Here are suggestions for improving the health of our shared tree. Will you help by investigating them? When you're done, set the status using the button in the right column. Dismissed suggestions and corrected errors will be removed on Monday with the next database update on WikiTree+. more information 
.
| Link |
Info |
Name |
Rel. |
Birth |
Death |
Gender |
|
Manager |
Marriage |
Status |
Comyn-44
 H   |
|
Agnes Egidea of Strathearn (Comyn) |
Child |
uncertain 1260 Buchan, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1325 |
Female |
 |
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
Comyn-2
H |
Sir Alexander VI Earl of Buchan (Comyn) |
Father |
uncertain 1214 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
before 6 Apr 1289 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Madison-125 |
25.08.2020 16:26:54 |
False suggestion |
connected appropriately in WIkiTree |
| Madison-125 |
25.08.2020 16:27:07 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Comyn-1
H |
|
Sir Alexander Comyn Knt |
Child |
uncertain 1262 Buchan, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
before 3 Dec 1308 Buchan, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
Male |
 |
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
Comyn-2
H |
Sir Alexander VI Earl of Buchan (Comyn) |
Father |
uncertain 1214 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
before 6 Apr 1289 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Madison-125 |
25.08.2020 16:27:34 |
False suggestion |
connected appropriately in WIkiTree |
|
Douglas-402
H |
|
Sir Archibald Douglas IInd of Douglas (Douglas) |
Child |
before 1175 Hermiston, Edinburghshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1240 Douglas, Lanarkshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
Douglas-108
H |
William Douglas Ist of Douglas (Douglas) |
Father |
before 1157 Douglasdale, Lanarkshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1214 Douglas, Lanarkshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q4170065 |
William I, Lord of Douglas |
Father |
1 Jan 1101 , |
1 Jan 1214 , |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Carruth-363 |
27.06.2021 00:53:58 |
False suggestion |
both dates are unsourced, 1198 is date mentioned in charter, not birth |
|
Comyn-99
H |
|
Lady Elena Brechin (Comyn) |
Child |
after 1242 uncertain Scotland |
uncertain Scotland |
Female |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
Comyn-2
H |
Sir Alexander VI Earl of Buchan (Comyn) |
Father |
uncertain 1214 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
before 6 Apr 1289 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Madison-125 |
25.08.2020 16:25:16 |
False suggestion |
connected appropriately in WIkiTree |
|
Comyn-22
H |
|
Elizabeth de Umfreville (Comyn) |
Child |
uncertain 1260 |
before 17 Feb 1329 England |
Female |
|
WikiTree-36
Lee-759
|
|
|
Comyn-2
H |
Sir Alexander VI Earl of Buchan (Comyn) |
Father |
uncertain 1214 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
before 6 Apr 1289 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Madison-125 |
25.08.2020 16:25:59 |
False suggestion |
connected appropriately in WIkiTree |
|
Menteith-15
H |
|
Eva Countess Lennox (Menteith) aka of Lennox |
Child |
Apr 1168 Menteith, Perthshire |
|
Female |
|
WikiTree-65
Crawford-15512
|
|
|
Menteith-14
H |
Gille Crist Gilbert Menteith aka Earl of Menteith |
Father |
1150 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland |
1198 Perth, Perthshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
Crawford-15512
WikiTree-65
|
| Q5561992 |
Gille CrÃst, Earl of Menteith |
Father |
, |
1 Jan 1180 , |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Lamoreaux-297 |
22.03.2020 04:27:53 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree has them connected appropriately |
|
Mure-9
H |
|
Gilcrist Mure Ist of Rowallan (Mure) |
Child |
uncertain 1200 Polkelly, Ayrshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1280 Kilmarnock, Ayrshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
Mure-10
H |
David of Polkellie Mure |
Father |
uncertain 1174 uncertain |
uncertain 1249 uncertain |
Male |
|
Grant-2647
|
| Q75650610 |
Sir Adam Mure of Rowallan |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Stevens-17832 |
09.01.2022 23:14:51 |
False suggestion |
|
|
MacDougall-301
H |
|
Isabel Stewart (MacDougall) aka of Lorn, de Ergadia |
Child |
uncertain 1364 uncertain Argyll, Scotland |
certain 21 Dec 1439 uncertain Scotland |
Female |
|
WikiTree-65
WikiTree-36
|
|
|
Ergadia-14
H |
Eoin John MacDougall (Ergadia) aka Fifth Chief of Clan MacDougall |
Father |
uncertain 1335 Lorn, Argyllshire, Scotland |
before Sep 1372 Innermeath, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q75389549 |
Ewen MacDougall, 5th of Lorn and 7th of Dunollie |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| Q75389549 |
Ewen MacDougall, 5th of Lorn and 7th of Dunollie |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| Q75389549 |
Ewen MacDougall, 5th of Lorn and 7th of Dunollie |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Cayley-55 |
31.01.2020 13:50:06 |
False suggestion |
connected appropriately in WIkiTree |
|
Mentieth-14
H |
|
Isabella Russell (Mentieth) |
Child |
uncertain 1210 uncertain Scotland |
before 1272 uncertain England |
