Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 555: Wikidata - Different birth date Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Stewart-32509
H
12 Dec 1813 Capt RN Arthur Stewart Esquire certain 13 Dec 1813 St Marylebone, London, England certain 30 Jun 1879 Cork, Ireland Male Miller-42849
Q75714670 Arthur Stewart ((1813-1879)) 12 Dec 1813 30 Jun 1879 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Miller-42849 06.12.2019 18:31:52 Comment Birth date correct as per baptismal record; source added to profile.
Miller-42849 19.12.2019 22:16:57 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
FitzGerald-3970
H
1452 Catherine Katherine Reagh (FitzGerald) uncertain 1440 Desmond, Kerry, Ireland 1506 Carberry, County Cork, Ireland Female Orphan
Q24882980 Katherine Fitzgerald, Lady of Hy-Carbery (Anglo-Irish Noblewoman of the Geraldine's dynasty {c.1452-1506)) 1452 County Limerick Republic of Ireland 1506 County Cork Republic of Ireland female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Willis-3076 08.04.2018 22:31:38 False suggestion no source to base Wikidata suggestion on
O'Donoghue-240
H
1784 Charles O'Donoghue 1778 County Kerry, Ireland 21 Feb 1808 Summerhill, Killarney, County Kerry, Ireland Male Falvey-115
Q75650854 Charles O'Donoghue, The O'Donaghue of the Glens ((1784-1808)) 1784 21 Feb 1808 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Falvey-115 08.08.2023 15:08:29 False suggestion He joined the army in 1793!
Hoare-860
H
1670 Edward Hoare uncertain Jun 1652 Dublin, County Dublin, Ireland certain 3 Nov 1709 Dunkettle, County Cork, Ireland Male Orphan
Q75664664 Edward Hoare ((1670-1709)) 1670 3 Nov 1709 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Watson-7240 20.11.2022 04:10:22 False suggestion
Hoare-861
H
1626 Major Edward Hoare uncertain 1620 England certain 3 Sep 1690 Cork, County Cork, Ireland Male Watson-7240
Q75975435 Edward Hoare ((died 1690)) 1626 3 Jul 1690 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Watson-7240 16.11.2022 13:55:07 False suggestion
Denison-13
H
1618 Capt. George Denison Sr. before 10 Dec 1620 certain Bishop's Stortford, Hertfordshire, England 23 Oct 1694 Hartford, Hartford, Connecticut Colony Male Vierson-2
Q96213552 Capt. George Denison (1618 - 23 Oct 1694 Hartford, Connecticut) 1618 1694 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cole-12288 27.07.2021 21:35:37 False suggestion both dates are estimates
Newenham-4
H
10 Sep 1752 George Newenham 10 Sep 1753 North Abbey, Cork, Ireland 21 Oct 1821 Summerhill, Cork, Ireland Male Watson-7240
Q75881493 George Newenham (Irish businessman (1752-1821)) 10 Sep 1752 10 Sep 1752 1750 10 Sep 1752 1750 10 Sep 1752 1750 1750 Cork Republic of Ireland 21 Oct 1821 Cork Republic of Ireland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Watson-7240 07.03.2023 01:37:09 False suggestion
McCarthy-9251
H
1803 Helen Morrogh (McCarthy) uncertain 1811 County Cork, Ireland 24 Aug 1879 Dublin, County Dublin, Ireland Female Falvey-115
Q75650821 Helen MacCarthy (Peerage person ID=272243) 1803 1878 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Falvey-115 05.04.2024 19:37:56 False suggestion WikiData is wrong
Fitzroy-5
H
28 Sep 1663 Henry 1st Duke of Grafton Fitzroy 15 Sep 1663 London, Middlesex, England 9 Oct 1690 Cork and Kinsale, Ireland Male WikiTree-57
Q538459 Henry FitzRoy, 1st Duke of Grafton (Illegitimate son of King Charles II and English duke (1663-1690)) 28 Sep 1663 London United Kingdom 9 Oct 1690 Cork Republic of Ireland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Luckie-23 09.09.2017 22:47:06 Corrected Added alternate birth date (and source) as wikidata - Gregorian Calendar
Luckie-23 30.06.2018 03:51:04 Comment Removed myself as Profile Manager
Fitz-Henry-9 16.03.2021 00:46:04 False suggestion Wikidata is wrong - Do not 'correct' - England Project managed profile
O'Grady-48
H
1765 Henry Deane O'Grady aka Grady uncertain 1764 certain County Limerick, Ireland certain 8 Sep 1847 certain Stillorgan, County Dublin, Ireland Male Waldron-201
Q75619878 Henry Deane O'Grady ((1765-1847)) 1765 1847 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Waldron-201 15.06.2022 17:16:52 False suggestion Conflicting evidence in contemporary sources.
Nagle-793
H
1728 Honora Nano Nóra de Nógla Nagle 1718 Ballygriffin, County Cork, Ireland 26 Apr 1784 Cork, County Cork, Ireland Female Nagle-752

