Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 205: Father is too young or not born Help Video (Difficulty: Advanced)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Crawford-602
H
Reginald Crawford Father 1145 Clydesdale, Lanarkshire, Scotland 1170 Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Crawford-15512
De Crawford-18
H
Reginald Crawford (De Crawford) Child uncertain 1100 Crawfordjohn, Clydesdale, Lanarkshire, Scotland 1146 Auchinames, Renfrewshire, Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 09.09.2020 18:52:18 False suggestion estimated dates for both
Erskine-92
H
Sir John Erskine of Mar (Erskine) Father before 1265 certain Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland uncertain 1296 uncertain Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Erskine-93
H
Sir William Erskine Child 1274 certain Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland after 1331 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 11.02.2022 03:51:04 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Erskine-92
H
Sir John Erskine of Mar (Erskine) Father before 1265 certain Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland uncertain 1296 uncertain Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Erskine-659
H
Margaret Mary Margaret Agnes Agnes Comyn Livingston (Erskine) aka de Livingston Child uncertain 1272 Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland after 1296 Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 11.02.2022 03:50:21 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Macruari-4
H
Roderick Ruari Macruari of Garmorgan (Macruari) Father before 1300 certain Scotland after 1325 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Macruari-3
H
Amie Euphemia Macruari Child 1306 Garmoran, , Argyllshire, Scotland 1350 , , Scotland Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 26.04.2022 16:28:48 Corrected
anderson-23510 25.05.2022 01:11:29 False suggestion Date is stated as before
Stewart-972
H
John Robert III King of Scots (Stewart) Father certain 14 Aug 1337 Dundonald Castle, Ayrshire, Scotland 4 Apr 1406 Dundonald, Ayrshire, Scotland Male WikiTree-65

Stuart-531
Bruce-2368
H
Elizabeth Douglas (Bruce) Child uncertain 1345 Scotland uncertain 1378 Female Shelton-1487
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 20.01.2019 09:25:10 Not corrected Have chatted with other profile members, Elizabeth Douglas has been joined to Stewart-972 and does not belong and I am not sure how she is even here
Thiessen-117 19.12.2022 17:39:11 False suggestion
Cranstoun-113
H
Radolphus Ralph de Cranstoun (Cranstoun) Father before 1338 certain Soltray, East Lothian, Scotland not living uncertain Soltray, East Lothian, Scotland Male Orphan
Cranstoun-114
H
John de Cranstoun (Cranstoun) Child before 1338 certain Soltray, East Lothian, Scotland after 1338 uncertain Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 05.04.2024 01:57:39 False suggestion
Haliburton-8
H
Sir John Haliburton aka Halyburton Father before Apr 1356 certain Haliburton, Berwickshire, Scotland after 1402 uncertain Male Orphan
Haliburton-7
H
Sir Walter Haliburton Knt. aka of Dirletoun Child 1364 Scotland before 10 May 1447 uncertain Scotland Male WikiTree-65
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 17.06.2021 04:59:00 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Haliburton-8
H
Sir John Haliburton aka Halyburton Father before Apr 1356 certain Haliburton, Berwickshire, Scotland after 1402 uncertain Male Orphan
Haliburton-5
H
Jean Halyburton (Haliburton) Child uncertain 1350 Dirleton, East Lothian, Scotland 1400 Midlothian, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 17.06.2021 04:37:10 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Ker-607
H
John Ker of the Forest of Selkirk (Ker) Father before 5 Feb 1358 certain Selkirk, Auldtournburn, Scotland after 6 Nov 1363 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Ker-606
H
Henry Ker of Altonburn (Ker) Child uncertain 1355 certain Selkirk, Auldtournburn, Scotland after 15 Jan 1364 uncertain Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 05.04.2024 01:58:30 False suggestion
Denniston-2
H
Robert Denniston Father before 1378 certain Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland uncertain 1405 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Denniston-1
H
Elizabeth Denniston Child 1387 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland Female WikiTree-65
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 07.07.2022 05:02:04 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Campbell-1034
H
Sir Hugh Campbell XIth of Loudoun (Campbell) Father before 1392 uncertain Loudon, Ayrshire, Scotland after 25 May 1430 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Campbell-15750
H
Hucheon Hew Campbell of Brounsyde (Campbell) Child uncertain 1399 certain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 09.11.2021 23:24:20 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Oliphant-73
H
Sir John Oliphant Father 1416 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland 23 Jan 1445 Arbroath, Angus, Scotland Male Orphan
Oliphant-70
H
Margaret Maggie Oliphant Child before 1424 certain Torrie, Fifeshire, Scotland uncertain 1491 Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 17.05.2021 05:16:22 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Gordon-4315
H
Sir Patrick of Methlic Gordon IInd of Haddo (Gordon) Father before 1443 certain Aberdeenshire, Scotland before 2 Mar 1534 uncertain Methlick, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Gordon-7045
H
Unknown Barclay (Gordon) Child uncertain 1452 certain Scotland uncertain 1540 certain Scotland Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Urquhart-93 24.01.2020 06:52:24 Corrected Edited year of birth
anderson-23510 02.02.2022 03:28:54 False suggestion Date is stated as before
Macdonald-488
H
Celestine Celestin Alexandri de Yle, Lord of Lochalsh Macdonald aka MacDonald of Lochalsh Father before 1448 certain Dingwall, Ross-shire, Scotland uncertain 1476 Scotland Male WikiTree-65
MacDonald-2309
H
Sir Alexander MacDonald Child uncertain 1455 certain Scotland uncertain 1495 uncertain Orinsay, Argyllshire, Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Snow-2128 29.04.2019 01:43:45 Comment corrected
Madison-125 18.05.2020 21:35:56 False suggestion Father's birth is an estimated 'before' date only
Ogilvy-184
H
Alexander Ogilvy of Deskford and First Lord Findlater (Ogilvy) Father uncertain 1494 certain Jul 1544 Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Ogilvy-194
H
Lady Marjorie Gordon (Ogilvy) aka Gartley Child uncertain 1503 Findlater, Banffshire, Scotland uncertain 1570 Kirriemuir, Angus, Scotland Female Thornton-8053

