria, Australia	Female		Freeland-1243
Gaston-237 H		Joseph Gaston	Father	28 Jan 1844 Williamstown or Adelaide, South Australia, Australia	1864 Balrootan North, Victoria, Australia	Male		Wiltshire-219
Gaston-1739 H		Eliza Keam (Gaston)	Child	uncertain 7 Jan 1871 Caroline, South Australia, Australia	uncertain 22 Feb 1967 Horsham, Victoria, Australia	Female		Gaston-1690
Gaston-237 H		Joseph Gaston	Father	28 Jan 1844 Williamstown or Adelaide, South Australia, Australia	1864 Balrootan North, Victoria, Australia	Male		Wiltshire-219
Gaston-287 H		William George Gaston	Child	21 Apr 1876 Horsham, Victoria, Australia	23 Jun 1939 Brunswick, Victoria, Australia	Male		Gaston-1690
Humphries-3294 H		John Humphries	Father	uncertain 1850	after 1891	Male		Orphan
Humphries-3293 H		Francis Frank Henry Humphries	Child	1893 Yando, Victoria, Australia	4 May 1956 Tallangatta, Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Wyatt-6651 H		William Alexander Panton Wyatt	Father	certain 30 Apr 1853 certain Ipswich, Queensland, Australia	certain 20 Sep 1875 certain Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	Male		Phillips-20168
Wyatt-5801 H		Charlotte Louisa Pearson (Wyatt)	Child	certain 22 Dec 1876 Sydney, New South Wales, Australia	certain 3 Oct 1955 certain Kingsgrove, New South Wales, Australia	Female		Phillips-20591
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Phillips-20591 14.10.2023 09:46:53 Corrected
McDonald-15198 H		William Edward McDonald	Father	uncertain 1854 Castlemaine, Victoria Australia	uncertain 1904 Heidelberg Victoria Australia	Male		McDonald-14600
McDonald-22994 H		Clarice Bedford (McDonald)	Child	after 1915 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	uncertain 1990 Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	Female		McDonald-14600
Long-20068 H		David Long	Father	certain 17 Sep 1854 certain Geelong, Victoria, Australia	certain 28 Jan 1885 certain Leopold, Victoria, Australia	Male		Threlfall-89
Long-20215 H		Frederick Leslie Long	Child	certain 15 Oct 1896 Geelong, Victoria, Australia	certain 9 Jan 1945 Malvern East, Victoria, Australia	Male		Threlfall-89
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Gardner-20624 30.05.2023 11:35:45 Corrected Father was non-biological
Williams-127546 H		Charles William Williams	Father	certain 1855 Wandiligong, Victoria, Australia	certain 1890 Ballarat East, Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Williams-127545 H		Thomas Walter Williams	Child	certain 2 May 1895 Grantville, Victoria, Australia	certain 17 Jul 1977 Heidelberg, Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Jennings-11766 H		Sydney Charles Jennings Snr.	Father	uncertain 1861 Birmingham, Warwickshire, England, United Kingdom	1909 St Kilda, Victoria, Australia	Male		Saward-247
Jennings-12242 H		Dorothy Eva Norton (Jennings) aka Hancock	Child	certain 15 Jan 1916 certain 337 Lennox St, Richmond, Victoria, Australia	certain 1981 Bendigo, Victoria, Australia	Female		Saward-247
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Saward-247 25.06.2022 03:31:10 Corrected Father is on birth certificate.
Simpson-12095 H		Frederick Simpson	Father	1861	1913 Orbost, Victoria, Australia	Male		Yarley-33
Simpson-12311 H		Laura Simpson	Child	1915 Boisdale, Victoria, Australia		Female		Yarley-33
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Fowler-5882 20.03.2018 13:05:09 Not corrected Dates seem to be accurate, sent PM a message
Blake-5834 H		Walter Blake	Father	certain 1863 Merino, Victoria, Australia	certain 26 Aug 1915 Noradjuha	Male		Bull-3568
Blake-5884 H		Nolan T. Blake	Child	uncertain 1920s	certain 1980s	Male		Bull-3568
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Molesworth-181 27.12.2018 12:00:33 Comment Left a comment on the profile. This is showing what the sources showed.
