Suggestions for WikiTree Profiles: Warning 563: Wikidata - Possible duplicate by father (Difficulty: Advanced)

Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information .

For detail description of the suggestions, see the Data Doctors Project page.

Link	Info	Name	Rel.	Birth	Death	Gender		Manager	Marriage	Status
St Leger-20 H	Compare	Sir Anthony St Leger	Wikitree Father	certain 1535 certain Leeds, Kent, England	certain 1613 certain Cork, County Cork, Ireland	Male		Thompson-57858 Kelleher-53
St Leger-5 H		Sir Warham St Leger aka Sentleger	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1580 certain Ulcombe, Kent, England	before 11 Oct 1630 certain Ulcombe, Kent, England	Male		WikiTree-36 Ross-1334
Q96075092		Warren St. Leger ((1579-1631))		1580	1631	male
Q16200697		Anthony St Leger (Irish judge)			1613	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 24.01.2023 18:13:41 False suggestion These are not duplicate people.
Raleigh-45 H	Compare	Edward Raleigh Esq	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1470 uncertain England	before 20 Sep 1508 uncertain England	Male		WikiTree-36 Wood-2151
Raleigh-76 H		Sir Edward Raleigh	Wikidata Father	20 Jan 1441 England	after 20 Jun 1509 England	Male		Wood-2151 WikiTree-36 Felch-7
Q96209137		Mary Raleigh (- Bef 1523)		1498		female
Q75765098		Sir Edward Raleigh (Peerage person ID=322429)		20 Jan 1441		male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Noland-165 15.09.2020 11:16:26 False suggestion dates in wikitree profiles are sourced - they're father/son
Courtenay-25 H	Compare	Sir Hugh Earl of Devon de Courtenay (Courtenay)	Wikitree Father	certain 12 Jul 1303 England	certain 2 May 1377 Devon, England	Male		WikiTree-36
Courtenay-5 H		Sir Edward de Courtenay (Courtenay)	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1332 certain Sherford, Devon, England	before 1 Apr 1371 England	Male		Orphan
Q75242035		Margaret Courtenay (Peerage person ID=4215)				female
Q75248335		Edward de Courtenay (Peerage person ID=9383)				male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 25.01.2022 13:42:05 False suggestion Those are two different profiles.
Darcy-223 H	Compare	John 5th Lord Darcy of Knaith and 4th Lord Meinell Darcy	Wikitree Father	1377 England	9 Dec 1411 England	Male		WikiTree-36
Darcy-225 H		Philip 4th Lord Darcy of Knaith Darcy	Wikidata Father	certain 21 May 1352 York, Yorkshire, England	certain 24 Apr 1399 England	Male		WikiTree-36
Q18576825		Philip Darcy (English nobleman and soldier)		1352	1399	male
Q105820769		Joan Darcy (Est 1400 -)		1398	May 1436	female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 30.05.2023 11:46:07 False suggestion Different people
Beauchamp-144 H	Compare	Sir John de Beauchamp (Beauchamp)	Wikitree Father	before 1249 Hatch beauchamp, Somerset, England	24 Oct 1283 Hatch, Somerset, England	Male		Orphan
Beauchamp-61 H		Sir John 1st Lord Beauchamp of Somerset de Beauchamp (Beauchamp)	Wikidata Father	certain 25 Jul 1274 uncertain England	certain 1 Jan 1337 England	Male		WikiTree-36
Q75400639		Beatrice Beauchamp (Peerage person ID=118630)		1304		female
Q19874700		John de Beauchamp, 1st Baron Beauchamp (English baron, died 1336)		1274	1336	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 09.01.2024 19:22:29 False suggestion These are not duplicate people.
Gifford-341 H	Compare	John Gifford	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1500 uncertain Itchell, Hampshire, England	before 5 Dec 1538 uncertain England	Male		Parsons-1809 WikiTree-36 Canning-229
Gifford-346 H		Sir William Gifford aka Giffard	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1482 Crondall, Hampshire, England	certain 17 Jun 1549 certain Crondall, Hampshire, England	Male		Greet-49
Q110526184		Richard Gifford, of Samborne (- 15 Nov 1568)			15 Nov 1568	male
Q99858722		Sir William Gifford, of Itchell (Abt 1475 - 17 Jun 1549 Weston-under-Edge, Gloucestershire)		1482	17 Jun 1549	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment thiessen-117 16.05.2022 17:29:12 False suggestion These are not duplicate people.