Parker-10195
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ward-30118 07.06.2023 19:13:58 Corrected fix later
Sutherland-Fisher-1 17.12.2023 10:14:41 False suggestion
Hamilton-1678
H
Sir William High Treasurer of Scotland Hamilton Ist of Sanquhar (Hamilton) Father before 1496 certain Cumbuskeith, Ayrshire, Scotland certain 8 Jan 1569 uncertain Sanquhar, Dumfriesshire, Scotland Male Hamilton-4105
Hamilton-1681
H
Isabel Hamilton Lady Semple (Hamilton) Child uncertain 1505 Sanquhar, Dumfriesshire, Scotland before 24 Aug 1546 uncertain Scotland Female Shelton-1487
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 01.04.2021 23:39:12 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Lockhart-215
H
James Lockhart VIth of Lee (Lockhart) Father before 11 Sep 1502 uncertain Lee Castle, Lanarkshire, Scotland uncertain 1532 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Lockhart-214
H
Sir Alan Lockhart VII of Lee (Lockhart) Child uncertain 1510 certain Lee Castle, Lanarkshire, Scotland certain 10 Oct 1547 certain Battle of Pinkie, Musselburgh, Midlothian, Scotland Male Gordon-7317
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 10.11.2021 01:12:03 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Semple-877
H
John Sempill VIIth of Fulwood (Semple) Father before 13 Jul 1512 certain Renfrewshire, Scotland before 28 May 1549 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Sempill-154
H
Robert Sempill VIIIth of Fulwood (Sempill) Child after 1514 certain Scotland before 8 Mar 1552 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Jennings-5056 14.03.2023 14:54:09 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Lockhart-5602
H
Stephen Lockhart of Wicketshaw (Lockhart) Father before 1513 certain Lanarkshire, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Lockhart-5603
H
Alexander Lockhart Child uncertain 1519 certain Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 10.11.2021 01:12:48 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Learmonth-221
H
Thomas Learmonth aka of Dairsie Father before 1520 certain Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Learmonth-101
H
Christian Clephane (Learmonth) Child uncertain 1517 Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 10.11.2021 01:13:26 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Hamilton-4840
H
Sir David Hamilton Father before 1 Oct 1531 certain Scotland certain 28 Nov 1584 uncertain Scotland Male Hamilton-4105
Hamilton-29211
H
Jean Hamilton Child uncertain 1539 certain Preston, Berwick, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 11.02.2022 04:02:16 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Knox-641
H
William Knox Ist of Silvieland (Knox) Father before Apr 1554 certain Ranfurlie, Renfrewshire, Scotland not living uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Knox-640
H
William Knox IInd of Silvieland (Knox) Child uncertain 1539 certain Renfrewshire, Scotland certain 5 Dec 1592 uncertain Male Kopriva-31
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 02.08.2023 15:21:01 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Grant-5691
H
John Ian Mór a Chaisteil Grant IIIrd of Glenmoriston (Grant) Father before Feb 1564 Glenmoriston, Urquhart, Inverness, Scotland before 31 Mar 1637 Glenmoriston, Urquhart, Inverness, Scotland Male Trowbridge-764
Grant-5690
H
Patrick Grant IVth of Glenmoriston (Grant) Child uncertain 1573 certain Glenmoriston, Urquhart Parish, Inverness-Shire, Scotland after 1643 uncertain Glenmoriston, Urquhart Parish, Inverness-Shire, Scotland Male Trowbridge-764
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Madison-125 30.11.2022 05:16:42 False suggestion Parents already connected, all dates are estimates
Brenton-484
H
Magistrate Henry Thomas Brenton Sr. Father certain 1583 Stow, Midlothian, Scotland certain 1649 Stow, Midlothian, Scotland Male WikiTree-103
Brenton-504
H
Henry Brenton Jr. Child certain 1591 Stow, Midlothian Scotland certain 1655 England Male WikiTree-103
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 04.11.2017 19:45:42 False suggestion Profile is a fake; don't waste time on it
Brenton-484
H
Magistrate Henry Thomas Brenton Sr. Father certain 1583 Stow, Midlothian, Scotland certain 1649 Stow, Midlothian, Scotland Male WikiTree-103
Brenton-426
H
Jams Bruntone Brenton Child certain 1584 Stow Midlothian Scotland certain 18 Apr 1653 Midlothian Scotland Male WikiTree-103
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Rassinot-1 04.11.2017 19:45:44 False suggestion Profile is a fake; don't waste time on it
Douglas-5307
H
Alexander Douglas IX of Mains (Douglas) Father uncertain 1584 Mains, New Kilpatrick, Dunbartonshire, Scotland after 1618 Edinburgh Parish, Edinburgh, Midloitian, Scotland Male Hand-1735
Douglas-7350
H
Sir Robert Douglas Child uncertain 1593 Inveresk, Midlothian, Scotland before 1669 Midlothian, Scotland Male Hand-1735

