Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Error 210: Father was dead before birth Help (Difficulty: Intermediate)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information Help.

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
Erskine-418
H
Henry Erskine aka de Erskine Father uncertain 1190 certain Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland after 1226 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Erskine-423
H
Sir John Erskine Child before 1246 certain Mar, Aberdeenshire, Scotland after 14 May 1271 uncertain Erskine, Renfrewshire, Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 02.02.2022 03:18:55 False suggestion Dates are before/after
De Levenax of Faslane, Roseneath and Glenfruin-1
H
Amelec Auley Mor of Faslane, Roseneath and Glenfruin de Levenax (de Levenax of Faslane, Roseneath and Glenfruin) Father uncertain 1199 Scotland before 1250 Male Orphan
De Faslane-1
H
Alwyn de Faslane Child uncertain 1255 Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stevens-17832 01.10.2021 16:35:57 False suggestion
Douglas-401
H
Sir Andrew Douglas of Hermiston (Douglas) Father uncertain 1240 certain Douglas Castle, Lanarkshire, Scotland after 1259 certain Hermiston, Roxburghshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Douglas-7021
H
Frisken Douglas Child before 1296 not living Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 26.05.2021 05:03:27 False suggestion Dates are before/after
Lindsay-2905
H
James Lindsay IIIrd of Craigie (Lindsay) Father uncertain 1250 Craigie, Ayrshire, Scotland after 1275 Craigie, Ayrshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Lindsay-5718
H
John Lindsay Ist of Dunrod (Lindsay) Child before 1344 uncertain Scotland after 1360 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 26.11.2021 21:21:06 False suggestion
anderson-23510 26.11.2021 21:21:23 False suggestion Dates are listed for before and after.
Cranstoun-114
H
John de Cranstoun (Cranstoun) Father before 1338 certain Soltray, East Lothian, Scotland after 1338 uncertain Male Orphan
Cranstoun-115
H
Sir Thomas de Cranstoun (Cranstoun) Child before 1367 certain Stobs, Roxburghshire, Scotland uncertain 1409 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 05.04.2024 01:57:40 False suggestion
Vaus-7
H
John Vaux (Vaus) Father uncertain 1350 Barnbarroch, Galloway, Wigtownshire, Scotland after 1384 Male Cochoit-2
Vaus-6
H
John Vaus aka Vaux Child uncertain 1400 Barnbarroch, Galloway, Wigtownshire, Scotland before 1456 Male Cochoit-2
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 06.07.2022 22:51:37 False suggestion Dates are listed for before and after.
Ker-606
H
Henry Ker of Altonburn (Ker) Father uncertain 1355 certain Selkirk, Auldtournburn, Scotland after 15 Jan 1364 uncertain Male Orphan
Ker-605
H
Robert Ker of Altonburn (Ker) Child uncertain 1380 certain Auldtounburn, Roxburghshire, Scotland after 20 Jun 1404 certain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Lamoreaux-297 05.04.2024 01:58:29 False suggestion
Sempill-177
H
John Sempill Ist of Fulwood (Sempill) aka Semple Father before 1395 uncertain Renfrewshire, Scotland after 1409 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Sempill-57
H
William of Noblestoun Sempill IInd of Fulwood (Sempill) aka Semple Child before 1419 uncertain Renfrewshire, Scotland before 1455 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 13.02.2023 15:42:33 False suggestion
Carmichael-1144
H
Sir William Carmichael Father before 1397 certain Scotland after 6 Jul 1434 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Carmichael-1143
H
Sir John Carmichael of that Ilk (Carmichael) Child before 1438 before 5 Mar 1495 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 11.05.2021 17:17:29 False suggestion Dates are before/after
Arnot-287
H
John Arnot of Arnot (Arnot) Father uncertain 1412 certain Arnot, Fife, Scotland after 1489 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Arnot-235
H
Elizabeth Arnot Child before 1502 certain Arnot, Fifeshire, Scotland after 18 Mar 1539 uncertain Scotland Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 01.09.2021 01:27:41 False suggestion Dates are listed for before and after.