Seymour-81 H	Compare	Sir John Seymour	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1402 uncertain England	certain 20 Dec 1464 uncertain England	Male		WikiTree-36
Seymour-44 H		John Seymour Esq.	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1425 uncertain Wiltshire, England	29 Sep 1463 England	Male		WikiTree-36
Q6257369		John Seymour (English noble (Seymour family))		1425	1463	male
Q76344535		Humphrey Seymour (Peerage person ID=703012)		1434		male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment thiessen-117 05.05.2021 20:59:09 False suggestion Definitely not the same person.
Stewart-1555 H	Compare	Sir John Stewart of Balveny First Earl of Atholl (Stewart)	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1440 uncertain Mortlach, Banffshire, Scotland	certain 15 Sep 1512 certain Laighwood, Perthshire, Scotland	Male		WikiTree-65 WikiTree-36
Stewart-1604 H		John Stewart Second Earl of Atholl (Stewart)	Wikidata Father	after 1475 uncertain Balveny, Fife, Scotland	uncertain 1521 uncertain Scotland	Male		WikiTree-65 Douglass-990 Felch-7
Q75257559		Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948)		1479	19 Apr 1522	female
Q1701828		John Stewart, 2nd Earl of Atholl (Scottish peer and soldier)		1475	1521	male
Q75257559		Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948)		1479	19 Apr 1522	female
Q75257559		Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948)		1479	19 Apr 1522	female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 19.03.2024 10:57:20 False suggestion WikiTree has them connected appropriately
Stewart-1604 H	Compare	John Stewart Second Earl of Atholl (Stewart)	Wikitree Father	after 1475 uncertain Balveny, Fife, Scotland	uncertain 1521 uncertain Scotland	Male		WikiTree-65 Douglass-990 Felch-7
Stewart-1555 H		Sir John Stewart of Balveny First Earl of Atholl (Stewart)	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1440 uncertain Mortlach, Banffshire, Scotland	certain 15 Sep 1512 certain Laighwood, Perthshire, Scotland	Male		WikiTree-65 WikiTree-36
Q75257559		Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948)		1479	19 Apr 1522	female
Q75257559		Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948)		1479	19 Apr 1522	female
Q75257559		Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948)		1479	19 Apr 1522	female
Q1240207		John Stewart, 1st Earl of Atholl (Scottish diplomat; eldest son of Joan Beaufort and Sir James Stewart, the Black Knight of Lorn)		1440	15 Sep 1512	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 19.03.2024 10:57:34 False suggestion WikiTree has them connected appropriately
Stewart-1604 H	Compare	John Stewart Second Earl of Atholl (Stewart)	Wikitree Father	after 1475 uncertain Balveny, Fife, Scotland	uncertain 1521 uncertain Scotland	Male		WikiTree-65 Douglass-990 Felch-7
Stewart-1555 H		Sir John Stewart of Balveny First Earl of Atholl (Stewart)	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1440 uncertain Mortlach, Banffshire, Scotland	certain 15 Sep 1512 certain Laighwood, Perthshire, Scotland	Male		WikiTree-65 WikiTree-36
Q75257559		Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948)		1479	19 Apr 1522	female
Q75257559		Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948)		1479	19 Apr 1522	female
Q75257559		Lady Janet Stewart (Peerage person ID=16948)		1479	19 Apr 1522	female
Q1240207		John Stewart, 1st Earl of Atholl (Scottish diplomat; eldest son of Joan Beaufort and Sir James Stewart, the Black Knight of Lorn)		1440	15 Sep 1512	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 19.03.2024 10:57:34 False suggestion WikiTree has them connected appropriately
Talbot-786 H	Compare	Sir John Talbot	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1485 certain England	certain 10 Sep 1549 certain England	Male		WikiTree-36 Jewett-369
Talbot-1503 H		Sir John Talbot	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1549 certain Grafton Manor, Worcestershire, England	certain 9 Dec 1581 uncertain Salwarp, Worcestershire, England	Male		Alvord-577 Meredith-1182
Q75507858		Dorothy Talbot (Peerage person ID=183732)		1527	5 Feb 1570	female
Q75251759		Sir John Talbot (Peerage person ID=12301)		1549	9 Dec 1581	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Ford-7139 07.08.2020 23:44:28 False suggestion Different people
Bigod-28 H	Compare	Sir Ralph le Bigod (Bigod)	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1215 England	before 28 Jul 1260 England	Male		WikiTree-36
Bigod-314 H		Hugh Justiciar of England Bigod	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1215 England	before 7 May 1266 England	Male		WikiTree-36 Athey-67
Q76308485		John Bigod (Peerage person ID=678203)		1245	18 Mar 1304	male
Q11710251		Hugh Bigod (Justiciar of England)		1211	1266	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 08.09.2020 17:07:46 False suggestion WT ok
De Shelton-14 H	Compare	Ralph Shelton (De Shelton)	Wikitree Father	1315 Shelton, Norfolk, England	17 Nov 1375 Shelton, Norfolk, England	Male		Orphan
Shelton-456 H		Sir Ralph Sheriff of Norfolk and Suffolk Shelton	Wikidata Father	Jan 1431 Shelton, Norfolk, England	certain 16 Jul 1497	Male		WikiTree-36 Lockwood-1016
Q105793160		Sir Ralph Shelton, of Shelton (18 Mar 1348 Great Snoring - 25 Apr 1424)				male
Q116136483		William Shelton (- 20 Jul 1421)				male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 28.11.2023 11:42:17 False suggestion Those are two different profiles.