Douglas-3089
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Douglas-3089 19.08.2023 19:17:53 False suggestion
McEntire-16
H
Pierce McEntire Father uncertain 1640 Argyll, Scotland uncertain 1740 Scotland Male Palmer-3658

Stremming-1
McIntyre-43
H
Philip McIntyre Child uncertain 6 Aug 1630 uncertain Glenorchy and Inishail, Argyll, Scotland certain 19 Dec 1719 certain Reading, Middlesex County, Province of Massachusetts Bay, New England Male Winans-206

Stremming-1
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Smith-40964 17.03.2024 17:10:57 False suggestion
Somerville-309
H
John Somerville aka Somervail, Somervell Father 1666 Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland uncertain 1717 Maryland Male Summerlin-92

Summerall-29

Slay-13
Somervell-8
H
John Somervell Jr aka Summerell Child uncertain 1666 uncertain 1702 Virginia Male Slay-13
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Svedahl-3 04.12.2021 06:10:41 False suggestion
Scott-11121
H
Samuel Scott Father 1700 Scotland 1734 Scotland Male Henning-520
Scott-11111
H
Andrew Scott Child after 1706 Scotland not living Colerain, Lancaster, Pennsylvania Male Henning-520
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID2478858 09.06.2016 03:33:21 False suggestion Old False error
Shand-170
H
George Shand Father uncertain 1730 Male Allison-1080
Shand-169
H
Christian Shand Child certain 6 Feb 1733 Forgue, Aberdeen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Female Allison-1080
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID6799742 08.06.2016 17:55:24 False suggestion Old False error
Semple-579
H
James Semple Father before 28 Jul 1732 certain Bonhill, Dunbartonshire, Scotland before 12 Nov 1784 certain South Carolina, United States Male Orphan
Semple-836
H
William Semple Child after 1741 certain South Carolina uncertain 1785 certain Abbeville, South Carolina, United States Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 27.10.2021 04:05:45 False suggestion birthdates are before/after
Elliot-3938
H
James Elliot Father certain 8 Dec 1732 certain Eskdalemuir, Dumfriesshire, Scotland not living uncertain Male Orphan
Elliot-3913
H
William Elliot Child certain 11 Jul 1740 Eskdalemuir, Dumfriesshire, Scotland not living Male Shaw-22329
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Graham-17201 14.01.2022 20:39:44 False suggestion
McNair-52
H
John McNair Father certain 1735 Kilkenny, Argyleshire, Scotland not living uncertain North Carolina, United States Male Wilkinson-828
McNair-1071
H
Neil Edward McNair Child uncertain 1740 certain Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland uncertain 1819 certain Richmond, North Carolina, United States Male Sellers-1052
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Traynor-575 16.05.2023 00:08:29 False suggestion
Colquhoun-672
H
John Colquhoun aka Calhoun Father certain 20 Feb 1747 Luss, Dunbartonshire, Scotland certain 1 Apr 1804 Luss, Dunbartonshire, Scotland Male Darsey-82
Calhoun-834
H
Laughlan Calhoun aka Colquhoun Child uncertain 1755 certain Scotland uncertain 1828 certain Cumberland County, North Carolina, United States Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Richardson-7161 25.10.2021 20:09:50 False suggestion suggestion is wrong.. his birth date is correct
Elkins-1563
H
Robert Elkins Father uncertain 1755 uncertain 1820 Kershaw, South Carolina, United States Male Dukes-653