Hamilton-29223
H
John Hamilton IInd of Torrance (Hamilton) Father before 23 May 1449 certain Scotland after 23 Oct 1475 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Hamilton-29222
H
James Hamilton IIIrd of Torrance (Hamilton) Child before 1479 certain Torrance, Lanarkshire, Scotland after 1494 uncertain Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 11.02.2022 03:51:46 False suggestion Dates are listed for before and after.
Hamilton-29222
H
James Hamilton IIIrd of Torrance (Hamilton) Father before 1479 certain Torrance, Lanarkshire, Scotland after 1494 uncertain Lanarkshire, Scotland Male Orphan
Hamilton-6409
H
Marion Hunter (Hamilton) aka Hambleton Child before 1514 certain Torrance Castle, Hamilton, Lanarkshire, Scotland certain 25 May 1596 certain Hunterston Castle, Ayrshire, Scotland Female Hunter-5770

Hunter-3749
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 01.03.2022 17:14:58 False suggestion
anderson-23510 01.03.2022 17:15:32 False suggestion Dates are listed for before and after.
Hamilton-28146
H
Andrew Hamilton of Brownmuir (Hamilton) Father before 1488 certain Scotland after 1545 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
Hamilton-28145
H
William Hamilton Child before 1553 certain Scotland before 9 Jan 1567 uncertain Scotland Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
anderson-23510 02.11.2021 13:59:36 False suggestion Dates are listed for before and after.
Munro-534
H
George Munro Ist Laird of Obsdale (Munro) Father uncertain 1565 Scotland uncertain 1589 Scotland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
Munro-3086
H
Robert Munro Child uncertain 1601 Ross-shire, Scotland certain 1680 County Down, Ireland Male Sutherland-Fisher-1
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Toemmes-1 08.04.2022 21:48:59 False suggestion
Preston-1467
H
Sir John Preston IVth of Valleyfield (Preston) Father uncertain 1574 uncertain Valleyfield, Culross, Fifeshire, Scotland after 6 Jan 1612 uncertain Scotland Male Lauder-514
Preston-5698
H
Sir Robert Preston of Gorton (Preston) Child uncertain 1616 certain Valleyfield, Culross, Perthshire uncertain Oct 1674 Culross, Perthshire, Scotland Male Lauder-514
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Anderson-23510 16.08.2023 19:20:10 False suggestion Dates are listed for before and after.
Anderson-23510 16.08.2023 19:20:25 False suggestion
Simpson-24734
H
William Simpson Father uncertain 1620 uncertain Scotland after 1694 uncertain Ireland Male Ross-19791
Simpson-13581
H
Sarah Campbell (Simpson) aka Thompson Child uncertain 1696 Londonderry, County Londonderry, Ireland uncertain 1775 certain Cherry Valley, Otsego, New York Female Browne-2174
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Ross-19791 21.02.2023 17:46:09 Comment Daughter's birth date is unknown/unconfirmed, her father would have been alive at her conception, however as her birth date is unknown, approx date of conception is also unknown
Ross-19791 01.03.2023 17:17:41 False suggestion
Reid-4942
H
James B Reid Father certain 11 Apr 1647 certain Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland after 27 Oct 1711 certain Monmouth, New Jersey Male Stradling-375
Reid-17824
H
John Reid Child certain 27 Nov 1713 certain Monmouth County, New Jersey certain 15 Jan 1771 certain Monmouth County, New Jersey Male Soden-183
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Stradling-375 30.03.2023 15:23:03 False suggestion
Turpie-429
H
John Turpie Father certain 22 Sep 1726 certain St. Andrews and St. Leonards, Fife, Scotland uncertain 3 Dec 1758 uncertain Kingsbarns, Fife, Scotland Male Turpy-1
Turpie-708
H
David Turpie Child certain 29 Sep 1760 certain Kingsbarns, Fife, Scotland certain 29 Apr 1764 certain Kingsbarns, Fife, Scotland Male Turpy-1
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Turpy-1 20.09.2021 18:13:15 Corrected May be error in records....