N.-17
Q596669 Nano Nagle (Foundress of Presentation Sisters) 1728 County Cork Republic of Ireland 20 Apr 1784 Cork Republic of Ireland female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
x-8644 26.02.2020 16:28:29 False suggestion wikidata has a source over 100 yrs old, does not reflect 21st century research
O'Donoghue-241
H
20 Nov 1801 Jane O'Connell (O'Donoghue) 6 Nov 1801 Cork, County Cork, Ireland 15 Apr 1867 Lakeview, Killarney, County Kerry, Ireland Female Falvey-115
Q75827247 Jane O'Donoghue ((1801-1867)) 20 Nov 1801 15 Apr 1867 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Falvey-115 08.08.2023 15:11:17 False suggestion WikiData is wrong, probably her baptism date.
Fitzgerald-559
H
1282 Joan Countess of Carrick, of Kildare Butler (Fitzgerald) aka FitzThomas uncertain 1281 certain Fermoy, Cork, Ireland before 2 May 1320 certain Laraghbryan, Maynooth, County Kildare, Ireland Female Wright-7062

Fields-574
Q6205050 Joan FitzGerald, Countess of Carrick (Irish noble) 1282 Fermoy Republic of Ireland 2 May 1320 female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Devlin-670 24.04.2018 01:50:02 False suggestion Dates are approximate
Arnott-81
H
26 Jul 1814 Sir John 1st Baronet Arnott, of Woodlands, Shandon, co. Cork Arnott 1st Bt. certain 26 Jul 1816 certain Auchtermuchty, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom 28 Mar 1898 certain Cork, Ireland Male Arnott-720
Q6219448 John Arnott (British politician) 26 Jul 1814 28 Mar 1898 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Luck-863 08.12.2021 18:53:23 False suggestion
McCarty-2126
H
1638 Justin Viscount Mountcashel, Lord Mountcashel McCarty aka McCarthy uncertain 1643 Cork, Ireland certain 1 Jul 1694 France Male Carlton-1183

N.-17

WikiTree-34
Q3190469 Justin McCarthy, Viscount Mountcashel (General in the Williamite War in Ireland) 1638 Ireland Ireland United Kingdom Republic of Ireland 1 Jul 1694 Barèges France male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
N.-17 26.04.2019 14:57:36 Corrected Adjusted birth date
N.-17 26.04.2019 14:57:49 Comment
Willis-3607 04.05.2019 13:50:20 False suggestion not corrected - both Wikidata & profile dates are reasonable estimates, no sources for baptism or age at death found
Fitzgerald-531
H
1194 Sir Maurice 2nd Lord Offaly Fitzgerald uncertain 1195 Ireland certain 20 May 1257 Youghal, Cork, Ireland Male Athey-67
Q3852424 Maurice FitzGerald, 2nd Lord of Offaly (Norman-Irish peer, soldier, and Justiciar of Ireland) 1194 Republic of Ireland Republic of Ireland 27 May 1257 Republic of Ireland Republic of Ireland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Zimmerman-2446 24.04.2017 02:35:46 Corrected Changed birthdate.
devlin-670 27.04.2019 16:22:20 False suggestion unsourced Wikidata keeps changing around a 5 year period
Browne-7377
H
6 Nov 1844 Bishop Robert Browne 9 Aug 1844 Charleville, County Cork, Ireland 23 Mar 1935 Cloyne, County Cork, Ireland Male X-8644
Q17479013 Robert Browne (Irish priest and catholic bishop (1844-1935)) 6 Nov 1844 23 Mar 1935 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
x-8644 23.05.2023 14:52:58 False suggestion Date of birth source attached in biography
Croke-174
H
28 May 1824 Archbishop Thomas William Croke 19 May 1823 Dromin, Castlecor, County Cork, Ireland 22 Jul 1902 Thurles, County Tipperary, Ireland Male Orphan
Q2423107 Thomas Croke (Roman Catholic Archbishop of Cashel and Emly in Ireland) 28 May 1824 Kilbrin Republic of Ireland 22 Jul 1902 Thurles Republic of Ireland male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
x-8644 08.03.2022 16:03:23 False suggestion different sources give different dates of birth
St Leger-9
H
1525 Sir Warham St Leger uncertain 1526 uncertain Ulcombe, Kent, England uncertain 1597 uncertain County Cork, Ireland Male WikiTree-36

Ross-1334
Q7969377 Warham St Leger (English soldier) 1525 1597 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Cayley-55 30.06.2020 20:20:52 False suggestion Wikidata date is approximate
Sneyd-169
H
1676 Ven Wettenhall Sneyd before 16 Jan 1677 Burslem, Staffordshire, England 1745 Kilmore, County Cork, Ireland Male Swetenham-16
Q59130625 Wettenhall Sneyd (18th-century Anglican priest in Ireland) 1676 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Swetenham-16 20.05.2022 15:26:54 Corrected
Swetenham-16 15.02.2023 22:30:36 False suggestion
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Corbet-788
H
17 Jul 1779 William Corbet 17 Aug 1779 Ballythomas, County Cork, Ireland 12 Aug 1842 St Denis, France Male Orphan
Q3119765 William Corbet (French general) 17 Jul 1779 Republic of Ireland Republic of Ireland 12 Aug 1842 male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
x-8644 31.03.2020 22:09:38 False suggestion different dates in different sources