Bullock-3110
Elkins-1562
H
Rebecca Whaley (Elkins) Child uncertain 1764 Scotland uncertain 1858 Duplin, NC Female Bullock-3110
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Winslett-23 29.07.2022 06:11:20 False suggestion
Howie-886
H
James Howie Father before 19 Mar 1760 Kilwinning, Ayrshire, Scotland Male Anderson-11596
Howie-318
H
James Howie Child uncertain 14 Mar 1760 certain Dreghorn, Ayrshire, Scotland after 15 Oct 1838 Troon, Ayrshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Howie-690
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Howie-690 19.01.2024 19:55:17 False suggestion
Callbreath-17
H
Thomas Callbreath Sr Father before 1778 Scotland 20 Jun 1798 Colchester, Delaware County, New York Male Orphan
Callbreath-23
H
Abigail Callbreath Child after 1784 New York after 1841 Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Finch-4985 23.02.2022 00:39:28 False suggestion
Callbreath-17
H
Thomas Callbreath Sr Father before 1778 Scotland 20 Jun 1798 Colchester, Delaware County, New York Male Orphan
Callbreath-18
H
James F. Callbreath Child 1786 Westchester, New York, United States 26 Oct 1874 uncertain Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Finch-4985 23.02.2022 00:39:28 False suggestion
Callbreath-17
H
Thomas Callbreath Sr Father before 1778 Scotland 20 Jun 1798 Colchester, Delaware County, New York Male Orphan
Callbreath-21
H
Mary Callbreath Child 1781 New York 11 Jan 1870 Brooklyn, Kings, New York Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Finch-4985 23.02.2022 00:39:29 False suggestion
Callbreath-17
H
Thomas Callbreath Sr Father before 1778 Scotland 20 Jun 1798 Colchester, Delaware County, New York Male Orphan
Callbreath-19
H
John Callbreath Child uncertain 1784 New York uncertain 1810 Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Finch-4985 23.02.2022 00:39:26 False suggestion
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Williamson-655
H
William Williamson Father uncertain 1806 Rosemartry, Ross-shire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male McMillan-190
Williamson-660
H
Agnes Williamson Child 22 Oct 1815 Dysart, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom 15 Nov 1898 Markinch, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom Female McMillan-190
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID2777127 11.06.2016 13:04:02 False suggestion Old False error
McFarlane-3616
H
George McFarlane Father before 11 Mar 1816 Kilmacolm, Renfrewshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 12 Feb 1872 certain Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Hill-41179
McFarlane-2880
H
Margaret Higgins Oliver (McFarlane) Child certain 26 Oct 1823 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 29 Apr 1882 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Female Hill-41179
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hill-41179 10.08.2023 21:49:34 False suggestion birthdates are before
Ewart-246
H
Thomas Ewart Father before 1828 after 1828 Male Thompson-18916
Ewart-247
H
Isabella Jardine (Ewart) Child 8 Aug 1828 certain Dumfriesshire, Scotland certain 12 Apr 1918 certain Simcoe County, Ontario, Canada Female Thompson-18916

Williams-27869
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
ID6372047 08.12.2016 18:25:24 False suggestion Old False error
Penny-1085
H
George Penny Father certain 18 Apr 1828 certain Rathen, Aberdeenshire, Scotland certain 23 Nov 1904 certain Reamshill, Fyvie, Aberdeenshire, Scotland Male Pennie-22
Penny-1241
H
William Penny II Child certain 20 May 1781 certain Perth, Perthshire, Scotland, uncertain 21 Sep 1897 certain Colombo, Western, Sri Lanka Male Pennie-22
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
pENNIE-22 14.09.2023 12:09:06 False suggestion 53 is not too old to be a father
pENNIE-22 14.09.2023 12:10:40 False suggestion Birth year is before 1752.No source for correct year