Turpy-1 20.09.2021 18:14:32 False suggestion May be error in records
Kerr-2654
H
James Kerr Father before 1749 Scotland after 1769 Scotland Male Orphan
Kerr-2623
H
Janet Kerr Child before 1782 Scotland before 1877 Scotland Female Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Murphy-4835 13.07.2018 13:43:14 False suggestion
Jamieson-4026
H
James Jamieson Father uncertain 1756 uncertain Scotland certain 1823 certain Shetland, Scotland, United Kingdom Male MacDonald-5873
Jamieson-4027
H
Mary Jamieson Child certain 1874 certain 1944 Female MacDonald-5873
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
MacDonald-5873 04.08.2022 23:24:56 False suggestion as per findagrave error
Link Info Name Rel. Birth Death Gender Manager Marriage Status
McCallum-354
H
John McCallum Father 15 Oct 1760 Kilmelford, Argyll, Scotland 15 Mar 1791 Kilbrandon, Argyllshire, Scotland Male Higgins-2044
McCallum-352
H
Catherine McCallum Child 15 Jun 1795 Kilbrandon, Argyllshire, Scotland 20 Nov 1875 Glengarry, Ontario, Canada Female Higgins-2044
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Dyer-10748 22.02.2022 03:34:23 False suggestion
Barklay-34
H
William Barklay aka Barclay Father certain 17 Aug 1791 certain Leslie, Fife, Scotland 1835 Male Orphan
Barclay-473
H
John Barclay Child 24 Jun 1837 Markinch Fife Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hylton-692 14.03.2024 04:39:15 False suggestion
Barklay-34
H
William Barklay aka Barclay Father certain 17 Aug 1791 certain Leslie, Fife, Scotland 1835 Male Orphan
Barclay-492
H
James Barclay Child 3 Mar 1839 Markinch Fife Male Orphan
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Hylton-692 14.03.2024 04:39:13 False suggestion
Carnon-1
H
William Carnon Father uncertain 1816 Scotland, United Kingdom. after 7 Apr 1861 Male Ballard-380
Carnon-19
H
Laura Kate Carnon Child certain 1863 certain Portsea, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom. Female Mace-276
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Mace-276 06.04.2023 16:38:44 False suggestion date of death is marked 'after', not exact, so there's no conflict
Cameron-3680
H
Hugh Cameron Jr. Father 27 Mar 1819 Scotland, United Kingdom 1 Nov 1860 Green Township, Indiana County, Pennsylvania, United States Male Domanski-15

McFeaters-9
Cameron-17278
H
Emily Craig (Cameron) Child 21 Feb 1862 Black Lick Township, Indiana, Pennsylvania, United States 10 Nov 1922 Mahoning Township, Indiana, Pennsylvania, United States Female McFeaters-9
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
McFeaters-9 21.12.2023 22:34:17 False suggestion THere is an error in FA--posted ast 1960 and should be 1880.
Murray-20405
H
James Murray Father uncertain 1823 after 1851 Male Greaney-17
Murray-20404
H
Helen Roger Murray Child certain 10 Sep 1853 certain Hawick, Roxburghshire, Scotland, United Kingdom certain 26 Dec 1923 certain Lumsden, Southland, New Zealand Female Greaney-17
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Howard-18870 14.01.2023 03:31:15 False suggestion Death date given is after 1851
Coventry-864
H
William Coventry Father 1824 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom 11 Oct 1864 Anderston, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Graham-32156
Coventry-866
H
Henry Coventry Child 11 Nov 1866 Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom 1868 Anderston, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male Graham-32156
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Graham-32156 21.02.2024 02:55:19 False suggestion Birth record states [[Coventry-864|William Coventry]] is the father but obviously is not due to dying two years earlier.
MacKintosh-323
H
Thomas MacKintosh Father uncertain 1840 certain 20 Nov 1883 Inverness-shire, Scotland, United Kingdom Male MacLean-435
MacKintosh-321
H
Donaldina Smith Ina Smith (MacKintosh) Child certain 10 Jun 1887 certain Inverness, Highland, Scotland, United Kingdom 1960 Female Sutherland-Fisher-1

MacLean-435
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment
Charles-1548 22.11.2018 06:39:23 False suggestion father is step-father.