Cudmore-718 H		James Anthony Cudmore	Father	uncertain 1865 certain Moonambel, Victoria, Australia	uncertain 1929 certain Heidelberg, Victoria, Australia	Male		Cudmore-654
Cudmore-720 H		Patrick James Cudmore	Child	certain 16 Sep 1935 uncertain	certain 12 Apr 2005 certain Griffith, New South Wales, Australia	Male		Cudmore-654
Andreasson-351 H		Carl Johann Anderson (Andreasson)	Father	1 Jan 1865 Göteborg, Vastra Gotaland, Sweden	23 Dec 1908 Dimboola, Victoria, Australia	Male		Anderson-47504
Anderson-73201 H		Ronald Bruce Anderson	Child	uncertain 12 Feb 1910 Warracknabeal, Victoria, Australia	certain 7 Jun 2009	Male		McGrice-37
Stamford-92 H		Henry Charles Stamford	Father	certain 1867 certain Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	certain 11 Oct 1895 certain Melbourne, Victoria, Australia	Male		Irving-10695
Stamford-99 H		Winifred Flanagan (Stamford)	Child	certain 6 Mar 1897 Williamstown, Victoria, Australia	19 Nov 1982 Western Australia, Australia	Female		Irving-10695

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
Gouge-422 H		Auguste Joseph Gouge	Father	uncertain 1871	after 1901	Male		Fuller-20463
Gouge-448 H		Marcel Gouge	Child	1903 Brighton, Victoria, Australia	1928 Moss Vale, New South Wales, Australia	Male		Fuller-20463
Gouge-422 H		Auguste Joseph Gouge	Father	uncertain 1871	after 1901	Male		Fuller-20463
Gougè-418 H		Pamela Valerie Margaret McClure (Gougè)	Child	certain 10 Jan 1908 Brighton, Victoria, Australia	1976 Australia	Female		Stuart-531
Ellis-18667 H		Edward Ellis	Father	uncertain 1871	certain 1923 Mitta Mitta, Victoria, Australia	Male		Orphan
Ellis-8551 H		Lillian Mary Kohne (Ellis)	Child	before 1928	certain 1964 Parkville, Victoria, Australia	Female		Weekes-256
Parrot-139 H		Ernest Garner Parrot	Father	certain 1873 Uppingham, Rutland, England	18 Jun 1931 Victoria, Australia	Male		Laffey-98
Parrot-141 H		Adrian A. Parrot	Child	before 1940s	2000s	Male		Laffey-98
Seaforth-3 H		Mr Barclay Seaforth	Father	uncertain 1875 Buxton, Demerara-Mahaica, Guyanal	uncertain 1914 uncertain Buxton, Demerara-Mahaica, Guyana	Male		Stüger-1
Seaforth-12 H		Albertha Seaforth	Child	uncertain 1935 Buxton, Victoria, Australia	uncertain 1980 Buxton, Demerara-Mahaica, Guyana	Female		Stüger-1
Lynch-13636 H		Thomas William Lynch	Father	certain 26 Aug 1880 certain Geelong, Victoria, Australia	certain 21 Sep 1917	Male		Zerbst-37
Lynch-13954 H		Mona Maria Condy (Lynch)	Child	uncertain 1921 certain Geelong, Victoria, Australia	certain 24 Jun 2005 uncertain Geelong, Victoria, Australia	Female		Zerbst-37
Andrews-23006 H		John Arthur Andrews	Father	uncertain 1882	1913	Male		Venables-249
Andrew-4441 H		Frances Jean Harland (Andrew)	Child	uncertain 1920 Victoria, Australia	8 Nov 1976 Fawkner, Victoria, Australia	Female		Venables-249
Lawler-1871 H		Robert Thomas Bob Lawler	Father	certain 11 May 1882 certain Donald, Victoria, Australia	certain 25 Aug 1921 certain Saint Arnaud, Victoria, Australia	Male		Cox-17512
Lawler-2139 H		Patricia Smith (Lawler)	Child	uncertain 1923 Victoria, Australia	after 2014	Female		Bailey-30029
Cheevers-48 H		James Cheevers	Father	certain 1891 Caulfield, Victoria, Australia	1947 Ringwood, Victoria, Australia	Male		Cheevers-47
Cheevers-47 H		Ms Maree Cheevers	Child	certain 1960s				Cheevers-47
McKenzie-3981 H		Joseph Clarence Clarence McKenzie	Father	certain 31 Jul 1891 Romsey, Victoria, Australia	certain 26 Jun 1919 New Norfolk, Tasmania, Australia	Male		McKenzie-3979
McKenzie-9720 H		Eunice Alma McKenzie	Child	13 Dec 1921 Launceston Tasmania Australia	31 Jul 1988 Launceston Tasmania Australia	Female		Stokes-3595