Grey-8 H	Compare	Sir Reynold 2nd Lord Grey of Ruthin de Grey (Grey)	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1323 Ruthin, Denbighshire, Wales	4 Aug 1388 Ruthin, Denbighshire, Wales	Male		WikiTree-36
Grey-269 H		Reynold 4th Baron Grey of Wilton de Grey (Grey)	Wikidata Father	1 Nov 1311 Wilton, Herefordshire, England	28 May 1370 Shirland, Derbyshire, England	Male		Orphan
Q99085788		Maud de Grey, (of Wilton) ((1350 - uncertain))		1350		female
Q75561304		Reynold Grey, 4th Lord Grey (of Wilton) ((1311-1370))		1 Nov 1311	4 Jun 1370	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 25.10.2022 19:43:13 False suggestion Different people
Aston-428 H	Compare	Sir Roger Aston	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1385 England	1447 certain Staffordshire, England.	Male		Orphan
Aston-424 H		Sir Robert Aston	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1414 certain England	certain 1464 England	Male		WikiTree-36
Q75321961		Sir Robert Aston (Peerage person ID=62011)		1414	1465	male
Q75321931		Isabella Aston (Peerage person ID=61988)			1477	female
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment thiessen-117 25.08.2021 18:23:46 False suggestion issue addressed in research notes
Dymoke-59 H	Compare	Sir Thomas 12th of Scrivelsby, co. Lincoln Dymoke	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1365 Scrivelsby, Lincolnshire, England	1423 England	Male		Lockwood-1016
Dymoke-2 H		Sir Thomas Dymoke	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1428 certain Scrivelsby, Lincolnshire, England	12 Mar 1470 certain Stamford, Lincolnshire, England	Male		WikiTree-36
Q76275727		Margaret Dymoke (Peerage person ID=656153)				female
Q75494689		Sir Thomas Dymoke (Peerage person ID=176152)		1428	12 Mar 1470	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 13.12.2022 10:01:05 False suggestion Different people
Digges-76 H	Compare	Thomas Digges	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1420 Kent, England	after 1470 England	Male		WikiTree-36
Digges-25 H		Thomas Digges	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1546 uncertain Wootton, Kent, England	certain 24 Aug 1595 certain London, England	Male		WikiTree-36 Gunnels-182
Q76322117		Joan Digges (Peerage person ID=688042)		1460		female
Q531345		Thomas Digges (English mathematician and astronomer (c.1546–1595))		1546 Wootton United Kingdom	24 Aug 1595 London United Kingdom	male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment Cayley-55 04.08.2020 20:12:53 False suggestion Different people
Harcourt-350 H	Compare	Sir Thomas Harcourt	Wikitree Father	uncertain 1377 Bosworth, Leicestershire, England	6 Jul 1420 Stanton Harcourt, Oxfordshire, England	Male		WikiTree-36
Harcourt-30 H		Sir Richard Harcourt	Wikidata Father	uncertain 1412 certain Witham, Berkshire, England	certain 1 Oct 1486 certain Minster Lovel and Cornbury, Oxfordshire, England	Male		Orphan
Q75591248		John Harcourt (Peerage person ID=230656)		1420		male
Q76201125		Sir Richard Harcourt (Peerage person ID=599994)				male
WikiTree ID Date Status Comment thiessen-117 29.03.2022 22:13:03 Comment needs research Cayley-55 02.08.2022 10:06:29 Comment These are not duplicate people. Cayley-55 09.08.2022 10:50:58 False suggestion These are not duplicate people.