Female |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
Menteith-11
H |
Maurice third Earl of Menteith (Menteith) |
Father |
uncertain uncertain Scotland |
before Jan 1233 uncertain Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q6933194 |
Muireadhach II, Earl of Menteith |
Father |
, |
1 Jan 1230 , |
male |
|
| Q6933194 |
Muireadhach II, Earl of Menteith |
Father |
, |
1 Jan 1230 , |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Lohbeck-3 |
30.04.2022 01:02:17 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Dunbar-1212
H |
|
James Dunbar |
Child |
certain 1706 certain Fordyce, Banffshire, Scotland |
|
Male |
|
Niven-282
|
|
|
Dunbar-1213
H |
Sir James Dunbar of Durn (Dunbar) 2nd Bt |
Father |
before 9 Jan 1665 |
certain Nov 1737 certain Morayshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q75502852 |
Sir William Dunbar |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| Q75502852 |
Sir William Dunbar |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Murray-20099 |
03.05.2022 09:22:08 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Haliburton-5
H |
|
Jean Halyburton (Haliburton) |
Child |
uncertain 1350 Dirleton, East Lothian, Scotland |
1400 Midlothian, Scotland |
Female |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
Haliburton-8
H |
Sir John Haliburton aka Halyburton |
Father |
before Apr 1356 certain Haliburton, Berwickshire, Scotland |
after 1402 uncertain |
Male |
|
Orphan |
| Q75532206 |
Sir William Halyburton of Dirletoun |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| anderson-23510 |
09.06.2021 23:35:47 |
False suggestion |
Disputed parentage |
|
Comyn-106
H |
|
John Earl of Buchan, 3rd Earl of Buchan Comyn |
Child |
uncertain 1260 Altyre, Morayshire, Scotland |
before 4 Dec 1308 England |
Male |
|
Orphan |
|
|
Comyn-2
H |
Sir Alexander VI Earl of Buchan (Comyn) |
Father |
uncertain 1214 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
before 6 Apr 1289 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Madison-125 |
25.08.2020 16:26:29 |
False suggestion |
connected appropriately in WIkiTree |
|
Lockhart-2767
H |
|
Malcolm Lockhart |
Child |
uncertain 1190 uncertain Lanarkshire Scotland |
certain 1273 uncertain Lanarkshire Scotland |
Male |
|
Orphan |
|
|
Lockhart-422
H |
Malcolm Lockhart aka Locard |
Father |
uncertain 1180 uncertain Scotland |
after 1229 uncertain Ayrshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q76056244 |
Sir Symon Lockhart |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| Q76056244 |
Sir Symon Lockhart |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| anderson-23510 |
02.12.2021 21:20:20 |
False suggestion |
Wikidata wrong |
|
Comyn-35
H |
|
Marjorie Comyn Countess of Dunbar (Comyn) |
Child |
Scotland |
10 Oct 1308 Scotland. |
Female |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
Comyn-2
H |
Sir Alexander VI Earl of Buchan (Comyn) |
Father |
uncertain 1214 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
before 6 Apr 1289 Buchan, Aberdeen, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| Q2577038 |
Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan |
Father |
1 Jan 1300 Buchan, United Kingdom |
1 Jan 1289 , |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Madison-125 |
25.08.2020 16:27:58 |
False suggestion |
connected appropriately in WIkiTree |
|
Menteith-6
H |
|
Mary Menteith |
Child |
before 1231 Menteith, Perthshire, Scotland |
before 1286 uncertain Scotland |
Female |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
Menteith-11
H |
Maurice third Earl of Menteith (Menteith) |
Father |
uncertain uncertain Scotland |
before Jan 1233 uncertain Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q6933194 |
Muireadhach II, Earl of Menteith |
Father |
, |
1 Jan 1230 , |
male |
|
| Q6933194 |
Muireadhach II, Earl of Menteith |
Father |
, |
1 Jan 1230 , |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Lohbeck-3 |
30.04.2022 01:02:16 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Keith-260
H |
|
Sir William Keith Great Marischal of Scotland (Keith) |
Child |
after 1306 uncertain Scotland |
after 2 May 1407 Dunnotter, Kincardineshire, Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
|
|
Keith-1295
H |
Sir Edward Keith Marischal of Scotland (Keith) |
Father |
uncertain 1280 uncertain Scotland |
before 17 Oct 1346 uncertain Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q116033392 |
Robert de Keeth |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| Q116033392 |
Robert de Keeth |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| Q116033392 |
Robert de Keeth |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Lohbeck-3 |
08.10.2021 22:41:39 |
Comment |
Parent already connected |
| Lohbeck-3 |
17.10.2021 07:28:41 |
False suggestion |
|
|
Urquhart-35
H |
|
Sir William Urquhart of Cromarty (Urquhart) aka Urchard |
Child |
uncertain 1390 certain Forbes, Aberdeenshire, Scotland |
uncertain 1472 certain Scotland |
Male |
|
Urquhart-93
|
|
|
Urquhart-717
H |
John Urquhart Sheriff of Cromarty (Urquhart) |
Father |
uncertain 1355 certain Scotland |
uncertain 1425 certain Scotland |
Male |
|
WikiTree-65
|
| Q76198174 |
John de Urchard |
Father |
, |
, |
male |
|
| WikiTree ID |
Date |
Status |
Comment |
| Urquhart-93 |
13.05.2020 02:46:42 |
False suggestion |
WikiTree profiles connected appropriately |
|